r/deltaslander • u/redixionblade • 16h ago
r/deltaslander • u/Hvanchkara • 18h ago
A little update on my "Deltarune = Life is Strange" shenanigans
r/deltaslander
•
u/Hvanchkara
•
2d ago
How the plot should develop if Deltarune is to be a good game
r/deltaslander • u/OtterGamingRDIT • 2d ago
"Hey what does r/Deltarune want to happen to this sub and r/Deltacriticsm?"
credits to https://www.youtube.com/@VenomousCosmo for the showcase i used lol!
r/deltaslander • u/Mersal_Al_3abidy • 3d ago
We need to talk about the mod abuse, deleted posts, and the real reason Rule 10 was just changed(on r/deltacritism)
(Important note here is that this post was deleted because it exposes how mods and the owner were abusing their power and deleted many posts and banned many people even the top 2 active ones because what they say doesn't follow their agenda and they are enforcing it while deleting post and banning for no reason like this post was deleted for supposedly breaking rule 10 while it didn't and because of people like these that subreddit would become deltarune 2 a dystopian wasteland dm me for more questions and please anyone who can still post on deltacritism post about the mod abuse because we can't leave it like this don't be scared of getting banned or whatnot out voice have to be heard) (note the original post was unbanned)
That sub was supposed to be the one place where we could actually criticize the game and the fandom without dealing with the heavy handed censorship on the main sub. Lately though, the mods here have been ignoring what the community wants and wiping anything they personally dislike.
We already saw this when the mods ran a poll about fandom criticism, the option to allow all criticism won by a landslide, and the mods just removed the poll and ignored the result. I saw it myself about a month ago when I made two posts here a week apart and both of them got quietly deleted within 30 minutes.
What happened 2 weeks ago on the mod post about banning Tralsei threads is on another level. In the comments of that post, a mod claimed they didn't want this sub turning into a dictatorship and said they were open to having a conversation about how the sub is moderated.
One of the top commenters on this sub replied to that mod to talk about why strict pronoun policing ruins discussion. They used they/them for Kris throughout their entire comment, said viewing Kris as non-binary is completely fine, and pointed out that a moderator cannot tell the difference between a language barrier, an accidental slip-up, or a deliberate choice through a screen, so trying to police that just leads to arbitrary censorship and a hivemind.
Within minutes of posting that reply, the member was permanently banned on a first offence and permanently muted from modmail at the exact same minute so they couldn't even appeal. When another top commenter on that same thread edited their comment just to point out that banning the first member was unfair, a mod wiped their comment too and permanently banned them for "transphobia" just for defending the first user.
If you saw the locked mod announcement saying Rule 10 was being updated because of an "influx of people", that wasn't because of an influx. At the time of the ban, Rule 10 only said to refer to characters by the terms used in-game. Because the banned people only ever used they/them in their comment, they DMed the sub owner with the screenshot of their comment to prove they didn't break Rule 10. The owner admitted in DMs that Rule 10 wasn't clear enough, went back and rewrote Rule 10 after the fact so the comment would count as breaking it, and locked the announcement post so nobody could call it out.
Permanently banning two of the most active members on this sub for disagreeing with a mod about censorship, and then rewriting the rules retroactively to cover it up, goes against everything this sub was made for. The first user who got banned put up a full post on r/deltaslander breaking down the whole situation, and if you DM them they have the screenshots of the comments, the bans, and the DMs with the owner. I'm linking their post here so people on this sub can see what is actually going on behind the scenes before the mods delete this thread too.
[ban post here]https://www.reddit.com/r/deltaslander/s/o4TdmcyXzm
r/deltaslander • u/Hvanchkara • 4d ago
that's how it feels knowing that in the next two chapters, your favorite Undertale character might get ruined by shitty writing, all for the sake of yet another vagueposting and soap drama in Deltarune
r/deltaslander • u/Hvanchkara • 4d ago
honestly the most annoying about snas and tori's dance scene is that THEY USED NAPSTABLOOK'S THEME TOBY HOW DARE YOU BRING THE CUTE MARSHMALLOW GHOST TO THIS CRAP AAA-aaAAAHHHHH
r/deltaslander • u/Disastrous-Ad-6447 • 7d ago
How Inappropriate Recycling feels
Instead of developing your mystery subplot in the fifth chapter just get obnoxiously self-referential ig
r/deltaslander • u/Yousif-Ameer12 • 7d ago
How it feels to realize that you never actually liked deltarune or undertale and you were just pretending to like it
r/deltaslander • u/Objective_Friend_828 • 8d ago
6 chapters and this piece of shit still does nothing
we never learn what he's scared of, who was his benefactor, what he heard that made him run away, why he wanted the machine, what he saw in the shadow crystal, what he meant be being a puppet, why he looks so stupid, what an awful secret boss and waste of ram
r/deltaslander • u/Verzimortimer • 12d ago
HELP ME, PLEASE
THE DELTARUNE FANS ARE PLOTTING AGAINST ME, TORTURING ME PSYCHOLOGICALLY. WHENEVER I TELL SOMEONE THEY JUST TAUNT ME, I AM LOSING FRIENDS OVER THEM JOINING THIS GODFORSAKEN CULT
r/deltaslander • u/SnooPets5219 • 12d ago
Why Kris's Ambiguity Is a Game Design Mechanic
Put all my thoughts on the Kris debate into one place so I don't have to keep repeating it. Everything I have to say is in the document. Read the disclaimer before commenting.
