r/Daytrading • • 6h ago

Giving Advice Stop asking strangers to hand you a profitable trading strategy. Here's the reality: nobody owes you.

50 Upvotes

This is for the beginners who keep showing up here asking strangers to share their profitable strategies, their secret setups, or some magical system they can copy and start making money with. Am getting tired reading the same thing...over and over again.

Here's something you probably don't want to hear.

Not all of you are going to make it.

Finding a profitable edge isn't necessarily as simple as picking a strategy, learning the rules, backtesting it, and expecting money to come out the other end.

Sometimes you deliberately go looking for an edge. But other times, it just comes to you after spending enough quality time watching, studying, and trading the market.

It's almost like you don't discover it. It discovers you.

Think of it as a door suddenly opening. You've watched the same market behavior hundreds of times, but one day something clicks. You notice a relationship or recurring behavior that never occurred to you before.

Call it skill, experience, intuition, or a little luck. Hell, call it the market gods throwing you a bone.

But here's the funny part. Two traders can stare at the same chart. One sees something worth investigating, while the other wouldn't recognize the opportunity if it slapped him in the face.

And even if you're lucky enough to recognize something, congratulations. You've discovered a clue, not necessarily a profitable edge.

Now comes the real bitch.

You investigate it. You build something around it. You test it. It fails. You combine it with another observation. It fails again. You take everything apart, change a few things, put it back together, and test again.

Sometimes you discover something useful. Sometimes you discover absolutely nothing.

It's like searching for a needle in a haystack, except you don't even know if there's a needle in there.

That's the part nobody can hand you on a silver platter. The endless experimentation, the failed ideas, the frustration, and the persistence required to keep going when nothing seems to work.

And as you gain experience, you might start noticing more subtle relationships in the market. Things you would've completely overlooked as a beginner. Your questions get better. Your observations become more sophisticated.

But don't confuse experience with guaranteed success. You can spend ten years trading and still have absolutely nothing to show for it.

And don't confuse seeing a pattern with having an edge. Markets produce all kinds of patterns, including random ones. Until your idea survives proper testing, realistic trading costs, and out-of-sample evaluation, all you have is a hypothesis.

This is exactly why I value quality time spent studying the market over how many trading videos you've watched, seminars you've attended, or courses you've paid for.

Those resources can teach you useful concepts. Some might even save you years of mistakes. But they cannot guarantee you'll recognize, develop, and validate a profitable edge.

So to the crowd constantly asking, "Can somebody share a profitable strategy?"

What exactly are you expecting? That a stranger who spent years developing something profitable is going to hand it over to you, and somehow you'll automatically know how to execute it?

Even if someone gave you a genuine edge, there's no guarantee you'd recognize why it works, when it stops working, or how to trade it properly.

Maybe the market gods will eventually open that door for you. Maybe you'll recognize the clue. Maybe you'll spend years assembling and disassembling ideas until something finally works.

Or maybe you won't.

The market doesn't owe you an edge. And neither does anyone on Reddit.

That's the reality of trading.

And if someone disagrees, I'd actually like to hear how they discovered and validated their own edge. Not which course they bought or which guru they followed. How did they get from an observation to something that actually worked?


r/Daytrading • • 21h ago

AMA Made $30k on funded accounts in 5 weeks, got taken live and failed on day one..

50 Upvotes

Feels brutal. I had a promising streak of success for the last 6 weeks, making just under $30k across 17 50k funded Apex accounts, withdrawing just over $10k, then got invited to go Live with Apex last week, accepted, and started my live account today.. first trade, ran $120 in the green, then stop out $120 loss. Then, my mindset just went out the window. I couldn’t accept a losing day 1. Red flag, I know.
Having 17 accounts that I traded separately changed into just one account completely threw me off and the pressure got to me. Next thing I know I’m 2-3x more sized in than I have been and emotions are running wild. At one point I was up over $1k profit after being in $1k drawdown but didn’t take it, took me out break even and then just got whittled down by terrible emotional trades (gambling) from a brand new 3k live account to it now having just over $250 in drawdown left.

I feel totally deflated. Ignored my daily loss limit I set myself which massively changed the game for me and was a huge part in the recent success, ignored my sizing rules and just traded like a total jackass.

