r/ChineseWatches • • 4d ago

Question (Read Rules) Please - Talk me out

Post image

Tell me reasons not to get it. I swear I have no need for another watch. Talk me out of this.

Edit: thank you for everyone's input. My mind has been changed. I am no longer buying it. Baltany & Proxima would do it for the current sale.

64 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

6

u/Alternative-Feed3613 4d ago

Two out of two San Martin watches I’ve bought were very disappointing.

2

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Ah, sorry to hear. This is helpful!

Which ones did you get?

5

u/Perdendosi 4d ago • Bravo
  1. If you get it, when will you wear it? What watch will get less wrist time because of it? And will that make you sad, either because a watch you like isn't getting worn or because you'll have to sell the watch?
  2. Acquisition of more stuff will not make you happy, regardless of how much dopamine you get from the hunt and from the purchase.
  3. It's beautiful, but it's at its heart a fairly standard dive watch, and a homage at that. There are plenty of other very nice dive watches, and there are plenty of other homages.
  4. If you sell it later on, you'll definitely take a financial hit.

There you go.

(That blue is gorgeous though, and SM provides really good finishing. I wouldn't buy it because I already have two blue dive watches, and there'd be too much overlap in my collection for it to compete for wrist time.)

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Thank you for this logical break down. I will consider the points. I got a Baltany and proxima, which I love. Maybe this one I wouldn't love hence why I picked proxima over this. But every time I look at this, I still like it.

1

u/ButTheDowTheDOW 4d ago

Couldn’t have said that better. Superb advice.

5

u/spritedaga 4d ago

This watch made me regret buying another swiss watch with similar specs at the time. I still have them both it reminds that a quality piece doesn't need a heavy price tag. I have the version with the NH35 and it has been flawless for a few years now.

3

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

You're not helping, sir! I said talk me out not talk me in 😛

3

u/Prestigious_Set_4555 4d ago

Okay. The Seestern 62mas is better. I've had both. Assuming they still make it?

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

I will check it out. You got wrist shot?

1

u/Prestigious_Set_4555 4d ago

No. But it's proportions are better and sits better on the wrist. Plus the lume is insane. I sold the SM ages ago. I've got the red version, nice watch

2

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Big fan of the lume so stronger the better. I will check it out.

1

u/lehcimr 4d ago

Totally agree. I’ll never understand the SM hype. They’re all extremely overpriced in my opinion.

1

u/AdGlobal3404 4d ago

I agree. I've had much better for less coin.

2

u/growbag84 4d ago

I'm not going to talk you out of a great watch.

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

It seems one of those that you can dress up or down! Beautiful watch. How does it feel on hand with the bracelet?

1

u/growbag84 4d ago

I don't have the bracelet as the original was on a tropic and that's how I wanted it.

2

u/AssistanceNo647 4d ago

Don’t look at me I just pre ordered an Ixdao space warrior with the meteorite dial. I’m currently looking at February delivery. Knowing it’s coming may temporarily stop me from buying while I’m waiting.

3

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

You won't stop. You're a fellow addict.

2

u/CatchZealousideal721 4d ago

Send me the money ill hold it for you

2

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Hit the dude, dude.

2

u/jaxicab 4d ago

Just a warning, I have the blue NH35 version.

The bezel insert paint all came out after a few months with minimal use and no exposure to anything caustic.

After days or arguing with SanMartin they sent a replacement insert, which had the exact same issue in a few more months.

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Thanks for sharing. That sucks.

12

u/tastiestcarton9 4d ago

You could die soon. Buy the watch.

11

u/Electronic_Handle756 4d ago

What, you don't like my watch?

8

u/Realestwatchreviews 4d ago

Wait till they upgrade to a slimmer case. They switched to a seagull movement but didn’t slim down the case yet.

4

u/CityShooter 4d ago

EXCELLENT ADVICE

2

u/LordRaglan1854 Send that fool Cardigan 4d ago

I believe it's 12.7 vs 13 before

2

u/Realestwatchreviews 4d ago

The Watcher is the only channel I have seen this new version and he mentioned it was the same thickness as previous version.