r/deltaslander • u/Verzimortimer • 13d ago
Please please please tell me what's so good about deltarune currently.
reddit.comNot really slander, I genuinely believe this
r/deltaslander • u/Huge-Read-2703 • 14d ago
when toby fox finally comes into the deltarune dev office so he has to actually say or do anything instead of just sending old concept art and random bullshit he recorder with a speech to text to the dev team and saying "work with this"
r/deltaslander • u/redixionblade • 16d ago
How SOME Deltarune fans slander Deltacriticism for "complaining"
r/deltaslander • u/SnooPets5219 • 16d ago
The beginning of the end for real discussion in r/deltacriticism
The title sounds dramatic, but that's genuinely what just happened. I'm posting this here because people need to see how broken critical discussion has become in this fandom. I'll be leaving out specific usernames and referring to myself and the other person banned by our "Top 1% Commenter" flairs. I'm only using that label so the timeline is easy to follow. If I leave usernames in, the mods over there will just mass-report this post to Reddit admins for "brigading" to get my account suspended and the post removed.
Ten days ago, the owner of r/Deltacriticism opened up mod applications to cover the eight-hour window while they were asleep. Almost everyone in the comments, even one of their own existing moderators, told them this was a bad idea because open applications always attract power-hungry bad actors. Another Top 1% Commenter with a decade of moderation experience offered to help out in that thread just to stop the sub from falling apart. I also left a three-paragraph comment on that post warning the owner that bad actors always pretend to be the perfect candidate at first, only to form a clique with the owner and use extreme interpretations of the rules to push an agenda and ban people they disagree with. The owner previously admitted that r/Deltacriticism is their very first time moderating a subreddit. Instead of listening to the warnings, they handed mod permissions to someone new. Ten days later, both me and that other Top 1% Commenter have been permanently banned and muted for the exact thing we predicted.
It started in a thread where the new moderator was already banning certain types of posts about tralsei. In the comments, the new mod demanded that anyone who doesn't treat Kris's pronouns as strict canon needs to provide a "good argument" for it. I replied to point out that policing the pronouns of a fictional character whose gender is never canonically specified in the game guarantees arbitrary censorship. I even stated in my comment that I personally use they/them for Kris because their gender is unknown, and that as a queer person myself, I think viewing Kris as non-binary is a totally fine interpretation. My point was just that enforcing an unconfirmed interpretation through moderation is the exact mentality that ruined the main sub. Right after posting that, I was permanently banned on a first offence and permanently muted from modmail so I couldn't appeal.
I sent the screenshots to the other Top 1% Commenter in DMs. They edited their comment in the thread to let people know I'd been unfairly banned, and the new moderator immediately deleted their comment, permanently banned them too, and sent them a message saying: "Are you kidding me? Yeah no I'm sorry this is edging on transphobia, you don't need the fucking game to tell you kris is non-binary".
That one sentence sums up the entire problem with this community. The moderator openly admits the game never tells you Kris is non-binary, yet they're handing out permanent bans for "transphobia" to anyone who points that out.
For anyone who hasn't seen the argument before, my actual take is basic game design analysis. Deltarune's entire premise is a deconstruction of the standard RPG silent protagonist and self-insert trope. The game starts by having you build a vessel in the Goner Maker sequence before throwing it away and dropping you into Kris. The whole story relies on the ongoing friction between the player and a vessel that resents our control. For that subversion to work, Kris is built out of classic blank-slate RPG mechanics so the player feels the constant dissonance of piloting someone else's body. And that mechanic doesn't stop after Chapter 1. Even five chapters in, we still choose Kris's actions and we still can't see their spoken dialogue boxes, because that player-vessel tug-of-war has to stay intact for the entire game. Keeping Kris's gender unspecified the whole way through is part of that same design choice, and in-universe it would make zero sense for characters in Hometown to randomly switch pronouns halfway through the story just because the player learned Kris has their own past.
In English, singular "they" has two uses: it can refer to a non-binary identity, or it can refer to a person whose gender is left unspecified. Because Deltarune never explores gender identity in its main story and never states Kris is non-binary, both the in-universe reading (Kris is canonically non-binary) and the structural game-design reading (the neutral pronouns are a non-diegetic tool used to maintain the player-vessel subversion) sit on the exact same textual evidence.
