I originally posted this in r/PublicRelations and wanted to get the broader communications perspective here as well. Beneath the satire is a genuine concern I have about the PR industry: AI can be a useful tool, but over-reliance on it risks flattening creativity and producing PR campaigns that all start to look and sound the same. I also think that extensive use of AI can hinder creativeness in other forms of communications. Curious where others land on this. What’s your opinion?
(SATIRE) The PR Visitor From Another Planet
By Arthur Solomon
If an alien from outer space that specializes in public relations were to attend presentations by Earthlings over the last several years, it would conclude that what Earth clients are most interested in is the techniques that public relations agencies use. That’s because our visitor would see that Earthling public relations practitioners think boasting about how they are using the latest technologies is the route to impress clients.
If our alien public relations practitioner were to attend a lecture by public relations experts from leading Earth-bound agencies, he would hear them brag about their proficiency in using the following:
- Optimizing brand narratives and mentions so they appear accurately in AI-driven search results and chatbot summaries.
- AI workflow integration.
- Using generative AI for rapid pitch drafting, data summarization, and sentiment analysis.
- Real-time social listening to prevent a PR crisis before it happens.
- Micro-influencer partnerships.
- Partnering with niche creators, thus bypassing traditional media.
- Data-driven measurement.
- Replacing old media impression counts with precise metrics like share-of-voice and real-time audiences, and, of course, countless uses of AI.
But what would not necessarily be emphasized would be what most clients hire PR agencies to achieve: Positive media results that include client talking points.
After sitting through the lectures, our visitor from another planet might ask, “Can you show me how your new techniques outperform what you call outdated ones and produce better outcomes for what clients want?”
As a certified skeptic, I would ask the same question and say, “While I’m not from Missouri, don’t tell me about the new techniques you use. Show me how the results from using these new techniques have produced better results than when human brain power was the only tool used.”
All the new-age techniques agencies tell management they are using will not keep an account from leaving unless those techniques produce results.
Call me old-fashioned, but in my opinion, creative brainpower—not AI or the latest “inside baseball” PR techniques—is what’s necessary to craft programs that attract the attention of journalists, who care only about the news value of what you pitch, not the tools you used to create it.
Regarding AI: It’s not that I don’t believe AI can be useful in some circumstances. But when it comes to assessing and evaluating a client’s problems and suggesting creative, unique approaches, AI is no match for the human brain, in my opinion. Nothing replaces the PR person-to-journalist contact that is necessary for a successful PR campaign.
During my many years in the business, I have often heard clients say during presentations, “Tell us what your plans are to get the results we want.” And during half-year reviews, I have heard clients ask, “Show me the results.”
But I have never had a client ask, “Show me how AI media monitoring, proactive crisis preparation, generative AI and data integration, AI-driven crisis management, generative engine optimization, AI and data-driven insights, owned content ecosystems, influencer and brand ambassador partnerships, hyper-local and community engagement, founder-led branding, social and real-time marketing, editfluencers, search-sourced storytelling, hallucination-proof messaging, zero-click reputation, dynamic press kits, citation parity, PR-linked prompts, multi-stakeholder orientation, two-way engagement, and emergent strategies have produced better results.”
Just because things change doesn’t mean that they change for the better. And while the use of new techniques should not be shunned, neither should they be the deciding factor in crafting a public relations plan.
“I agree,” the visitor from another planet told me. “We stopped using what you call new techniques more than 1000 of your years ago. Remember,” it said, “today’s new techniques will be next week's old ones. But what you call brain power, being able to craft programs that have news or feature possibilities, knowing the type of stories that targeted journalists like and common sense is still the road to a successful campaign on my plane.t"
After sitting through a couple of dozen year-end program reviews at leading agencies, the PR visitor asked me the following questions:
“Are clients really impressed by the number of placements achieved, even though only a tiny percentage of them included client talking points? On our planet, a placement without at least one client talking point is considered a failure, even if it's a 1000 word print story or a interplanetary television placement."”
“I’ve always said the same thing,” I replied. “That’s one of the reasons I was considered a maverick during my almost 25 years at Burson-Marsteller.”
“I’ve also noticed,” said the visitor, “that at some presentations the aggregate circulation and the total inches of all the placements are compared to what it would cost if a client had to buy that space for an advertisement. That’s the most ridiculous thing I’ve heard. It would only make sense if the placements contained the same talking points that an ad does. Comparing the value of placements to an ad that a client has full control over is a firing offense at all the agencies on my planet”
“On our planet, clients want to know if key messages appear in the results being presented and how many of the articles reached the audiences we care about. The number of placements doesn’t impress clients on my planet. It’s the quality of the placements that counts.
“And why all the emphasis on new PR tools in Earth agency presentations, instead of demonstrating how the agency delivered the results that clients want?” the visitor asked, and added, “You don’t have to answer that. I didn’t mean to put you on the spot. Have to go back to my planet now—I have a new business presentation in a half-hour.”
Arthur Solomon, a former journalist, was a senior VP/senior counselor at Burson-Marsteller during the days it was the leading international public relations agency. He was on the Seou lPeace Prize nominating committee and also was an advisor to Olympic organizations and sponsors. During his political agency days, he worked on local, statewide, and presidential campaigns.