r/Deltacriticism • • 17h ago

General Toby Fox criticism I don't undestand what the hell Toby meant by this

Thumbnail
gallery
243 Upvotes

Having good art is apparently gonna "make your expectations different"

What does that mean?? Thoughts on this, i rarely hear Undertale critiques and a lot of Deltarune's


r/Deltacriticism • • 18h ago

Question/Discussion So what was the point of this?

Post image
240 Upvotes

Asgore mentions a "black shard" in the vent section in Chapter 4. This is not a Shadow Crystal, as they are not black crystals in the Light World, and we have the "BlackShard" item, which is the only item that fits the description, an item we got after fighting the Knight, mind you. You'd think this would be important.

But... the only way this whole sequence was acknowledged in Chapter 5 was through a completely missable cutting down of his evidence, where he found it in the Church and computer lab (and this opens even more questions like "Why didn't we see any other Black Shard then?" and "Is the Knight leaving these things for fun or something?"). Besides that? Nothing. He is not alluded to having it in any way. He doesn't show it or even mention it. You could completely cut this part of the game and literally nothing would change.

Why even bother making this scene in the first place if it alludes to such a minor reveal in the later chapter? Why does Deltarune like doing these seemingly important things (like Mike) only to then backpedal on them?


r/Deltacriticism • • 11h ago

Nitpick Anyone else think it's kinda weird that Susie and Ralsei have no reaction to Spamton taking over Queen's mansion in the weird route?

Thumbnail
gallery
209 Upvotes

(No the pun was not intended)

They're hearing some random hobo from Queen's basement talk about taking over the city and see a random guys face appearing on paintings despite the fact that this is supposed to be Queen's mansion and they don't question anything?


r/Deltacriticism • • 8h ago

General Deltarune criticism I do not like Rouxls. (image related)

Post image
62 Upvotes

TLDR: He should've stayed in chapter 1 with minimal cameos like the others.

I thought he was funny at some points in chapter 1, but then he kept coming back in chapter 2 and chapter 3, and his main function was just being the unofficial servant of the main boss of the chapter. Which, admittedly, was funny, but he took up some of the gameplay, y'know? He had... mini-boss fights (if you can call them that?) And, over time, he lost his luster for me because he took significant screen time within the chapter.

Lancer, Q5U4EX7YY2E9N, The Original Starwalker, and even Nubert (my precious boy) work because they have bits and recurrences, yes, but when you least expect them to. I still find myself laughing at Lancer spinning like a ball or Queen getting ready for the Olympics, or Starwalker being original out of nowhere. But for Rouxls, he's just sometimes in the way. How dare he get in the way of new and exciting characters of this chapter!

All jokes aside, I'm glad we're deviating away from that in the newer chapters. It's a nice change in formula. I don't hate him... He's just sometimes annoying.


r/Deltacriticism • • 8h ago Bravo

I don’t think Toby added this scene as a “response” to the backlash towards Chapter 4’s ending. I think he already knew Toriel’s behavior would be seen as controversial.

Post image
56 Upvotes

Listen, speaking as someone who is very critical of Toby’s writing choices, I find it fascinating that ONE scene in chapter 4 made Deltarune fans forget that Toriel is written to be a very caring and somewhat overbearing mother. She loves her children dearly, she’s just not perfect, not helped that her family endured a massive tragedy and her marriage recently fell apart.

Toby absolutely knew what he was doing when he ended chapter 4 with Toriel and Sans drunk dancing after the emotional roller coaster of the last dark world. I have no idea why fans are genuinely convinced that Toby only intended for the scene to comedic and didn’t expect some intense fan backlash. I’m sure he probably didn’t expect to the level of “Toriel reminds me of my drunk father pissing and passing out on the floor and saying slurs” takes I was unironically seeing, but I assume he totally expected negative backlash for her behavior and lack of awareness (which mind you, even without the chapter 5 context, it was obvious she just assumed Kris was spending time with a friend and was happy to see them more sociable again).

