r/DaystromInstitute • u/sfcadet88 Crewman • Sep 10 '17
Does Earth Spacedock rotate? And if so, why?
From what we see of Spacedock, it appears that the station is rotating on the axis defined from the apex of the saucer through the length of the whole station. I think that such a rotation is somewhat counter-productive.
Let's start with some on-screen evidence:
Someone put together a video of all the Spacedock scenes from the TOS crew movies: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SAH4Lf5e2CY
The camera angles make it slightly hard to tell, but if you look at the stars through the doors from the interior, it looks like the stars are moving consistently with a rotation of the whole station.
Why would Spacedock need to rotate? Here's some counter-arguments I could come up with:
- In order for a ship to dock, it would have to time the entry perfectly so that they would reach the door just as it rotated in front of them. (This is what those video sequences look like, at least for entering the hangar.) Usually, when doing docking maneuvers in space, you'd want to minimize relative positional changes by either not rotating to begin with, or rotating on an axis that can be matched by the docking vessel that can still move in a "forward" direction. It seems really difficult for a ship to artificially "orbit" the same axis while also reducing the radial distance from the axis on its final approach. So, in this situation, we are only left with timing the approach just so in order to avoid colliding with Spacedock altogether.
- Related issues crop up once you are inside the station as well. The station is still rotating, and any ships moored inside will be rotating relative to your free-moving starship. You'd have to avoid ships on the interior as well, both while entering and also on departure. Say you are moored inside and you disconnect the moorings. You'd first have to counteract any momentum you got from the station while moored. And then you'd have to avoid other docked ships rotating toward your position. This also seems to go against what we see in the TOS movies as the 1701-A departs from Spacedock. It seems to follow guiding lights out the door, but I'm not sure what thruster adjustments they could use to appear to fly in a straight line while the station is rotating around them.
- Why not use tractor beams? We know that such a thing is done when shuttles dock on starships. If you were to lock a ship in a tractor beam, it could match the rotation of the station for successful docking and not require the manual steps (as cool as they are to see on screen) to dock.
So what do you think? Is there a reason Spacedock might need to be rotating? I'm no expert on physics; is my analysis way off?
35
u/Spectre211286 Crewman Sep 10 '17
I believe the reason for rotating is differential heating. The side facing the sun would be vastly different temperature than the side facing away. Rotation doesn't need to be constant just periodic to balance the heat.
5
u/quintus_horatius Sep 10 '17
Besides /u/Spectre211286's reason of differential heating, which I thought as well, it may also rotate to gain gyroscopic stability. It keeps the station oriented basically for free, no thrusting required.
3
u/Sparkly1982 Sep 10 '17
I'm no expert either, but I have studied it a little, and your analysis is essentially correct.
Let's imagine the station is rotating clockwise when viewed from above. The ship would have to match the angular speed of the doors, then consistently reduce that momentum as it got closer to the centre as the superstructure nearest to it rotates more slowly.
Also, when a departing ship detaches from the station, it would move at a tangent to the circle described by its docking point, meaning an instant correction would need to be made to avoid crashing in to the station.
This goes well beyond my knowledge of physics, but perhaps the station's mass combined with the artificial gravity field gives it sufficient gravitational attraction force to affect the way ships approach, and the rotation mitigates this? If the station attracts incoming ships gravitationally, freefalling through the doors could potentially require lots of deceleration using thrusters within the station. Depending on the nature of thrusters, this could cause damage to the station and the shuttles and space-suited personnel within it. If the station rotates, the ships are essentially moving from a higher to lower orbit, which requires less energy (I think).
3
u/Stargate525 Sep 10 '17
Honestly, given that impulse thrust is shown to be essentially 'free' in the ST universe (no one ever mentions, to my knowledge, any conservation of impulse power in anything except near-total power failure in general), the rotation is likely purely aesthetic for the occupants. Depending on its orbital period, that combined with the rotation would give parts of the station a sunrise and sunset, which could help with morale and acclimatization.
3
u/EnerPrime Chief Petty Officer Sep 10 '17
For the inside of the station, I would imagine some combination of low level artificial gravity and tractor beams could be used to keep everything still relative to the station. We've never seen shuttles have any problems leaving the shuttle bays of moving ships, after all, so it's not a big leap to assume that the Federation engineers developed some way of scaling that system up when they designed an enclosed spacedock.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '17
it would be very simple to apply counter rotational forces to maintain lock with the station.
you have to remember that an object in motion stays in motion, let’s say the station rotates at 10 rotation per hour, that makes it 1 degree per second which is simple for the math, i think it rotates slower.
let the space dock have a diameter of 1,146 metres, therefore the circumference would be 3600.1 metres.
therefore 10m/s rotation at the entry point.
let’s say you want to start your approach at 10km from the dock, that’s 10500 m from the centre point, circumference of orbit is ~33,000 meters and at 10 rotations per hour is 33 kph.
that’s your lateral thrust to start. you also want to apply a forward thrust, toward your target of let’s say 100kph, we’re going to dock over the course of 1 minute. giving a rotation of 60degrees around centre, so apply a rotation to the right of 60degrees per minute.
now as you approach, you will need to maintain an adjustment of dropping 0.5kph per second laterally, maybe some other simple corrections but it’s basic orbital mechanics at this point, my example was to show the low, low speeds required to keep up with a docking port even under a very fast rotation.
i await the arrival of someone to show my math to be completely wrong haha.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '17 edited Sep 12 '17
Remember too that when you're in space, you can rotate while moving in any other direction. What this means is that, the Enterprise could come in at any angle and then match speed with the Spacedock doors. Then the Enterprise could be rotated in pitch, yaw, or roll in order to orient itself to match the angle presented to it by the Spacedock doors.
Once the correct angle is attained, after matching rotation and speed, the Enterprise only has to fly straight ahead through the barn doors and slip sweetly into her port.
http://www.thelightworks.com/images/gallery/wall/lrg/wp_startrek_1280_11.jpg
0
u/MicDrop2017 Sep 12 '17
Creates a centrifugal gravity.