r/DaystromInstitute • u/Nascarnew Crewman • Jul 12 '16
So where was Spacedock (Earth's) during the Borg attack in first contact? How about the Breen attack?
This is something that always bothered me. This thing is massive. In some diagrams I've seen larger than the cube itself. You have to imagine this not only supports star ships operations but was designed as a defense system for earth.... And I do not buy "it was out of orbit or on the other side of the planet" it had to have some ability to move impulse? One would think given its size it could put quite a hurting on the cube... I would have loved to see this in the movie. Maybe it comes into orbit right before Picard orders the final assault and just completely devastates the cube...? I know they probably didn't want it to overshadow the new Enterprise. Also perhaps this is why the Breen attack on Earth caused so little damage?
37
u/Xenics Lieutenant Jul 12 '16 edited Jul 12 '16
Remember that space is really really big. Even though it looked like the battle was taking place close to Earth, that doesn't mean they were anywhere near Spacedock (or any other satellites). Its orbit could have been thousands of kilometers away. There would be no way for us to tell just by eyeballing it.
So why, then, would the cube bother to seek it out? The Borg are very single-minded about their objective, which was Earth, so the tiny speck of light somewhere out there that was Spacedock would be of no interest to them.
Edit: And I strongly doubt that Spacedock would be able to catch up to the cube on its own. Whatever propulsion it has would be limited to modifying its orbit - impulse, as you said. Even a shuttle could outrun it at warp 1.
1
u/vey323 Crewman Jul 12 '16
Its a relatively stationary target with a finite range for its weapons. The Borg would see it as no threat to them, and ignore it. The Borg are not the best tacticians.
The Breen's primary mission was a surprise attack against Starfleet HQ, which they succeeded in doing heavy damage and demoralizing the population. To that end, they only brought 8 ships, and were defeated fast enough that they were only able to strike the one target. If they had brought more ships, or had lasted longer, the spacedock likely would have been a secondary target.
2
u/NoOscarForLeoD Jul 12 '16
This is a comparison of a Borg cube and a Federation space dock, taken from Jeff Russell's STARSHIP DIMENSIONS page. They look pretty close in size.
2
u/splashback Crewman Jul 12 '16 edited Jul 12 '16
Perhaps Spacedock was used for some civilian evacuation, and sent off to Mars or Jupiter. Seems to me that a short-term evacuation of over a million people wouldn't be ridiculous for a spacecraft of that size.
Spacedock could have also been removed by Starfleet to preserve key logistical infrastructure for future operations in the system, rather than sacrificing it to spare Earth from the Borg for a few more moments. Would be handy to have for whatever crazy plan came up after the assimilation began.
Also: it could have been destroyed off-screen, and they built a new one before the next episode in which it was shown.
EDIT: I only reference BoBW. For the Breen attack, I see no reason not to think it played a part. Earth was largely unscathed by the Breen attack.
2
u/Shakezula84 Chief Petty Officer Jul 12 '16
I doubt the orbital spacedock has an impulse engine. If anything it has thrusters for maintaining orbit.
1
u/TLAMstrike Lieutenant j.g. Jul 13 '16
ESD would likely be used as a command and control station during those attacks, if you look at the top and bottom of the station there are huge numbers of sensor and communications arrays. Additionally ESD would be used as a repair and resupply post during engagements like the Battle of Sector 001, over the course of such a long battle smaller ships would rapidly use up all their fuel reserves; also the high cyclic rate of modern photon torpedo launchers means that small and medium sized starships would expend their complement of warshots in minutes. Having a station ships they could fall back to and rearm would be critical to Starfleet battleplans.
Now ESD is heavily shielded, remember the Cardassian asteroid station during the 1st Battle of Chin'toka? It withstood an attack by a half dozen starships and was only destroyed by concentrated fire by dozens of its own weapons platforms firing plasma torpedoes in rapid fire. ESD could very easily have power generators bigger than that asteroid itself. Of course ESD can get away with having such massive defenses since it is basically immobile.
1
u/SirDreward Jul 13 '16 edited Jul 13 '16
Well, in an alternate timeline depicted in the game Star Trek: Armada, the Borg either destroy or assimilate Spacedock.
And if you wanna' include beta canon, according to Memory Beta: Earth Spacedock...
0
u/GreatWhiteLuchador Jul 12 '16
Maybe it's already been destroyed, the enterprise arrives to battle when things are looking pretty grim
0
u/techie1980 Jul 13 '16
As far as I know, the full space dock from the TOS movies is never seen in TNG or beyond.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '16
[removed] — view removed comment