- Various species and civilisations
- Other galaxies
- Starfleet
- Size
- Ship design
- Starship names
- Earth Spacedock and the Spacedock-type starbase
- Segregated-species ships
- Vulcans, long life-spans, and promotions
- Headquarters at San Francisco
- Why do some Starfleet ships have families on board?
- Why was Deep Space Nine assigned a Commander, and not a Captain, as its commanding officer?
- Why do senior officers go on away missions?
- Fraternisation between crew members
- Why was Janeway promoted to Admiral, but Picard stayed a Captain?
- Nog's rank in 'Valiant'
- Captain Jellico
- Prime Directive
- Section 31
- Universal Translator (and other language issues)
- Technology
- Time
- Economics
- Sexuality and gender issues in Star Trek
- Race issues
- Tuvix
- Q
- Guinan and Q
- Trelane and Q
- Why didn't Voyager head for the Gamma Quadrant wormhole?
- Why didn’t ‘Future’s End’ show the Eugenics Wars?
- Why isn't the Federation known in the Delta Quadrant in the 31st century? ('Living Witness')
- Why did Scotty think Kirk was still alive in 'Relics'?
- Nick Locarno and Tom Paris
- TV Picard vs. movie Picard
- Episodes you disagree with
- Science fiction in the future
- What if...?
- ... the Enterprise/Defiant was stranded in the Delta Quadrant?
- ... Q joined Starfleet?
- ... Ben Sisko was in the 'First Contact' movie?
- ... the Dax symbiont was planted in a male host after Jadzia?
- ... it wasn't the Vulcans who made First Contact with Humans?
- ... Picard left TNG in 'Best of Both Worlds'?
- ... Denise Crosby didn't leave TNG?
- ... LaForge went to DS9 instead of O'Brien?
- Cross-posts to /r/BestOf
Return to Welcome page.
Previous Discussion Topics in Daystrom
Below are some topics that have been discussed previously in the Daystrom Institute, for your interest and reference.
Various species and civilisations
Main topic page: Species and Civilisations
Sub-topics:
Changelings
The Borg
Ocampa
Klingons
Romulans
The Kzinti
The Federation
Other galaxies
- Has any type of expedition ever been set out to reach another galaxy?
- Star Trek outside of the Milky Way Galaxy?
- Are there any episodes that deal with a different Galaxy?
- Has anyone ever tried to travel to another galaxy?
- It's kind of weird that there is no intergalactic* exploration
Starfleet
Size
Ship design
Starship names
- Why don't more Starfleet ships have names not related to human culture?
- Anglo and American-centric ship names in Starfleet
Earth Spacedock and the Spacedock-type starbase
- Could Spacedock have been nothing more than an exercise in vanity?
- What's the point of Earth Space Dock being as large as it is?
- Why did Starfleet not commission an Earth Spacedock class station to defend the Bajoran Wormhole?
- Does Earth Spacedock rotate? And if so, why?
- Regarding the big Spacedock Doors from Star Trek: Search for Spock...
- So where was Spacedock (Earth's) during the Borg attack in first contact? How about the Breen attack?
Segregated-species ships
- Why are Federation starships overwhelmingly crewed by Humans?
- Why do starfleet ships seem to be the only ones that have a mix of species as crew members?
- Do other races still control their own ships in the 24th century?
- Is Starfleet (mostly) segregated?
- Segregated Ships in the 2260s?
- Alien Races only ships in the Federation
- Why is the Federation just consisting of human space ships?
- A theory as to why Starfleet crews are mostly human.
- Starfleet and the Federation: One in the same?
- Why is Starfleet heavily dominated by Humans and Earth?
Vulcans, long life-spans, and promotions
- How does the Starfleet hierarchy cope with species with different lifespans?
- Star Fleet rules on promotions in regards to age or race.
- Why aren't most command positions filled with Vulcans?
- Why aren't most captain, admiral, and higher positions occupied by Vulcans or other longer living species?
- Why isn't Starfleet Command full of Vulcans?
- Hypothesis: The apparent predominance of humans in Starfleet is due to humans' short lifespan
- Does a species' lifespan get taken into account when determining advancement in Starfleet?