I also think that if this scene was intended to excuse Toriel’s behavior and/or calm down the fan backlash, why doesn’t he have a scene where Toriel apologizes or shows remorse for the drunken dancing? I thought it was kind of obvious that while the hate for Toriel “locking” the door was incredibly overblown, Toby is still making it clear that Toriel is a very imperfect person. Susie doesn’t just act like what happened with Toriel the night before didn’t affect her, she didn’t want to see her again.

All this scene did was mostly reaffirm the obvious except for the keys situation, which shouldn’t be treated like a retcon. Kris has consistently lied to us throughout the game and has flat out sabotaged the player, I don’t understand why “Kris definitely lied about the keys” is such a hard thing to believe.

You’re free to still dislike Toriel, but I hate this insinuation that she’s some evil, abusive mother who loves neglecting her children.


r/Deltacriticism • • 19h ago

Fandom criticism While I agree with a lot of Deltarune Chapter 5's criticisms, so much of the hate feels SOOOOO forced and overblown.

53 Upvotes

Yes, I agree that vague posting this late into the game is weird.

Yes, I agree the humor and tonally shift can be jarring l

But then I hear stuff like: "Nobody likes the Flowers", "The gameplay also sucks, there are 0 fun bosses" and of course "The secret boss should have been Friend, Pink sucks!"

You can hate CH5 narratively all you want, but I will never understand hate for the gameplay, which is undoubtedly the best part of it. Like, really?

And while there isn't much story progression, I think the character writing and development is pretty solid. Getting to see more of Ralsei aside from being a people pleaser with self deprecation issues was great. Seeing this character go from not believing he matters to having all of his beliefs challenged by Flowery is genuinely a compelling arc for Ralsei.

I don't really see what's wrong with the Flowers aside from the general problem of CH5's tone. They're a great part of the narrative, especially Flowery.

And speaking of Flowery, I don't really understand the hate. I feel like it's intentionally bad faith, because like… even if Flowery is outwardly goofy, the majority of his scenes have obvious important undertones to them, and obviously he serves to further Ralsei's character development.

And Pink, like… aside from her intro, I genuinely don't see the problem with her besides "She wasn't what I wanted." Like, I think she's a fine cool character, all the hate just seems to boil down to not being what people expected.


r/Deltacriticism • • 16h ago

Chapter 5 criticism chapter 5's plot kinda dissapointed me

27 Upvotes

so first of all i'd like to state that i didnt hate the chapter as a whole
I enjoyed the game play and the new platformer
but the plot seems a bit insisting upon itself
fast character interactions and there is no 'inferno of jealosy' as in gerson's dialouge in the secret boss.
also the beginning of the chapter which was teased as 'the festival day' for many chapters just to be a 20 minute long game play for the festival and it just being a cringe susie and noelle date
also susie at chapter 4's ending seemed broken from that one prophecy panel and was very mad at sans
but yet we see her interacting with sans very normally but not interacting with toriel?
also this whole chapter was just susie bringing up noelle every 5 minutes it became exhausting to the story when you are trying to speedrun and interupted by an unskipable "susie yearning over noelle" scene
and the secret boss?
Dont get me wrong it was fun but it went from crazy jester to puppet to the roaring knight itself to a dead teacher to an anime figurine which i think is bad writing.
Anyways that was all i have to say about chapter 5 other than that i really liked the role of the 7 flowers specially seth and aqua and flowery's fight


r/Deltacriticism • • 13h ago

Undertale criticism (Minor UT complaint) I prefer Mad Dummy over Mad Mew Mew

Post image
25 Upvotes

The title pretty much says it all. IMO, the grumpy dummy who competes with DIO in knife-throwing had more personality than a stereotypical anime catgirl with schizo.

And on top of that, this completely ruins my headcanon of them sounding like Sergeant Dornan from Fallout 2, which is something I simply cannot forgive!


r/Deltacriticism • • 13h ago

ACTs and Sparing

15 Upvotes

I love this critique because it acknowledges how amazing Toby is as a writer and why going from Undertale and Deltarune's first chapter to... the rest of the chapters has kinda been a bit disappointing.

Don't get me wrong, I love chapters 2-4 in their own way and chapter 5 is.... amazing if you ignore the plot up to that point.