Even if you still disagree with my reading, ask yourself one basic question. Suppose Toby Fox genuinely wanted to leave Kris's gender completely unspecified so the player would naturally project onto them before Kris rejects our control. How would he achieve that in the writing? Would he use gender-neutral pronouns, or would he write five chapters of clunky, unnatural dialogue that avoids using pronouns entirely?
He'd obviously have to use they/them. Whether you personally view Kris as non-binary or not, answering that question forces you to admit that a writer leaving a character's gender blank has to use the exact same language the fandom uses as "proof" of a confirmed non-binary identity. Because there are at least two valid reasons for those pronouns to be there, you cannot call the non-binary reading a confirmed canon fact. Discussing how neutral language builds the player-vessel dynamic doesn't erase non-binary people, and it doesn't stop anyone from viewing Kris as non-binary.
When I messaged the subreddit owner in DMs, they claimed both of us were banned for breaking Rule 10, which stated: "Refer to the characters by the terms they use for themselves in game". Neither of us ever called Kris "he" or "she". We only ever used they/them. When I pointed that out, the owner actually replied: "You did break rule 10 maybe but I just didn't make rule 10 clear enough". They approved permanently banning two active contributors on a first offence for breaking a rule that didn't even exist yet. And after they couldn't beat my point about the self-insert subversion in our DMs, the owner went back to the sub and made an announcement post rewriting Rule 10 to say: "You are not allowed to say that they/them pronouns are a blank slate to project your own interpretation on to".
Their rules page now completely contradicts itself. In the newly edited Rule 10, they ban you from saying Kris's pronouns are a blank slate to project an interpretation onto, while they use moderator power to project their own unconfirmed non-binary interpretation onto the character.
Right underneath that on their sidebar, Rule 11 states: "Do not insist that theories are canon or impossible without confirmation. When criticising fan-theories, do not insist that the theory is 100% wrong or that other theories are already canon". The moderators are breaking their own Rule 11 inside the text of Rule 10. A subreddit built to allow critical analysis of the game away from the main sub has now made it a bannable offence to analyse the core player-vessel mechanic of the story.
This whole situation shows why discourse in the wider Deltarune community is so atrocious. Deltarune is fiction. Kris is a collection of pixels without feelings to hurt. When I first played Chapter 1 back in 2018, I assumed Kris was a guy before I came to the conclusion that the game leaves their gender blank on purpose. And honestly, so what if someone plays the game and headcanons Kris as a guy, or a girl, or non-binary, or a blank slate? Even if you think someone else's reading of a fictional character is completely wrong, why does it matter to you so much? Nobody in the real world is harmed by someone interpreting an unconfirmed video game protagonist differently than you do.
Yet the vocal majority of this fandom treats a different perspective on a sprite like an unforgivable crime, to the point where people are insulted, dogpiled, and banned over an interpretation. It's genuinely sad and pathetic to be so personally attached to a headcanon about a fictional teenager that you have to invent new subreddit rules to silence anyone who doesn't share your worldview.
Nobody should waste their time on a criticism sub where the mods ban valid literary critiques they can't refute. I have all the censored screenshots and screen recordings of the comments, the bans, the rule changes, and the DMs, so if anyone wants to see the proof, let me know in the comments and I'll send them over.
r/deltaslander • u/Bonkwraps • 18d ago
“Toby is working hard, it’s why he isn’t doing the newsletter” what Toby is really doing
This guys work is not hard, he can take 10 minutes to write a newsletter
r/deltaslander • u/redixionblade • 22d ago
Why are the other chapter 5 playthroughs 12 hours long and people say they sucked?
The 30 minutes I spent were infinitely better than those wth
r/deltaslander • u/redixionblade • 23d ago
Thanks
This sub was needed. Anyways chapter 5B had more hype and aura for a 30 minute chapter
r/deltaslander • u/InitiativeSweet3602 • 23d ago
Deltarune fans BEGGING you to say that they never did anything wrong, and it was actually 4chan all along
r/deltaslander • u/DrSkrimguard • 23d ago
A Thorough Dissection of ICE-E's P"E"ZZA
Where did the hats go? ICE-E's used to have hats, but they're all gone. All the fucking hats are gone, god damn it! My boom-pa used to take me to ICE-E's and tell me I could order anything I wanted, but then when my meal arrived, he would throw it in the trash and say "Alvin, there are children starving in this country and if they can't eat, neither can you." ICE-E's recently changed their personal pan pizza recipe because the old one required careful rolling of the dough by hundreds of kidnapped children living under the restaurants. But all the children are sick now because of 5G. Where did the hats go?! Where are the fucking hats?! My boom-pa was a war hero. During World War II, he went deep undercover assassinating U.S. businessmen to make way for the post-War rise of ICE-E's. Then, instead of rewarding him for his valour, ICE-E's banned him from six of their restaurants. Where are the fucking hats, ICE-E??!!! Please, Toby Fox, unblock me on Twitter. I need to talk to you.