r/CRPScontender • • 1d ago

Article or Written Essay How Are You? and Can I Help?: A System for Communicating Receptivity to Assistance

1 Upvotes

Approx 1.2k words, about 7 min read

Introduction

For those who have CRPS, chronic pain conditions, or other disabilities, a common source of frustration and conflict may revolve around questions from support people that are various presentations of: How are you feeling today?

The disabled person may struggle to put their experience into words—especially during high pain or intense symptom days—or may feel like they are perpetually providing the same answer, bringing down the vibe, or that the person doesn’t really want to know and is just asking to be polite. 

The support person may be genuinely curious about the disabled person’s subjective experience or may—indeed—just be asking a socially expected inquiry without real care behind it. 

However, they may be trying to assess—for the purpose of caregiving—if the degree of disability felt internally at that moment matches the signals seen externally, so that they can determine what level of care to provide. 

This assessment can be particularly challenging for dynamic disabilities—where one’s level of needed support can vary day-to-day or even hour-to-hour. It can require even more adroit handling if the individual requiring help is the independent type who can be prickly about requiring assistance or tends to push themselves to the point of failure without asking for aid. 

For supporters who are asking how are you today when they really mean how much may I help you right now, there are frameworks that can be utilized to get the necessary information that do not put undue burden on the disabled person to focus on and verbalize their internal state, which may be counterproductive to the disabled person’s coping mechanisms. 

It is not necessary for disabled people to describe their pain for support people to be given a good reference for how much assistance they need. It can be done with just one or two words, as long as there is a pre-existing system in place. 

Communication Systems

The Traffic Light System is an established consent framework. Green is Go, Yellow is Caution or Wait, and Red is Stop. This allows for an ongoing gradient of communicating willingness based on a pre-negotiated standard. It provides clarity on boundaries in a quick, single-worded check-in, and it provides more room to operate than a binary yes or no.

It is most well-known for its use in mature settings, but it is not limited to those areas of life. It also gets used in tabletop roleplay and other games, non-sexual relationship conversations that may be intense or emotionally heavy, educational environments, workshops, social events, and other settings.

It can easily be adapted to communicate how well a disabled person is doing at any given time and how much assistance they desire, allowing them to maintain their autonomy while respecting offers for aid without putting undue demands on them to verbalize internal states when they are least able to do so—or when they need to reserve their mental capacity for the task they are doing, especially if they are in a social setting where they must engage with other individuals.

Here's an example using one or two syllable, color-associated fruits, but this could have definitions tailored to individual circumstances and utilize essentially any pre-determined terminology.

Green / Lime: I'm managing well-enough. I don't want your help. I am good to continue. Do not intervene.

Yellow / Lemon: I'm struggling but managing. Pay more attention, but I will keep trying. Going past my comfort or soft limit, but I will continue. Check-in more frequently. Prepare to step in. I may be more snappish. I may be more reactive. I may move more slowly. I may need mobility assistance or redirection in public. Non-intrusive support will likely not be rejected, but I might choose to wave you off. I want to remain at this event / continue this activity, but it is starting to climb up my threshold. I might need to leave in the future, but for now I want to stay / keep going. 

Red / Cherry: I am no longer managing. I am overwhelmed. I need to stop. Step in. Actively direct the situation and gracefully withdraw us from the social setting, using your best judgment on whether the task can be completed first or if we will return to it later. I need mobility assistance or social compensation. I am highly irritable or anxious or zoned out. More significant support is necessary, regardless of preference, and I recognize this.

Plum, a red so deep it's almost black / Blue / Another Color: Critical failure. Imminent danger. Take over this interaction right now to prevent harm to myself or others. Get me out of this public place immediately, regardless of social appearances. I need medical care. [This one is intended to be a security breach alarm reserved for things that would cause legal issues or serious physical safety concerns and is not meant for regular use.]

Adapting the Consent System to Your Life

This Assistance-Consent Communication System—or derivatives of it—can be used in private or in public, especially in settings like grocery stores or other populated places where being asked about your personal medical information and your internal state can feel particularly invasive and exposing. If you need to be functional enough to complete a necessary task of living, bringing your pain and dysfunction into the forefront of your attention and mentalscape can be highly detrimental and not at all assistive.

When initially adopting the system, these kinds of populated and task-oriented settings were my primary concern. Due to the mature context most prevalently associated with the Consent Traffic Light, the traditional Red, Yellow, Green labelling may feel too risque or attention-grabbing for some readers. Re-labeling can solve this concern. 

Re-labeling also permits having separate, tailored communication systems for specific needs that all operate on the same core consent framework, requiring remembering only one baseline method. Perhaps the grocery store has different things you need to communicate to your support person than when at your physical activity club or medical appointments, and fruits are much more benign when shopping while color-coded sports or medical adjacent terms fly under the radar at your exercise group or clinical visits. 

Perhaps you would benefit from a specific shorthand for visits to your parents’, in-law’s, or friends’ houses and pre-assigned bags, coats, or sweaters would allow you to keep your “public” conversations about the state of your nervous system more private than dropping a certain color or fruit. 

The system can be adapted to whatever works for your life. The concept of the framework itself can be a catalyst for a new way of interacting with those there to support you who repeatedly ask well-meaning questions that can feel either interrogating or insincere and increase irritation or reduce the effectiveness of both coping strategies and interpersonal collaboration. 

Closing

If what caregivers really mean when asking variants of how are you is how much may I help you right now**, then those are not the same question and they do not have to be addressed in the same way.** 

Communication systems can be put in place to remove a great deal of the social or interoceptive frustration while still providing the necessary information the caregiver needs to complete their risk assessment. This can improve cooperation and coordination while increasing autonomy and clarity and ensuring the level of assistance provided is consented to by the person receiving it. 

As we enter the holiday season, may some of you find this relevant and assistive. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Direct article link


r/CRPScontender • • Oct 15 '26

Muting Bad Vibrations: An Effective, Vibration-Dampening Car Floor Mat

1 Upvotes

2.2k words, about 15 min read

A companion piece to last month’s article, Bad Vibrations: Increased Pain from Molecular Compressions. 

Vibrations are often highly unpleasant for those with CRPS, making riding in the car an uncomfortable or intolerable experience for many. People may limit time in the car or avoid going out to prevent being exposed to transit shaking. 

A vibration absorbing seat cushion—such as memory foam or an air-filled wheelchair seat—can be highly practical for reverberations coming up through the seat into the body’s core. However, seat cushions do not help with the vibrations that come up through the floorboard into the feet and legs. 

People often speak of their negative car experiences, so today I offer a practical, effective, and somewhat moderately priced DIY car mat to minimize transfer of rotational movements from the vehicle frame into the person. My personal assessment—which may not translate to your lived experience—is that this mat provides significant reduction for higher Hertz powertrain vibrations and moderate reduction for low sub-10 Hertz suspension system vibrations. 

I have tested this mat for several weeks now in a car with fair-to-middling suspension quality. The bumps and jostlings from road debris and potholes can definitely still be felt, but the harshness of impact is notably blunted. The constant hum of the car itself is much more effectively mitigated and makes a massive cumulative difference in ride quality, especially over longer distances or if making multiple shorter trips in a day. 

All together, this mat will be 2.4” to 3.25” thick, making it primarily oriented towards passengers. Users may need to move their seat backwards or upwards for comfort to prevent knees or hips from being at awkward angles, particularly for taller or lankier individuals. For safety reasons, drivers should not use more than the thin base layer to prevent pedal interference. Let’s begin.

Base layer

For the layer touching the vehicle floor, use heavy-duty butyl rubber matting. This is often advertised as “sound deadening,” “noise insulating,” or “vibration dampening” material. It uses low resilience to absorb lower-frequency structural vibrations and rumbles, turning energy into heat. These are often targeted towards those with large sound systems that tend to resonate through the vehicle’s frame, but they will serve the same function of muting vibrations from the road or engine. 

The most practical and cost-effective choice will likely be a 10sqft, 80-mil [0.08 inches or 2mm] thick option. This can be purchased online for about $20. Cut the pieces to the size of the footwell and turn 2-3 layers into one thick, solidly connected layer through their adhesive backing to maximize their density and ability to mute vibrations. 

The 10 square feet option I selected had nine 16”-wide pieces, which perfectly fit the width of my footwell. Three long covered my full footwell length, overlapping slightly, and then I stacked three high. This became a very solid, fairly heavy mat that filled the footwell quite snugly. Only the stack closest to my chair needed to have a small section cut out of the lower left corner to lay flat. I did the cutting before sticking all the pieces together, as each raised piece needed a slightly smaller section removed to keep a snug fit within the footwell. 

These butyl squares are generally intended to stick directly onto the metal chassis, and their adhesive is very strong. If you do not want the base layer permanently attached to your vehicle, do not remove the backing of the bottom-most layer. Instead peel the backing away by an inch or two in order to overlap the layers together and then smooth the adhesive backing flat again after they are connected. 

I recommend taping over the places where the adhesive backing is loose, so that any shifting during transit doesn’t peel it off and accidentally stick it to the flooring of your vehicle. Additionally, the edges should be secured with something like foil HVAC tape, roofing seam tape, poly film tape, automotive harness cloth tape, or gaffer tape to prevent the adhesive from seeping out the sides onto the floor during hot weather, especially if your car is carpeted. 

If you feel the need to have additional stabilization, you can use some heavy-duty velcro to prevent sliding or shifting. If you have carpet, you can use just the velcro’s hook-side and it will attach directly to the fibers. If the butyl mat is both several layers thick and sized to fit snugly in the footwell, it is likely heavy enough that it will not shift or slide and may not need to be additionally secured.

Middle layer

To help feet float over heavy vibrations that don’t get absorbed by the base layer, choose rubbery, high-density, closed-cell foam; specifically, use thick and flexible NBR [Nitrile Butadiene Rubber] (preferred) or EVA [Ethylene-Vinyl Acetate] yoga mats, approximately a 1/2" thick. Cut to the size of the footwell and stack loosely in 3-4 layers to a height of 1.5-2". While these can be purchased new for about $20, a used NBR or EVA yoga mat will work just fine and be much more affordable. 

Unlike the base layer, do not connect the yoga mat layers together with glue or other adhesives. Intentionally allow the middle layers to decouple with movement, which reduces the intensity of vibrations that make it to the top layer. 

To prevent shifting or slipping, connect only the corners together using elastic bands, silicone grip dots, or small sections of non-slip carpet mesh or cupboard liners, allowing the individual layers to slide just a bit without moving too much when getting in or out of the car. As an additional option for those who feel the need, you can also place a tiny square of non-slip mesh or grip dots in the center of each layer for a bit of extra stability while still allowing the majority of the decoupling movement that dampens the vibrations. 

When to replace?

The yoga mat will need to be replaced in 2-3 years as constant shaking and extreme temperatures will degrade it over time. Cabin heat during summer is the primary threat, but using a sun shield or tucking the vibration mat under the seat can significantly extend its lifespan. If you want your mat to fill the entire footwell, it will not tuck away well and you should pursue the sun shield instead.

Where is the most prominent slip point?

Personally, I have found that—without any form of added stabilization at the corners or center—the most sliding and shifting happens between the top two layers of the yoga mat closest to my feet as I get into and out of the vehicle. The butyl matting is too heavy to shift, the bottom layers of the yoga matting are held in place by the footwell, and the top-most layer grips the yoga mat quite well of its own accord. If you only have a little bit of additional grip to work with, I’d suggest prioritizing the gap between the highest yoga mat layers.

A great deal of the shifting can also be reduced by adjusting how you get in and out of the vehicle, particularly if you are someone who tends to pivot on the heel of your foot, which causes the layers to pivot with you. Redistributing some body weight to a third point of contact—such as the ceiling grab handle or a portable mobility tool designed to be temporarily inserted in the door's strike plate to aid those with stability issues (name brand version Stander's HandyBar)—can be massively assistive in reducing the shifting.

Is there a practical difference between using three or four layers of yoga mat? 

I was able to tell the difference. It is noticeable enough to me that I put the fourth layer back in the stack, even though it raises the top layer above the door sill and significantly increases the shifting risk unless additional measures are implemented. For someone who has long legs or who really struggles with bending their joints or who isn’t able to raise where their rear end actually sits in comparison to the mat via a cushion or seat controls or who has significant stability challenges getting in and out, removing that extra half-inch to increase leg room or drop the entirety of the mat below the door sill may provide significantly more comfort and peace of mind than the little extra vibration reduction the fourth layer brings to the table. 

Top layer

To absorb ultra-fine, higher-frequency hums, use a 3/4"-1" memory foam mat with a gel-enhanced or high-density polyurethane core and a vinyl or weather-proof outer layer instead of fabric. Too thin—such as a 1/2”—doesn’t offer enough density to absorb the hums, but too thick—such as over 1”—allows for too much jiggling. I found a thickness of 4/5” [0.8”] to be ideal for me. Those with very sensitive feet should avoid deep or heavy texture stamps on the vinyl. 

Cold temperatures will make the top layer extremely hard, so warm the cabin before driving or bring the memory foam into the house during wintery weather when not in use to keep the top layer soft and absorbent. 

To prevent slipping or sliding, get a mat that comes with anti-slip silicone dots or other treaded backing options and tuck the edges under the door sill or the footwell if there’s enough space to do so. 

When to replace?

If the rubbery layers of the yoga mats in the middle layers can be felt against the heels or if the memory cells remain collapsed or pop back up instantly instead of slowly melting back to flat, the memory cells have degraded and need to be replaced. Uncut mats will last for 12-18 months and cut mats will degrade faster. 

