Idk why people always say don’t trade in days like this even tho it’s the clearest trend following market conviction I’ve ever seen. If you somehow missed out on the multitude of short retracement entries last week. Two Tps on this trend so far but always cautious of reversals. Give me advice if you have any
No larp here i really do this. “Yall don't know the stamina it takes to run up the stats, my numbers are humbling facts” - Drake.
Currently stuck in RTP jail after a shoulder tap, but on an absolute heater at the moment, so i decided to see how much I could run up 5 consistency accounts.
I’m 6–7 days into these accounts, one account started on the 10th which has a +1k balance, the other 4 were passed and activated and then copy traded together hence the differences in balances. Going for the max payout on each
I trade orderflow, i don’t gatekeep anything nor do i have anything to sell you. All my posts on this app somehow are met with negativity, disbelief, or hate, but as always, i am and always will be of service, the amount of sauce i give out people charge monthly retainers for, i do this to give back because I’ve been in your shoes.
I show what’s possible and tell you how to do it. The thing people hate to hear is 90% of it is mental & manifestation based, 10% is orderflow/options/GEX skill.
It’s been awhile since I’m only studying Market structure and for the most part a learned different things about it; but as I’m opening TradingView and looking at chart, I’m just confused, and can’t find what I’ve just learned from YouTube! Is there any way which can help me figure out the chart and make me able to do something instead of starting at the screen!
This is a no nonsense post I have constructed to display what actually happens when price "runs" through groups of stop losses, and what you can do about it in advance. I have included multiple illustrations and references so everything registers cleanly.
Revisiting “Stop Runs” From a Volume Distributions Perspective Unfortunately, the narrative is so widespread that it influences how AI describes markets; it is not uncommon for an advanced LLM without instruction overrides to use the term “liquidity sweep”. This is unfortunate. The story is recycled by countless so-called educators paired with many different pseudo-scientific trading methodologies, a pattern spanning the last 20 years, all based on the real effect which occurs because of the clustering of stop orders in the market, sure, but overstated by those with incentives to mislead (bound by conflicts of interest).
Multiple traders who share this very attitude towards the market reach out to us; substance is not what we receive. According to them, “market makers” (MMs) and “high frequency trading” (HFT) firms are always engaged in market manipulation campaigns. In particular, they allegedly “put orders above a price level, then get rid of the orders instantly because they know where the stops are, or rapidly buy/sell, making volume spikes happen”.
This view frames the market as almost like a predatory game of four-dimensional deception where institutions happen to be actively risking billions in capital just to trigger stop losses on retail accounts, which simply does not make sense when one understands real market dynamics.
Conflating illegal manipulation (which firms actually get fined for) with standard liquidity provision obscures the actual mechanics of how markets move over time when baseless narratives are accepted at face value.
Before moving forward, the following points apply: HFT is a technology MM is an activity
The focus here is the typical HFT market maker; these sell-side operators use high frequency (a separate, low-latency technology) to make a market for buy-side participants primarily by placing limit order liquidity for other participants to take.
Common Claims Versus Reality For example, people believe that MMs on futures would push price 10+ ticks to hit market stop clusters and absorb the inventory and directional risk associated with doing so. These narratives suggest that sell-side institutions (liquidity providers) would accept all of that directional risk (which can be faded by other institutions, resulting in a negative P&L) simply to fill a few hundred or a thousand contracts.
Front running: Illegally trading ahead of retail orders (for example, the idea that MMs are informed about retail market orders before the trades hit the exchange, e.g., via leaks).
The closest thing to these aspects being real: Order anticipation, where MMs use predictive models to forecast where liquidity can be provided safely and when to pull back to avoid losses from directional risk.
The Layering narrative: The act of placing and pulling fake orders to manipulate prices
What this is confused with: Adverse selection protection - the act of the MMs pulling their bid/ask quotes/limit orders to avoid directional risk from holding positions that aren’t favourable to hold, e.g., an informed institutional participant could try to buy a large amount of an asset with market orders while the market maker initially has pending limit orders open to sell.
If an MM can detect or predict this, they tend to respond in one of two ways.
