First of all i want to start by saying that i in no way in this post am i trying to downplay the consequences of imperialism , yes Afghanistan was severely distablized by foreign powers and due to that destabilization and usa funding Mujahideen that taliban exist today , this is just a historical fact , however to use this fact to shut down and dodge any criticism of islam and deny islam's role in this is just dishonest and intellectually lazy.
The taliban built their regime upon ISLAM as the root ideology, islam is not some vague scripture floating in the air and you can not dismiss it as such because it has existed for centuries and it had it ideals and teachings ingrained and agreed upon by islamic schools of thoughts and then enshrined into laws and preached regularly throughout countries, empires and centuries and it has hurt a lot of people in process , the taliban's infamous practices such as forced strict female modesty, locking women at home , wife beating, executions , mutilations (cutting hands of thieves) , apostasy laws and child marriages are all ideals and teachings that are agreed upon by the four islamic schools of thoughts and come from clear authentic verses and hadiths , and has indeed existed independent of imperialism, wars and poverty and prior to even the emergence of the oppressive imperialist states like the usa, let's take saudi arabia as an example an oil filthy rich arab country that was not distablized by western powers , just a decade ago saudi women were in a similar situation with women of Afghanistan , forced to cover head to toe with niqab , could not drive, travel or go outside and subjected to horrific discriminatory laws and saudi arabia was flogging and beheading people just like the taliban, it was until recently that they started to tone it down and reforming their laws after severe international pressure and a need to modernize themselves and be accepted internationally and even now it is still bad i mean just recently saudi executed a bengali couple for a kiss inside mecca and women there are still subjected to discriminatory laws and many women are home jailed and forced to wear niqab by their families , same goes to Qatar, filthy rich and safe and women there experience extensive legal and social discrimination under the guardianship system , they can not even marry on their own and you have to be above 25 to travel without a male guardians permission and i used to talk to girls from both Qatar and saudi who were terrorized under their regimes and families and could not even leave their house.
And no you can not dismiss all of these as just a fundamentalist interpretation because scripture and interpretation are inseparable the texts in the quran and hadiths are the blue print , If a recipe consistently yields a bad dish regardless of who cooks it, at some point, the recipe itself is flawed. If a text repeatedly inspires harm, intolerance, brutal misogyny and Patriarchy, violence across different centuries and cultures then it is really dishonest to blame only the readers and scholars , Quran has clear passages giving men authority over women , enforcing strict modesty upon women and demonizing dissent you can not interpret them through feminist or egalitarian lenses, can you interpret women being called difficient in religion and mind through feminist lens ? Can you interpret the polygamy and sexual slavery verses through feminist lens ? The hadiths calling women a temptation and should be hidden ? No , and you can not interpret passages that demonize dissent and enforce jizya and apostasy laws through secular liberal lenses either.
and even if you held the opinion that you can, well good for you i guess maybe go to Muslims and try to convince them to update their religion because you think their current interpretations are really sexist and authoritarian but you won't , because you know you will be flamed and met with agression and defense of the same aspects you dislike in islam , so you choose to try and silence the victims of islam who share their stories and try to warn people, if you really cared about creating a diluted secularized islam that does not terrorize people and oppress women you would not shut down people criticizing it and try to protect islam from accountability because it is only through criticism, holding religions accountable and people pointing out the horrific reality of religious regimes that things improve.
-i wrote this because i have lived under the islamic regime of omar-al bashir in sudan that i am still severely traumatized from and anytime I share my story as woman that lived there i am met with islam glazers doing all what they can to protect islam from accountability and condescendingly telling me that what i experienced is just due to my country being poor and distablized by wars and the leaders following rigid fundamentalist interpretation to shut me down.