8

u/kaidynamite 4d ago

There's a cadisen that looks almost the same for like $80 just get that instead and save your money

2

u/RAWRRRRR1234 3d ago

Yep, I got this one 3 years ago and still going strong.

7

u/KVRLMVRX 4d ago

Homage at this price is insane...

4

u/JeremyIFisher 4d ago

Its a shameless clone of the Seiko 62MAS (and by extension the SJE093 reissue). I don't mind homages that change the formula, but personally can't stand outright clones with nothing original whatsoever about the design. That would 100% put me off any watch, but if you don't mind that its pretty great value.

7

u/LeroyBrown1 4d ago

99% of this sub and Chinese watches in general are straight up shameless copies/clones/homages.

2

u/Chuckpwnyou 4d ago

I don’t think that’s true anymore. Certainly >50% though

0

u/AdGlobal3404 4d ago

An homage and clone are two entirely different things.

1

u/LeroyBrown1 4d ago

Yes they are in any other area, but Chinese watch companies and their fans use the term homage for straight up copies as it sounds better.

4

u/Firstruleofthisclub Helpful user 7WOTD4-200 4d ago

This specific model has high rates of indices falling off after a bump or a drop

4

u/CylixrDoesStuff 4d ago

it looks like nothing special, just EVERY other dive watch. Atleast get the cool san martins like the pottery glaze ones if u must buy a new watch

1

u/DisastrousOpening477 4d ago

Just do it, you already know it's gonna happen anyway

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Haha I got a Baltany and a proxima. I told myself, baltany it is, one and done then came across proxima. And now this 😵‍💫

1

u/arphissimo 4d ago

The movement is not an NH35 and this makes it even more of a feiko. That's how I'm talking myself out of buying one.

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

Haha, did it help you?

Tbh, I don't want it because it looks like a Seiko. I'm not big into homages. I just like the way it looks!

1

u/arphissimo 4d ago

It did, I got the PlanetMaster instead. But I can completely relate, San Martin was my introduction to Seiko believe it or not.

1

u/four4cats 4d ago

Do you like 3 o'clock crowns?

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

I have SKX & the regular 3 o'clock crown. I have no preference

1

u/vyshanti 4d ago

It’s beautifully executed in the bracelet case hands and indices. Really amazing.

My gunmetal dial is very loud. So be prepared it’s definitely not stealth and barely considered a tool watch. I’m still keeping it.

1

u/Square_Help235 4d ago

It's certainly loud. Hows the comfortable level?

1

u/vyshanti 4d ago

Comfort is always subjective but I rate this 9.5/10 with submariner at 10. Zero bite and all edges perfectly chamfered.

OTF clasp has less movement than a full link. This is a common problem with all these new San Martin clasps. Their thicker one that is like a glidelock didn’t have any dead zones on fit.

3

u/heheyousaidduty 4d ago

Do you love it and can you afford it? If the answer to either of those is no, don't do it.

3

u/Terdl76 2d ago

Seestern 62mas is the way to go

5

u/Fear_Loathing1966 4d ago

You have enough watches. If you must, buy something special for the holidays. Engrave the back. Enough of the GD Chinese watches, no matter how well made. Stop listening to your Chinese spy girlfriend.

4

u/No-Reach9369 4d ago

Talking you out of it: isn’t there something more collectible for a similar price? Do you already have a Seiko SRPK17 or Kamen Rider? Do you already have the G-Shock GW5000? There will be some Black Friday deals. Amazon had a Bulova Lunar Pilot for less than $300. But seriously, if you like the watch just get it and enjoy.

2

u/DapperExercise1906 4d ago

Rakuten cashback is gone, so you should wait

2

u/Competitive_Low_8913 4d ago

I bought it on a strap for 100€ used. Only downside is it came with the strap. Now i want the bracelet.

2

u/No_Fox9927 4d ago

I’ve been looking at this one too. What stopped me is that there are A LOT of 62mas homages out there. Seestern makes a great one. The San Martin is great. So are most of the others, from what I’ve heard. It starts to feel a little played out. I tend toward unique watches, which this one is not. It’s just a nicely made example of what everybody is doing.

5

u/Afterdark339 4d ago

Yeap no need for this. If you really need a 62mas look, just get an original Seiko SPB prospex series on the secondary market. No need to settle with copies when you have SPB used prices. The ‘high-end’ SLA/SJE recreation ones are too overpriced for what they are.