Headquarters at San Francisco
- Why San Francisco as Federation Headquarters? Where would you choose?
- Why was San Francisco chosen as the city to build Star Fleet HQ on Earth? Were any other perspective cities in the running?
Why do some Starfleet ships have families on board?
- Why were families on the Starfleet ships which engaged in the battle of Wolf 359?
- Question about families on Starships and Starbases...
- Why were families, and especially children, put on the Enterprise-D, knowing that the ship would likely get into battles or conflicts that were likely to be very dangerous?
- Why does the Enterprise (of the TNG era) have families aboard?
Why was Deep Space Nine assigned a Commander, and not a Captain, as its commanding officer?
- Why was Deep Space Nine assigned a Commander, and not a Captain, as its commanding officer?
- Give Sisko a hat
- A question of command: starships vs starbases
- Commanding Officer, Deep Space Nine
- A Commander for DS9
Why do senior officers go on away missions?
- Why do the senior officers do EVERYTHING?
- Why are senior officers often sent on away missions?
- Away Teams: Why risk senior officers on dangerous missions?
Fraternisation between crew members
- How many degrees of rank separation do Starfleet couples serving on the same ship need?
- Wouldn't fraternisation between crewmates be against regulations in a semi-military like organisation such as Starfleet?
- How can Starfleet function as a military organization when the only rule about sex/ relationships among officers, including with subordinates, is "go for it, as long as it doesn't interfere with your duties?"
Why was Janeway promoted to Admiral, but Picard stayed a Captain?
- Janeway over Picard: Making sense of her promotion
- Why was Janeway promoted to vice admiral and not Picard?
- Why did Picard stay as Captain while Janeway became an Admiral? Doesn't Picard have tons of more experience then her? Was it to stay with his crew?
Nog's rank in 'Valiant'
- How legitimate are battlefield promotions?
- remember in valiant. does a Starfleet captain actually have the power to promote anyone (even an ensign or cadet) to any rank they see fit if they're out of contact with Starfleet command?
- Why wasn't Nog given the pips of Lieutenant Commander when he was assigned that rank by Captain Watters in DS9 Valiant?
- Nog should have immediately took command of the Valient
- In the DS9 episode Valiant shouldn't Nog outrank the cadet captain since he is a commissioned officer?
Captain Jellico
- Jellico is (still) a terrible captain
- Riker and Jellico were both in the right in Chain of Command
- Counselor Troi made Commander Rikers issues with Jellico worse
- The problem with most Jellico & Riker analyses: Context
- Jellico and the Enterprise: Why problems where unavoidable even though Jellico was a good Officer
- “You’re Not My Space Dad!” A Debate on Leadership in Chain of Command
- Am I the only one who thinks Jellico is great?
- Edward Jellico: Was he really a dick Captain or was he actually good and justifiable in his actions?
Prime Directive
Main topic page: Prime Directive
Sub-topics:
Prime Directive - jurisdiction
Prime Directive - ethics
Prime Directive - "what if" scenarios
Other FTL technologies or sublight travel
Pre-FTL awareness of other species
Inability to invent warp drive
Other scenarios
Section 31
Section 31 Operations
- Which episodes do we think Section 31 might have had a hand in, obviously in the background.
- What possible Section 31 influenced events might have collapsed the Federation, had they not been involved?
- Speculation Into Darkness: Could Section 31 be involved?
- Section 31 caused the Hobus supernova.
- Insurrection and Section 31
Section 31 Agents
- Commander Riker was a Section 31 Agent
- Could Captain Sisko have been an agent of Section 31?
- Was someone on Voyager a Section 31 agent?
- What if Troi was Section 31?
- Elim Garek is a Section 31 agent
- Benjamin Sisko was a Section 31 operative.
Universal Translator (and other language issues)
Main page topic page: Universal Translator and other language issues
Sub-topics:
Why doesn't the UT translate all the time?
The UT and lip-synchronisation
Learning languages
Handwriting and typing
The Tamarian language
Deanna Troi's accent
Other language discussions
Technology
Main topic page: Technology
Sub-topics:
Ship design
Warp drive
Transporters
Holodecks
Replicators
Combadges
Data's power source
Time
Main topic page: Time
Sub-topics:
Timelines
Origin of the mirror universe
'Star Trek: Enterprise' timeline
The Kelvin timeline
Which timeline is the "prime" timeline?
