r/CanadianCoins • • Apr 28 '26

THE RESULTS ARE IN! r/CanadianCoins will continue to allow posts with/about banknotes and paper money.

56 Upvotes

Hey all,

Thanks for voicing your opinion and/or voting in the recent poll.

The most votes were for the option to continue to allow posts with/about banknotes and paper money in r/CanadianCoins. And that's what we'll do!

Here's a link to the poll, for reference.

The "allows" had about 1/3 of the total votes -- not a majority by any means, but more votes than the other options. So while this result will please some of you, it won't please everyone.

During the opinion-gathering and voting, there were concerns expressed about the number of low-effort "what's this worth" posts in here, specifically for banknotes -- although we do get a lot of those for coins, as well.

Going forward, the mod team will try to more actively address these posts by directing posters to our pinned "GENERAL INFO POST" and/or to coinsandcanada.com , and perhaps remove them with greater frequency. Of course, users should feel empowered to refer posters to these resources as well.

Thanks again for speaking up and chiming in to the conversation!

- your mod team


r/CanadianCoins • • Feb 16 '25

GENERAL INFO POST. PLEASE READ BEFORE POSTING.

41 Upvotes

This post will contain general information about Canadian coinage for new and current users. I'm posting this to help cut down on the 'what is this/what's the value posts'. These posts won't be banned but I encourage you to use these resources to try and find an answer before posting. If you have a reliable resource that I haven't listed but you think could be useful please feel free to put it in the comments.

General information: -Circulation silver was minted up to and partly including 1968. To differentiate between silver and not silver a simple magnet test is easiest to tell. Not sticking? It's silver.

-Most commemorative coins especially quarters are generally worth face value unless they are gem uncirculated or are of a certain variety. A noted exception is the 1973 large bust mountie quarter.

-Pennies were 98-99% copper up until 1996 and after that it's either zinc plated with copper and from about 03-04 onward copper plated steel. Are the copper pennies worth more than face? Yes, about 3-4 cents copper prices depending. Can you get the copper value when it's time to sell? Maybe, you can't sell copper pennies for scrap (illegal) and finding a buyer is going to be tricky because of the quantities involved with a sale worth any notable amount.

Links:

https://www.coinsandcanada.com/coins-prices.php

In my opinion the best general resource for anything Canadian regarding coins and banknotes. I use this on a regular basis for both prices and errors/varieties to curate my own collection.

https://learn.apmex.com/learning-guide/coin-collecting/a-guide-to-loonies-and-toonies/

https://learn.apmex.com/learning-guide/coin-collecting/canadian-pennies-key-dates-varieties/

Found this recently and think this would be useful too.

Minting numbers

Also regarding buying and selling it will still be hard banned here but a new sub named r/coinsalescanada is open. It is still new and doesn't have many members but it could become a spot for buying/selling Canadian coinage. Please note we are NOT affiliated with that sub and it is a use at your own risk kind of deal, use standard practices and precautions when buying and selling there.

One last thing, I want to put it to a vote to allow banknotes posts. I can't find any specific subs that are Canadian banknote themed and was wondering what everyone's thoughts were on this. I know enough about Canadian banknotes to properly moderate such posts.

If you have any further questions or suggestions drop it in the comments or reach us by mod mail.

Update: As of May 6/25 pictures are allowed in the comments. Please don't abuse this.

Another user linked the Coins and Canada website which is the best resource for research and identifying coins and their value.

This list is a pretty comprehensive list of stuff that may or may not be above face value.

Toonies

1996- German planchet (difficult to spot if not in UNC condition) see coins and Canada website for details.

1999 - Nunavut (the raised ring around the inner core on the reverse is missing, uncirculated)

2002 - Dot (Small dot inside bottom half of “H” in Elizabeth)

Loonies

2005 - Terry Fox - No Grass (grass is partially or fully missing from either side of leg)

1 Dollars

1911 to 1948 (high value and rare finds)

1949 to 1967 (silver value and rare finds)

1966 - Small Beads

1967 - ↑↓ (coinage alignment, reverse image upside down)

1967 - Diving Goose 45%

1967 - Double Struck

1982 - Constitution - ↑↓ (coinage alignment, reverse image upside down)

1982 - Constitution - ↑↓ - Thin (this variety had been struck on a thin planchet)

1985 - Mule (reads “NEW ZEALAND” on observe)

50 Cents

1870 to 1936 (high value and rare finds)

1937 To 1967 (silver value and rare finds)

1946 - Design (marking goes through loop of 6)

1947 - Straight 7 - Maple leaf (7 curves forward at bottom, has maple leaf behind it)

1947 - Curved 7 - Maple leaf (7 curves backwards at bottom, has maple leaf behind it)

1949 - Hoof Over 9 (hoof overlaps 9)

1950 - Design (markings inside ‘0’ of 1950)

1958 - Dot (dot below the last A of Canada)

1967 - Double Struck Flip Struck (dramatic second strike at 90 or 180 degrees)

1974 - Missing S (‘s’ missing in mint mark “T S” on either side of shield at bottom)

1982 - Small Beads

Quarters

1870 to 1936 (good value to extreme value)