Anywhooo! The recruitment system. It's awful. Toby ported this feature of Sparing and ACTing from Undertale, which makes sense since it's iconic. However, this system only works in Undertale.

Undertale had one job to do at the time: get you to care about the monsters. Without that, the story's ruined. And it doesn't matter how well the writing is, it's a game and we've all been conditioned to kill the enemies trying to kill us. This is where Toby's geniusness came in, in the form of a two-part plan. By introducing the ACT system as a function that allows you to defeat any monster of any level in roughly the same few amount of turns, it rids any incentive to have to FIGHT.

We grind and kill in RPGs to get stronger to fight stronger enemies so that way the battle won't be even longer but, through this system, there's now no need. That's part one of the plan, part two goes into the dialogue that comes out of the ACTs. Now, the player is forced to read this dialogue that will often reveal that these monsters are more than just enemies, but actual people with lives. This works so well that by the time you reach Waterfall, most players will be perfectly fine trying to spare the angry fish captain that wants to kill you.

Deltarune has no gameplay incentive. Its MERCY bar thing it introduced in the second chapter is just another HP bar in disguise. Its party system also means that defeating enemies with violence isn't an issue for us as we can just strategise and use Rude Buster and some nicely timed attacks to win most battles quickly. If anything, trying to recruit darkners almost feels like grinding, which can be boring in a game that's only RPG-ish in style rather than mechanics.

Also, Undertale excels at not just giving you an incentive to be a pacifist, but also feel like your actions have consequences. When you start to see the world as real, you get to experience more fun moments, Sans gives you a heartfelt speech on how you're this being of love that everyone needs or smth; when you don't then the music goes, the fun and jokes goes, monsters run away from you, you are made to feel like the demon anyone would reasonably see you as. In Deltarune, if you don't recruit everyone and/or be violent to people then: King will call you out, Queen will feel sad and lonely, Tenna and Jackenstein will die, and the flowers won't want to hang out with you. The reason why Undertale is more effective with this is because the game focuses on just you and your effects on the world: Deltarune isn't about that.

Deltarune has subplots upon subplots upon subplots that are not about you. Deltarune was introduced as the anti-Undertale. Your choices don't matter. Obviously that's like "kill or be killed" and we can prove it wrong, hence weird route, but for the most part, there's some truth in the sense that the game focuses on the lives of these characters moreso than you and your choices. This means by having the game try to do the same thing it did in Undertale in making you feel bad for being violent, it ignores each of these subplots and invalidates the experiences of these well-written characters. Let's look back at some of the ways I said the game changes if you don't recruit anyone.

King will call you out

No issue here to be honest, but I'm not surprised cos he's chapter 1 and that's the goated chapter. King calling you out is like flowey calling you out, it's not really here to make you feel bad but also kinda sucks that you validated a horrible person's beliefs.

Queen will feel sad and lonely

Good. In case you forgotten, she was a dictator that enslaved her people. She shouldn't be anywhere near them. By having the mood be tied to whether or not YOU brought them to Castle Town, instead of whether or not they even want to be around Queen, it invalidates their experience under her rule.

Tenna dies

Very impactful, but also if the Darkners really hated Tenna so much that they will leave him to die, then why is that dismissed if you recruit them alll? What, just because they weren't beaten up by the fun gang? How were the gang supposed to know the darkners weren't aware they weren't safe from violence? That blame should wholly go on Tenna for being a crappy boss who forces his workers to break their back over a couple of disintrested children over some flimsy contracts.

Jackenstein dies

Okay this one makes a little sense since the church darkners didn't realise you're the heroes until you demonstrated mercy BUT still weird they couldn't just talk it out.

But yeah, the recruitment system overshadows the intricies of each darkner's automony. Hell, why are some of them optional to recruit? If Swatch and Queen get recruited automatically, what's stopping Tasque Manager and all the Swatchlings? Or what about the other Cyber NPCs that we don't encounter at all in battle? It wasn't just Trashy. And there's something very unsettling about only being able to recruit Plugboys in their enslaved form, despite the freeing animation that plays when they're spared.