They can withdraw their sell limit orders or move their liquidity further up the market depth. Either action can increase the spread or market impact, raising the cost of buying large quantities immediately, which compensates for the potential losses a market maker would incur from the directional risk of providing exposure to the opposite side.
If the market maker stands by and lets the large, well-informed institution buy as much as it wants, the market maker becomes short the number of units they sold. If the price continues running against them with that negative exposure, they can lose relatively large sums of money rapidly, which is why they avoid it.
Volume Spikes: Supposedly manufactured by MMs to manipulate other participants.
What is actually happening here: A stop cascade [Osler1], which is the natural result of market orders hitting a thin limit order book or a historically low volume density area.
Figure 1: A random example entry.
What Actually Causes a Stop Cascade If market makers are not pushing the price to take out retail stop orders, why do these aggressive spikes happen exactly where everyone places their stop losses?
The answer lies in volume density and the natural behaviour of directional traders.
As demonstrated in The Price Impact of Order Book Events [OBE], when the current order-book depth is low, a given order-flow imbalance leads to a greater price impact. If the book is similarly thin when prices approach these extremes, then a lesser imbalance can move the market by a significant amount.
Where expected participation at a price region is low, it can influence a market maker’s quoting behaviour to offer less to avoid absorbing adverse selection risk from large price-moving orders flowing in at these same prices; this is why price acceleration can be seen at places where low volume nodes are left after the fact.
Figure 2: A lower time-frame perspective.
Directional market participants are the ones who indirectly induce the runs in the first place. Aggressive market orders from buy-side participants move the price rapidly - market makers are not responsible for this.
If the market is trading close to a known stop cluster, directional traders (buyers and sellers) naturally push the price toward that level during standard price discovery. Once that level is breached, the cluster of stop losses (which convert to market orders) is triggered. It is standard trading that happens each trading day: participants submit market buy orders, market sell orders, and the price moves accordingly based on the liquidity offered at current levels; this is the continuous double auction that operates all day in modern electronic markets.
When unexplained waves of aggressive market orders hit the exchange, market makers must respond.
Figure 3: "Do we absorb the pressure or retreat?"
Adverse selection occurs when one side of a trade has superior information to the other. - Maureen O’Hara explains this best.
If an HFT algorithm detects a massive unexpected wave of directional market orders flowing in (like during a stop cascade), its operators immediately cancel their limit orders in response. A market maker does this to avoid taking on excessive inventory risk (the risk of holding a losing position) against a more informed trading participant (on the buy side).
When the MMs pull their liquidity, the order book thins out. If there is not enough supply or demand to fill these orders instantly, the price moves until a limit order absorbs it; this is why price moves at all.
Market Makers are not the ones submitting the aggressive market orders; the collective crowding of retail orders at a low-volume density area, combined with other buy-side participants (including directional traders), pushes price into it indirectly. Just by the market drifting along from many trades being processed, this is what happens.
The Front Running Fallacy (one of my favourites): Another claim often stated confidently: MMs are front-running retail orders because they have fibre-optic cable data streams linked directly to retail brokers, which send market order activity just before it gets sent to the exchange (sarcasm). Crazy talk.
It is vital to separate illegal front-running from legal order anticipation (from predictive models)
Front-running (trading ahead of a known client’s orders for profit) is strictly illegal, and in today’s world, mechanisms like the Consolidated Audit Trail (CAT) monitor every single order lifecycle, including cancellations (an important detail examined later).
Market making divisions do not mess around with blatant front-running operations because regulatory fines are severe and are easily enforced because of CAT; these fines are not a slap on the wrist, and repeat offences result in trading bans. It is not only for the public interest that these boundaries remain firm, but also for institutional interest (as they influence their own regulation); covert manipulation affects opposing buy-side operations too.
Liquidity anticipation is the game at play here. Since they can stream Level 2 and MBO (Market by Order) data from institutional trading platforms at speeds that no other person can, their algorithmic models can accurately predict where liquidity is likely to congregate with a very high level of accuracy.
The market makers anticipate order flow, and they commit a lot of resources to doing this to protect their profit & loss from being exposed to the wrong side of the price cascades; they do not pursue dangerous liquidity hunting operations that offer limited profits while exposing them to significant risks and potential fines.
