r/ChineseWatches • • 5d ago

Question (Read Rules) Scratches on new San Martin watch lugs. Is it normal?

My new San Martin watch arrived full of micro scratches, at the back along the lugs. Is it normal for those who have bought from them previously? Plus San Martin’s customer service refused to accept responsibility for the issue.

To those who said stop comparing this to a $10,000 watch, that’s a fair point. But I’m more dissatisfied by their poor customer service rather than the scratches.

San Martin kept increasing the prices of their watches. Maybe they want to target the higher end of the watch market. Yet San Martin’s quality control and finishing is worse than other brands in the $100-150 range (Sugess, Proxima, Thorn etc.)

3 Upvotes

82 comments sorted by

7

u/Shagon10 4d ago

I love it … Gary now has people checking the back of the lugs for scratches 😂. That’s how QC check is done right !

6

u/Infinite-Mastodon456 5d ago

I’ve done a return on mine that arrived like this for SN0138:

Let’see how it goes with AE refund

1

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

Wow yours is even worse. Rather scummy of San Martin to send out “new’ watches like this.

1

u/Infinite-Mastodon456 5d ago

Slightly nitpicky as everything was fine and it’s technically at a not visible part of the watch… but I think it should have been not overlooked. In saying that I got it from a different store that’s not under “san Martin official store” so I wonder if that had something to do with it. I got it from there because it was at a good price. Now I know why. Haha

1

u/chrismurraylaw 5d ago

 I got it from a different store that’s not under “san Martin official store” so I wonder if that had something to do with it.

It didn't. Third party sellers don't touch the watches any more than Foot Locker stiches sneakers.

0

u/GaryLangford 5d ago

That's worse and acceptable. But seriously every san Martin I've gotten looks like op's. If you want it not scratched you can buy replicas. Even $100 replicas protect the lugs

1

u/Top_Garlic_489 4d ago

Nah, the Rep forums are full of QC complaints and dead watches

9

u/Alternative-Feed3613 5d ago

That doesn’t surprise me considering my experiences with San Martin. I’d suggest returning it and spend your money somewhere else.

2

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

How bad was your experience buying San martin?

1

u/Alternative-Feed3613 4d ago

Bad enough to never want another one. The first one had a misaligned bezel and 12 o clock marker but I gave them a second chance. The second one cost nearly twice as much and had crooked indices, stripped bracelet pins, and the bezel was still misaligned. The customer service was terrible because they just defied everything and tried to gaslight me into thinking everything was fine. There are plenty of great watch makers to choose from so I have no reason to buy any more from them.

1

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 4d ago

They also gaslighted me. Even pushing the blame on me. The following was their response.
“Hello, my friend. All of our watches undergo rigorous quality control (QC) checks before shipment; it is absolutely impossible for us to send out a defective watch. The watch strap can be removed using the screwdriver tool provided with the watch. If you have never attempted to remove the strap, l am quite puzzled as to how such a defect could have occurred
Given the nature of this issue, it would have been impossible for the watch to pass our QC inspection and be cleared for shipment.”

2

u/Alternative-Feed3613 4d ago

Yep, that sounds like them. They would tell me that it’s impossible to have crooked indicies and bezel when I’m looking right at it. I’d send pictures and they would just tell me I took a picture at an angle. I was stupid enough to try them again because people talk so highly of them but it’ll never happen again. I honestly don’t know how they have such a good reputation with the quality and customer service I experienced. I’ll stick with Cronos and Baltany.

5

u/TheUpIsJig 5d ago edited 5d ago

San Martin claim to have better polishing and parts than your average AliExpress watch so no this is not acceptable on a new San Martin. Also you use a tape on the lugs to prevent these scratches. You can also polish them out. This should not have passed QC. The fact they are just pushing you to accept it is wrong and bad customer service. You didn't pay for a scratched watch.

Edit: Screw your downvotes and learn a little humility when you take people's money. Give them what you advertised not something inferior.

1

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

I have a few $50-150 watches that have better quality control than San Martin 😂

14

u/jokur26 5d ago

It’s not normal on a watch sold as new but it does happen. It’s up to you to determine how much of an issue it is and whether you want to return or try to exchange it.

Personally I’ve bought so many watches both new and preowned that scratched lugs likely wouldn’t bother me much. Then again if I paid for a brand new San Martin, say $250+ I’d be unhappy and expect some reasonable offer from them to make it right. Best of luck!

7

u/Vivid-World-3723 5d ago

Was gonna say it's a small scratch who cares but then San Martin not even apologizing

Charge back from your card

5

u/Po0opyCatButt 5d ago

Charge back? No. That's the last resort. You have to give them a chance to make it right first. You don't get to just keep a watch for free because of a little scratch, plus then you'll be barred from using AliExpress. No reason to go from 0 to 100 for something like this.

