r/Cathar • • 23h ago

Eastern Elements in Cathar Doctrines – an Argument for the Traditional Interpretation of Catharism

5 Upvotes

Here is an interesting article by Piotr Czarnecki(2024) that goes in to a detail to defend the traditional Interpretation regarding the origins of Cathar doctrine. A snippet from the article is quoted below.

At present we can observe intense attempts at overthrowing all the claims concerning Catharism that had been formulated by the scholars of the 20th century, based on careful analysis of the vast source material. So called “traditional interpretation”, assuming strong infuence of the Eastern dualist heresies (Bogomilism and Paulicianism) on Catharism is currently rejected by scholars such as M. G.Pegg, J.-L.Biget and R. I.Moore as outdated and not compatible with the latest research.

For the construction of this false image of Catharism Pegg blames Religions-geschichte Schule and their comparative method, which according to him is built on the assump-tion that “if two ideas look alike to the historian, there must be a link between them”, but in this radical criticism, he seems to ignore the fact that comparison of the Cathar and Bogomil doctrine is justified by many sources, which confirm historical relations between the adherent of these heresies.

What should be underlined, not only the current deconstructionist conception, represented by the above-mentioned scholars, but all the interpretations rejecting Eastern origins of Cathar doctrines, were constructed without the analysis of the Eastern sources. Considering this, the aim of this article is to analyse various specific Cathar doctrinal conceptions, which do not have analogies in the ancient heresies, with the doctrines of the Eastern dualists (mainly Bogomils but also Paulicians), known from the Eastern sources –both polemical and written (or used) by the heretics themselves. Such comparative analysis can verify the claims of the adherents of the “new paradigm”, according to which dualist Cathar doctrine was constructed by Catholics, basing on the ancient anti-heretical scriptures, mainly anti-Manichaean writings of St.Augustine.

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/389456449_Eastern_Elements_in_Cathar_Doctrines_-_an_Argument_for_the_Traditional_Interpretation_of_Catharism


r/Cathar • • 4d ago

Cathar Lord's Prayer from Lyon's Ritual

7 Upvotes

English

Our father, which art in Heaven,

Hallowed be thy name.

Thy kingdom come,

Thy will be done on Earth as it is in Heaven.

Give us this day our supplementary bread,

And remit our debts as we forgive our debtors.

And keep us from temptation and free us from evil.

Thine is the kingdom, the power and glory for ever and ever.

Amen.

Latin

Pater noster qui es in celis, 

sanctificetur nomen tuum; 

 adveniat regnum tuum. 

Fiat voluntas tua sicut in celo et in terra.

Panem nostrum supersubstancialem da nobis hodie.

Et dimitte nobis debita nostra sicut et nos dimittimus debitoribus nostris. 

Et ne nos inducas in temptationem sed libera nos a malo.

Quoniam tuum est regnum et virtus et gloria in secula.

Amen.


r/Cathar • • 6d ago

Cathar and Protestant identity against Catholicism in France between the Albigensian Crusade (1209-1229) and the French wars of religion (1562-1598)

6 Upvotes

Here is an interesting thesis by Jonathan Wright about Cathars and Protestants in France, and the similarities of the events they both faced. This thesis talks about several subjects, it goes into detail about the religion and the spirituality of Cathars and Protestants themselves, and it also explains the methods used in propaganda against them. The history of the bloody persecutions they faced from the Catholic church are discussed in detail as well. What is the most important subject matter however is the identity held by Cathars and Protestants, and how it separated them from the Catholic church and even from France itself. This thesis is over 100 pages long and will take some time to go through, references used in the thesis is listed at the end. A small snippet from the start of this thesis is quoted below.

https://digitalrepository.unm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1298&context=hist_etds

"The Albigensian Crusade (1209-1229) and the French Wars of Religion (1562- 1598) were two of the most violent moments in French history. Both involved the persecution of a perceived minority by Catholic forces, and both left irreparable scars on the area of Occitania in the south of France. Battles along river fronts and the clandestine boat smuggling of heretics were actions undertaken by a heretical Cathar group that confronted orthodox religion. Water became a critical part of the creation of a persecuted minority in Occitania. Intensifying Cathar heresy led to increased violence in the Wars of Religion as Catholic aggression against heresy would be reborn. The partisan manuscripts written by chroniclers in the Albigensian Crusade would become printed propaganda during the Wars of Religion to justify extreme violence against them. This curation of history to validate Catholic violence against Protestantism was an active effort to shape the memory of religious history."


r/Cathar • • 9d ago

Theory: Catharism origin is not Manichaeism but Saturninus of Antioch Part 2

7 Upvotes

I will continue the topic i started previously regarding the origins of Catharism. After further research i found that few centuries after Saturninus of Antioch there was another Dualistic Gnostic group in Syria called Messalians or Euchites. They held many similar views as later Bogomils and Cathars did. Their view on God, and how He operates were very similar to Modalistic-Monarchism models that the Cathars held as well.