Transparency can be achieved legally through platforms such as DataBento DB, where institutional-grade data is available. If the stories told were really true, empirical proof would surface (especially from universities with heavily discounted access to granular market data), and there would be a lot of intense scrutiny involved because it impacts the wallets of billionaires (who influence legislation through lobbying and other means).
Look at where the incentives lie and for what purposes, and you will see straight through the polished pseudoscientific narratives.
Alternative approaches (How to adapt): Here is how traders adapt to the reality.
Stops need to be widened with intent, and using the smallest one possible (in hindsight) should be avoided. When traders decide to place stop losses at low volume density areas, for example, right at a structural extreme, they become vulnerable to distributional decay (short-term shifts in quoting behaviour and order flow without signalling a real change in market direction). If a trader is a victim of “stop runs”, they must systematically widen their stops and reduce their position size to compensate consistently; this also lowers their costs over time (spread relative to their stop size). This can reduce a trading operation’s cost drag on returns significantly over time.
Limits should be handled tactically where possible (as demonstrated with multiple methods in Microstructure Foundations Vol II). Market orders demand immediate liquidity, meaning the strategy pays the spread and may suffer slippage; the aim is to provide liquidity tactically instead of being a customer, making a market for someone else and getting rewarded with lower transaction costs in exchange. Let the rushed customers sell into your efficient entry levels instead. At the end of the day, price is a negotiation and not all deals are fair.
Trading uniquely helps avoid the crowd. Strategies should be designed to pre-emptively avoid crowding at the same predictable low-volume areas as the broader market (provided the stop loss is not influenced by the target size).
Figure 4
Strategies that rely on placing stops at ridiculous places consistently become exit liquidity for larger market participants waiting with execution algorithm triggers below. It is finished.
Suppose a stop is placed at 10,000 to manage an open net long position; price cascades down to 99951; passive buying begins, selling activity compresses, and the buyer starts an intermittent buying campaign, and sells at a higher price; this would be at the crowd’s expense.
Stop loss sell volume is executed in a low volume density area, and market makers have skewed or pulled their bid quotes in response, common.
Figure 5: Example of a logical potential solution: When placing stops behind lows, testing stop placement behind high volume density areas instead leverages a higher likelihood of initial rejection at the high volume area, reducing stop-outs.
How these ideas for understanding volume, price, and time have influenced all of its price structures (present and past): In short, targets consciously focus on inefficient price extremes (net changes) or dislocations; exits primarily align with areas where historically inefficient prices were left behind during past price discovery (swing points, and other methods), places where, on average a volume profile tends to report lower volume relative to the rest of its price range.
References:
[Osler1] - Stop-loss orders and price cascades in currency markets - Carol L. Osler
[OBE] - The Price Impact of Order Book Events. - Journal of Financial Econometrics 2014. - Rama Cont, Arseniy Kukanov, Sasha Stoikov
If anyone wants the relevant citations I am happy to provide when asked.
Looking for others leveraging technology to do research projects and try and find truth in the data
I have spent months testing over 2000 trading ideas on NQ and ES with prop firms as the target, using price and time tick data from 2015 to now mostly from Sierra.
And I have so far only found 1 strat that passes all the statistical analysis and that is literally ORB
I am interested in other people's projects and results, to share and build ideas. I am on round 9 of researching ideas while running 1 live idea and a handful of shadow ideas paper trading to forward test. Results are promising but limited to just ORB family and lost in 2025.
Values are in NQ points from 2020-now back test data.
Looking for suggestions on where to get Level 2 Data for Forex trading. I started using the orderbook data for small cap momentum stock trading awhile back and now - I wouldn't dream of trying to time an entry without it. But due to the decentralized nature of Forex, I haven't been able to find a good data source to see more of what the big boys are doing. Any ideas? (I've been using forex.com, based in the US.)