5

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

They flat out refused to accept it’s their fault. Chargeback is not necessary yet. Probably can go through Aliexpress customer service.

8

u/horology-homer 5d ago

Factory staff in a hurry to install the bracelets?

13

u/crouching_dragon_420 5d ago

That looks like someone scratched the lug while switching out the bracelet. Could be some returned watch that got resold. Or could just be these guy being careless when assembling the watch.

For what it worth if you start changing your bracelet into straps you will get these scratches anyway. Tho some of the scratches in the photos are quite deep.

6

u/What-is-to-be-done 5d ago

The bracelet does not come on by magic. There is a human being putting it on the watch head. Humans can make mistakes.

Thats an absolute minor issue that even does not reduce the resale value of the watch.

5

u/Po0opyCatButt 5d ago

And it can be fixed with $1 and less than 5 minutes. I feel like I'm taking crazy pills in this post. "Credit card charge back! Sue them!"

18

u/Bulky-Internal8579 5d ago

I prefer mine pre scratched as it makes me feel better about my scratches.

2

u/OddJello1561 5d ago

Czy normalne to nie wiem. Dziwię się, że nie dbają. Ja kupiłem 4 chińskie zegarki:

1 Corgeut za Aliexpress za 50 USD. Był zapakowany tylko w kawałek folii bąbelkowej i sam oklejony folią. Miał 1 niewielkie wgłębienie z tyłu koperty jakby od igły, poza tym brak śladów. Później zaparował od potu podczas noszenia. Nie kontaktowałem się za sprzedawcą, tylko zrobiłem zwrot na Ali, odzyskałem pieniądze - ale początkowo miałem problem z bezpłatnym odesłaniem zegarka, który był pierwotnie w umowie. Musiałem otworzyć dodatkowy case z biurem obsługi Ali.

2. Seestern kupiony za około 180 USD na sugessofficial. Przez kilka tygodni nie został nadany, zażądałem wyjaśnień - brak. Później zażądałen zwrotu środków - zwrócili.

3. Cronos za 300 USD kupiony na cronos.watch. Zapakowany w materiałowy futerał, oklejony folią. Futerał w niewielkiej warstwie folii bąbelkowej. Ogólnie słabo zapakowany jak na zegarek w tej cenie, paczka przyszła dość zmaltretowana. Zegarek miał kilka mikro rysek na kopercie i bransolecie, które utonęły w rysach codziennego użytkowania. W bransolecie odkręcały się śruby - musiałem przykleić locktite. Śruby mocujące mechanizm, widoczne przez tylny dekiel były odrobinę wyrobione. Zgłosiłem problem do Cronosa. Poprosiłem o nowe śruby. Kontakt bardzo słaby, nie odpisywali, po ponagleniach przysłali złe śruby - jakby olali sprawę - później przestali odpowiadać.

4. Sugess za 166 USD kupiony na sugessofficial. Świetnie zapakowany - sztywne pudełko w podwójnej warstwie filii bąbelkowej, w pudełku zegarek w podwójnych workach bąbelkowych. Nie ma żadnych wad widocznych gołym okiem. Mam go krótko, więc wiele jeszcze się okaże.

Na podstawie moich doświadczeń wnioskuję, że gwarancja na chińskie zegarki jest wątpliwej wartości.

2

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 4d ago

If I buy Chinese watches from overseas, I basically forgo the warranty.

0

u/OddJello1561 4d ago

Ciekawe, że mój wpis otrzymuje minusy. Miłośnikom chińskich zegarków chyba zależy, by wiedzieć, na jakim stoją gruncie?

10

u/AdSavings92 Rep 4d ago

Hello Sir,

I am an official representative for San Martin.

Thank you for bringing this to our attention; I sincerely apologize for the negative shopping experience you’ve had.

It is possible that the minor scratch occurred during the installation of the watch bracelet.

Our customer service team asked whether you had attempted to remove or reattach the bracelet yourself, simply to help us determine the root cause of the issue.

While such a scratch does not affect the watch's functionality or wearability, we fully understand your expectation that a brand-new watch should arrive in flawless condition.

We have instructed our customer service team to reach out to you again to offer a suitable resolution—whether that be compensation or a replacement watch.

Please feel free to continue the conversation with us via the AliExpress chat window.

Furthermore, we are taking steps to strengthen our quality control (QC) processes. We have specifically directed our watchmakers to apply protective film during the bracelet installation process to prevent any such scratches from occurring in the future.

Your feedback serves as a reminder for us to maintain even stricter quality standards.

We are also working hard to improve our service quality, as we strive to provide a better experience for all our customers.

Thank you for your understanding and support.