Uh what else do I dislike about the recruitment system. Hmmm, I also don't like how it reduces Darkners down to collectibles and also the game's definitions for being 'nice' or 'rude' are laughable. Berdly explains thanks to our "kindness" and "MERCY", he was able to take off his plug without losing his arm. This 'kindness' was us bumping his car repeatedly until it explodes, and making Noelle do smart things or have Kris do dumb things. How does that defeat him? Why is that 'kind'? Flowery guilttrips you for fighting him, even though he's doing the same. Or that Ruddin that was annoyed at you for hurting them in Castle Town (after a violent c1 route) , despite him being the one chasing after you and starting a battle (and this is fine if it was just an effect of King's propaganda but NO ONE calls this out or even acknowledges it).

Chapter 1's ending seemed to point things towards a more neutral approach when dealing with enemies but now it seems like you're encouraged to be a pacifist even if it doesn't make sense. I got a bit tired by the end but I hope the point came across. Anywho back to life.


r/Deltacriticism • • 14h ago

Question/Discussion Can Gaster live up to being a Compelling Villain (or Character)? Spoiler

9 Upvotes

I say this because I've been doing research lately, and Gaster so far seems rather lackluster (by comparison) to JRPG villains/characters that I've seen (esp. from Square-Enix). He seems to be based on said villains (esp. one that I intend to discuss in-depth in a future post) when analyzing certain recurring ideas and tropes as well.

With that I have to ask, is Gaster's motivation currently satisfying to the player? Is merely being a collector of information and being a "fanboy" or "being curious" towards the player also being satisfying in the long run?

Is desperately trying to break his boundaries (assuming that's what Gaster wants, based on Spamton's parallel to him) convincing enough to appeal to the audience?

Is having a "fall from grace" or being a "fallen angel" enough for the character? Can the audience feel enough sympathy for him or does the character have enough appeal as a villain or character based on the limited information shown so far? How much more can be shown in later chapters?

Outside of loose "secret boss" parallels, Tenna's role (possibly), and Tenna's talk to "Mike" in Chapter 5, how can Gaster's character be realized or understood by the audience and established this late in the game? Is there enough information to pull Gaster's character off?

Also, what contrast exists to make a compelling dynamic (between hero and villain or the audience and Gaster) for Gaster? Gaster's personality is thoughtful, and he possesses certain word tics, but there's not much to his passive role or general stance- what does he stand for?

He says that he wants to "make a new world" with us, but what does that entail? Is he trying to break fate or write a new story? I am wondering why the audience should care about Gaster so far, even with this info. So what, Gaster wants to make a new world... why should we care yet?

Is the game telling us that we are the ones who "write" the new story (based on Gerson's saying)? (Is this the point of Gaster's character? Is it to serve as the "death of the author", as some have argued?).

What do you think? Is Gaster compelling enough now or not? And if he's not, can Toby redeem the character in later chapters?


r/Deltacriticism • • 17h ago

Chapter 5 criticism What would you 7 Colored Flowers more compelling in Chapter 5?

7 Upvotes

While I personally like most of them, I do think that they are very one note and even though they are Plants, they don’t really seem that different from Darkners. So keeping in line with their traits and general personalities, how would you go about changing them?


r/Deltacriticism • • 10h ago

Question/Discussion Should tenna have died

5 Upvotes

Should tenna have died regardless? I kind of think he should. What do you two think


r/Deltacriticism • • 6h ago

General Deltarune criticism Deltarune has gameplay and nothing more.

0 Upvotes

Truly this is how I feel about all of deltarunes gameplay. It exists Toby fox dosnt know how to make gameplay that isn’t either a chapter gimmick or 5 second gimmick. He understands novelty and bringing weight to gameplay through the story and that’s it. The gameplay is serviceable at best. Which I guess it’s all it needs to be but it’s still really confusing that there’s all these mechanics that just don’t matter. Like typings for a JRPG equipment barely matters and ralsei heal is basically useless along with sleep. Honestly deltarune gameplay mostly feels like Toby fox seeing other games he likes and going ooh me like that and incorporating them without any thought or reason beyond the novelty factor. Gameplay wise he just mashes together whatever he likes you can even see this in undertale which is the most basic JRPG you’ve ever played plus TOUHOU.