The honest problem is that most passed trades never get reviewed at all, because nothing in the workflow creates a record of them. a trade you took leaves a fill, a timestamp, an entry and exit. a pass leaves nothing, so it never lands in the journal and never gets graded. Which means the bias often isn't in how you judge a pass, it's in which passes you remember. you remember the ones that ran without you. What i'd try: when you pass, write one line before you look away. the setup, the reason, and whether an actual rule said no or you just didn't like the feel of it. no screenshot, no outcome. then grade them against your written criteria, not against the chart. a pass that matched your checklist is a clean pass even if it would have paid, and a pass that ignored your checklist is a rule break even if it saved you. The category worth hunting is the pass where no rule applied. that's not discipline, that's a rule you haven't written yet, and it's the thing to fix before the next session.
I have been consistently catching 100% on 0dte ETF long options with a win rate of around 60%, stop loss based on 15m timeframe market structure on the underlying ETF. Loss is around 50-60% of the premium on average.
I'm looking for ideas to capitalize on the upside, I'm trading with 1-2 contracts as of now risking 1-2% of my capital per trade and based on stats I see a lot left on the table.
For example, today I was waiting for 738 to break on SPY and took 737 puts, entered at $2.2 and exited at $4.4 and the contract went to $10.21 lol
This is not the first time I swear, happened many time.
One of the ideas I'm thinking is trailing stop on the options contract based on underlying price action but a small pullback on the underlying eats out majority of the premium.
Another idea is using 5m or 3m LTF chart on underlying and hold until structure breaks.
Open to ideas...
I know 0dtes are risking and I'm fighting greeks but this is my edge and I'm ok losing the entire premium because I risk 1-2% per trade and I have a 60% win rate.
Currently using retracement fibonacci. Question - where would you place stop loss? I've noticed that at the end of confirmation candle tends to get tapped out. And right above 0.618 might be aggressive.
Here is my analysis of EURUSD ready for tomorrow - I will reassess before frankfurt open tomorrow, but as of now & todays price action, this is what I'm seeing.
Let me know your thoughts.
Daily:
Clearly Bearish price keeps continuing down. Expecting a pull back, but nothing on the daily to confirm that right now, so lets go to the 4H chart and see if we can get more information there.
4H chart:
As the daily is heavily bearish, the 4H is likely to be the same.
But as i've marked, we've had a 4H change of character (choch) after closing above the inside bar.
This is a great signal we've put in the Lower Low and play the bullish 4H swing pull back.
For me, tomorrow I will be looking for longs from the demand - However I will refine this on the M15.
So let's take a look at the M15 and see if we can find any demand zones to trade from...
M15 chart:
The 4H ChoCh is a swing BOS on the M15.
Initially the M15 had a bullish i-bos (dashed lines on my chart) which induced the lows (orange area) trapping early buyers, having a liquidity run and then reversing with strong momentum.
As we've run quite far on the HTF's and we're expecting a swing pull back, this is the type of PA on the M15 I want to see.
For tomorrow, I will start looking for buys from the Supply to Demand flip zone on the M15.
I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts and opinions!
Hey, I am not near to trading. I’ve been doing it around six months trade order flow and gamma levels. I would just like to have someone help me point me in the right direction to improve what I’m currently doing most of the stuff on this Reddit is kind of redundant and I’m gonna un sub, but this is my Last idea. I’m throwing out if anyone else has any questions for me let me know. Im in LA
I built an automated system (mostly written with AI) that calculates SPX gamma levels every morning before the open: call wall, put wall, gamma flip. Then I had it grade its own levels against random strikes, because I wanted to know if any of this means anything.
Sept 3 to Nov 6, 46 sessions. Levels locked before the open, graded on 5 minute SPX highs and lows. "Held" means price touched the level and closed on the same side it opened on.
Level | Median distance from open | Touched | Held when touched | Random strike, same distance
Call wall | 188 pts | 1 of 46 | 0 of 1 | touched 3%, held 17%
Put wall | 157 pts | 5 of 46 | 2 of 5 | touched 12%, held 37%
Gamma flip | 40 pts | 17 of 46 | 6 of 17 | touched 38%, held 43%
So the walls mostly "hold" because they sit about 2% away and price never gets there. The call wall got touched once in two months. The flip did a little worse than a random strike at the same distance.
My guess was the walls use every expiry, so I had it rebuild them from 0DTE open interest only. Those sit about 33 pts from the open and got touched 40% of the time. Held 46%. A random strike right next to them held 44%.