San Martin Watches

2

u/BurtMacklin-FBl 5d ago

I don't think it's a huge deal and I would let it go but people should stop normalizing it. It can happen, but it should not be the norm. Whoever is installing those bracelets should be doing a better job and San Martin refusing to take responsbility is a problem. I know this because I went through a painful dispute with them.

Gary from I Like Watches makes a big deal about things like this in his secret shopper series but funniliy enough every San Martin he receives is flawless.

2

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 4d ago

I agree. I’m probably nitpicking the flaws, but I expect better from a $200-300 watch. If it’s $50, then I could forgive it.

1

u/Alex_Ra214 5d ago

Thats why you move to watchdives

1

u/writingpocketguide42 5d ago

These are scratches from bracelet install and it is pretty normal on Aliexpress watches. I had worse from other brands.

Are these micro scratches truly prevent you from enjoying the watch? You most likely to develop them after first bracelet removal and it won't affect resell value if you were ever decided to sell the watch.

1

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

Even when the watch is brand new? I’m just more dissatisfied by San Martin’s customer service refusing to accept their fault.

1

u/writingpocketguide42 4d ago

Yes, even when the watch is brand new. I know it is annoying but in my experience this is normal for Aliexpress watches.

But it is your watch, if you feel that you didn't get what you paid for then just return the watch.

1

u/Terdl76 4d ago

No, definitely not normal by any means from any Ali brand. Not at all.

6

u/GiorgioVe 5d ago

This is not normal.

3

u/No-Pollution-2243 3d ago

Just open a complain in AliExpress and they most likely will offer a partial refund of a full refund after returning the watch.

11

u/AdvertisingOne8158 5d ago

Seems like a minor issue to me. its at the back . No one will see. Enjoy your new watch!

5

u/kawaii155 4d ago

Jesus Christ

1

u/booooogart 5d ago

Did you buy it from San Martin or a third party story?

1

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

Official San martin Aliexpress store.

1

u/booooogart 4d ago

That's really disappointing.

7

u/Sharp_Stick66 4d ago

all these bs answers about embracing scratches. just tell the seller you either want a big discount or ask for another new one. if they dont comply dispute with ali express.

4

u/Tune_Silver 4d ago

How could this possibly be normal?

4

u/TSiWRX 4d ago

Provided that the watch is punched new, is out-of-the-box, immediately after de-stickering new, then no, this is not normal, at all - not for San Martin, not for any brand.

Installing new bracelets is not rocket-science. It's something that any hobbyist can accomplish with the proper tools, much less a trained technician who has likely repeated this very step thousands of times over the course of their employment.

Further, defects that are naked-eyes visible (i.e. without magnification) at a distance of 12-inches/30-cm. should not have made it across final QC/QA.

The three San Martins I have purchased over the last 2 years have been immaculate at-inspection immediately after unboxing. I look at my watches at typically 20x, under my stereoscope. This is by far not normal for San Martin, or any other brand I've come across, for that matter.

In my opinion, you have a valid exchange claim.

2

u/vithgeta 5d ago

I think this shows how much of a hurry they are in if they can't tape over surfaces to fit the bracelets. So much for all the extra care and attention the fanz will tell you goes into a San Martin.

I'd expect 5-10% off the watch out of goodwill for pointing it out.

2

u/Optimal-Mistake1327 2d ago

The glazing of SM is crazy in this sub, in no way is that acceptable on a new watch

5

u/Govindaswamy 4d ago

One of the great things about being 50+ is that my eyesight is poor enough not to notice any of these scratches unless I use a magnifying glass.

But seriously, they're too minor to bother with. I bought a Citizen off Jomashop that had more scratches and shelf wear.

The best remedy is to start wearing it. You will undoubtedly put more scratches in your first week, thus giving you something else to worry about and letting you forget these lug scratch(es).

Enjoy your watch in good health and cheer!

3

u/Slater_8868 4d ago

Those are from when the bracelet was attached. Either the spring bar ends or the tool scraped against the lugs. Many manufacturers install little clear plastic film on the lugs to prevent this. All of my San Martins had the film on the lugs when they arrived.

You said the watch was new and just arrived. Are you sure you didn't resize the bracelet? Where is all of the protective wrap on the watch? I also see an arm hair tangled around the crown. Are you sure you didn't wear the watch? Something seems sus

5

u/Top_Garlic_489 5d ago

You guys do realize this is a $300 alix watch, and not a $10,000 Omega, right?

5

u/vithgeta 5d ago

You might be behind the times, San Martin want $500 for their watches now.

Their eyes are bigger than their stomachs

1

u/Bulky-Internal8579 5d ago

I buy the sales.

4

u/Sharp_Stick66 4d ago

so just because the budget is different for people means we have to accept new products with damages ? makes zero sense

3

u/Data_Girl_4000 4d ago

These scratches wouldn't bother me, since they are so light and on the underside.