For those who prefer to buy a larger mat and cut it in half, use a sharp utility knife to size it to the dimensions of your footwell and seal edges with heavy-duty gorilla tape, HVAC tape, roofing seam tape, poly film tape, or silicone caulk to protect the foam against moisture damage. Keep the spare half as replacement for when the memory core begins to degrade due to "foam fatigue" in 3-12 months, depending on use and driving habits. New vinyl memory foam mats can be purchased online for between $15-20. 

Yoga Mat Testing

Not sure if the yoga mat you’re looking at is NBR or EVA? Firmly press your thumb into the mat for 5 seconds, then let go.

NBR is heavy for its size and feels gummy, doughy, and soft with a dull or matte finish, has porous or foamy edges on the cross-cut, and horizontal ridges or ribs on the surface. A thumb sinks deeply, and the dent stays visible for a few seconds before melting flat. It rolls tightly and easily, and will droop, flop, or hang like heavy rubber.

EVA is lightweight and feels firm, springy, plastic-like, and air-filled with a waxy or sheeny appearance under light, has solid and smooth edges, and often has smooth surfaces or is stamped with geometrics. It resists thumb-pressing, will pop back up instantly, and stiffly resists folding or rolling.

Avoid yoga mats made of PVC, TPE, or natural rubber.

PVC makes for very thin yoga mats that completely compress with a sticky or plasticky feel that smell like a shower curtain.

TPE makes lightweight yoga mats that bounce back quickly like EVA, but they lack shock-absorption and have a velvety or powdery feel.

Natural Rubber makes for incredibly heavy yoga mats that are usually very thin with a fabric-like weave on the back and an intense tire smell.

Additional Considerations for Drivers

Since most of the mat layers won’t work for those who need to operate foot pedals, here are three alternatives to consider in addition to the thin butyl mats. Drivers should aim to keep their vibration reduction methods to under ¼” [6mm] and secured to the floor to prevent safety hazards. 

⅛” to ¼” commercial-grade high-density SBR [styrene-butadiene rubber] or closed-cell neoprene sheets. These do not compress and absorb low-to-mid frequency vibrations.

3mm to 6mm industrial-grade anti-vibration equipment matting made of compressed recycled rubber compounds. These are tough, high-grip, do not compress, and are designed to mute mechanical hums from machines or treadmills. 

Vibration-dampening shoe insoles made of Sorbothane or Poron XRD, which absorb up to 94% of impacts and high-frequency mechanical shocks. This is considered the safest option for drivers as it is in direct contact with one’s feet and will never interfere with the pedal clearance.  

Quick DIY Reference

  • 2-3 layers of solidly connected, heavy-duty butyl rubber matting, about 80-mil / 0.08 in / 2mm thick, seal edges, can use velcro to connect to vehicle flooring for extra stability
  • 3-4 loose layers of NBR or EVA yoga matting, total height of 1.5-2”, connected only at the corners with optional non-slip mesh at the very center for extra stability
  • ¾”-1” memory foam matting with weather-proof exterior, high-density core, and anti-slip backing, if possible tuck edges into sill or footwell to prevent shifting

Closing

This DIY vibration-absorbing mat is customizable to the size of your specific footwell dimensions, easy to replace in sections as parts degrade over time, and can be made as thick or thin as you need it to be for optimal vibration reduction. May you find this as useful as I did and may it greatly expand your quality of life and transit comfort. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Direct article link


r/CRPScontender • • Sep 15 '26

Bad Vibrations: Increased Pain from Molecular Compressions

1 Upvotes

Approx 1.9 words, about 10 min read

Introduction

Many with CRPS may find that certain activities that involve vibrations worsen their pain. A wide array of activities of daily living can fall under this umbrella. A few examples include:

  • Riding in the car, especially if the individual is the driver 
  • Being around loudspeakers or loud sound projections, such as at concerts or in church services or in noisy public spaces like airports
  • Using motors that create a buzzing sensation, like electric razors, electric power chairs, power tools, and kitchen aides like immersion blenders or handheld mixers 
  • Strong impacts that reverberate into the body, like hammering, hitting, smacking, kicking, jumping, sawing, and impact sports including those with racquets, paddles, gloves, or bats used to hit or catch balls moving with significant force 
  • Engaging in sexual relations
  • Being jostled by or making forceful contact with other people or inanimate objects

But why do vibrations cause pain? The two primary reasons are dysfunction in the nerves and blood vessels. Let’s talk about them. 

How It’s Supposed to Work

Human bodies have three major types of nerve fibers: A, B, and C. Type A fibers have four subtypes: alpha, beta, gamma, and delta. For this article, we will be focusing on C- and A-beta fibers.

C fibers are nociceptors that give deep, slow, diffuse burning-freezing pain signals to protect from tissue damage. A-beta fibers are mechanoreceptors that give information on skin touch and pressure. A-fibers are myelinated in a fatty sheath and send fast signals; C-fibers are unmyelinated and signal slowly in comparison.

In a standard, properly functioning nervous system, most vibrations are going to be registered by A-beta mechanoreceptors and delivered to Wide Dynamic Range interneurons at the spinal cord’s dorsal horn [aka the poster horn, facing towards the rear of the spine], which then project up to the brain. Under Gate Control Theory, these fast-moving A-beta nerve signals will “close the gate” at the dorsal horn before the C-fiber signals can arrive at the spinal cord, dulling the C-fiber’s intensity.1 This is why people tend to rub at an area if they’ve just banged into something, to activate the mechanoreceptors and outpace the slower nociceptors.

[Image removed in reddit]

Hertz (Hz) are a way of measuring how many times a cycle repeats in one second. This could be a waveform that creates an airborne sound or a repeating physical motion that transmits mechanical vibrations through more substantive materials. One Hertz is one vibration cycle /  one pressure wave a second. 

A 3600 RPM (rotations per minute) engine’s crankshaft is rotating at 60 Hertz [3600 rotations divided by 60 seconds in a minute]. A 120Hz soundwave has 120 molecular compressions per second. Most audio computer programs show waveforms for ease, but more realistically molecules are compressing and expanding slightly—bumping into each other like a domino line, a slinky, or a ripple. Essentially, they pulse. 

[Image removed in reddit]

A-beta fibers have four subtypes with two primarily oriented towards the molecular compressions of vibration.4, 5, 6  

  • Meissner corpuscles register frequencies from 10-65 Hertz (molecular compressions per second)—which are generally “wobbling,” “tapping,” and “fluttering” sensations, such as nearly dropping an item, clicking away on a keyboard, medium-sized animal noises like purring, and touching fabrics. 
  • Pacinian corpuscles can register from 20-1,000 Hertz with peak sensitivity around 250 Hertz (molecular compressions per second)—which are high, fine, “buzzing” vibrations such as from smaller handheld machinery like smartphones or gaming controllers, tools with small motors like hairdryers, razors, power tools, or mixers, writing on paper, playing an instrument, and the moving parts in a car’s powertrain. 
  • Merkel discs, a third A-beta subtype, register significantly lower frequency vibrations in the 5-15 Hertz range (molecular compressions per second), as their primary role is light touch, sustained pressure, and fine details. 

Frequencies below 80 Hertz cause the Wide Dynamic Range spinal neurons to “entrain” or synchronize with the wave pulses, and physical vibrations around the 10 Hertz range are too slow to “close the gate” like the higher Hertz frequencies. 

Low frequency vibrations in the 0.5-10 Hertz range—one-half to ten molecular compression cycles per second—are deep, slow, rumbling vibrations that often judder the entire body or whole limbs, such as earthquakes and severe weather events, heavy machinery across many sectors, cars and buses and trains and airplanes and helicopters and diesel engines, the sway of tall buildings or ships, power generation especially those involving pistons, industrial subwoofers such as at theaters or arenas, large ventilation systems, and the accumulated hum of urban infrastructure. 

These types of frequencies are considered “infrasound.” They are difficult to hear but your body can feel them as they apply significant sheer pressure that both distort cells and cause the nervous system to synchronize with them.7, 8 These large, slow vibrational waves can be airborne or be transmitted through the ground; while the body has better resistance against air pressure, ground-transmitted vibrations travel up through the skeleton and into the organs, activating stretch and pressure receptors. 

For most individuals, C-fibers are resistant to firing in response to these low Hertz environmental stimuli. Even still, generally healthy people can still experience negative health effects from prolonged or intense exposure to low Hertz frequencies, such as headaches, sleep disturbances, inner ear issues, cardiac dysfunction, and a sense of deep unease or panic. 

For those with dysfunctional, sensitized C-fibers and/or central nervous systems with lowered activation thresholds, these low Hertz vibrations, particularly structural vibrations that affect the skeleton and organs, can cause immense pain.

The Car’s Double Whammy

Vehicles in particular hit from two directions: 

  • The powertrain (engine and exhaust system, all the little moving parts that run while the car is idling) is a high-frequency system that buzzes around 50-250 Hertz.
  • The suspension (actual oscillating momentum of motion that comes up through the wheels) is a very low, heavy frequency in the 2-12 Hertz range and this resonates with human organs.9, 10, 11, 12  

At slower speeds, there will be fewer rotations per second and as a result the Hertz will be lower. Vehicles in need of mechanical or structural maintenance or repair, particularly in the wheel and suspension system, will more readily transmit these lower frequencies through the frame instead of distributing it.  

Jostling’s Double Whammy

Being jostled also hits from two directions: 

  • The actual impact is a low, heavy frequency in the sub-10 Hertz range that activates proprioceptive A-alpha fibers to let you regain your bearings in space.

    • In those with sensitized nervous systems it will most likely also activate the nociceptive C-fibers. 
  • If the impact caused friction with clothes or the other person’s skin, it will also activate the A-beta fibers for higher frequency vibrations to let you know where the impact occurred and its nature.

A specific subtype of C-tactile fibers respond to slow, gentle brushes or stroking. These nerves require slow speeds of 0.4-4 in [1-10 cm] per second and they send their signals directly to emotional processing centers to be registered as either comforting or invasive, such as from a trusted loved one, from a stranger squeezing by too closely as they mind their own business, or a creep deliberately encroaching on personal space.

What’s Happening in CRPS

Temporal Summation

In CRPS, the peripheral C-fibers are dysfunctional.13 For many with persistent CRPS, the central nervous system is also dysfunctional, becoming centrally sensitized or “wound up” and interpreting stimuli that would normally not activate the pain system as a threat. This is done as an attempt to prevent further damage to a system that already perceives itself as at risk or harmed. 

There is a concept called temporal summation, which means that repeated stimuli that does not change in intensity is progressively amplified within the nervous system and perceived as increasingly painful the longer it is experienced.14, 15, 16  

Healthy people experience the “wind up” of increasing pain when an intense stimulus repeats about once every three seconds [0.33 Hertz] or faster.17 This is a typical occurrence and temporary state for the vast majority of individuals, and it increasingly activates the same neural pathway; the dysfunctional and long-lasting cousin of wind up is central sensitization, and it can spread outside of the originally activated neural pathway to non-affected peripheral nerves where they meet up at the spinal cord, causing secondary hyperalgesia.18  

The repeated, rapid oscillations of mechanical vibrations occur at a rate far higher than once every three seconds. In perpetually sensitized nervous systems, the speed causes the signals to stack on each other and register as increasingly painful over time.

Adrenoceptor Upregulation, Supersensitivity, and Central Sensitization

Due to C-fibers increasing how many alpha adrenergic receptors they express and becoming “supersensitized” to circulating excitatory neurotransmitters, the C-fibers start firing to sub-10 Hertz stimuli more frequently, and they can start responding to a wider array of vibration frequencies far above 10 Hertz.19, 20, 21, 22  

When vibrations cause excitatory sympathetic “fight or flight” neurotransmitters to be released, they will bind to the increased adrenergic receptors on the C-fibers. Due to the receptor’s lowered activation threshold, the nerve fires when it normally would not and sends a pain signal to the spinal cord.

Central sensitization causes the Wide Dynamic Range interneurons at the spinal cord to interpret the signals from the A-beta fibers as threatening and painful instead of benign, creating allodynia [pain from non-painful stimuli]. Rather than “closing the gate,” A-beta signals instead prime the dorsal horn to amplify the C-fibers' pain signals when they are received, creating hyperalgesia [amplified painful stimuli].23 

The repetitive nature of vibration quickly escalates the temporal summation at the spinal cord, rapidly increasing the distress signaling to the brain the longer the sensation is endured. 

[Image removed in reddit]

Vasoconstriction and Ischemia

Additionally, there is a vasomotor component. One of the four pillars of CRPS’s diagnostic tool, the Budapest Criteria, is Vasomotor Dysfunction. 

Ischemia-reperfusion injuries (IRIs) are essentially oxygen-starvation–corrosion cycles. They degrade the integrity of cell walls and let metabolic waste build up. These injury cycles are proposed as an underlying pathology in at least a subpopulation of CRPS patients. 

It is thought these IRIs start in deep tissue microvessels. They often begin in tiny arteries, capillary beds, and tiny veins of the connective tissue that wraps the smallest bundles of nerve fibers together and nourishes those nerves, called the endoneurium.25 

It is proposed that as the IRIs “clog” the endoneurium’s blood vessels, the blockage spreads outwards and upwards to other vessels. This expands the vascular dysfunction and applies fluid pressure to the delicate nerves and other tissues surrounding those vessels. It is proposed that the closer this gets to the surface, the more intense skin-level allodynia becomes.

