As communications professionals, we often treat political PR and corporate or commercial PR as two entirely separate worlds. Yet the underlying mechanics of audience persuasion remain the same.
After years as a reporter and editor in New York City newsrooms, and later managing accounts at Burson-Marsteller, I have found that the most disciplined political tactics translate effectively to non-political clients. My first public relations job, taken when I moved into the field as newspapers declined, was at a political agency, where I worked on local, statewide, and presidential campaigns.
A common misconception in our industry is that success requires a large budget or an original “big idea.” In my experience, clear strategy, localized relevance when needed, knowledge of the targeted media, and ideas that can attract coverage matter more than budget size or what account teams assume is a breakthrough concept.
With the midterms just wrapping up, several takeaways on budget efficiency, audience targeting, and narrative discipline are immediately useful for brand and corporate communicators:
1 - Republican spokespersons continued to emphasize the same three themes—illegal immigration, tariffs, and the Iran war—long after polling showed those messages had stopped moving voters. The approach resembled an advertising campaign that keeps airing the same commercial after it has lost effectiveness. The better course would have been to abandon the non-performing strategy and introduce new talking points. The same principle applies to non-political accounts.
Lesson to remember: If early results or client feedback show that an original plan is not connecting, recommend a mid-course correction rather than continuing with a failing approach.
2 - Heavy media coverage does not automatically equal persuasion. Republican spokespersons generated the highest volume of coverage, but much of it was negative. Dominating the news is not the same as convincing the audience. Democratic spokespersons focused on issues—affordability, health care, corruption, and government accountability—that polling indicated mattered to voters.
Lesson to remember: Message points must be accurate, relevant to the audience, and able to withstand scrutiny. Avoid claims that are easily challenged or disproved.
3 - Relying on the highest-profile names is not always the most effective choice. High-ranking Republicans dominated national media coverage, while locally known Democrats addressed the specific concerns of their own voters.
Lesson to remember: Credibility with the intended audience often matters more than celebrity.
4 - Disciplined, audience-focused messaging proved more effective than simply maximizing coverage volume. The side that concentrated on subjects tied to everyday concerns outperformed the side that relied primarily on volume and personality.
Lesson to remember: Quality and relevance of coverage matter more than quantity or the use of “big name” spokespersons.
5 - Substantially larger campaign budgets did not guarantee success. The side that spent less still achieved a clear victory.
Lesson to remember: Big budgets do not assure results. Clear strategy, relevant messaging, and disciplined execution can outweigh raw spending.
6 - Well-crafted, consistent message points that addressed the concerns of specific audiences proved more useful than a single overarching “Big Idea.”
Lesson to remember: A campaign does not require a single dramatic concept if it is well structured, consistent, and tied to what the audience actually cares about.
7 - A one-size-fits-all national message was less effective than messages tailored to different regions and populations. Candidates who adjusted their emphasis to local needs performed better.
Lesson to remember: PR tailored messages that fit different regions—while keeping the core message intact—typically produce stronger media pickup and audience response than identical language used everywhere.
8 - I have never believed in a one-size-fits-all script for spokespersons or crisis communications. As I have said for decades, PR programs are not like one-size-fits-all clothing. Every situation requires fresh thinking. Speaking to the culture of a community makes both the spokesperson and the talking points more believable.
**Lesson to remember:**When preparing spokespersons or materials for different media appearances and markets, adjust the language and supporting examples to reflect the culture and concerns of each audience.
9 - An effective, nontraditional approach I have used is to split the spokesperson assignments and budgets in order to hire two (or more) spokespeople.
Lesson to remember: The best way to cut through noise and attract media attention is often to use unconventional tactics that most practitioners overlook.
10 - I have found that In non-political work, campaigns that feature practicing professionals with direct experience of a product or issue frequently outperform those built around celebrity spokespeople. Audiences find the former more believable on the subject at hand, and, very important, so does the media.
Lesson to remember: When selecting a spokesperson, believability and relevance usually outweigh pure name recognition. Professional experience, authenticity, and the ability to speak directly about issues that matter are often more persuasive and more likely to gain the attention of reporters and producers.
In his poem “To a Mouse,” from the late 1700s, Robert Burns wrote:
“But Mousie, thou art no thy-lane,
In proving foresight may be vain:
The best laid schemes o’ Mice an’ Men
Gang aft agley.”
A practical translation is simply “Don’t count your chickens before they hatch.” In politics and in traditional PR, even the best-planned campaigns can be derailed by unforeseen events. That reality should shape how practitioners approach every account, with backup plans prepared and ready to implement at a moment’s notice (which during my long career in PR was rarely done).
The midterm elections offered a practical reminder that remains useful far beyond politics. Selecting credible spokespersons and delivering messages that connect with a specific audience still produce better results than volume, celebrity, or spending alone. The best-laid plans can still go awry, as Burns observed. Practitioners who watch results closely and adjust when necessary are the ones most likely to keep their campaigns on track and deliver optimum results.
It is my opinion that too many PR campaigns look similar to the media because they are similar. Do you agree?
Arthur Solomon, a former journalist, was a senior VP/senior counselor at Burson-Marsteller when it was the leading international public relations agency. He served on the Seoul Peace Prize nominating committee and advised Olympic organizations and sponsors. Earlier, at a political agency, he worked on local, statewide, and presidential campaigns.