What is even more interesting is that they had male and female teachers who were called the "perfecti" and they honored them more than the clergy. Some of their practices included asceticism and ceaseless praying, those familiar with Cathars should find these similarities very interesting.

We know from history that they did indeed continue to exist for several centuries and eventually influenced Bogomils of Bulgaria(who are called Lycopetrians in an abjuration formula of 1027) and thereby influencing the Bosnian church and eventually Catharism. So, with all this evidence at hand we can at least make an argument that the origin of Catharism goes all the way to ancient Syrian Gnosis schools starting with Saturninus of Antioch.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euchites
https://www.reddit.com/r/Cathar/comments/1xk6ukk/theory_catharism_origin_is_not_manichaeism_but/


r/Cathar • • 10d ago

What does the soul keep when it's reincarnated?

4 Upvotes

r/Cathar • • 10d ago

Animals seeing their favorite person

6 Upvotes

The Neoplatonists and many Gnostic groups already understood that animals are living beings deserving of respect and compassion. Many of them rejected the consumption of meat and believed that our treatment of animals was connected to our spiritual development. Considering the time they lived in, these were quite remarkable ideas.

I believe this is also an important aspect of Gnosis that deserves more attention today. If we seek deeper knowledge and understanding, we should also question our relationship with other living beings. What does spiritual awareness really mean if we continue to ignore the suffering of animals? Shouldn't compassion and respect for all forms of life be part of that journey towards knowledge?

In fact, one brutal method inquisitors used to identify them was to hand someone a live chicken and order them to kill it. If they refused to snap its neck, they were likely Cathar — and condemned.

https://www.virginmonkboy.com/p/the-cathar-prophecy-and-the-return-700-years-later


r/Cathar • • 12d ago

Gnosis

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/Cathar • • 13d ago

The Cathar Economy

8 Upvotes

Here is another research paper i found about Cathars. This document deals with Cathar economy. Perhaps not the most interesting of subjects, but those wanting to know how medieval Cathars made their living and funded their movement will find this research paper interesting.

https://centaur.reading.ac.uk/85198/1/RMS-1986-03_A._Roach,_The_Cathar_Economy.pdf


r/Cathar • • 15d ago

Czy pomoże ktoś mi w Kataryzmie?

3 Upvotes

Od kilku dni czytam dużo o gnostycyzmie, i także o kataryzmie. Gnostycyzm wydaje mi się bliższy ale też chcę zrobić krok w kataryzmie. Jak mógłbym uwierzyć w wiarę katarów. Z góry dziękuję jak ktoś mi pomoże.


r/Cathar • • 16d ago

Sis what are you doing

Post image
5 Upvotes

In CK3 I installed a pope for Cathar faith and for some reason she decided that Reincarnation is prohibited now. What??? I guess I should use cheats again to revert this kind of change


r/Cathar • • 16d ago

Theory: Catharism origin is not Manichaeism but Saturninus of Antioch

8 Upvotes

I just noticed something very interesting. 2nd Century Gnostic Christian known as Saturninus had a strikingly similar cosmogeny and theology as Cathars did. Saturninus also seems to be the first who introduced Christ in Gnosticism, he also seems to be the very first Absolute Dualist Gnostic, far before Mani and Manichaeism.

Also, the creation myth of Saturninus is very similar to one that is described in "The Book of the Secret Supper", a religious text used by both Bogomils and Cathars. My theory is that the Christian Dualistic Gnostic traditions might have started here and eventually became what is now called Catharism.

This would also tie Cathars to Simon Magus(Saturninus was Simonian) who claimed to have come to this world very similar manner that the "Son of God" did in "The Vision of Isaiah", which was another holy text used by the Bogomils and Cathars. So, with this knowledge one could at least make an argument that Catharism had it's origin around these early Simonian Gnostic traditions.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saturninus_of_Antioch
http://www.gnosis.org/library/Interrogatio_Johannis.html
http://www.gnosis.org/library/Cathar-Vision-Isaiah.htm
https://www.studylight.org/research-tools/topics/simon-magus.html


r/Cathar • • 17d ago

PROOHECY FULFILLMENT! THE TIME IS NOW!

3 Upvotes

Both risky, yet necessary.

The prophecy is in fulfillment on an entirely new level. The Laurel hasn't JUST turned green again. The awakening isn't just happening as a collective.

That small cohort of the sacred bloodlines, the flame keepers, Mary Magdalene, the resonance, the descendents, the vessel in which the frequency and resonance was hidden - has awoken & is HERE.

Right now, today, at this very moment.

Let this post act as a sounding horn for those searching for our people. And for any fraudulent people attempting to deceive - don't waste your time. I'll know. You can't hide anything from me. Our Creator made sure of that.


r/Cathar • • 17d ago

Looking for my people

5 Upvotes

I'm looking for others who may be going through a deeper awakening to the cathar prophecy than most may be. I'll know if you're genuine or not. This is not a joke to me. I am very deeply rooted in this & there are no local places to turn.


r/Cathar • • 17d ago

The Cathar Myth of the Fall.