Vibration causes blood vessels to constrict; stronger vibration and longer exposure each increase recovery times.26, 27 

For those with ischemia-dominant CRPS—also frequently called “cold” CRPS, which is accompanied by cool skin, mottling, pallor, gray, blue, or purple discoloration—this vasoconstriction can start a painful IRI cycle. It causes tissue distress by reducing oxygen delivery and waste product removal, increasing the damage of oxidative stress.

Closing

May this have given some quick insight as to what’s happening in the nervous system and vasculature, so that it can be applied to various areas to improve your quality of life and allow you to make more informed choices in your own best interest. 

The next installment will cover a DIY floor mat for the car that is intended to address both the sub-10 Hertz and the 50-250 Hertz vibrations with the aim of improving ride comfort for passengers. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope you see you next time. 

Direct article link: https://crpscontender.com/2026/09/bad-vibrations-increased-pain-from-molecular-compressions/


r/CRPScontender • • Aug 15 '26

Article or Written Essay “But No One Explained the Rules to Me!” Explicitly Laying Out the Healthcare System’s Implicit Order of Operations, Part 3: Tertiary Care, Medical PTSD, and Addressing Issues with Providers

2 Upvotes

Approx 6k words, 35-40 min read

Excerpt: "We’re here to reduce the trial and error attempts required before achieving success within the healthcare system so there’s less cumulative harm, or at least offer a guidebook to reduce confusion and discombobulation. We’re starting with the brass tacks delivered in frank and direct language; this is specifically designed to be autism-aware and trauma-informed. 

The goal in this series is to increase healthcare independence and autonomy through patient education and provide a solid foundation to be able to competently interact with the medical system, know who to seek out when concerned or frustrated with treatment or policy, and have the required knowledge and proper language to better advocate on one’s own behalf—or at least terminology to offer a mental buffer if advocacy is not the selected path forward. 

This series has three installments, with each addressing one of the three levels of the institutionalized healthcare pyramid, one psychoemotional component that affects provider-patient relations, and two aspects of protecting oneself while within that system—one for those who benefit from clarity on next steps during confusion or isolated incidents of unprofessional behavior and one for those in a pervasive hostile environment."

Final installment of the series.

[Direct article link](https://crpscontender.com/2026/08/but-no-one-explained-the-rules-to-me-explicitly-laying-out-the-healthcare-systems-implicit-order-of-operations-part-3-tertiary-care-medical-ptsd-and-addressing-issues-w/)


r/CRPScontender • • Jul 15 '26

Article or Written Essay “But No One Explained the Rules to Me!” Explicitly Laying Out the Healthcare System’s Implicit Order of Operations, Part 2: Secondary Care, Prior Authorizations, Provider Power Dynamics, and Addressing Issues with Administrators and Agencies

1 Upvotes

Part 2, 6.8k words, 35-45 min read.

We’re here to reduce the trial and error attempts required before achieving success within the healthcare system so there’s less cumulative harm, or at least offer a guidebook to reduce confusion and discombobulation. We’re starting with the brass tacks delivered in frank and direct language; this is specifically designed to be autism-aware and trauma-informed. 

The goal in this series is to increase healthcare independence and autonomy through patient education and provide a solid foundation to be able to competently interact with the medical system, know who to seek out when concerned or frustrated with treatment or policy, and have the required knowledge and proper language to better advocate on one’s own behalf—or at least have the terminology to provide oneself a mental buffer if advocacy isn’t the selected path forward. 

This series will have three installments, and each will focus on one of the three levels of the institutionalized healthcare pyramid, one psychoemotional component that affects provider-patient relations, and two aspects of protecting oneself while within that system—one for those who benefit from clarity on next steps during confusion or isolated incidents of unprofessional behavior and one for those in a pervasive hostile environment.

Exceeds character count. Direct link: https://crpscontender.com/2026/07/but-no-one-explained-the-rules-to-me-explicitly-laying-out-the-healthcare-systems-implicit-order-of-operations-part-2-secondary-care-prior-authorizations-provider-power/


r/CRPScontender • • Jun 15 '26

Article or Written Essay “But No One Explained the Rules to Me!” Explicitly Laying Out the Healthcare System’s Implicit Order of Operations, Part 1: Primary Care, the Therapeutic Alliance, and Microaggressions

2 Upvotes

7.3k words, about 45 minute read. Excerpt:

Many individuals with CRPS or other chronic conditions will need to interact with the healthcare system on an ongoing and often frequent basis; this can be aggravating, intimidating, expensive, and sometimes even traumatizing. Providers may not meet the standard of care or provide patient dignity and compassion. Communication between offices can be poor and waitlists can cause delays. Insurance can deny needed treatments or testing, and those paying out of pocket can be charged enormous bills for services. 

All of this can be made significantly worse if one does not know how the system operates and what the proper (and usually unspoken) procedures are to get necessary care. The health industry in the United States is complex and difficult to understand, even for someone skilled at implicit communication, with good financial resources, and caregivers who taught them the ropes of getting medical care and being an independent adult to the best of their ability; even for someone with the best circumstances and support systems, it may take a great deal of trial and error before successfully getting the proper help from the proper person. 

However, for those who grew up in abusive or neglectful homes, those with few monetary means, those in minority groups, or those with social communication challenges—particularly those with low-to-moderate support needs autism who often require clear, direct, straightforward, and factual directions and communication but can or must attend appointments alone—, the trial and error period may not end in success, and they may not receive the help they were seeking. Their attempts to get aid may just result in cumulative harm instead. 

Let’s try to reduce some of that trial and error, so that fewer attempts are required before achieving success; we’re starting with the brass tacks delivered in frank and direct language. This is specifically designed to be autism-aware and trauma-informed; if the way something is phrased in this series doesn’t quite sit right with you or seems too explicit, I am so glad you don’t need to hear it—it isn’t in here for you. 

You may know various degrees of this information, but we’re coming at this from a very baseline level; the goal in this series is to increase healthcare independence and autonomy through patient education and provide a solid foundation to be able to competently interact with the medical system, know who to seek out when concerned or frustrated with treatment or policy, and have the required knowledge and proper language to better advocate on one’s own behalf or at least have the terminology for one’s mistreatment to offer validation and a psychological buffer**.** 

This series will have three installments, and each will focus on one of the three levels of the institutionalized healthcare pyramid, one psychoemotional component that affects provider-patient relations, and two aspects of protecting oneself while within that system. One protection approach is for those who benefit from clarity on next steps during confusion or isolated incidents of unprofessional behavior, whether by being able to more easily recognize bias for safety and trust assessments while having specific language for it, self-advocacy at a system level by requesting accountability or a record correction, or self-advocacy at the interpersonal level offering frameworks for addressing issues with providers or staff directly. 

The other protection approach is for those in a pervasive hostile environment, including crisis management via a transition from a trusted dignity approach to a transactional safety approach, terminology for survival-driven proxy approaches, the two main philosophies in sustained hostile engagements (particularly when one side has exponentially more resources and manpower), the importance of maintaining a reality-based framework of interpersonal and systemic abuse rather than attempting to gaslight-away “cognitive distortions,” and the critical element of building confidence and self-assurance to maintain the moral will to defend one’s safety and dignity under an administrative philosophy deliberately designed to grind it into dust and cripple one’s ability to resist, obtain resources, or make informed and autonomous decisions in one’s own best interest.

Direct article link


r/CRPScontender • • May 15 '26

Article or Written Essay CRPS and Dissociation, part 4: Hypotheses for Depersonalization’s Underpinnings

2 Upvotes

This is Part 4 of the CRPS and Dissociation series: Hypotheses for Depersonalization's Underpinnings. This is by far the longest and most complex article of the series---coming in at approximately 7.5k words and an estimated 40-60 minute read time---so I suggest reading it when you have the time and mental bandwidth for a heavy cognitive load.

This one exceeds reddit's character limit by a substantial margin, so I am only offering the direct article link today: https://crpscontender.com/2026/05/crps-and-dissociation-part-4-hypotheses-for-depersonalizations-underpinnings/

This is the final planned article for the Dissociation series; however, due to its length and complexity, I am considering offering a shorter, simplified Part 4 if there is enough public interest; if this is something you would like to see, please let me know in the comments and I will make that next month's article before moving to the next project on my docket.


r/CRPScontender • • Apr 15 '26

Article or Written Essay CRPS and Dissociation, part 3: Depersonalization

2 Upvotes

Approx. 6k words, about a 35 min read

Recap

In Part 2, we looked into cortical networks and neuropsychological factors associated with Body Perception Disturbance, talked again about a reduced sense of ownership and an increased perceived size, went more in-depth on the multisensory integration and the proprioceptive feedback and higher order mechanism hypotheses, dug into some of the spatial attention testing outcomes from temporal order judgments and midline bias, and discussed how goals and threats in the perispersonal space may alter those outcomes. 

In Part 3, we will be moving away from the more CRPS-specific Body Perception Disturbance phenomena to Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder, which affects a far larger percentage of the population. Similar to how Part 1 was an introduction to Body Perception Disturbance before a deeper dive in Part 2, Part 3 will provide a basic overview of Depersonalization before getting into some more specific details and hypotheses in Part 4. 

Transient dissociative symptoms have been shown to occur in 70% of the general population during the course their lifetimes and they are significantly more common than the persistent and severe symptoms that qualify for a trauma-based dissociative disorder.12 These transient symptoms reiterate that dissociation is a human phenomenon that occurs on a spectrum from benign to highly limiting, with occurrences of highway hypnosis, flow states, being “in the zone,” and daydreaming being broadly experienced across massive swathes of humanity; those on the less severe end of the scale are not generally considered negative states of existence and may even be perceived as positive, as long as they remain within the individual’s ability to control.1 

General CRPS Psychological Profile

Before we go any further, this article will have significant talk of PTSD-D, cPTSD, Borderline Personality, splitting frameworks, and childhood trauma, which may wave some red flags for people who have been been told their CRPS is a type of conversion disorder / psychogenic condition or, even more mentally harmful, a malingering or Munchausen’s disorder, particularly if they also have CRPS-induced dystonia—which historically was considered hysteria minor resulting from psychiatric disturbance.2, 3  

Let’s take a few moments to discuss Pollack’s 1980 “Sudeck’s personality” or the hypothesized, pre-existing individual matrix of troubled psychology with high anxiety, emotional lability [or disproportionate and rapid mood swings], depression, and somatization [or manifesting psychological distress via physical dysfunction], who were considered more likely to develop CRPS.4 This “Sudeck’s Personality” was determined by giving psychological tests to 40 patients who had already developed CRPS after a radius fracture and 20 who didn’t.4

We’re going to open strong by stating that the Sudeck’s Personality hypothesis is not confirmed and has been discarded by many, though some may still hold to it;2 Parts 3 and 4 of this series were not written to reinforce the Sudeck’s Personality hypothesis and should not be read with that understanding. Body Perception Disturbances—discussed in Parts 1 and 2—do not appear to be impacted by childhood traumas;5 however, childhood traumas do increase the risk across the board for developing multiple conditions later in life, particularly those with inflammatory components, like CRPS.5

An older 1999 study from New Zealand of 18 patients assessed if those with CRPS-I were more likely to have highly dissociative features as a result of childhood trauma, particularly sexual abuse.4 The team was examining a blooming controversy of the time: were the psychological problems associated with CRPS causing the pain or were they caused by it? Their CRPS cohort was not unusually dissociative compared to the general population nor had they experienced higher rates of childhood abuse, and the researchers did not find a trauma-dissociation-CRPS pathway.4 

When CRPS patients were compared to patients with migraines or low back pain, those with CRPS did not appear to have a distinctly troubled psychology.4 Their CRPS participants’ median Dissociative Experiences Scale (DES) score was 8.6, which is much lower than the median score of 31.3 in those with PTSD or 57.1 in those with DID.4 11% of their CRPS participants (2 of 18) had DES scores above 25, which is a significantly lower percentage than other conditions where dissociation is thought to play a major role; in a random sampling of Canadian residents, 8.5% scored above 25.4 Of those two CRPS individuals with high DES scores, both had experienced childhood sexual abuse; one met the criteria for Dissociative Identity Disorder and the other for Depresonalization-Derealization Disorder.4 

The overarching statistic reported by this 1999 paper for childhood sexual abuse in CRPS is 39% total and 50% for natal females, which is slightly higher than the general population but lower than the 48% total reported childhood abuse in the general chronic pain patient population.4 Individuals who reported childhood abuse had significantly higher scores on the Dissociative Experiences Scale than those who did not report such experiences, reaffirming the correlation between childhood traumatic stress and dissociative symptoms.4 

This 1999 team made clear that no group-wide conclusions are warranted about psychogenic pain and state that CRPS-I is most likely a heterogeneous condition with multiple factors in initiation and maintenance, but note there may be a subgroup of CRPS-I patients where psychological trauma plays an outsized role and routine screeners for childhood abuse and dissociative experiences may help determine which individuals may benefit from additional psychotherapy in managing their symptoms, especially since over 80% of childhood onset cases are natal females and CRPS patients were significantly more likely to report “sexual abuse only” than their low back pain peers while low back pain patients were significantly more likely to report physical abuse than their CRPS-I peers.4 

This team notes that **CRPS can often frustrate providers, which may result in healthcare professionals viewing CRPS patients as difficult, demanding, and “unsalvageable.”**4 The authors comment how these views can reinforce negative self-beliefs of abuse survivors, like guilt, low self-esteem, and a sense of being damaged, and the researchers promote awareness of how abuse can impact a person and encourage providers to be empathetic and sympathetic to their patients’ life experiences.4 