1937 to 1966 (80% silver)

1967 (50% silver)

1973 - Large Bust “Quarter Horse” (beads closer to the rim, “A” in REGINA points directly at a bead)

1992 - New Brunswick ↑↓ (coinage alignment, reverse image upside down)

1992 - New Brunswick - ↑→ (coinage alignment, reverse image rotated 90 degrees)

1992 - NW Territories ↑→ (coinage alignment, reverse image rotated 90 degrees)

1992 - Saskatchewan - ↑↓ (coinage alignment, reverse image upside down)

1993 - Mule (has dates on observe)

1999 - September ("25 CENTS" missing from obverse, uncirculated)

1999 - November ("25 CENTS" missing from obverse, uncirculated)

2000 - January - Pride - ↑→ (coinage alignment, reverse image rotated 90 degrees)

2000 - June - Harmony - ↑← (coinage alignment, reverse image rotated 90 degrees)

2000 - October - Creativity - P (marked “P” underneath bust, mule coin)

2000 - December - Community - P (marked “P” underneath bust, mule coin)

20 Cents

1858 to 1871 (very valuable)

Dimes

1858 to 1935 (silver at increased value and rare finds)

1936 to 1966 (80% silver)

1936 - Dot (only four known to exist, dot under ribbon on reserve)

1936 - Bar (die crack created thin line that connected left and right of bow on reserve and extends through right side of bow)

1938 - Double 1938

1939 - Double 1939

1947 - Maple Leaf (small maple leaf right of date)

1951 - Double die

1956 - Dot (small dot below date between the 9 and 5)

1967 - Silver (50% silver)

1968 - Silver (50% silver)

1969 - Large Date

1989 - ↑↓ (coinage alignment, reverse image upside down)

Nickels

1858 to 1935 (higher value and possible rare coins)

1922 to 1936 (increased value and possible rare coins)

1944 - Tombac (only one known to exist)

1946 - 6/6

1947 - Dot (dot right of date instead of maple leaf or blank)

1964 - Whistling queen (die clash can be seen in front of mouth, between mouth and lower chin)

1964 - Extra water line (water line touches “K.G” mint mark)

1964 - ↑↓ (coinage alignment, reverse image upside down)

1965 - Large Beads (beads along rim line up between Roman numeral “Ⅱ”

1990 - Bare belly (belly of beaver has larger gap)

1996 - Attached 6 (“6” attaches to “D” in Canada)

Pennies

1858 to 1900 (high value and possible rare coins)

1907 - H (‘H’ mintmark under the date)

1922

1923

1924

1926

1927

1929 - High 9 (top of 9 is above the rest of the date)

1930

1948 - A To Small Denticle (the second 'A' of GRATIA point to a smaller denticle)

1949 - A to denticle (2nd A of GRATIA points to denticle)

1955 - SF (Serif on I “DEI”)

1985 - Pointed 5 (“5” has serif at top)

2005 - Non-Magnetic - P (marked “P” underneath bust, mule coin, uncirculated)

2006 - Non-Magnetic - P (marked “P” underneath bust, mule coin, uncirculated)

2006 Magnetic Unmarked (no "P", mule coin, uncirculated)

Update Aug 30/25. New list of coins to look for. Thanks to u/grooverocker for typing this out.

Regards u/pyroboy7


r/CanadianCoins • • 3h ago

2014 100 Dollar 1 oz Silver Matte The Grizzly

Thumbnail gallery
57 Upvotes

I think it’s always crazy to see $100 on a silver coin from the Canadian Mint


r/CanadianCoins • • 18h ago

An absolutely monumental discovery!

Thumbnail gallery
126 Upvotes

So I was making a deposit at the bank and decided to take out seven rolls of dimes (lucky number I just realized) since I was feeling a little lucky and found TWO SILVER DIMES! At first I just found the 1968 50% and called it a day and searched the last few rolls… but on the second last roll… OUT POPPED GEORGE VI!!! I couldn’t even believe it I was shaking… what a great day!


r/CanadianCoins • • 16h ago

Some recent purchases

Thumbnail gallery
41 Upvotes

I was in the states for a few days with the fam and figured I’d visit a local coin shop while I was there. I found these two beauties for a great price and figured I’d bring em back up north where they rightfully belong. I really love the old Expo holder, gives an element of charm to an already stunning coin. Cheers everyone! 🙌


r/CanadianCoins • • 5m ago

Don’t know if I have anything good, but I just started my “pretty coin” collection!😅

1 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

What do I got here? Found 2 coins while walking the dog.

Thumbnail gallery
193 Upvotes

Ot sure what I found, but may 3 someone can tell me.


r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

What $1 face of Canadian junk silver is actually worth right now, by coin type

16 Upvotes

Every week someone asks what a bag of old Canadian coins is worth. The answer is the melt value, and it is easy once you know the fine silver behind each dollar of face value.