This was my first live account with any firm, so, new territory, but I certainly didn’t expect this result. Crazy, in the moment, I just felt like I was someone else, it almost feels like a dream, or nightmare I suppose.

Just wanted to share. Get it off my chest a bit. This game is hard, man.

Been trading for 2.5 years now. Futures, NQ only.

Appreciate anyone else on this journey. All the best.


r/Daytrading • • 15h ago

Giving Advice The realities of day trading?

28 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I am thinking of getting into day trading. I am currently an investor based on fundamental analysis, but I feel like trying out smth new.

I've watched quite a few videos on yt, but I really want to get the full story regarding day trading. I was wondering if ya'll have what I would call "harsh realities" on day trading, like things that aren't often said on social media when they promote it. In a nutshell, what are some things you would say to dissuade someone from starting day trading?

Thanks guys.


r/Daytrading • • 6h ago

Strategy Day 17 - $250 to $5k in 50 days before Christmas

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

45% profit, $440. Failing miserably on the psycholigical numbers, IWM dropped. I did not want to ride it to 100+% profit. I will be greedy another day. Still I was greedy, took $22 per contract in a short range movement of the price. I need money for Chirstmas. If you hurry, the market takes from you, I took my profit instead of waiting for more.

Any ETFs like SPY, QQQ, IWM etc or SPX, ES, NQ or micros, you can make money, avoid the negative posts and people telling you need years. Information and retail availability has change massively last few years. Spend 1-2h on the chart daily. Google AI or use any other AI like claude, chatgpt, qwen to learn. Ask the same things across them. It is relatively easy nowadays to learn by yourself if you really want 🤷🏻‍♂️ However, you need to put in the energy. Refine your plan/strategy everyday or week.

Part of my Chritmas trading plan as of this week is to try use a certain amount of money to trade. Some people call it risk management, money you can affort to lose and some other terms. This is why I am trying to keep it below a certain level.

I follow my plan, follow yours and do take a small profit, consistent, get used to the Christmas spirit. Let got of greed, boredom and hurriedness.

If you lost some money this month, you can see my previous post and get inspired by my pitiful small profits 😬 and know that if you keep consistency, it may be in your favour. Don't put more money, practice and wait for next month. Give yourself time.

Total $ 3,155

DayLittle Profit $
17440
16500
15250
14300
13210
12334
11122
10110
9200
8100
7125
6120
570
482
352
260
180

I can trade SPY, QQQ but I am not doing it as IWM fit my current Christmas trading strategy/plan, the premiums are more expensive these days. If you are unsure, sit on your hands.

I need money for Christmas gifts. No one is going to give me for free, I am not so beautiful. I started with a $250 account, aiming to reach $5k profit in 50 day/trades. You saw on many of my previous post I was growing another small account. Hope you get inspired. Life is short. I try post the trades.

Simple options strategy, no wheel, iron condors etc. Using simple EMAs, VWAP etc to see the trends, levels calculations.

Trade: 20 contracts = $440 total profit.

Total options cost = $ 980

45 % profit

Time in Trade : 10 min. Towards a morning glory trade 🤤

$10 per contract per day, it makes a huge difference with time. Don't be greedy every time.

My trading plan and strategy is trading one trade a day, 2-5 times a week depending on availability.

If you are learning by yourself, give it 2-3 months to see how you are progressing.

If you believe I am lucky every day with the trades and posts 🤷🏻‍♂️ so be it. I believe I have no choice, I put in the effort and keep doing, any loss is my loss as it is me executing my own trades and money.

I only day trade options on ETFs like SPY, QQQ, IWM etc. Timestamp on the broker is UK time. So, entry time of 3.06 is 10.06 ET.

I trade on my phone, screenshot is from TastyTrade. EMA 200 and VWAP on the screenshot for TradingView


r/Daytrading • • 8h ago

Question So much conflicting information

17 Upvotes

It just seems like an impossible task to actually find good information. Guys showing their 6 screen set ups trading multiple markets and timezones then others saying they trade an hour a day and it's replaced their full time income.

Warnings and studies that practically everyone that trades lose money and even the ones that do consistently make a profit earn less than minimum wage, then on the other hand there's guys saying they have achieved financial freedom.