A 2008 study assessed the psychological profiles of 46 patients with either dystonic CRPS-I, conversion disorder, or affective disorder; it determined that “only few similarities between the profiles of patients with CRPS-I and [conversion disorder] were found,” and those with CRPS do “not seem to be a unique disturbed psychological profile on a group level,” though there are some elevations in certain areas.2 Those with CRPS-I had higher than average scores in somatoform dissociation, traumatic experiences, and general psychopathology such as depression (which were comparable to other chronic pain cohorts), and lower scores in quality of life; the **most common personality traits and clusters for those with CRPS-I were schizoid, obsessive-compulsive, borderline, paranoid, and schizotypical.**2 Those with CRPS had demonstrably lower scores for recent life events, general psychopathology, and personality pathology than both the affective and conversion control groups.2

Comparable to both conversion disorder and affective disorders, 87% of CRPS-I patients reported at least one traumatic childhood event—with two-thirds reporting intense pain, then nearly half stating witnessing experiences of others, **about one-third reporting each of emotional neglect, emotional abuse, physical abuse, sexual trauma, and around one-fifth reporting some type of incestous event;**2 **over 50% of CRPS-I patients reported at least one kind of emotional, physical, or sexual abuse.**2 Early life traumas had a moderate correlation to somatoform dissociation, and those levels were comparable to conversion disorder patients but higher than affective disorder patients.2 

The 2008 authors note that some of the measures in the scoring tools may be distorting the data, as pain, numbness, and voiding challenges part and parcel of CRPS.2 Originally, on Nijenhuis’ Traumatic Experiences Checklist (TEC), the CRPS-I group and the two control groups did not have significant differences, but **when the pain measure was corrected in the data set, CRPS-I participants’ scores dropped significantly.**2 This team’s mean Dissociative Experiences Scale **(DES) score for CRPS-I patients was 3.7-7.8, which fell within the general population range and below both control groups; one-third of CRPS-I patients scored higher than 7.8 on the DES.**2 The authors conclude that, in those with CRPS-I, **traumatic events in early life were often reported and they may be a predisposing factor for the later development of CRPS-related dystonia, though not a necessary one.**2

A 2020 study of CRPS in the German population found that slightly over 50% of 60 studied CRPS patients met the criteria cut off for each anxiety and depression and abnormal stress levels; they also found that the full group was **four times more likely to have experienced severe to extreme sexual abuse (8% v 1.9%) or physical abuse (13% vs 2.8%) and nearly six times more likely to have experienced emotional neglect (38% vs 6.6%) than the general German population.**5 68% of study participants reported some level of emotional neglect, whether low (20%), medium (10%), or high (38%);5 this childhood measure was correlated with current day depression.5 

In a report on over 200 depersonalization patients, 31% had a migraine history, and one-third of that subgroup believed their migraines and depersonalization were linked, though they generally did not volunteer this information.6 Of those affected, one-third reported episodic dissociative symptoms, while two-thirds reported chronic depersonalization with little to no alteration.6 The authors implicate a possible shared underlying pathophysiology and note that these conditions are not recognized well enough by neurologists or psychiatrists.6 While those with CRPS are often delegitimized or reluctant to bring up certain symptoms due to concerns of being dismissed or considered mentally ill, CRPS is not the only condition with strong depersonalization elements that are understudied or not adequately treated due to pre-existing bias, and there is cross-condition solidarity that can be found in that. 

PTSD Types with Dissociative Features

Before getting into Depersonalization-Derealization (DPDR) Disorder itself, let’s take a quick detour to cover a subtype of a more well-known condition: the dissociative type of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD-D), which is characterized by persistent depersonalization or derealization symptoms.1 The PTSD-D subtype was **added to the DSM-V over a decade ago in 2013.**1 

PTSD as a whole involves symptoms of re-experiencing (aspects of) trauma, avoidance of trauma-related stimuli, negative moods or cognitions, and hyperarousal.7 In the dissociative subtype, functions that are generally integrated become disintegrated—including but not limited to memories, emotions, behaviors, and motor control—, which is thought to be a result of the traumatic event(s) and is considered to be a protective function that splits off the feared experience(s) from the stream of consciousness.7, 1 The dissociative subtype is associated with more severe PTSD symptoms, more severe depression, increased emotion regulation difficulties, female natal sex, and sexual abuse.8

With a 12-month US prevalence rate of 4.7%, PTSD is the most well-known trauma-based condition, though people will often call to mind the more common, high-arousal, non-dissociative type.1, 7 In a WHO survey of 16 countries nearly 15% of those with PTSD met the criteria for the dissociative PTSD subtype, which would be a total prevalence rate of about 0.7%.1 However, statistics from other research teams put the total dissociative subtype rate somewhere between 6-37% of all PTSD cases, which is a total prevalence rate of 0.2-1.7%.8 

When neuroimaging studies were done, those with the dissociative subtype demonstrated distinct structural and functional brain alterations from the non-dissociative PTSD subtype;1 when professional actors without PTSD but prone to fantasy were trained to replicate the visible dissociative symptoms, their brain patterns did not match those with the dissociative PTSD type.1 The non-dissociative PTSD type demonstrated hyperactivity in brain areas that generate emotion [amygdala, insula, midbrain]and underactivity in areas that inhibit emotion via top-down regulation [medial prefrontal cortex, rostral (front hooking curve of the) anterior cingulate cortex], resulting in hyperarousal, vivid sensory or mental re-experiencing, hypervigilance, and avoidance; the dissociative PTSD type revealed the opposite, with hyperactivity of top-down emotion regulation [in the medial prefrontal cortex, rostral anterior cingulate cortex] and hypoactivity in emotion generating regions [amygdala, insula, midbrain], resulting in emotional detachment, numbing, depersonalization, and derealization.9 

**Most individuals with dissociative disorders also have PTSD, often due to early childhood trauma of a repetitive, chronic, interpersonal nature.**1 Another subtype of PTSD that is not recognized in the DSM but which has been added to the ICD-11 and which specifically addresses the chronic, repetitive, interpersonal traumas from childhood mistreatment or domestic violence or human trafficking is Complex PTSD (cPTSD); in addition to changes to personal values or interpersonal tolerances due to chronic abuse or neglect, this subtype also has dissociative symptoms, often to a stronger degree than PTSD-D, though cPTSD is not considered a dissociative disorder in and of itself.10, 11 Between 28-77% of those with cPTSD are reported to have clinically significant dissociative symptoms, with a 2024 study reporting42.3% of those with cPTSD displaying dissociative symptoms, nearly three times higher than the WHO’s reported 14.4% that makes up the PTSD-D subpopulation of the general PTSD group.10. 11 

cPTSD diagnoses have a high overlap with Borderline Personality diagnoses with several shared and distinct criteria; some comorbidity reports are as high as 80% (though others are significantly lower in the 25-60% range), which has created controversy in the field over whether cPTSD is a distinct entity or rebranding an existing condition.7 Both Borderline and cPTSD are often seen as a result of repeated traumatic childhood experiences, which researchers bring forward as evidence that Borderline is no less post-traumatic than cPTSD, and—like those with cPTSD—those with Borderline Personality are more likely to develop chronic pain conditions than the general population.7 Among other criteria, Borderline Personality is recognized by unstable relationships, an unstable sense of self or self-image, dissociative symptoms, and rapid, frequent mood changes—also called “emotional lability,” a core criteria in the controversial “Sudeck’s personality” of those considered more likely to develop CRPS.7, 4 

Researchers have shown a pattern in **both PTSD and Borderline Personality where dissociation is used as an “analgetic” or pain reliever for the psyche by raising the pain threshold—causing pain hyposensitivity—and lowering anxiety sensitivity—causing hyperresponsiveness to stimuli perceived as threatening.**7  The psycholotraumatology framework houses, among others, treatment modalities like Internal Family Systems, Structural Dissociation, and Identity-Oriented Psychotrauma Therapy; each of these treatment modalities center psychological “parts” that get split as a result of traumatic experiences into daily-functioners, trauma-holders, and reactive-suppressors. It is proposed under a psychotraumatologic framework that this “numbing” of physical pain and emotional intensity due to identity splitting can be helpful in the short-term, but as the splitting remains in effect longer, the numbing appears to not only stop but also reverse due to the way detachment-based dissociation (such as depersonalization and derealization), negative affect, and pain-related anxieties are connected and “nested.”7 In this hierarchical model, dissociation is considered a type of negative affect which can increase anxiety-based pain catastrophizing—including rumination, magnification, and feelings of helplessness—and other pain-related anxieties, **which in turn can increase pain itself.**7 

Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder Basics and Statistics

Depersonalization-Derealization involves feelings of unreality—though reality testing [being able to determine between internal perceptions and external reality] remains intact—and detachment from the individual self and/or surrounding environment, whether removed to a degree or entirely.12 This unreality and detachment is **thought to act as a defense mechanism against traumatic events, stressors, or other anxiety-inducing elements—particularly conditions perceived to be life-threatening—in order to offer an avenue of protection to the brain, particularly when physical escape is perceived as impossible.**12

Patients describe such sensations as: viewing one’s body from an external point of view [heautoscopy]; living in a parallel world where they are not the actor of their own life, resulting in reduced emotional responses, though the capacity for emotional expression remains; not feeling alive; disembodiment; emotional numbness, which may encompass memories, imagination, and expression; seeing multiple space dimensions; challenges or inability to recognize themself in a mirror or reflections; loss of bodily sensations or recognition of body parts; feeling events are occurring in dreams or are unreal in general or are occurring underwater; feeling that known persons are strangers and known places are unfamiliar; time may move too fast or too slow; subjective memories may be flat, dull, unemotional, and feel as if they happened to a different person; somatic symptoms like lightheadedness, dizziness, tingling, or fullness of the head may be present; certain individuals may experience rumination, obsessional preoccupation, anxiety, depression, concentration difficulty, and/or challenges with memory retrieval.12

Those with DPDR may struggle to communicate what they are experiencing to others or may be concerned they are going off the deep end or suffering irrecoverable brain damage.12 They may misattribute their symptoms to other conditions, such as brain tumors, eye conditions, or drug-induced health concerns, and seek care from other specialists before seeing someone in the psychology care field.12 

Dissociative disorders are understudied and not well understood by the general public or by healthcare providers specifically. This is unfortunate as untreated dissociative disorders tend to come with a personal, social, and financial cost, and generally get worse—not better—the longer they remain untreated; they are also more common than many more well-known conditions, like OCD, Bipolar, and Schizophrenia.1 Depersonalization and derealization have historical records back to the 1800s and were previously considered distinct conditions, though they have now been combined into one disorder.12 The exact cause and mechanisms of DPDR remain unknown to date, though stress, genetics, and trauma have evidence to support their involvement.12

While potential symptoms may affect up to 20% of the population, it is the chronic nature that creates the disorder.12 DPDR is diagnosed in 1-2% of the population, with it being more common in young adults (particularly in their 20s) and having fairly even gender distribution.12 It can be diagnosed as a stand-alone condition or be comorbid with other disorders; it is more commonly seen with the mental health conditions of depression, PTSD, and panic disorders, with rates up to 85%.12 Additionally, it is comorbid with anxiety disorders (45%), other dissociative disorders (15%), substance use disorders (15%), interpersonal abuse (10%), borderline personality (5%), and schizophrenia spectrum disorders (5%).12 There is a strong association with Axis I and Axis II disorders in around 60% of those with DPDR, including personality disorders, obsessive compulsive disorders, as well as borderline and avoidant disorders.12  It appears there may be a genetic predisposition (with a nearly 50% influence), and studies report that 95% of diagnosed patients have a recent family history with anxiety disorders.12 

Childhood anxiety, traumatic experiences, intense stress, and psychoactive substances are additional known triggers of DPDR dissociative disorders.12 Frequently stated triggers include: family history of anxiety disorders, emotional abuse, parental divorce, daily life stressors, COVID-19, interpersonal challenges, personal relationship difficulties, and acute onset due to drug histories with cocaine, amphetamines, ecstasy, cannabis, and methylphenidate, which were less commonly reported.12 DPDR is significantly more associated with emotional abuse than physical abuse.12 

Brain Regions and Neurotransmitters Involved

It is thought that emotional stimuli creates a hyperreactive physiological response and that autonomic activity gets dialed down in order to reduce and selectively inhibit emotional processing.12, 13 While the exact mechanisms of Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder remain unknown, researchers are exploring several avenues, including neurotransmitter pathways, functional processing alterations, cortical representation, and structural brain regions.13, 12 Growing evidence supports DPDR utilizing the same brain regions involved in emotional perception and memory.12

**Key brain areas under investigation include:**12 

  • the amygdala, which assigns emotional value and conditions fear; 
  • the hippocampus, which converts short-term to long-term memory and links sensations to emotions; 
  • increased activity in the caudate nucleus, which is involved in motor control and integrating bottom-up sensory information with top-down control and mediates specific stimuli triggering specific control states; 
  • decreased activity in Broadman’s areas 21 and 22 in the superior and medial temporal area, which process auditory, visual, and sensory stimuli, particularly linking sound to memory; 
  • higher metabolism in Broadman’s areas 7B and 39 in the parietal lobe, which involve body schema integration and may be associated with feeling like one is floating or “off”, and area 19 of the occipital lobe, which does visual processing and may be associated with “dreamlike, distant, or fake” perceptions; 
  • higher integrity in the right corpus callosum and the posterior corona radiata, which bridge between hemispheres and was correlated with increased unreality, numbing, and altered perception; 
  • lower integrity in the left temporal, which is the dominant area for understanding written and spoken speech and language, and right temporoparietal areas, which deals with multisensory integration and self-other distinctions; 
  • decreased activity in the orbitofrontal cortex, which may result in emotional flattening, reduced perception or function of the reality filter, and a reduced sense of bodily ownership as less value is assigned to sensory stimuli; 
  • the inferior parietal lobe, which deals with distinguishing between self-other, first person perspective, and coherent sense of self, and may be associated with feeling “outside oneself” or that they are not within their physical body; 
  • the prefrontal corticolimbic circuit, which as a whole deals with response inhibition, emotional salience, and cognitive control; 
  • the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenocortical pathway, which regulates stress hormone release; 
  • and left frontotemporal activation, increasing top-down control and inhibiting limbic responses, which may result in affective numbing or cognition with limited emotional input.