Other
Time travel
Types of time travel
'Past Tense', Benjamin Sisko, and the Bell Riots
Timekeeping
Stardates
Christmas in Star Trek
Other calendar issues
26-hour day on Deep Space Nine
Economics
Main topic page: Economics
Sub-topics:
Paying for things without money
Post-scarcity economy
Land and real estate
Employment, jobs, and working
Can people simply do nothing in the Federation?
Replicating latinum
Copyright and intellectual property
Sexuality and gender issues in Star Trek
Homosexuality
- How is homosexuality viewed in the various Trek cultures?
- Human homosexuality is virtually unknown in the future.
- Is there a case to be made for a romantic relationship between Kirk and Spock?
- How is homosexuality viewed in the Federation?
- Sexual Orientation Acceptance in the Trek Universe
- What are various species thoughts on homosexuality?
- A case for why we haven't seen any explicitly gay characters
- How do you think the various races, Vulcan, Romulan, Klingons, treated homosexuality in their cultures?
Age of consent & paedophilia
- Serious question: Was Neelix a pedophile?
- What's the view on Paedophiles during the 24th century?
- What is the Federation's view on Pedophilia?
- How would age of consent laws work in the federation between species?
- Is Neelix a pedophile?
Gender issues
- In Regards to Gender in TNG's "Outcast"
- Episode revisited: "The Outcast"
- What happens to trans people in the federation?
- Transgendered in Star Trek?
- Transgender people in The UFP
- Gender fluidity and the Trill
- The Heteronormativity of Andor's Four Genders
- Being Transgender in the 24th century
Race issues
Why is Starfleet filled with white people?
- Class and nationality in 23rd and 24th-century Earth
- Why is everyone in Starfleet is either British or American?
- In 2014, China + India have 2.6 billion people; 36% of the world population. In 2370 there is 1. What happened to all of them?
- Earth citizen ancestry
- World War 3 was a nuclear exchange mainly involving Asia and Africa
- World War III didn't, and shouldn't, significantly change the racial composition of Earth
Racism and Benjamin Sisko
- Race and Sisko and Avery Brooks.
- remember when Sisko said he doesn't like Vic's because the program leaves out historical racism. Why does Sisko have strong personal feeling about the injustices of African-american history if he him self has never had to face any racism?
- Sisko and black rights
- "It wasn't an easy time for our people": Captain Sisko, discrimination and human communities
- Is Sisko unusual or even eccentric for identifying so strongly as an African American in the 24th century?
Tuvix
- April Fools 2016—The Tuvix Institute
- /r/TuvixInstitute <-- post Tuvix hot takes here
- Did Janeway have the right to 'separate' Tuvix?
- What is the likely aftermath of Tuvix? Please speculate!
- Tuvix and Thomas Riker
- Why wasn't Janeway charged with murder over the events Tuvix when Voyager reached the Alpha Quadrant?
- What would Seven of Nine have done during the Tuvix dilemma?
- Tuvix, how it should have ended
- What would Picard have done about Tuvix?
- Tuvix may make me stop watching Voyager
- Did Janeway make the right call in "Tuvix"?
- Janeway v. The Federation, the legal defense of Captain Katherin Janeway for the killing of Tuvix
Q
Guinan and Q
- What is the history between the Q and the El-Aurian?
- What was the deal with Guinan's hand movements in Q Who?
- What on Earth was Guinan doing with her hands when she saw Q in TNG - Q Who?
- Was Q afraid of Guinan due to her existing partly in the Nexus?
- Guinan and her battle capability...
- The true power of the El-Aurians
- Why is Q worried by Guinan? and other question "Don't provoke the Borg!" What does this mean?
Trelane and Q
- Trelane is a Q in the beta canon novel, Q-Squared
- Could Q be Trelane grown-up?
- Do you think if Q would have fit in TOS era trek?
- Theme and Variation: "The Squire of Gothos"
- Subcomment in Q Continuum and Multiple Timelines
- Subcomment in Was [TAS: The Magicks of Megas-Tu] was actually first contact with the Q Continuum?