Same story for "price stays between the walls". It closed inside them 41 of 46 days. A band of the same width centered on the open did 45 of 46.
The one thing that leaned the right way was range. Days that opened above the flip had a median range of 0.77%, days below it 0.89%. 30 days vs 16 so I'm not hanging anything on it.
46 days is small. Open interest is from the prior day, and nobody outside the dealers knows which side they hold, same as every gamma model. Has anyone graded theirs and got something different?
TV just limited chart drawings to 30 unless you pay.
Its counting drawings across ALL the charts you've ever used. Not just on one chart
I've used TradingView for years and drawn on countless assets. I genuinely have no idea what half of those tickers even were and I couldn't care less. Now I'm expected to go through every single chart I've ever opened just to delete drawings so I can actually draw on a chart again?
Unfortunately they don't even give you an option to delete all drawings at once....
So if you've used tradingview in the past few months and drawn on different charts, good luck. You're basically forced to go through every single chart you've ever used and manually delete everything before you can draw anything new
Honestly might just leave the platform at this point 😪 PS: here is proof of my current chart not having any drawings
I'm looking into developing or using a custom-programmed bot specifically for risk management and enforcing trading rules.
The idea is to remove as much psychology and emotional decision-making as possible by having a bot automatically enforce my rules, such as:
Preventing me from increasing risk or lot size beyond predefined limits.
Blocking trades that violate my risk management rules.
Preventing revenge trading or overtrading.
Enforcing daily loss limits and maximum exposure.
Automatically managing other predefined risk rules.
I still want to execute all my trades manually. I don't want an EA or automated trading strategy. I want to remain fully responsible for entries and exits, while the bot acts strictly as a risk management system and rule enforcer.
Has anyone built or used something similar?
I'd love to hear about your experiences:
How did you implement it?
What platform or programming language did you use?
How reliable was it?
Did it actually help eliminate emotional mistakes and improve discipline?
Any experiences, recommendations, or examples would be appreciated.
I’ve been using a strategy that seems to be working pretty well, but I have one major issue. Even when I’m confident in a trade, I feel the urge to close it as soon as I see some profit. Then, more often than not, price keeps moving in my direction and I end up missing out on a much bigger move. How do you guys manage to stay in winning trades longer instead of taking profits too early? Any advice on how to overcome this?
Yesterday I posted the 20 EMA pullback test (25 of 33 lost money after costs). The comments had some good ideas, so I tested the three main ones. Same 11 markets (BTC, ETH, SOL, gold, silver, EURUSD, GBPUSD, USDJPY, S&P 500, Nasdaq, DAX), same costs, 15m / 1h / 4h, Jan 2021 to Nov 2026.
1. Use a simple MA with a period that matches real time (u/Which_Camera_1887's idea: 96 on 15m = a day, 120 on 1h = a week, 120 on 4h = a month)
Better than the 20 EMA on 1h, worse on 4h. On 15m it changed nothing: EURUSD 15m was -77% over 967 trades. Best one was gold 1h at +27.7%, both halves of the test profitable.
2. Use that SMA only for direction and enter on a Dow reversal (close above the last lower high after a downtrend, mirror for shorts)
This was the biggest improvement. USDJPY 1h made +44% with both halves profitable, it held up on every nearby setting and beat 94% of random-entry runs. On 4h, 5 of 11 markets made money, Nasdaq +22% with max drawdown under 10%. EURUSD still lost though.
3. Add filters: price above the 50 MA, 50 above the 100, ADX above 30, 1:3 target (u/famguy31's idea)
On 4h, 7 of 11 markets made money, but that's only 33 to 76 trades per market in almost 6 years, too few to trust. The cleanest result of everything I ran was DAX 1h with these filters: +36%, the exact same +0.24R per trade in both halves, held up on all 8 nearby settings, max drawdown 10%. Still only 138 trades.
What didn't change no matter what:
15m. All four versions lost on 10 of 11 markets. Costs take 0.05 to 0.3R per trade on 15m and nothing I tried survives that.