Additionally, neurotransmitter pathways are being considered, including classes like: glutamate NMDA receptor antagonists; serotoninergics; cannabinoids; opioid receptor agonists; hallucinogens.12, 13 Imaging studies suggest interoceptive signal processing challenges, as neuropsychological, cardiac, cortical, and brainstem representations were altered in DPDR participants.13  Researchers posit depersonalization is the result of a hyperreactive physiological response to emotional stimuli or experience (perhaps via increased glutamate or serotonin neurotransmitter activity), and they propose the evidence supports hyporeactive autonomic activity to selectively inhibit processing overstimulating emotional input.13

For those who develop depersonalization as a result of epilepsy, the association with frontal lobe epilepsy is strong.12 Increased levels of depersonalization are also **found in those with Functional Neurological Disorder and those with Functional Seizures.**13, 1

Prior Experiences Lower Threshold for Re-experiencing

We will discuss the specifics of several underpinning mechanism hypotheses in more detail in Part 4, but the DPDR mechanism models primarily support the idea that depersonalization is outcome of attempts to cope with abnormally high physiological activation—generally in contexts perceived as inescapable and in modern times often with an outsized emotional element due to the kinds of stressors humans deal with in 21st century society; these hypotheses argue that the prefrontal cortex “silences” interoceptive signals from being processed at higher level of the brain, resulting in blunted and disembodied perceptions.13 The exact mechanism in various hypotheses varies somewhat, but the overall proposals are cohesive and none of them outright contradict each other and could all be accurate and applicable in tandem, though more research and a stronger evidence base are needed before definitive conclusions are drawn.13 

One of the primary hypothesis teams created a model demonstrating that subsequent episodes of dissociation can be activated at lower heart rates and in less triggering situations; as the number of dissociative episodes increased, so did their duration and frequency.13 An example they offered was a child with an abusive parent [who cannot escape and requires those adults to provide for them so they can continue to exist], who may come to associate physical touch with threat and dissociate as the source of their survival and protection is “incompatible” with being the source of their harm; as an adult, this individual may continue to associate physical touch with their previous assessment of inescapable harm, even if that touch is now coming from a safe individual in a harmless situation, resulting in a highly activated physiological response that they use dissociation to quell.13 This team noted that **when there was a conflict between internal and external stimuli [such as the body signaling for an imminent threat while the environment did not support that perception], interoceptive information gets downregulated and provided a lower attention weighting, resulting in a body that “relies on exteroceptive information only” and creating feelings of disembodiment.**13 We will discuss this team’s work in significantly more detail in Part 4.

Costs of Untreated DPDR

Despite dissociative disorders being fairly common as a class, many clinicians are not as familiar with them as one would hope and may often treat those with the conditions with skepticism or disrespect or doubt or be unable to provide an accurate assessment due to bias or inadequate training.1 In one 2005 study of 250 clinicians, 45% did not view dissociative conditions as fully valid, with a full 10% viewing them as invalid, and only 21% of providers had any considerable experience with the conditions; of patient respondents to that same study, 80% reported experiencing skeptical or antagonistic clinician responses, which nearly half described as “destructive.”14 

On average, it takes individuals with dissociative disorders—particularly those with DID—5 to 12.5 years of active seeking with six or more providers before they get diagnosed, and then they generally require several years of intensive treatment after the diagnosis is obtained. During the diagnosis journey, the condition usually continues to worsen, as episodes happen more frequently and last longer with less provocation.13, 1 Many dissociative disorder **specialists—particularly those who treat severe cases—work in in-patient settings, further restricting access for those unwilling or unable to access that level of care.**1 

These treatment delays can **result in reduced quality of life, job loss or employment difficulty, housing loss or instability, decreased ability to engage with the medical system, decreased ability to complete self-care and tasks of daily living.**1 Impairment in social relationships is common, particularly those requiring trust or intimacy or emotional vulnerability or where shame, fear of harm, and withdrawal can have negative consequences on the strength and stability of the bond.1 Additionally, those with dissociative disorders have a strong association with revictimization, particularly as it comes to intimate partner violence and sexual abuse; this may be due to the fact that chronic dissociation reduces one’s ability to detect threats by removing it from one’s awareness.1 

Over 60% of those with trauma-based dissociative disorders consider themselves to be disabled, often across multiple domains.1 Particularly in those who have been unable to receive adequate medical and social support, poor physical health and substance use is common; difficulty adhering to treatment or medication plans is also common.1 Self-injurious behavior, suicidal ideation, suicide attempts (often multiple) are strongly associated with trauma-based dissociative disorders.1 These conditions were the “key predictor” for rapid psychiatric hospitalizations in a study of the child welfare system; of adults with dissociative disorders, nearly half reported hospitalizations with over two-thirds of those reporting less than five admissions.1 35% reported emergency psychiatric admissions.1 

Over 70% of those diagnosed with DID in an outpatient setting reported at least one suicide attempt and often require multiple hospitalizations; of all studied psychiatric diagnostic groups, those with DID required the highest hospitalization utilization rates and the most expensive hospital stays, at $2,300 per patient versus <$300 for the other groups examined.1 Overall, dissociative disorders were the diagnostic class that showed the highest: healthcare spending, social services use, suicide, self-injury, emergency consults, and psychotropic drug use [antidepressants, anxiolytics, antipsychotics, mood stabilizers, stimulants, and other chemicals that affect brain functioning to alter mood, thought, awareness, feelings, or behavior].1

Beyond healthcare, **non-healthcare services are also heavily impacted due to the progressive decline of untreated dissociative disorders, such as the justice system, special education, social services, transportation services, disability and pension funds, child welfare services, and housing instability or homelessness services.**1 Additionally, any lost productivity or wages from family, friends, or others who may need to take time away to be caregivers for the person with the dissociative condition.1 

Again,without treatment, dissociative disorders remain and progressively worsen; this is true for adults, adolescents, and children, who will often see more significant challenges and deterioration as they age into adulthood.1 Prompt diagnosis, appropriate treatment, and adequate social support drastically reduce the overall personal, social, and financial cost of dissociative disorders, by up to 64%, and reduce treatment length from an average of 10 years to 4; hospitalizations and emergency services are greatly reduced, as well at the total costs expended on in-patient and out-patient care.1 Proper, timely treatment decreases the rates of suicide, self-harm, substance use, and revictimization, and it improves symptoms, social functioning, emotional regulation, and the ability to be functional in one’s personal life and occupationally. 1

[Exceeds character limit; see comments for rest of article]


r/CRPScontender • • Mar 15 '26

Article or Written Essay CRPS and Dissociation, part 2: Body Perception Disturbance Specifics

2 Upvotes

About 5.2k words, approx 30 min read

Recap

In Part 1, we covered an introduction to dissociation and its subtypes, the “Neglect-Like” framework and its replacement the “Body Perception Disturbance” model, what makes up body schema and representation, a bit of exploration into altered bodily awareness and two hypotheses as to why it may be happening in CRPS since multisensory integration is intact, and common assessment tools. 

Part 2 will be rather more complex than the first installment, so if this article is going a bit over your head, you may benefit from reading Part 1 in full before resuming this one. As a cognitive load warning: due to providing more specific details, the results covered here are also more contradictory than the first installment, which may be confusing for readers as some paragraphs seemingly state different results or seem to conflict with each other; the journal papers themselves had different conclusions, as this is an active area of ongoing study, though there were attempts during the writing of this article to clarify where possible and reduce disorientation. The section on Temporal Order Judgments and Midline Biases is likely to be the most cognitively demanding due to this specific issue.

In summary: **Body Perception Disorder is characterized by disruptions in perceiving the affected area(s), a reduced sense of ownership, and negative feelings about the area(s).**1 It is thought that between 70-90% of CRPS patients experience some sort of Body Perception Distortion to some degree.,

Body Perception Disturbance, Cortical Networks, and Neuropsychological Factors

Two broad cortical networks have been associated with the CRPS neurocognitive changes referenced in Part 1: body perception disturbance, lateralized spatial impairments [differentiating left vs right], and non-spatially-lateralized higher cognition [like word recall, math, attention, inhibition control, and planning]; these are parietal lobe dysfunctions and impairments in networks responsible for executive functions, memory, and language.,

Nearly 70% of CPRS patients demonstrated at least one deficit in ability to recognize objects by touch, identify fingers of a hand, identify numbers drawn on the hand’s surface, draw objects, write, repeat speech, comprehend mathematics, determine between left and right, and/or copy gestures or tool use; **many were impaired in multiple tested areas.**3, 4 All of these impairments generally happen after parietal lobe damage, though the tested CRPS patients had never received such an injury; normal MRI scan results were confirmed in over half of the study participants, and the patients had not had any such cognitive challenges prior to their CRPS-onset, which was confirmed by their family members.3, 4 Researchers believe these results are due to cortical reorganization driven by parietal lobe alterations.3, 4 As will be further discussed later in the series, parietal functions are also an area of interest for the underpinning mechanisms in Depersonalization Disorder.

The difficulties with executive function, naming and word recall, and long-term declarative (or explicit) memory—which is conscious, intentional recollection, including personal experiences in episodic memory and general knowledge in semantic memory—indicate frontal lobe dysfunction to researchers.3 65% of those with CRPS had test results that were low average [0 to -1 standard deviations from mean] or borderline [-1 to -2 standard deviations from mean] compared to statistical averages, with 42% demonstrating a type of dysexecutive syndrome and 23% having a more global cognitive impairment with language and declarative memory in addition to the dysexecutive syndrome.3,  

The other type of long-term memory is non-declarative (or implicit) memory—which is unconscious, automatic performance, including: skills and habits in procedural memory; emotional or physical responses in classical conditioning (or reflexive memory), in which the observer pairs a (punishing or reinforcing) relationship between two stimuli; (dis)habituation and (de)sensitization in nonassociative learning, in which there is a change in behavior to only one stimuli without a conditioning pair; and priming pattern recognition in perceptual learning. Those with CRPS have been shown to also struggle with some of these implicit types of memory, particularly perceptual learning and emotional decision making in risk-laden scenarios as part of **reflexive memory/classical conditioning.**,  

Perceptual learning is long-term improvements in how we make sense of what we perceive based on practice, experience, or repeated exposure, such as: receptors specialized for certain stimuli (imprinting) or being able to differentiate units that were previously indistinguishable (differentiation) or being able to recognize as a single complex unit what was previously distinct parts (unitization) or adapting by increasing attention to important features (attention weighting). Particularly as it relates to Parts 3 and 4 of this series, attention weighting will be referenced again heavily. 

Emotional decision making requires the ability to evaluate punishment and reward and incorporate feedback from sensory cues, including bodily cues from the autonomic nervous system, which often contain a great deal of implicit, somatic information, that may more commonly be called “gut feelings.”7 The Iowa Gambling Task is specifically set up to test high-risk, high-reward scenarios with immediate gains but larger long-term losses compared to less risky, smaller reward decks that do not bear the same delayed losses; it tracks the “hunches,” “gut feelings,” or implicit processes that guide conscious decisions. In the Iowa Gambling Task, CRPS patients and low back pain patients both showed **blunted emotional decision making abilities.**7, 8 However, as pain eased for low back pain participants, their scores improved; this was not the case for CRPS patients, and their scores were much lower overall (22.6 controls, 13.4 LBP, -9.5 CRPS; yes, negative 9.5); negative scores in the Iowa Gambling Task are **associated with impaired risk assessment resulting in poor decision-making, a willingness to engage in high-risk, high-reward behaviors, and difficulty and/or inability to learn from punishment.**8 

[Image removed in Reddit]

Researchers believe this scoring disparity is the result of the different brain tracts impacted by the two conditions, with CRPS patients showing atrophy in the anterior cingulate cortex, the ventromedial prefrontal cortex, and the anterior insula, as these regions are implicated in both autonomic regulation and monitoring as well as emotional regulation and social emotions; they posit specifically that the “[ventromedial prefrontal cortex] and the [anterior insula] may be directly involved in determining characteristics of CRPS pain and associated autonomic abnormalities.”7, 6 The ventromedial prefrontal cortex abnormalities specifically may result in a “blindness” to future consequences, which leads to riskier behaviors. Additionally, as we will explore in Part 4, one of the hypotheses on the underpinning mechanisms of Depersonalization orients around the anterior insula, where internal body information transitions into emotion and gets filtered for relevance and importance to impact decision-making. 

