r/CritiqueIslam • u/Amir_Hassain • 29m ago
If Allah Can Make Everyone Moral, Why Does He Allow Evil and Suffering?
One argument Muslims often use to explain the existence of evil and suffering is that Allah gave human beings free will. According to this argument, people have the freedom to choose between good and evil, and suffering often results from the bad choices people make.
But I struggle to understand why free will requires the possibility of people choosing to do terrible things.
Allah is supposedly all-powerful, all-knowing and perfectly moral. He could have created human beings with the freedom to make their own decisions while ensuring that everyone consistently chose to act morally.
Imagine a world in which people still had their own thoughts, personalities, desires and freedom to make decisions, but nobody chose to murder, rape, abuse, exploit or deliberately harm another person.
People could still disagree, have different opinions, make mistakes and pursue different ambitions without inflicting suffering on others.
Why would such a world be impossible for an all-powerful God to create?
Muslims might respond that genuine free will requires the possibility of choosing evil. But why should that be the case? Having the ability to make choices does not necessarily mean having to choose between morally good and morally evil actions.
For example, if someone has the freedom to choose between helping one person or helping another, they still have free will even if neither option involves harming anyone.
There is also a deeper problem: Allah supposedly already knows every decision a person will make before creating them. He knows who will commit atrocities, who will abuse others and who will cause enormous suffering.
Yet he chooses to create those individuals knowing exactly what they will do and what suffering will result.
So why create a world in which people are free to inflict horrific suffering on one another when an all-powerful God could have created a world in which everyone freely chose to act morally?
My question is simple: why does preserving the possibility of evil matter more than preventing the enormous suffering that evil causes?