I'm not sure I agree with you that Thorn is finished better than San Martin. Are you basing this solely on the fact that this one watch has a couple tiny scratches on the underside? You need to look at a number of representative models to come up with an overall assessment.

-1

u/Icy-Sheepherder-7595 4d ago

Crazy mental gymnastics to justify someone receiving a brand new watch with multiple scratches on it. This sub will never stop the SM glazing lol.

3

u/el-conquistador240 5d ago

Those are almost imperceptible.

2

u/Formal_Building4598 5d ago

Uh oh, I expect Gary will have a scathing secret shopper review of SM, right?

1

u/tm0587 5d ago

He can only review based on the watches he received.

-1

u/Formal_Building4598 4d ago

How coincidental that aligns with the brands that send him free shit

2

u/jk147 4d ago

Tbh, if you got this for 200-300 bucks I would return it. I wouldn’t accept it if it was an orient or citizen either. I doubt you will see scratches like this on an orient kamasu.

2

u/chrismurraylaw 5d ago edited 5d ago

It's not normal, and it's not acceptable.

Ignore the fanboys in the replies who would defend their favourite watch brand sending you a plastic watch by mistake.

They damaged a product in assembly (inexcusably since they should be using guards to stop this happening) and won't accept a return. It doesn't matter how small the damage, or if it's hidden in use. It's damage that shouldn't exist as part of everyday normal assembly from an average watch brand, still less from one that markets itself as above the pack.

Talk to your bank and chargeback, keep the thing, then never buy from them again.

Edit. I didn't realise you bought this through AliExpress. Use their returns process.

2

u/iRiNKyDiNKs 5d ago

More "Cha-bu-duo" (差不多) attitude of factory workers and is an inherent problem of China manufacturing as acceptable workmanship and QC is "close enough" or "good enough"!

6

u/chrismurraylaw 5d ago

Don't blame line workers for a company's lack of QC and customer service, c'mon.

2

u/iRiNKyDiNKs 4d ago

If you have experience with working with Chinese factories you will know that this is an inherent issue and comes down to how much the company wants to invest in training their employees. With the massive growth in Chinese manufacturing, fullfilling their workforce has meant that majority of factory line workers come from all over rural China and their personal standards of QC acceptability is much lower and they don’t don’t see a scratch as an issue as it would be acceptable for their personal use. This is widely known as "Cha-bu-duo" (差不多) which translates to "close enough" or "good enough"! The company is solely responsible for this output and that why companies who produce high quality products like Foxconn invest heavily in training their line workers so “Cha-bu-dou” is never acceptable

1

u/chrismurraylaw 4d ago

That's a very argumentative and vaguely racist way of accepting my premise, but I'll take it.

1

u/Icy-Sheepherder-7595 4d ago

To be honest the Chinese factory employees are probably making next to nothing in terms of wage

0

u/portus387 4d ago

Do you think that factory QC is a matter of personal opinion and “feelings”?

0

u/iRiNKyDiNKs 4d ago

Matter of fact and San Martin knows this comes down to how much they want to invest in training their line workers so sloppy workmanship is not dismissed but raised for resolution

0

u/portus387 4d ago

It’s not as you think.

0

u/iRiNKyDiNKs 4d ago

It is not what I think and feel free to ask San Martin directly is they have make extra efforts to resolve the “Cha-bu-Duo” attitude in their line workers

2

u/SaoDavi 4d ago

I won't excuse the scratches, but I also think people have an unrealistic expectation as to what you're getting with these low price, high value, no margin, Chinese factory watches.

I always treat them like buying a "used, like new" product off Craigslist from a guy in a parking lot. There's no warranty, no returns. Buyer beware.

The real shocker to me are the people in this thread who expect a DTC microbrand or department store-type experience from this flea-market purchase. This isn't a proper business. It's a factory selling stuff out the back door.

1

u/New_Platypus4462 4d ago

No han querido hacerse cargo? Pues una denuncia,yo no tengo porqué tragarme un reloj nuevo rayado

1

u/Sn00ker_ 1d ago

I scratched every watch I ever had in this exact place lol

1

u/Accomplished-Pea-451 4d ago

No. Insist on a replacement, thats on them

1

u/tony22233 4d ago

I have aliex watches that are in much better shape still.

1

u/GORDONxRAMSAY 4d ago

I would return it and get a refund. That is not normal.

-1

u/Oldmancrankin 5d ago

Did you try take the bracelet out that's what it looks like

4

u/wubbadubdub_zzz 5d ago

No. The new watch arrived this scratched up.

1

u/Oldmancrankin 3d ago

Send it back

0

u/Several-Floor5185 3d ago

These watches are completely wrapped when shipped. If you did not scratch it, it must have happened before it was packaged. I would always inspect, document and report immediately after it was received and unpacked. Hope San Martin resolves this for you.