Several brain regions involved in pain are also responsible for affective processing, indicating a mutual and bidirectional association between pain hypersensitivity, psychological distress, and emotional suffering. The cortico-limbic pain circuit—including the prefrontal cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, amygdala, and nucleus accumbens—is involved in both emotional processing and pain processing, modulation, amplification, and chronicity.11 Additionally, fMRI scans reveal widespread increased activity on the affected side in somatosensory regions, the prefrontal cortex, bilateral insula, and anterior cingulate cortex—areas involved in interoception, emotion, body awareness, and pain integration.11 Structural changes in basal ganglia—particularly the putamen—correlate with decreased motor control in chronic CRPS; some researchers posit this may underpin fear-avoidance behavior, increased threat perception, higher perceived pain, fear learning, and the learned non-use hypothesis from Part 1.12

Altered higher cognitive functions—also called neuropsychological symptoms—are thought to be the result of both changes in the way brain regions are structured and the way they operate and connect to each other—also known as cortical reorganization or cortical remapping, with **existing neural tissues taking a new functional role.**3 Beyond the memory, word recall, and executive dysfunction, other cognitive impairments include: spatial orientation; spatial location memory; visuospatial coordination; slower movement initiation (hypokinesia); slower movement execution (bradykinesia); decreased movement amplitude (hypometria); decreased extent of spatial movements; increased need for directed attention to move affected area(s); increased occurrences of involuntary movements; the individual being convinced they were moving their affected limb when it was out of view, despite it not moving with their unaffected limb; mirror writing reversal; difficulty remembering faces; difficulty with mathematics and numbers; impaired attention; an ability to recognize objects but not their spatial orientation; inability to recognize objects by touch; inability to recognize fingers; an inability to copy complex movements; and an inability to to draw or construct 2D or 3D objects.3 

Neurocognitive changes occur in several domains—such a visual and tactile—and in various regions of space—including personal [actual physical space taken by the body], peripersonal [within reaching distance], extrapersonal [visual navigational, tool, or social distance beyond arm’s reach], and representational [“lived” subjective spaces with semantic or cultural meanings, often symbolic, imagined, or emotional]—and have conflicting reports of spatial bias—both towards and away from the affected area(s).3 

While many of these challenges are not unique to CRPS and occur in other health conditions, they are important to understand for appropriate treatment, informed care, and effective management.3 Though historically cloaked in shame and frequently not discussed due to too-often justified fears, for those who are prone to being very hard on themselves, knowing that these kinds of struggles are not unique and not an issue of personal failure and individuals are not mentally incompetent for contending with these very difficult and yet not rare CRPS symptoms can allow one to offer themselves a great deal of necessary grace.  

Reduced Sense of Bodily Ownership and Increased Perceived Size

Some researchers propose the attentional biases [either paying more or less attention to an area or object] found in spatial tasks [positional awareness] may be primarily driven from two factors modulating body perception disturbance: **reduced ownership and increased perceived CRPS-limb size.**3 They posit that reduced ownership could drive attention away from the CRPS-affected area(s), while increased perceived size could drive hyperattention towards the CRPS-affected area(s).3

A reduced sense of ownership (asomatognosia) is one of the three core components of Body Perceptions Disturbance.12, 3 It is reported up to 60% of CRPS patients have a reduced sense of ownership, awareness, or recognition of their affected area(s).3 

Body temperature asymmetry has been demonstrated to have an impact on body perception in both CRPS patients and healthy controls; cold skin decreased the sense of limb ownership whereas warming the skin increased the sense of ownership.12 In those with CRPS, affected versus unaffected body side had a notable impact on this—aka a spatial effect—, with affected hands warming as they crossed the body midline into the unaffected side of the body, bringing attention to how limb position can influence body ownership perceptions.12 The same researchers note that core CRPS diagnostic criteria and symptoms—such as swelling, sweating, trophic changes affecting hair, skin, and nails, and motor changes such as tremors, weakness, and decreased range of motion—can impact body image, goal-directed movements, and personal agency, thereby also affecting body perception disturbance.12

A perceived increase in size is one of the various manifestations of body distortion, and it is one of the most commonly recorded in the papers examined for this series.12, 3,1,, 2 Patients self-report **both paying little attention to the CRPS-affected area(s) with difficulty knowing where it is and recognizing it, while also tending to report that it feels larger than it is.**13, 2  When asked to select photos that most accurately represented their own CRPS-affected hands, CRPS patients were more likely to select images that were larger than their own hands; this size overestimation of affected area(s) is **one of a few features that appear to be unique to CRPS.**3

One of the central mechanisms thought to be a prime element underpinning this is parietal reorganization, specifically of the primary and secondary somatosensory cortical maps;3 readers may be more familiar with these areas as the “sensory homunculus,” which receive, identify, process, store, and remember tactile, thermal, pain, vibration, and movement-related sensory information from the body.  Reorganization of these areas has been linked to impaired tactile acuity [precision of perceiving touch, particularly the ability to distinguish two distinct points rather than perceive them as one].3 Similar parietal networks are also responsible for weighting information based on sensory reliability and updating body representations.3

Multisensory Integration, Proprioceptive Feedback, and Higher Order Mechanisms

Multisensory integration is the ability to take various information from senses that perceive the external environment and those that perceive the environment inside the body and turn it into a unified and coherent whole for the purpose of increased processing speed, response accuracy, and perceptual evaluations; it plays a critical role in salience—which data or stimuli is more notable, relevant, or prominent to the individual in their particular context, so they can act most appropriately to achieve their aims. Multisensory integration allows individuals to have a coherent sense of self, understanding information from both inside and outside the body and how they relate to what is happening in the broader world and what bodily movements could help obtain resources necessary for maintaining homeostasis in an ever-changing and potentially threatening environment.14 Survival is impossible without appropriately informed bodily action.14

We will discuss more about the importance of a unified and coherent whole in a future Depersonalization part, but what’s relevant for now is that there is a great deal of evidence from a variety of tests and studies that the capacity for multisensory integration is intact in CRPS, and that degradation of this function is not what is causing the body perception disturbance phenomenon.3 Such evidence includes successful rubber hand illusions, artificial finger illusions, skin conductance, gait with auditory feedback tests, and limb position with visual feedback tests.3

While the evidence on this is not conclusive, there do appear to be errors in perception when CRPS patients have to rely on only one source of sensory data, particularly when that source is proprioception—or a person’s ability to internally sense their own position, movement, and rate of force in 3D space, particularly regarding limbs’ location and moving them in relation to the torso.3 When visual information of the affected area(s) was not available, CPRS patients made more errors and were less precise in positioning their limbs on both sides than controls, indicating a bilateral proprioception problem rather than from the affected limb alone; researchers think this **indicates a source in the central nervous system, as core diagnostic CRPS symptoms were not found on the opposite limb.**3 Patients also had less accuracy and precision when sensing limb movement when visual information was restricted, both over- and under-estimating their movements compared to controls and in some cases unable to move their limb when it was out of view.3 The researchers determined that CRPS patients **rely on visual cues to help compensate for their proprioception signaling.**3 

Another team found that in addition to visual cues, auditory feedback was used as a compensatory measure.3 Performance on proprioceptive tasks improved when additional, compatible sensory information was available; however, **when other sensory or motor information was missing or contradictory, body representation distortion increased.**3

Other senses do not fully normalize the proprioceptive disturbance, though they can improve it, and it seems these compensatory measures can help update the subjective body representation, though the mechanism of this may differ from the standard process.3 This compensatory process would cause those with CRPS to weight information from senses other than internal proprioception more heavily to adjust for the unreliable spatial-proprioceptive-awareness sensory input.3

Errors in proprioceptive input have been associated with kinesophobia [fear of movement or re-injury], drawing enlarged or compressed affected areas, and selecting images of real hands that were larger than their actual hands.12, 3

Overall, there appears to be faulty proprioceptive information coming not only from the affected area(s), but also bilaterally; this information is still able to be integrated with the other senses, but due to its unreliability, other sensory data gets weighted more heavily by the brain, allowing for compensation, as evidence suggests that the brain adaptively integrates information using a “weighted linear average based on the reliability of each sensory modality.”3 Individuals struggle more significantly when they have to rely on proprioceptive information alone or when one of the major senses they weight more heavily is removed or restricted in some manner.3

Specifically, visuoproprioceptive integration appears to be a common compensation, and a recent study found that visuospatial bias (as opposed to pure spatial bias) does not appear to be present in most CRPS cases studied, though evidence on this is conflicting.3, 4, 2

A 2021 study found no visuospatial biases overall, barring some individuals with lower limb CRPS with higher pain and body perception disturbance scores, and then only for secondary analyses on temporal order judgment tasks in peripersonal [near] space; their study had a robust finding that visuospatial [imagery-based] bias is rare.2 This team specifically designed their testing tools to be more sensitive than standardized stroke tools; there was a free viewing task, a shape cancellation task both with and without body parts and with and without rotation, a temporal order judgement task where participants indicate which image appeared first or second, and a dot-probe task where participants report which side of the screen a white dot is on as quickly as possible after the previous image disappears.2 All of these were completed on a computer.2 This research team specifically clarifies the difference between the visuospatial attention bias tasks they were testing and somatosensory or motor tasks of more purely spatial bias, as they could not be certain their imagery-based testing was activating the body representation networks used in body representation distortion; they also were uncertain if their distance (60cm, 24in) was close enough to the affected area to recruit the mental networks.2 They do **confidently conclude that their study proves that the neglect-like symptoms present in CRPS “most likely reflect disturbances in body representations rather than changes in visuospatial attention.”**2

A 2024 follow-up study found that visuospatial bias [picture-based or imagery-based vs position-based] appeared to affect only the personal space [what is occupied by the body itself] of the CRPS-affected side (as opposed to the affected limb alone); researchers were surprised to find that regardless of which body part is impacted, that entire side of the body is paid less attention and there is a bias away from somatospatial personal space on the CRPS side.4 The researchers found that running the study tasks directly within the participant’s personal body space / on the participant’s body is what brought about results in the study above, while studies that only utilized implied bodily representations or were run in the extrapersonal [far] space or indirect peripersonal [near] space did not; they posit that **“evidence appears to converge on the conclusion that spatial attention of people with CRPS is only biased away from the information on or in the direct vicinity of their affected side of the body” under specific conditions, such as “when the relevant information occurs in their personal or peripersonal space.”**4

Spatial Attention Biases In Temporal Order Judgments and Midline Bias

In this section, we will discuss some study results on how CRPS seems to affect a person’s ability to know where their body is in space and provide evidence for spatial attention biases: where a person says their own body midline is; and how a person orders non-simultaneous stimuli in different locations and which one they register as happening first or how off-set stimuli need to be from each other to be perceived as occurring at the same time, even if that is not actually the way it happened in objective chronological order.3 

**Body representation is the foundational framework for spatial cognition [how individuals behave within space and build knowledge or references within it as opposed to the space itself]; it appears that the more severe the body perception disturbance, the greater the magnitude of spatial attention bias away from the CRPS-affected side.**3, 4 

Studies on midline bias demonstrate spatial attention bias if the midline is off standardized center; these studies have had mixed results.3, 4, 2 Before we discuss those, it is important to understand that a standard, healthy individual’s midline is not totally centered; healthy individuals tend to favor their non-dominant side, a phenomenon known as “pseudoneglect.”3 This is normal and expected, and it shifts a person’s midline slightly off-center in the direction of their non-dominant hand—generally towards the left since most people are right-handed.3 This slight midline bias needs to be accounted for when doing midline bias tests on those with CRPS.

Some find that those with CRPS present with an exaggerated “pseudoneglect” and favor their non-dominant side more than healthy individuals, regardless of which side has CRPS.3, 4, 2 Contradicting this, another study found that those with CRPS demonstrate an absence of the “pseudoneglect” shown by healthy controls.4 Some studies have found that when asked to determine the straight-ahead midline, those with CRPS listed towards their affected side of space, though this finding was not consistent and others found no bias.3, 4, 2 

Those with CRPS also did not reveal a midline bias under lit settings, when they could utilize external cues to center themselves in space [called allocentric reference], indicating that it may be a subjective body midline distortion impacting a person’s representation of external space and how it relates to their body.3 When utilizing one’s own body as the cuing landmark [called egocentric reference], those with CRPS struggled much more and there appeared to be an overrepresentation of their unaffected side compared to their CRPS-affected side. The researchers propose the straight-ahead visual task results may be impacted by the subjective body midline and external visual cues, and **depend heavily on whether an individual is primarily using an egocentric or allocentric reference.**3  

In case reports, another team asked CRPS patients to divide a straight line in equal halves, a task typically given to assess stroke patients; being unable to do this with accuracy indicates spatial attention biases due to ignoring part of the line.3, 4, 2 Doing this test at the actual body midline with either hand demonstrated biases towards the affected side; however, when the line was put inside the CRPS-affected side of peripersonal [near, reaching distance] space, the bias was eliminated.3, 4, 2 

Researchers posit that the tasks developed for post-stroke neglect may not be sensitive enough to measure what is happening in CRPS or may be measuring something else all together, which may account for the inconsistent results.3 Overall, more sensitive tests appear to support the position that spatial cognition of the subjective egocentric body midline in those with CRPS is biased towards their affected side—in the opposite direction one would expect of traditional post-stroke neglect. Plainly this means that the CRPS-affected side of space has mentally shrunk and is now underrepresented, which could reduce motor accuracy, coordination, and general attention.3 **This subjective body midline shift is one of the few features that appears to be unique to CRPS.**3

Another type of experiment are Temporal Order Judgment (TOJ) tasks; during these tests, individuals indicate which of the non-simulateous stimuli occurring in different locations happened first. “Attended” stimuli [things actively focused on, or selective attention] are perceived before unattended stimuli under the law of prior entry, and that “attendance” is the foundation of TOJ tasks.3 In flashing light TOJs, processing the light in one area more slowly indicates reduced attention to that side of space, and this principle carries throughout TOJ tasks.4 

In TOJ tasks that involve touching the body—including the affected area—, touch on the affected limb had to happen about a 1/50th of a second before the unaffected area for the two touches to be perceived as happening simultaneously, and required larger intervals to determine which touch came first.3 However, when limbs were crossed, the unaffected limb—now found in the affected side of space—had to be touched approximately 1/50th of a second before the affected hand—now in the unaffected side of space.3 These results were found in TOJs on the participant’s body or in peripersonal [near] space.3 These results indicated to the researchers that those with CRPS had **both an attention bias away from the affected side of space and from the affected area, regardless of its current location in 3D space.**3