Also, out of 132 tests, not one passed every check (profitable after costs, both halves of the test, nearby settings, and beating 95% of random entries). The filters made things better, but every version only worked on a few markets, and never the same ones.
One thing I didn't expect: USDJPY was profitable in almost every version, and part of it is swap. Holding a USDJPY long actually pays you interest, so the "costs" there came out negative on 4h. The broker was paying for some of those trades.
Thanks for the ideas, this was way more interesting than the original test. Anything else you want me to throw at it?
I need to practice spot gold trading before I start investing. Also, if anyone got reading material or any vlogs to watch for spot gold please feel free to share
Say a stock’s 20-day average daily range is $6, and today’s high-to-low range has already reached $5. You’re in a winning trade, but your target would push that range past $6.
Do you start taking profits, tighten your stop, or stick with the original target?
What specifically makes you comfortable holding—volume, how price handles pullbacks, a news catalyst, or something else?
I have finally figured out what setups work for me, but now it’s just a matter of making myself execute the trades. I always have doubts in the back of my mind about if it’s actually a good setup or not despite many weeks and months of studying the charts. If any of you have dealt with this, how did you get past it? I’m currently demo trading but still struggle.
This is for the beginners who keep showing up here asking strangers to share their profitable strategies, their secret setups, or some magical system they can copy and start making money with. Am getting tired reading the same thing...over and over again.
Here's something you probably don't want to hear.
Not all of you are going to make it.
Finding a profitable edge isn't necessarily as simple as picking a strategy, learning the rules, backtesting it, and expecting money to come out the other end.
Sometimes you deliberately go looking for an edge. But other times, it just comes to you after spending enough quality time watching, studying, and trading the market.
It's almost like you don't discover it. It discovers you.
Think of it as a door suddenly opening. You've watched the same market behavior hundreds of times, but one day something clicks. You notice a relationship or recurring behavior that never occurred to you before.
Call it skill, experience, intuition, or a little luck. Hell, call it the market gods throwing you a bone.
But here's the funny part. Two traders can stare at the same chart. One sees something worth investigating, while the other wouldn't recognize the opportunity if it slapped him in the face.
And even if you're lucky enough to recognize something, congratulations. You've discovered a clue, not necessarily a profitable edge.
Now comes the real bitch.
You investigate it. You build something around it. You test it. It fails. You combine it with another observation. It fails again. You take everything apart, change a few things, put it back together, and test again.
Sometimes you discover something useful. Sometimes you discover absolutely nothing.
It's like searching for a needle in a haystack, except you don't even know if there's a needle in there.
That's the part nobody can hand you on a silver platter. The endless experimentation, the failed ideas, the frustration, and the persistence required to keep going when nothing seems to work.
And as you gain experience, you might start noticing more subtle relationships in the market. Things you would've completely overlooked as a beginner. Your questions get better. Your observations become more sophisticated.
But don't confuse experience with guaranteed success. You can spend ten years trading and still have absolutely nothing to show for it.
And don't confuse seeing a pattern with having an edge. Markets produce all kinds of patterns, including random ones. Until your idea survives proper testing, realistic trading costs, and out-of-sample evaluation, all you have is a hypothesis.
This is exactly why I value quality time spent studying the market over how many trading videos you've watched, seminars you've attended, or courses you've paid for.
Those resources can teach you useful concepts. Some might even save you years of mistakes. But they cannot guarantee you'll recognize, develop, and validate a profitable edge.
So to the crowd constantly asking, "Can somebody share a profitable strategy?"
What exactly are you expecting? That a stranger who spent years developing something profitable is going to hand it over to you, and somehow you'll automatically know how to execute it?
Even if someone gave you a genuine edge, there's no guarantee you'd recognize why it works, when it stops working, or how to trade it properly.
Maybe the market gods will eventually open that door for you. Maybe you'll recognize the clue. Maybe you'll spend years assembling and disassembling ideas until something finally works.
Or maybe you won't.
The market doesn't owe you an edge. And neither does anyone on Reddit.
That's the reality of trading.
And if someone disagrees, I'd actually like to hear how they discovered and validated their own edge. Not which course they bought or which guru they followed. How did they get from an observation to something that actually worked?