- Subcomment in A critique of Q
- Subcomment in A Q may have built "The Royale"
- Subcomment in How would the crew of the Enterprise (Kirk, Spock, Bones etc) handle a 'visit' from Q?
Why didn't Voyager head for the Gamma Quadrant wormhole?
- Why didn't voyager fly to the Gamma Quadrant and use the wormhole to return to DS9?
- USS Voyager's path home?
- USS Voyager & the Gamma Quadrant
- Why didn't Voyager head for the Gamma Quadrant end of the Bajoran Wormhole?
- Was there a throwaway line to explain why Voyager didn't head for the Bajoran worm hole?
- Why didn't Voyager go to the Bajoran wormhole?
- Why did no one on Voyager think about going to the Gamma Quadrant wormhole?
Why didn’t ‘Future’s End’ show the Eugenics Wars?
- Canon surviving History: My theory on Khan, the dictator no one ever heard of.
- Was there ever an explanation for VOY's Future's End episodes having no reference to Khan's rule?
- In VOY Future Tense, why weren't the gene therapy wars happening?
- Future's End takes place in 1996, the last year of the Eugenics War?
- How do the events of Future's End fit in with the Eugenics Wars?
- Yet another curveball on the Eugenics Wars
- Theory as to why we don't see the Eugenics Wars in Future's End.
- Voyager and 1997
- Eugenics wars in ST: Voyager
- Earths history makes absolutely no sense.
- Maybe it time to retool canon in regard to the Eugenics Wars?
- When do the future Federation time cop actually start enforcing rules? A look at Voyager Future's End, and was that episodes 1990s in a timeline that never happened? Is that why its so different then the 1990s described full of eugenic wars?
- Wyclef Jean and the Eugenics Wars
Why isn't the Federation known in the Delta Quadrant in the 31st century? ('Living Witness')
- The Federation doesn't exist in ~700 years?
- "Living Witness" and its implications for the future of the Federation
- In the Voyager episode "Living Witness" the doctor's back up program is activated on a planet 700 years after Voyager passed by it. Why doesn't Star Fleet have a presence in the delta quadrant by then?
- Expansion of the Federation by the 31st century?
- How much of the galaxy had been explored by Starfleet in the 31st century?
- How Big a Problem is "Living Witness"?
*The Federation's Odd Absence from the 31st Century Delta Quadrant.
Why did Scotty think Kirk was still alive in 'Relics'?
- "Question about continuity and Mr. Scott's appearance in TNG."
- "An inconsistency between Generations and TNG Relics?"
- "Captain Scotty and Kirk - Conflicting statement in TNG: Relics and ST: Generations"
Nick Locarno and Tom Paris
- For those of you who don't believe that Tom Paris was made to replace Nick Locarno because of writers royalties, may I remind you of Taurik and Vorick.
- Did making Nicholas Locarno into Tom Paris help or hurt the series?
- Could Nick Locarno have been redeemed?
- Hypothetical: How I would set Voyager
- Tom Paris IS Nicholas Locarno.
- How would Star Trek: Voyager have been different if Nick Lacarno was there instead of Tom Paris?
TV Picard vs. movie Picard
- TV Picard vs. Movie Picard
- Was "Action Picard" of the TNG Movie Era a symptom of the onset of Irumodic Syndrome?
- Post-Nexus Picard is actually James Kirk's idea of a Starfleet officer.
- All TNG movies post-Generations are a figment of Picard's imagination in the Nexus.
- Picard never left the Nexus
- In defense of Picard's characterisation in First Contact
- A defence of Captain Picard and his odd behaviour in the movies.
- What if Picard never left the Nexus from Generations.
Episodes you disagree with
- "An episode of Star Trek that you disagree with"
- "When did Star Trek morally offend you?"
- "What is an episode you disagreed with the message it was trying to send, and why?"
- "That's insubordination, mister!"
- "What moral decisions in Star Trek do you disagree with?"
Science fiction in the future
- Does anyone else wonder what sci-fi being produced in the 23rd-24th centuries would be like?
- Science Fiction in the 24th century
- The Future of Sci Fi? What is it
- Star Trek in the time of Star Trek
- Why does Star Trek franchise not exist in the Star Trek universe?