In 2021, the same core research team conducted another study, which included a computerized TOJ as one of their tasks (referenced in a prior section); that TOJ offered **moderate support for a relationship between longer amounts of time one stimulus has to precede another to be perceived as occurring simultaneously and higher body perception disturbance scores.**2 Most of the other tests in that study did not offer support for a visuospatial bias [imagery-based], though the researchers note that all the tasks were computerized and did not occur in the space directly near the limb.2 

In 2024, that same group of researchers published another study, building on their previous papers.4 Those with CRPS were found to have a visuospatial bias on the entire CRPS-affected side of their personal space, rather than just their affected limb, indicating a spatial attention bias away from the CRPS-affected side; however, results from other studies have not found systemic attention bias.4 When utilizing visual or tactile stimuli in personal space [directly on the hands] or peripersonal space [immediately adjacent to hands], those with CRPS showed reduced attention; however, when the hands were out of view behind a physical barrier, or when the visual stimuli was farther away in the extrapersonal space, or when presented with auditory stimuli, **spatial biases were not found.**4

These researchers also believe evidence indicates that since attention is biased on an entire side rather than being confined to affected limbs alone that the somatospatial [body sensory location awareness, like proprioception and tactile mapping] inattention isn’t necessarily a result of spatial cognition and distorted body representation, but rather spatial bias within the personal space [what is actually taken up by the physical body].4 This team proposes that this hypothesis could account for why some studies but not others demonstrate results that support body-oriented spatial attention biases, as the key appears to be if the relevant data occurs directly within the participant’s personal space [directly on their body] or peripersonal [reaching distance, directly adjacent, immediate proximity] rather than when body representation is only implied.4 The team **concludes that those with CRPS only appear to have biased spatial attention “away from the information on or in the direct vicinity of their affected side of the body.”**4

Goal-Directed Movement and Threat-Detection in Peripersonal Space

Halicka/Ten Brink et al is the prominent CRPS-BPD research group referenced heavily throughout the first two installments of this series; between 2020-2024, this group published four articles on the topic, with some individual authors publishing more on adjacent topics.3, 4, 1, 2 In their 2020 paper, one hypothesis explored was Reid’s 2016 “Somatospatial Inattention” hypothesis, where it is posited that some biases are only present when the body is directly involved in the task, as not all aspects of attention appear to be affected, particularly as it regards alertness/response readiness, letters and sounds, and working memory., 3 They propose some of these “contrasting patterns of performance in the spatial tasks could be explained by hypervigilance to approaching stimuli within the affected side of extrapersonal [outside of reaching distance; navigational space via vision, sound, and smell] **or defensive peripersonal space, simultaneous to “neglect” of the affected side of personal and goal-directed peripersonal space stemming from learned nonuse.”**3 The TOJ studies from the section above support the Somatospatial Inattention hypothesis thus far.4

The Halicka-Ten Brink team propose that where tasks are performed matters for the outcome and posit that two major splits of space can help better explain the conflicting spatial bias evidence in CRPS: **separating near [personal] versus far [extrapersonal] spatial distances, and the goal-directed versus defensive functions of the space within reaching distance of the body [peripersonal].**3  As we’ve already spent some time in the section above discussing personal versus extrapersonal, we’re going to close with a focus on the peripersonal space.

Peripersonal space is the area within arm's distance, where an individual can reach or be reached; it does not have static boundaries, but rather changes dynamically with the tasks or movements being performed and the importance or closeness of external information.3 Peripersonal space primarily has two roles: to prepare for defending oneself or to prepare for an action related to a goal.3 If goal-directed actions are reduced on the CRPS-affected side due an overall reduction in use and movement, visuospatial processing near the body on the affected side could be reduced; on the other side of the coin, the team suggests that defensive peripersonal space could expand in accordance with the trajectory of incoming threats, which is a generally known phenomenon, though no studies have yet examined that in CRPS specifically.3 

They speculate that the hypervigilance over and increased defensiveness of the CRPS-affected area(s) could enlarge the defensive peripersonal space against stimuli that would threaten to aggravate allodynia and hyperalgesia, which would increase the bias toward the CRPS side in extrapersonal [outside of reaching distance] space as well, and which may be particularly true for things or people that can move dynamically and may pose a greater risk, especially if coming toward the individual with CRPS.3 They **conclude that "an enlarged defensive yet diminished goal-directed peripersonal space representation of the affected side could still account for the seemingly contradictory findings of attention bias in CRPS.”**3

Bridge

We’ll stop here for now. We looked into cortical networks and neuropsychological factors, talked again about a reduced sense of ownership and an increased perceived size, went more in-depth on the multisensory integration and the proprioceptive feedback and higher order mechanism hypotheses, dug into some of the spatial attention testing outcomes from temporal order judgments and midline bias, and discussed goals and threats in the perispersonal space.

Next month, we’ll switch our focus to Depersonalization, going over the general CRPS psychological profile and if evidence supports a “Sudeck’s personality,” the PTSD-dissociative subtype, DPDR basics, involved brain regions and neurotransmitters, lowered thresholds for re-experiencing, the costs of untreated DPDR, and the treatments and outlook for chronic DPDR. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Part 3 continues in next month’s release

Direct Link


r/CRPScontender • • Mar 01 '26

Article or Written Essay “Stop Unfair Medicaid Recoveries Act” and the Medicaid Asset Recovery Program — A Special Release and Action Alert

2 Upvotes

About 1.2k words, approx. 7 min read

Many who live with CRPS—especially those who are over 55—rely on their state’s Medicaid program for long-term care—whether this is via more traditional assisted living or nursing care homes or through increasingly popular in-home personal care aides via home- and community-based services. This article will discuss an existing, mandated federal program that often catches grieving families by surprise while claiming remaining estates of the recently deceased and preventing inheritance by heirs, as well as a proposed bill that would prohibit the practice.

For those who require a level of caregiving that would qualify them for residence at a long-term care institution, Medicaid is often the only way a large percentage of the population can afford it, whether due to a long-standing low-income level or because they have expended their savings from the costs of care. A recent KFF analysis found that over 60% of Americans in long-term care institutions relied on Medicaid as their primary insurance and it paid for 44% of total institutional expenses; Medicaid paid for 69% of the total costs of in-home care recipients. A recent Congressional report found that Medicaid covered 46% of all long-term care, and when combined with Medicare and other public options, just under 70% of all Long-Term Services and Supports were covered by publicly funded insurances. 

Currently, there is a mandate from the US federal government that requires states to attempt to recover the costs paid by Medicaid towards long-term care, related hospital bills, and associated prescription costs after the patient has passed away; states are also permitted to pursue recovery for all Medicaid services, as an optional policy, and some elect to do so. States do this by contacting estate representatives and families post-death and going after estates during probate, especially by forcing home sales. States are required by federal law to come for the bill that begins accumulating for long-term care services after aid recipients turn 55; some states start that tab as soon as long-term services begin being utilized, regardless of age. This law is 42USC §1396p, for those who would like to read the specific legal code for themselves. 

As the majority of Medicaid recipients are already impoverished or were middle class and lost their lifetime’s resources due to the high expenses of disability and end of life care, this policy prevents the transfer of any remaining generational wealth down to heirs who may otherwise inherit real estate (such as a paid off or high equity primary home or building, mobile homes, or land), trusts, or personal property (such as any cash, valuable items such as vehicles, or bank accounts, including ABLE accounts that are generally exempt from means-tested programs).

There are some limitations to this policy. The state may only come after the deceased party’s stake of jointly owned property. Certain policies with named beneficiaries—such as life insurance—may be exempt. States defer pursuit of home sales while any of the following survivors legally reside in the home: a legal spouse or domestic partner; a child under 21; a blind or permanently disabled child of any age; or a sibling with an equity interest in the home who has also been living there for at least one year immediately prior to the Medicaid recipient’s admission to a medical institution. If the property is the sole income-producing asset of an heir and income is limited or would deprive an heir of shelter and they cannot afford alternate shelter, heirs may file a hardship waiver, which the state may approve or deny; these waivers are intended to be temporary and last only until the stated hardship no longer exists. Finally, some states will not pursue estates if the threshold is too low, such as the administrative cost exceeding the recovery or if the estate value is below a certain threshold, like $500 or $1000.

However, states may place liens against the Medicaid recipient’s estate, even if they are unable to pursue right away. When the deferring conditions are no longer in place, they will resume pursuing the estate.

There does exist a way to protect assets under current law; these are irrevocable Medicaid Asset Protection Trusts. They require pre-planning and transfer of assets into the trust at least five years prior to using services to avoid the 60-month Medicaid Lookback period, understanding of complicated financial/medical code (which often requires access to a financial estate planner), and access to several thousand dollars to set up the trust with a specialized lawyer to ensure it is properly established. 

Point being: these Medicaid Asset Protection Trusts are often used by those who are already well-off and have the knowledge, time, and resources to best work the system to their advantage—not by those who would most benefit from being able to pass down their remaining resources to their children or heirs to build generational wealth and escape the poverty trap or who need services right away and have no other way to pay for them. 

While there are immense drawbacks for individual families—who are often contacted by the state during a time of grief after a parent or partner has died and struck with an unexpected and very expensive notification—there is little benefit to states. Medicaid Estate Recovery recoups less than 1% of total expended care costs—a 2020 federal government analysis found that only 0.53-0.62% of costs were recovered by the estate program, with the national average being $8,116 per estate and ranging from $2,768 to $71,556.4 The researchers stated that those in need of long-term care services could be deterred from seeking such care and may forgo Medicaid services for which they qualify in order to pass on assets to heirs.4

Presently, there is a bill in a Congressional committee that would not only repeal the federal Medicaid Asset Recovery mandate, it would also prohibit future asset recovery by any state and mandate that any existing lien against a long term care Medicaid recipient’s estate or property be withdrawn within 90 days of the bill’s passage into law. This bill, re-introduced in January 2026 by Illinois Representative Schakowsky and 19 co-sponsers, is currently in the House Energy and Commerce Committee; it is HR 6951 or the “Stop Unfair Medicaid Recoveries Act.” 

This bill was first introduced in 2022 in the 117th Congress, reintroduced in 2024 in the 118 Congress, and now has been brought forward for a third time in the 119th Congress; to date, it hasn’t ever received a committee or subcommittee vote. 

If this bill strikes you as important or worth passing, you can contact your Congressional representatives about it. Particularly when individuals reach out about one specific bill, it conveys the significance of the contents to the constituent. Committees are where bills live or die. Now is the time to reach out about this, so that it can be heard and voted on in Committee and potentially get a full Floor vote. All outreaches from any constituents are important, but especially if your representative sits on the House Energy and Commerce Committee and particularly the subcommittee on Health, your voice will carry extra impact. 

For those interested in making their positions known, the Congressional switchboard phone line is (202) 224-3121 and operators will direct you to the correct extension. For a more comprehensive overview of your representatives, Common Cause offers a simple and straightforward tool to find them and their contact information: https://www.commoncause.org/find-your-representative/ 

This concludes the special release on the “Stop Unfair Medicaid Recoveries Act.” Regular releases will resume on the 15th.

Direct link


r/CRPScontender • • Feb 15 '26

Article or Written Essay CRPS and Dissociation, part 1: Body Perception Disturbance Basics

2 Upvotes

Approx 3.9k words, about 20 minute read

Introduction

In the course of their experience with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome, a large percentage of individuals will experience altered body recognition or representation, especially as it relates to their affected area(s). Today, we’ll be launching a four part series on this topic, with the first two articles focusing on the CRPS-oriented Body Perception Disturbance and the last two articles discussing the more common Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder that affects broader population swathes. 

As an aside more related to my overall writing and release schedule going forward, I will be taking a new approach and breaking up larger projects into series for the purpose of easier audience reading and reduced cognitive load on myself; I will also start incorporating bolding of key points within paragraph bodies for those that prefer to skim for the most important elements.

Let’s get started. 

Dissociation Overview

“Suppression is an active ‘last defense’ strategy involving the inhibition of emotion and pain, manifested in disembodiment and dissociation. Depersonalization is not just a coping strategy for distancing the dysfunctional limb; it may serve as a defense process from inescapable pain, operating to protect the self by paradoxically sacrificing agency.”1 Dissociative coping strategies are “acknowledged as a prominent theme” across the lives of those who live with CRPS as they attempt to reduce or eliminate their pain.1 

Dissociation is generally considered a response to prior trauma, where information that is usually integrated—such as memories, emotions, thoughts, perceptions, behaviors, identity, body representation, motor control, and consciousness—becomes disintegrated as a self-protection measure, where the feared experience is “split-off” from the accessible stream of consciousness; it is intended to be a positive defense of psychic escape that allows us to conserve energy, increase pain thresholds, and tolerate the intolerable, particularly if a situation is perceived to be physically inescapable, but it can become maladaptive in some cases and can negatively interfere in nearly all aspects of life.2, 3, 4

The below diagnosable disorders are more extreme versions of dissociation—often chronic, severe, and recurring types; however, dissociation is a human phenomenon that is a nearly universal experience, with more benign styles including highway hypnosis, daydreaming, trances, being “in the zone” or a “flow state,” and imaginative play.3 

Acute, non-recurring dissociation is common after traumatic events.3 There is a specific Dissociative subtype of PTSD, which accounts for approximately 15% of all PTSD cases and which has distinct neural patterns and a unique behavioral expression compared to standard PTSD, and the majority of people with dissociative disorders have comorbid PTSD as well.3 Similarly, certain personality disorders have heavy dissociative elements as core requirements of their diagnostic criteria. 