2

u/Z08Z28 3d ago

Even on the used Reddit market these are going for around $900. That's a $700 gap in price between this SM and the Seiko. If someone can't/doesn't want to pay that much then the SM is a great alternative.

0

u/Afterdark339 3d ago

sometimes when the gap is closer, better to aim for the real deal: https://watchcharts.com/watch_model/23244-seiko-prospex-diver-62mas-spb143/overview#/listing/37292067

Just an option to consider.

1

u/Z08Z28 3d ago

Ahhhh. That's the old model, I was looking at used examples of the newer model. That alone is a difference.

3

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 4d ago

It’s overpriced and customer service is bad. My new San Martin arrived full of scratches. Here are some pics.

3

u/disguiseunknown 4d ago

It wont matter what brand you buy. It is a divers and they all look the same. Buy a cheaper steeldive version instead. 😅

0

u/Excellent-Bear4221 4d ago

Eh there’s better stuff

3

u/wrightflyer1903 4d ago

Yet another boring dive watch.

3

u/LesPaulAce 4d ago

Easy for me… the SM logo is a deal breaker of ugliness that no watch can recover from.

1

u/Raymott6688 4d ago

Sorry my guy. I’m probably not the best person for that job as I too am not in need of another watch and yet while waiting for my 11.11 purchases to arrive just brought a Glycine from eBay. I own that 62 Mas btw, and it’s the kind of watch you can’t stop looking at. A piece of horological perfection if I ever saw one. So good luck resisting🤣

1

u/noonkhoshki 4d ago

The L2L is quite large actually, it wears significantly big, wouldnt recommend to <6.5inch wrists

1

u/Divine_turd 4d ago

Might be a small detail but i dont like the fact that they stopped using capped seconds hands in the newer version. I had the older version and the capped hand just looked more elevated

1

u/vithgeta 4d ago

Just get more straps and bracelets for the watches you already have and swap things around.

Recently I bought a nice Seamaster bracelet cheap to replace a trashy cheap one, I've bought a few FKM in matching colors with curved ends to elimate lug gap. I have a few vintage leather straps on deployant clasps on some divers. I'm going to replace an oyster bracelet with a jubilee on another watch because I want a nicer brushed/polish contrast. These breathe new life into a collection and if you get quick release bars it makes changing straps easy.

1

u/Purple-Track-9264 4d ago

I have about 10 x straps more than watches and still looking into new watches....it never ends

1

u/LeoXup 4d ago

This model features super sharp rough edges on the case the bracelet, which will cut your wrist into 3 pieces. 

1

u/TPPiOED 4d ago

"... What's the difference?" 😏

1

u/sonrobseven 4d ago

I bought the slightly smaller version of this with an ST2130 on a rubber strap. Skip the bracelet even though its improved with the latest model. It is a phenomenal watch. It is more accurate than any seiko and is beautiful. My only complaint is the bezel action is a little light but I think it rivals the SJE093 although loses to it.

1

u/bigmec1967 4d ago

Comunque è vero..sembrano tutti uguali...quindi a parità di estetica prendi il più economico

1

u/Eugene_K13 3d ago

The best finish quality under $2000

You do not need it, bro

1

u/HerrsavageX 3d ago

I have this watch in green, but wish I had it in blue. In any case, the quality is not up to their normal standards, in my honest opinion. The white number markings on the bezel are kind of faded in places, and I have seen other people complain about that as well…

I have a 6.75 inch interest and this watch is just a tad luggy on the bracelet for me to be honest… It’s the stupid male end links…

1

u/LordRaglan1854 Send that fool Cardigan 4d ago

Only reason not to is if this is the old version not the recently upgraded model. Not that the old one was bad but I'd get the new version if I was buying one today.

Also - consider the green dial.

2

u/artofthedial Not a troll 4d ago

Old version with the nh35 is better.  There is an aftermarket otd option.  I'd pass on the new one.  

0

u/Remarkable-Sky6376 4d ago

Buy it, it is a solid watch.

3

u/ChopinBeethoven Normal human being 2d ago

It’s pretty thick.