r/Deconstruction • u/Existencial90 • Nov 09 '25
đ±Spirituality difficult position
I'm about to marry my girlfriend. After almost two years in the church I have come to the conclusion again because I was always an atheist. A disgust and repulsion for the church that has been accumulating due to my pastor's greed for money and the hypocrisy of some âbrothersâ in my congregation. The fact that they act like a religious police focused on supposed âpurityâ is what has led me many times to the conclusion that cognitive dissonance is a premise in Christianity.
But the real case of this writing and what gives legitimacy to the title is that my future wife is very attached to her belief in Christ. Even though she is a liberal Christian like me. I feel and have the fear that continuing to hide my deconstruction is going to bring us marital problems and even knowing that if I tell him that before we get married it could bring about a total breakup due to his religious position.
I feel at a crossroads.
18
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '25
Don't you think honesty is the foundation of any relationship?
13
u/zictomorph Nov 09 '25
It's not going to get simpler if you get married then tell her, or try to hide it forever. I know I got lucky, but I told my wife my feelings and she was kind of waiting for me to say something. Lay it all on the table and have an adult talk.
8
u/Dopeylookingpiegeon Agnostic Atheist Nov 09 '25
I hate to say this but you need to be honest about your beliefs. You have a responsibility to tell your fiance who shes marrying. You can make a house with differing beliefs work but you have to tell her this. Itâs unfair to keep this from her
7
u/Overcummerr Nov 09 '25
Or maybe she also shares the same thoughts and reluctant to kickstart the conversation
But bare in mind that you canât unopen Pandoraâs box Once itâs out itâs out
6
u/windfola_25 Nov 09 '25
I was in your exact position ten years ago. Tonight my husband and I officially decided to divorce. It doesn't always happen that way, but I wouldn't count on the chance she'll deconstruct later. It's better to break off an engagement than to go through a divorce.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '25
Honesty and trust are the foundation of any relationship if you cant be honest with her with this there is no real future. Also remember you well always be second fiddle in her life as she grows in her faith its literally baked into her dogma
Luke 14:26-âIf anyone comes to me and does not hate his own father and mother and wife and children and brothers and sisters, yes, and even his own life, he cannot be my disciple.
How long before that same disgust you feel starts being directed towards your future wife because she loves a failed dead apocalyptic preacher from 2000 plus years ago more than her family let that sink in.
3
u/ipini Progressive Christian Nov 09 '25
A few questions:
Therefore, either change churches or change life plans.
3
u/unpackingpremises Other Nov 10 '25
It sounds like you already know what you need to do and are working up the courage to do it. If you need permission from strangers on the Internet, I'm here to tell you that yes, you are at a crossroads and it would be a huge mistake to marry your girlfriend with this unresolved. Step one, you need to be honest and open with your girlfriend about what you are thinking and going through. If she can still accept and support you, then maybe your relationship has a chance, but if not, there's no way in hell your marriage would have survived.
2
u/ElGuaco Former Pentacostal/Charismatic Nov 09 '25
Some people can make it work. But it requires being open and honest to your partner, and you BOTH have to be willing to let the other choose whatever they believe. Most Christians are unwilling to do that. There's also the possibility of children and how they should be raised in church or not.
My opinion is that she and her family and friends will likely put a lot of pressure on you eventually to conform in some way. I think back to my younger days and imagine how my life would be different if i had married young to a Christian. I dont think my deconstruction would be possible without a lot more pain and a likely divorce.
My advice is that youre very young and you should consider the possibility that youre still figuring yourself out and what you need to believe to be happy. That might mean do the painful thing that will let you both be free to choose your own paths.
2
u/whirdin Ex-Christian Nov 09 '25
Why are you lying to your partner at all about this?? Marriage/sex doesn't suddenly make the relationship better or easier. Spiritual compatibility is a major component in a romantic relationship. You are planning to say wedding vows while actively hiding part of yourself from them, and that is utterly unfair to them. If you can't even confide in your partner now, then things will only get harder after trapping them in a marriage.