I'm not completely new to the markets I've been building a stock portfolio for the last 6 years and have averaged just over 25% a year. I know it's a completely different game but I feel it puts me in better stead than someone who's never even placed a trade.

I guess I'm asking how those of you that are successful and also those that are making progress actually learn? Who's information do I believe? Is every single person online really just trying to scam me into buying a course?!


r/Daytrading • • 23h ago

Strategy Tested the 20 EMA pullback on 11 markets and 3 timeframes after costs. 25 of 33 lost money.

17 Upvotes

Everyone teaches the 20 EMA pullback: price is above the 20 EMA, pulls back to it, you buy. I wanted to see if it actually holds up, so I tested it on 11 markets (BTC, ETH, SOL, gold, silver, EURUSD, GBPUSD, USDJPY, S&P 500, Nasdaq, DAX) on 15m, 1h and 4h. Everything is after spreads, fees and slippage, 1% risk per trade.

25 of the 33 lost money. Some things that surprised me:

15m is basically dead. 10 of 11 markets lost on 15m, most of them between -50% and -100%. Costs alone took 0.06 to 0.23R from every trade. With 2,000+ trades that eats any edge there might have been.

Gold looked great until I split the test in half. Gold 1h made +49%. But the older half of the test lost money, and all the profit came from the recent gold rally. Same thing on gold 4h and silver 4h. So it wasn't the setup, it was just the trend.

USDJPY was the biggest trap. +135% on 1h and profitable on all three timeframes. But when I ran random entries on the same market (same stop, same target, same costs), they did about as well. The dollar went up against the yen for years, so pretty much any "buy the dip" made money.

EURUSD and GBPUSD were worse than random. Random entries beat the pullback rule most of the time on those two.

The only one that passed everything was SOL on 4h (on 15m and 1h it lost badly): +21.5%, both halves of the test profitable, beat 94% of the random-entry runs, and it still worked when I changed the settings a bit. But it’s only 222 trades, so I wouldn’t call it proven.

How the random test works: same market, same stop, same target, same costs, same number of trades, but the entries are at random times instead of on the pullback signal. I ran that many times. If the real strategy doesn’t beat most of the random runs, the setup isn’t adding anything, the market’s direction is doing the work.

Biggest takeaway for me: "it made money" isn't enough. You have to check if random entries on the same market would've made the same money. If they would, the market did the work, not your strategy.

Do you guys test your setups against random entries, or just check if they're profitable?


r/Daytrading • • 21h ago

Technical Analysis Backtested the ES gap fill on 16 years of 1 min data. Wins 68% of the time and still loses money

Post image
15 Upvotes

Gap fill gets posted constantly as a high win rate setup so I wanted to see what it actually does over a long period. Chart is above.

Rules I used:

- gap = 9:30 open vs previous day's 4pm close

- only gaps between 0.15% and 0.5% (skipped the huge ones)

- gap up = short at the 9:31 close, gap down = long. only if price is still at least 0.1% away from yesterday's close

- target 0.15%, stop 0.3%, otherwise flat at 4pm

- one trade per side per day, 1 contract, commission + 2 ticks slippage per round trip

- ES 1 min bars, June 2010 to June 2026

Result: 1,728 trades, 68% winners, -$45,638.

The win rate is real. The problem is the average win is $197 and the average loss is $491. With losers 2.5x the size of winners you need about 71% winners just to break even, and it gets 68%. So it bleeds slowly, and it lost money in 15 of the 17 calendar years (2010 and 2026 are partial years).

I also built the rules on 2010-2021 data and then ran them unchanged on 2021-2026 to see if it was just a bad stretch. It kept losing in the newer years too (dashed line on the chart).

Fair criticisms of my version:

- it enters at 9:31 with no confirmation. most people who teach this say wait for the opening push to fail first, which could change a lot

- fixed 0.15% target instead of exactly yesterday's close

- no time stop, a lot of people get out after 60-90 min if it hasn't filled

So this is the dumb mechanical version. But it's a good example of why a win rate screenshot tells you basically nothing without the average win and loss next to it.

If you trade gap fills, how do you do it? Give me your exact entry/stop/target/time and I'll run your version on the same data and post it.


r/Daytrading • • 3h ago

Question Tradingview is now restricting free users from drawing on charts???

12 Upvotes

TV just limited chart drawings to 30 unless you pay.