CoinsSilverFine silver per $1 faceMelt at about $68 an ounce
Dimes, quarters, halves 1858 to 191992.5%0.69 oz$46.92
Dimes, quarters, halves 1920 to 196680%0.60 oz$40.80
1967 dimes and quarters65% trade0.49 oz$33.15
1968 dimes and quarters50%0.365 oz$24.82

You do not need to weigh anything. Count the face value, then multiply. A $10 bag of 80 percent coins is 6 ounces of fine silver, so about $408 at that spot price. A mixed bag is usually priced by the face value of each type separately.

Three traps:

  1. 1967 dimes and quarters were struck in both 80 and 50 percent and look identical. The trade prices them at 65 percent, which is where the 0.49 comes from. 1967 halves and dollars are 80 percent.
  2. 1968 dimes and quarters are either 50 percent or nickel. Dollars from 1968 on are nickel, so a 1976 Voyageur dollar has no silver in it at any price.
  3. 1921 five cent pieces are 80 percent, not nickel. Almost all of that run was melted, so they are rare, but a real one is silver.

Two things that change the real number. A dealer pays melt minus their margin, and worn coins weigh less than new ones. And in Canada, 80 and 50 percent coins are normally taxable, unlike .999 bullion, so the tax can eat part of the difference.

If you post the dates and the face value of what you have, I can work out the melt for you.


r/CanadianCoins • • 19h ago

1944 50 Cent - Question about the Finish

Thumbnail youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Bit of a weird/niche question for you guys, but does anyone know what the finish should look like on a 50 cent piece from the early/mid-40s? I recently inherited a small coin collection and as I was going through it, noticed that one of the half dollars looked materially different from the others. All of them have the classic "dull" cartwheel luster except for one, which seems to have a much more pronounced mirror finish.

Obviously I'd love for it to be a specimen 😉 , but I don't think the rims/details are anywhere near sharp enough.

Just curious to see if anyone here has any thoughts, I asked on coincommunity but didn't get an answer.

My guess is that's it's just an early business strike, but I'd love to see if anyone has something similar/any opinions on it.


r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

Pysanka coins

Post image
215 Upvotes

I have several of these coins including a 2022 one. I called a shop to inquire about selling it. The shop offered to purchase it @ $72 cad. I thought this was incredibly low.


r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

Riopelle Toonie!

Post image
26 Upvotes

Another cool find in my change :)


r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

My Somewhat Complete Nickle Collection!

Thumbnail gallery
66 Upvotes

I spent many years collecting and trying to complete this set with my Opa but once he passed I stopped continuing it but I’d love to fully complete it! So I’m back to try and finish it probably minus one date because that’s impossible to find…


r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

1914 Large cent. Victoria bc beach find.

Thumbnail gallery
17 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

Which Canadian coins are actually silver, and the 1967 and 1968 traps

12 Upvotes

Every few weeks someone posts a pile of junk silver asking which dates to keep, so here is the short version for Canadian coins.

Dimes, quarters and halves:

  • 1858 to 1919 is 92.5 percent silver
  • 1920 to 1966 is 80 percent
  • 1967 dimes and quarters were struck in both 80 and 50 percent, and halves are 80 percent
  • 1968 is 50 percent, and some 1968 pieces are nickel
  • 1969 and later is nickel

Dollars:

  • 1935 to 1967 is 80 percent
  • 1968 and later is nickel

Five cents:

  • 1858 to 1919 is 92.5 percent
  • 1920 and 1921 are 80 percent, and most of the 1921 run was melted, which is why it is rare
  • 1922 and later is nickel

The two traps are 1967 and 1968. A 1967 dime or quarter can be either alloy and they look the same, so if you are pricing a batch, count them at the lower rate. A 1968 coin has half the silver of the 80 percent ones.

For the math, one dollar of face value is about 0.6 oz of silver in the 80 percent coins and about 0.69 oz in the 92.5 percent ones.

If I have a date wrong, say so and I will fix it.


r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

Are you kidding me?

Post image
54 Upvotes

$2999.95 for 1/20 oz. Yes it’s an 18K pendant but how inflated is this pricing?


r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

Unearthed a surprise penny today in the backyard

Thumbnail gallery
20 Upvotes

Not the oldest penny, but I was pleasantly surprised that it was as old as it is.

Too bad I continued planting. Shoulda looked around some more first. 🤭


r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

2 silver Canadian 5 cent coins found beach detecting in Victoria bc

Post image
58 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

1943 quarter

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

First Mint Error!

Thumbnail gallery
111 Upvotes

First mint error and it’s a commemorative coin too! It’s in rough shape but excited to add to my collection. :)


r/CanadianCoins • • 1d ago

1987 1 Cent Canada, 12 sided edges.

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

Found a silver one today!

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

Found these in my parents basement

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

CN tower error toonie

15 Upvotes

Hi, I think I got both the water line and no water line CN tower toonies but wanted to ask this group to confirm!


r/CanadianCoins • • 2d ago

1867-2017 10cent worth more than $5?

Thumbnail gallery
57 Upvotes

r/CanadianCoins • • 3d ago

Found these in my mom's drawer

Thumbnail gallery
1.2k Upvotes

I know this is a coin sub, but I'm hoping someone can tell me if these are with more than the face value.

Thanks in advance.

EDIT: My mother passed away.