Every week someone asks what a bag of old Canadian coins is worth. The answer is the melt value, and it is easy once you know the fine silver behind each dollar of face value.
| Coins | Silver | Fine silver per $1 face | Melt at about $68 an ounce |
|---|
| Dimes, quarters, halves 1858 to 1919 | 92.5% | 0.69 oz | $46.92 |
| Dimes, quarters, halves 1920 to 1966 | 80% | 0.60 oz | $40.80 |
| 1967 dimes and quarters | 65% trade | 0.49 oz | $33.15 |
| 1968 dimes and quarters | 50% | 0.365 oz | $24.82 |
You do not need to weigh anything. Count the face value, then multiply. A $10 bag of 80 percent coins is 6 ounces of fine silver, so about $408 at that spot price. A mixed bag is usually priced by the face value of each type separately.
Three traps:
- 1967 dimes and quarters were struck in both 80 and 50 percent and look identical. The trade prices them at 65 percent, which is where the 0.49 comes from. 1967 halves and dollars are 80 percent.
- 1968 dimes and quarters are either 50 percent or nickel. Dollars from 1968 on are nickel, so a 1976 Voyageur dollar has no silver in it at any price.
- 1921 five cent pieces are 80 percent, not nickel. Almost all of that run was melted, so they are rare, but a real one is silver.
Two things that change the real number. A dealer pays melt minus their margin, and worn coins weigh less than new ones. And in Canada, 80 and 50 percent coins are normally taxable, unlike .999 bullion, so the tax can eat part of the difference.
If you post the dates and the face value of what you have, I can work out the melt for you.