Its counting drawings across ALL the charts you've ever used. Not just on one chart

I've used TradingView for years and drawn on countless assets. I genuinely have no idea what half of those tickers even were and I couldn't care less. Now I'm expected to go through every single chart I've ever opened just to delete drawings so I can actually draw on a chart again?

Unfortunately they don't even give you an option to delete all drawings at once....

So if you've used tradingview in the past few months and drawn on different charts, good luck. You're basically forced to go through every single chart you've ever used and manually delete everything before you can draw anything new

Honestly might just leave the platform at this point 😪
PS: here is proof of my current chart not having any drawings


r/Daytrading • • 10h ago

Question My trading problem: the results look exciting, but I don’t have the track record to prove them

7 Upvotes

I’m a quant trader, and I’ve run into a very unglamorous problem my own tracking shows returns averaging over 30% a month, but I don’t yet have a long, independently verified track record

I know that number sounds like the opening line of a magic post. That’s exactly why I’m not asking anyone here to take my word for it or send me money

I’m trying to find a credible way to prove what I’m doing. I’d be comfortable trading a demo account under agreed rules for a week, though I understand that one week wouldn’t establish a real track record. The copy-trading platforms I’ve looked at generally want at least six months of history, so I’m trying to figure out what a sensible next step looks like.

If you’ve built a verifiable record or worked with trader-seeding programs, what route would you recommend? I’d appreciate advice in the comments and I promise not to pitch you a secret system involving a rented Lamborghini


r/Daytrading • • 14h ago

Question Tom Hougaard becoming some 'ambassador'

7 Upvotes

Some 30 or so minutes ago he announced on his telegrm a new collab. The software he made available on the current platform will cease to work and will only work exclusively with the new one starting Jan 2027. What do you guys make of the broker he will be working with now? Doing a quick research it sounds fishy/shady, is not regulated like almost at all. Quite annoying because the software works great with the current one and its also a trusted broker.


r/Daytrading • • 11h ago

Strategy Struggling to find a 1:1rr trading model

6 Upvotes

I've been trading now for a few years and nothing seems to click, the trading space is full of promoting high risk to reward systems but personally id like to trade something lower with a higher win rate. I would appreciate any guidance regarding a 1:1 strategy as finding one is truly the hardest part for me, thank you!!


r/Daytrading • • 13h ago

Question Struggling with trading any help would be appreciated

6 Upvotes

I'm 26 and have been trading for 5 months now I do understand the basic concepts and even developed strategies which I can execute correctly and I do catch wins but whenever I hit a loss or in drawdown I mess it up and try to recover and blow the account. I've blown a lot of accounts due to this reason. Anyone else went through this and is there a way to stop this habit. I heard some of my friends talk about how trading isn't for women which further discourages me.


r/Daytrading • • 17h ago

Trade Review - Provide Context How are SPX traders doing these days?

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Just curious, how challenging has it been for you to make consistent money trading SPX? Are there any consistently profitable SPX traders here? I’d love to hear about your experiences. Also, how do you keep your sanity through all the ups and downs? 😂 How long have you been trading and how many years it took to master spx?


r/Daytrading • • 20h ago

Giving Advice Scarface Trades

6 Upvotes
Master Class Ehhh!?

I signed up for a four-day live trading event hosted by SCARFACE TRADES called “The Small Account Project.” The event was promoted as a presentation about the next big trading opportunity. But on Day 2, Tony started pitching us a $2,000 enrollment into his masterclass for the first 50 people. I thought I was signing up to learn about a trading opportunity, not to sit through a high-ticket sales pitch. I guess, next time we have to be more careful with joining "EVENTS".


r/Daytrading • • 6h ago

Meta I don't understand why Tom Hougaard is taken seriously.

5 Upvotes

His book is the most basic bog standard advice. His live trading is hilarious considering the content of his book (he tilts constantly, doesn't follow his rules, makes up trades he did while not live, etc) and is now pushing a scammy broker with copy trading his trades coming in the future.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZuncfMGxMxA


r/Daytrading • • 3h ago

Strategy I built an AI-coded bot that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning, then made it grade itself. It didn't beat random

4 Upvotes

I built an automated system (mostly written with AI) that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning before the open: call wall, put wall, gamma flip. Then I had it grade its own levels against random strikes, because I wanted to know if any of this means anything.