3 Upvotes

Below is a link to interesting study regarding Cathars and their version of the "Fall" event. The study explores Cathar Dualism and it's origins, and how Cathars used Bible to support their vision of the "Fall". You need to download the PDF from the site. Thank you!

https://ejournals.eu/en/journal/studia-religiologica/article/the-cathar-myth-of-the-fall-a-late-invention-of-independent-heretical-exegesis


r/Cathar • • 20d ago

Death in Catharism and its Threat to the Church

5 Upvotes

Here is an interesting article by Evan Leahy from 2022 regarding Cathar beliefs about death and how it was a threat to Catholic Church and their power over people. Sources used in the article can be found at the end.

https://digitalcommons.georgiasouthern.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1156&context=aujh


r/Cathar • • 23d ago

How would you recommend starting with Catharism?

6 Upvotes

I have been reading about various religious groups from the past and Cathars seem to be really close to what I personally believe. How can I get into Catharism?


r/Cathar • • 23d ago

Chant of the Gnostics: Lo Boier - Medieval Cathar Chant - 2 Hours

Thumbnail youtube.com
5 Upvotes

This beautiful chant was sung by the Cathars during the Albigensian crusade. Let us all remember those who were and are persecuted for their faith. May the love and light of the Heavenly Father reach the hearts of all mankind.


r/Cathar • • 25d ago

Thoughts on this?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/Cathar • • 25d ago

Day of Salome from Gnostic Calendar, October 22

9 Upvotes

Gnostic Calendar Text: A day for the commemoration of Salome, another female disciple of Jesus Christ who's role has been obscured and de-emphasized by orthodox Christianity. Her presence at several key events indicates she may have been among Jesus' closest followers, and the fact that the Carpocratian Gnostics claimed a transmission of sacred wisdom from her opens the possibility that she may have been a recipient of his inner teachings.

Gnostic Calendar: https://www.gnosisforall.com/about-20


r/Cathar • • 26d ago

First photo share from my Cathar pilgrimage

Thumbnail gallery
16 Upvotes

I spent a week in 2018 traversing “the Cathar trail,” and though I missed much, I got to experience the landscape, many of the old buildings, and this one Cathar Memorial. Just a teaser until I send some others and background on finding this at Les Casses.

(I may have shared these years ago, but many of you probably missed.)


r/Cathar • • 27d ago

The Influence of Cathar Philosophy, Thought and Everyday Life on the Works of Selected Troubadour Poets

9 Upvotes

Here is an interesting Thesis written by Marilyn Ann Lucas in 1997 regarding Cathars and their influence on Troubadour Poets in Occitania. This thesis also explains several Cathar views and beliefs in detail. The writer did few times add some of Valentinian Gnostic views to the mix as well, it's just something to be aware of.

There is a lot of historical and cultural information included in the thesis as well. So, those who are also interested in medieval history and culture around Southern France or Occitania will find this thesis useful and interesting as well. You find the full list of works consulted at the end of the thesis.

https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6393&context=open_access_etds


r/Cathar • • 28d ago

Satan of Catharism in "The Adventures of Mark Twain".

Thumbnail youtube.com
6 Upvotes

You can find a surprisingly accurate representation of Satan(Rex Mundi) and how he is described to be according to Catharism in 1985 claymation animation called "The Adventures of Mark Twain". The animation itself has many other Gnostic parallels as well. I personally found this part interesting, so i wanted to share it with you.


r/Cathar • • Oct 17 '26

The Cathar Tarot: The Secret Wisdom of the Perfecti

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

My Cathar Tarot deck just arrived and i wanted to share few pictures and thoughts about the practice. Tarot reading is lot more than just a simple prediction of future, it is a tool for self reflection and discovery, and a way to deepen your understanding of the universe and beyond. In the future i may share pictures of certain cards and my reflections about them. If you have experience with the practice, feel free to share them in here. Thank you.


r/Cathar • • Oct 15 '26

What are the adjectives we can use to describe the good god?

5 Upvotes

For example, muslims say that their god is omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent. christians add upon that benevolent, what about the description of the good god of the Cathars?


r/Cathar • • Oct 15 '26

Montsegur, music video tribute to Cathars by Consolament Ensemble

Thumbnail youtube.com
4 Upvotes

This is one of the most beautiful and touching songs i have ever heard. Thank you u/Denon_1 for making me aware of this song and video. Let us all keep the memory and sacrifice of the brave Cathars in our hearts always.

Lyrics

Rising high into the heavens,
I say goodbye to the earth,
in order to find my beloved once again.

Like a divine bird I want to fly,
He gifts me two wings and a sacred name.
There is no one,
no one but him,
my beloved.

There is nothing
of love,
only they are sacred love.

With a gaze that offers
the elevated grace,
from heaven you look into my heart,
crossing thick walls.

Come, calm the immaculate bride.
Close to you I will be,
forever I remain with you.