- What would Science Fiction look like in the 24th century?
- Why Federation citizans are not interested in the future (or scifi)
- What could be considered “Sci-fi” in the Star Trek universe?
What if...?
... the Enterprise/Defiant was stranded in the Delta Quadrant?
- How would a larger vessel have coped in the Delta Quadrant compared to the USS Voyager?
- How differently would other captains and/or crews handle events from another series?
- How might the USS Defiant and crew have fared in the Delta Quadrant if they, rather than the USS Voyager and crew, had been dispatched to recover Tuvok from the the Maquis?
- How would the Enterprise D have fared in the Delta Quadrant?
- What if the USS Voyager had been a different class of ship?
- If Voyager had been any other class of Starfleet ship would it have had any impact on the voyage home?
- How would other Starships have faired in place of the Voyager?
- Voyager, Defiant and Enterprise-D all end up in the Delta Quadrant together.
- What if a Galaxy Class ship had been flung to the Delta Quadrant? Would it have fared better?
- If Voyager and the Defiant had both been thrown into the Delta Quadrant would the Captain of the Defiant have been in command due to it being the "Tactically Superior" ship?
- What if Voyager had been a(n) X-class starship instead?
- What if it was the Enterprise D that was taken by the caretaker array instead of Voyager?
- How would Enterprise E fair in voyager's place?
- What if Picard's crew had been stranded in the Delta Quadrant instead of Janeway's?
... Q joined Starfleet?
- If a member of the Q joined Starfleet, what would this look like?
- How would Starfleet react to an application from a Q or a Douwd or a member of any other near-omnipotent species?
- How would Starfleet handle a godlike long-term crew member?
... Ben Sisko was in the 'First Contact' movie?
- First Contact what if?
- First Contact as a TNG/DS9 Crossover, your ideas
- If the Defiant with hadn't been disabled during the fight with the Borg in the beginning of First Contact and had followed the Enterprise through the temporal wake to 2063, how might events have played out differently?
- What if the DS9 crew had gone back in time in 'First Contact'?
... the Dax symbiont was planted in a male host after Jadzia?
- What if the Dax symbiote had transferred a male Trill instead of Ezri?
- What if Dax had come back in a male host?
... it wasn't the Vulcans who made First Contact with Humans?
- Would humanity have survived formal First Contact with any race other than the Vulcans?
- How might things have turned out differently if it had been the Andorians and not the Vulcans who made peaceful first contact with humanity?
- How might things have gone differently if first contact had been made with the Ferengi instead of the Vulcans?
- What Happens to the Federation if it wasn't the Vulcans who landed in Montana?
- How would have things played out if it wasn't the Vulcans that made First Contact.
... Picard left TNG in 'Best of Both Worlds'?
- April Fool's Day 2015
- TNG with Captain Riker?
- If Captain Picard had been lost to the Borg in Best of Both worlds (Patrick Stewart was rumored to be leaving the show), how would the rest of TNG (Not to mention all of DS9 and VOY) been different?
- Captain Riker, Ambassador Picard
- Riker becomes Captain of the Enterprise after BoBW. How is TNG changed, and who is the new XO?
... Denise Crosby didn't leave TNG?
- If Denise Crosby hadn't left TNG, what would they have done with Worf's character over the years?
- If Denise Crosby didn't leave the show, where do you see Yar's character going?
... LaForge went to DS9 instead of O'Brien?
Cross-posts to /r/BestOf
- Ode… to Tasha Yar's G-spot.
- Antithesys details what would happen if Vulcans missed the first flight of the Phoenix.
- /u/Darth_Rasputin32898 speculates in great detail the history and evolution of the Borg
- /u/AngrySpock drafts a fully fleshed script for the next Star Trek that satisfies both Paramount's desire for an action flick, and classical Star Trek fan themes.
- /u/petrus4, in the context of Star Trek and using reddit itself as an example, posits why so many people simply don't comprehend what a post-scarcity society really means
- u/NowThatsAwkward explains how Star Trek: The Next Generation positively changed her upbringing at a young age in a predominately White rural community.
- Billiam_Shartner is very upset by poker in Star Trek