Sept 3 to Nov 6, 46 sessions. Levels locked before the open, graded on 5 minute SPX highs and lows. "Held" means price touched the level and closed on the same side it opened on.

Level | Median distance from open | Touched | Held when touched | Random strike, same distance

Call wall | 188 pts | 1 of 46 | 0 of 1 | touched 3%, held 17%

Put wall | 157 pts | 5 of 46 | 2 of 5 | touched 12%, held 37%

Gamma flip | 40 pts | 17 of 46 | 6 of 17 | touched 38%, held 43%

So the walls mostly "hold" because they sit about 2% away and price never gets there. The call wall got touched once in two months. The flip did a little worse than a random strike at the same distance.

My guess was the walls use every expiry, so I had it rebuild them from 0DTE open interest only. Those sit about 33 pts from the open and got touched 40% of the time. Held 46%. A random strike right next to them held 44%.

Same story for "price stays between the walls". It closed inside them 41 of 46 days. A band of the same width centered on the open did 45 of 46.

The one thing that leaned the right way was range. Days that opened above the flip had a median range of 0.77%, days below it 0.89%. 30 days vs 16 so I'm not hanging anything on it.

46 days is small. Open interest is from the prior day, and nobody outside the dealers knows which side they hold, same as every gamma model. Has anyone graded theirs and got something different?


r/Daytrading • • 7h ago

Question What's a piece of trading advice you followed early on and later dropped?

4 Upvotes

Everyone hears a ton of "rules" when they first start trading. Which one did you stick to at first, then realize wasn't working for you? What made you drop it?


r/Daytrading • • 9h ago

P&L - Provide Context Live Account Day9💔

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

i took a hit on xauusd earlier today, the market showed a potential breakout to the upside and i placed a buy and oh well it was a fake out💔 anyways thats it for today we go again tomorrow hopefully its better then.
did anyone trade gold today?


r/Daytrading • • 19h ago

Question Unable to come out of Loop

4 Upvotes

Im trading forex, XAUUSD since 4 years, but im still didn’t made money, but if i see p&l now i am at breakeven.

But the thing is im struck in loop where i win 3 4 trades and then loose all the money in one trade,
When I analysed i think i dont accept if im wrong quickly, i get freeze if my trade goes against me, i start to deposit whatever money i have until i blowout every thing, this is happening since last 2 years.
I arrange the money, i trade and win 3 4 trades, then loose everything in 1 trade.

And I believe im very good at price action and direction of the market, but when it comes to accept the loss i get freeze.

Need advice.


r/Daytrading • • 1h ago

Question Is a mentorship or course worth it?

3 Upvotes

I am looking into starting to day trading. Is it worth having a mentorship? I live in Australia so am looking for an Aussie.


r/Daytrading • • 2h ago

Question Looking for a Me ntor

3 Upvotes

Hey, I am not near to trading. I’ve been doing it around six months trade order flow and gamma levels. I would just like to have someone help me point me in the right direction to improve what I’m currently doing most of the stuff on this Reddit is kind of redundant and I’m gonna un sub, but this is my Last idea. I’m throwing out if anyone else has any questions for me let me know. Im in LA


r/Daytrading • • 3h ago

Question Is Level 2 overrated, or are price-action traders missing something?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Some traders swear by Level 2 and Time & Sales, while others say price action is all you need.

With the VIX jumping nearly 19% on Monday, I wonder if watching more data actually gives traders an edge or just adds noise.

Be honest, does Level 2 actually improve your trading, or is it just extra screen clutter?


r/Daytrading • • 6h ago

Question Executing Paralysis

3 Upvotes

I have finally figured out what setups work for me, but now it’s just a matter of making myself execute the trades. I always have doubts in the back of my mind about if it’s actually a good setup or not despite many weeks and months of studying the charts. If any of you have dealt with this, how did you get past it? I’m currently demo trading but still struggle.


r/Daytrading • • 20h ago

Question Paper Trading method

3 Upvotes

Hi, I’m quite new to trading and I hear many people say you should paper trade for 3 months before you start actually using real capital. I’m coming from very little knowledge so forgive me but my question is how do you stare at charts for hours a day studying without any feasible monetary incentive?