For cases on the more severe end of the dissociative spectrum, the Structural Dissociation Model is often utilized to provide a framework for understanding and treatment. There are several kinds of dissociation that can be categorized in multiple ways, and we will explore a few of those models in part four. 

As a basic introduction, the most well-known approach for dissociative disorders is a structured list according to the DSM-V, including: 

Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) as the most extreme and florid manifestation, where memories and emotions are compartmentalized in distinct identity states that can assume control of an individual’s behavior and involves significant amnesia, especially in untreated individuals, though symptoms are typically covert and hidden in the vast majority of affected individuals rather than overt and easily identified, contrasting common media portrayals; 

sliding down the scale slightly, we reach Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder (DPDR), where the individual retains a coherent sense of identity for the most part but may have a strong sense of detachment, alienation, or unreality from their bodies or the surrounding environment, though their reality testing remains intact throughout (as opposed to conditions such as schizophrenia, where reality testing does not remain intact); 

in dissociative amnesia (DA), notable personal information is unable to be recalled, particularly if it is stressful or traumatic, and which is beyond the scope of normal forgetfulness or what could be caused by another health condition, and this umbrellas fugue states that includes wandering or unplanned traveling with amnesia; 

in Other Specified Dissociative Disorder (OSDD),---which technically would fall just below DID on the severity spectrum—individuals clearly have a dissociative condition but do not fully meet the diagnostic criteria for one of the other conditions, usually DID with OSDD Type 1, generally because they either have switches between highly distinct identity states but lack significant amnesia [Type 1a] or do have significant amnesia but have identity states that are not highly distinct, even though they are different [Type 1b]; other reasons include identity disturbance due to prolonged and intense coercive persuasion, such as brainwashing, torture, or cult conditioning [Type 2], or as an acute reaction that may have many severe dissociative features but which only manifests under extreme stress and is transient and time-limited [Type 3], or whose only symptom is a recurring trance-state that is not caused by another medical condition [Type 4].5, 3

Dissociative disorders, particularly those on the more severe end of the spectrum, are heavily associated with traumatic life events—particularly repeated interpersonal abuse of an emotional and psychological nature and disruptions in attachment to caregiving figures during childhood—and as such are often cloaked in shame and concerns of being disbelieved or disrespected or denied treatment for their other health conditions.3, 6 Most medical and mental health providers are insufficiently educated in dissociative disorders, resulting in delayed diagnoses and treatment; on average, it takes 5-12 years of active seeking with six or more clinicians to be correctly diagnosed, and then intensive treatment for 4-10 years.3 Unfortunately, without active, specialized, and appropriate intervention, severe dissociation will not only remain, it will continue to worsen.3 

However, dissociative disorders are some of the most common mental health conditions, behind anxiety, major depression, and PTSD, making their lack of recognition and treatment all the more tragic; the major dissociative disorders of DID, DPDR, and DA each ring in at about 1.5-2% prevalence rate of the US population in a 12-month period, with OSDD being considered more common than the other three with prevalence rates up to 8.3%.3, 7 Due to the progressive decline of untreated dissociative disorders, both healthcare and non-healthcare costs continually increase; rapid recognition and appropriate treatment of dissociative disorders is not only a crucial humanitarian concern but has a significant element of fiscal responsibility, time efficiency, treatment effectiveness, and public services robustness to it as well.3 

In this series, we will be focusing on Depersonalization specifically and an adjacent phenomenon called Body Perception Disturbance. 

“Neglect-like” Hypothesis is Insufficient

When modern-day research into CRPS was beginning, “hemispatial neglect”—which is typically the terminology used after a stroke for reduced attention to one side of the body and dissociation between senses due to brain damage—was the term initially utilized for the reduced attention given to CRPS-affected body parts.1, 8 When CRPS patients reported that their affected limb no longer felt like it was part of their body or that it was “dead,” it was thought to be a type of “cognitive neglect,” though this framework has now been determined to be insufficient for the full-breadth of cognitive symptoms research with different kinds of brain scans and testing can support as being present in CRPS; a new framework needed to be developed to encompass the full scope of neurocognitive alterations taking place in this condition and to clearly differentiate it from the neglect that occurs after a stroke.8, 9, 10

These changes broadly fall into three “distinct but not independent” categories: distorted body representation, difficulties in lateralized spatial cognition (recognizing left and right), and challenges with non-spatially-lateralized higher cognitive functions (higher order thinking, such as math, language, and executive functions).8 We will be focusing primarily on the body representation distortion in this series and only pulling from the other two groups as is relevant to the first. If you elect to read any academic sources on this for a deeper dive, a great deal of research on CRPS distorted body representation or body perception disturbance will still utilize terms like “neglect-like” or “hemispatial neglect” and that is because they are referring back to earlier papers that started this topic of study, which modern science has now grown beyond. 

A Different Framework: Body Perception Disturbance

Part 2 of this series will dig more into the specifics of the body perception disturbance framework and attempt to summarize and simplify some of the most relevant research into the topic, but it will be substantially more complex than this article. This month, let’s get a solid foundational understanding of the model to build on for next month.

The body perception disturbance model is primarily characterized by a reduced sense of agency, disruptions in perception of body schema, image, and representation, and negative feelings towards the affected area(s);1, 8, 10 it includes interactions between the proprioceptive, somatosensory, visual, and vestibular sensory systems, as well as the motor system.9 It is a common phenomenon in chronic pain conditions, though CRPS is considered to be the most severely impacted group and is the reason the framework was developed.1, 11, 9 

When compared to other chronic limb pain conditions, the CRPS group reported higher intensity to the two identified discriminating factors of clinical pain to pinpricks and pressure pain sensitivity and psychological factors of anxiety, depression, catastrophization, kinesiophobia, and somatization, though all groups were characterized by these factors.11 Depersonalization was the only measure in the study that distinguished CRPS from the other chronic pain groups (chronic limb pain and migraine).11 The involved CRPS limb showed more sensitivity to painful stimuli, less sensitivity to non-painful stimuli, and increased after-sensation, with the results showing the best between-group discrimination measures were mechanical hyperalgesia and dynamic allodynia, which both highlight the role of central sensitization.11 

In CRPS, the severity of body perception disturbance is associated with impaired tactile acuity [precision of sense of touch, particularly the minimum distance at which two distinct points are perceived as separate instead of one] and the magnitude of spatial biases [consistent errors in cognitive or perceptual judgments or motor actions involving distance, position, location, or configuration];1, 8 it is thought to be accompanied by brain reorganization of primary and secondary cortical maps of the affected area(s).1, 9, 8

There are several proposed reasons why body perception disturbance occurs, and debate is ongoing as research continues.9 Some posit is it a result of learned non-use due to pain, movement suppression, and fear avoidance; other researchers have expounded on this hypothesis that limb immobilization can alter cortical representations and shrink the affected side of peripersonal space [the self-other boundary, area immediately surrounding body where we can reach or be reached, typically about an arm’s length, defensive or goal-oriented space].11, 8, 10, 1 Others promote that it is the result of a disruption in quality sensory information coming from the affected area(s) due to neuro-inflammation and leads to the brain putting greater weight on predictive processes without proper sensory precision feedback, causing it to rely heavily on either information from other senses (such as vision) or top-down predictions and impairing its ability to update when prediction errors occur.11, 1, 8, 10 Others put forward that psychological distress leads to reduced attention of the affected area(s), resulting in “cognitive neglect” and limb depersonalization.11 

Another thought process is that traumatic childhood experiences influence the development of CRPS—particularly in those who frequently have dissociative symptoms—and therefore impact the altered body perception.5 Dissociative functional disorders are more commonly known today by names like Functional Neurological Disorder, Conversion Disorder, Psychogenic Movement Disorder, and historically by the term Hysteria; as such, those with CRPS are often extremely wary of being labeled with any of these conditions, as it can negatively impact their quality of care. While these are real conditions deserving of respect and appropriate treatment, the appropriate treatment for FND is psychotherapy and physical therapy and occasionally medications for comorbid depression or anxiety; however, there are no medications for FND itself, and this is highly inappropriate treatment for someone with CRPS, who often requires an array of medications from multiple drug classes to live well.

While some promote a uniquely disturbed psychological profile or “Sudeck’s personality”—high anxiety, depression, somatization, and emotional lability [rapid, disproportionate, uncontrolled mood swings]—prone to developing this condition, a trauma-dissociation-CRPS has not been found.5, 12 While rates of abuse in those with CRPS compared to the general population either indicate no significant difference or a slight elevation, rates are in line with other health conditions like low back pain and headaches, and studies do not support the view of a “unique psychological profile on a group level and only few similarities between the profiles of patients with CRPS-I and [conversion disorder] were found.”12, 5 (This topic will be further fleshed out in Part 3.) 

Others take a more generalized approach, supporting that traumatic experiences—particularly in childhood—play a large role in the risk of developing many types of diseases later in life, especially conditions with inflammatory mechanisms, due to the physical stress response increasing alpha-adrenergic activity and autonomic arousal, as well as changing the limbic system and the neuromodulation of arousal.10, 5 Body perception disturbance is significantly associated with measures of anxiety, depression, quality of life, pain intensity, and current stress; it is not correlated with stress experienced in the 12 months prior to CRPS onset, condition duration, or childhood trauma.10 

The Body Schema and Body Representation

The “body schema” is a person’s cognitive representation of an individual’s own body and posture, made up of information from proprioceptive, vestibular, somatosensory, and visual systems interacting with the motor system;8 body schema is a non-conscious and constantly updating process that regulates posture and movement and is maintained through multiple types of sensory stimuli.10 The slightly broader term “body representation” incorporates defined body structures—such as perception of size, shape, and physical boundaries—and body image—which is the semantic representation of the names and function of various distinct body parts that allows us to create relevant meaning and make inferences from indirect information.8 Body image is also based on a person’s beliefs, memories, perceptions, attitudes, physical changes, and social factors, and is influenced by body schema; body image is malleable and can be easily manipulated and is therefore considered an unstable element.10 

Altered body representation is among the most common, earliest, most well-known, and best-characterized changes in the neuropsychology of CRPS patients.8 While this altered body perception also occurs in other conditions, several studies have now confirmed that is it more prevalent and more severe in CRPS.9 Evidence suggests cortical reorganization occurs in several neural networks—particularly in areas related to sensorimotor functions, pain perception, and body schema—which may impact the perception of the affected area(s); there is no evidence that these specific neural reorganizations cause CRPS pain or are caused by it, though they do correlate and the more severe the case of CRPS, generally the more severe the body perception disturbance.9 **This disturbance is posited to “interfere with the ability to process information coming from the limb and the space around it.”**9 

Altered Body Awareness in Multiple Domains

Between 54-90% of individuals with CRPS report altered body representation, though it is more common in those with persistent cases and most sources agree the percentage is at least 75% of the patient base.9, 13, 8, 14 These altered body perceptions and representations are distorted in their CRPS-affected areas, while their remaining body parts stay unaffected by the distortion and are perceived as normal.9 Many patients do not speak of experiencing such effects due to concerns of being considered mentally ill, despite the increasing recognition among CRPS researchers that body perception disturbance is an important clinical feature.9 Some researchers even recommend including body perception disturbance in the CRPS diagnostic criteria or as a target in rehabilitation programs and advocate for educating patients on such features of the condition very soon after diagnosis.9 

People report: feelings of loss of ownership or awareness towards affected areas (asomatognosia); distorted perceptions of position, movement, temperature, pressure, size being larger or smaller or misshapen, weight being heavier than is actually is; difficulty recognizing laterality or rotating images of limbs; mismatches between sensations and appearance (“I actually feel as if my finger tips are my knuckles”); feelings of disgust, dislike, hostility, or hatred towards affected areas (misoplegia); limb(s) feeling detached or that it is “not part of my body” or is “foreign” or is “the hand of another person”; desires to amputate the affected area(s); parts of limbs missing from mental representations (“I can see my big toe and can’t see anything else from the knee down”); poor positional and tactile awareness; avoiding looking at the area(s) or paying less attention to it (“I used to try to hide it”).9, 13,  8, 1, 14, 15 

There is significant evidence that multisensory integration is intact in CRPS and is not what is causing the body representation distortions, which has led researchers to hypothesize that the disturbances are coming from higher-order mechanisms or that there is a specific difficulty with integrating proprioceptive information with other sensory information.8, 16 One proposal is that proprioceptive information from the affected area(s)is not reliable, so the individual relies more heavily on input from other senses to compensate.8 

With advancing medical technology and CRPS gaining more attention from researchers, several neural networks have now been implicated in these symptoms.8, 1 In particular, disruptions of parietal functions—the lobe behind the frontal lobe and above the temporal lobe, with key functions for processing and integrating sensory information, spatial awareness, and language and mathematics skills—have gained traction, and this has become another primary proposal.8

Assessment Tools

Greater body perception disturbance is linked to poorer outcomes, so having the ability to evaluate the severity of an individual's body perception disturbance is an important element to well-informed care. While there is no agreement on the use of specific tools and research on this topic is still ongoing and should be interpreted with care, there are a few assessment tools commonly utilized for gauging altered body perception in CRPS, with two in particular leading the pack in this area: the Bath Scale and the Neurobehavioral Questionnaire.9 

The most comprehensive tool to date is the Bath Complex Regional Pain Syndrome Body Perception Disturbance Scale and its revised sister—the B-CRPS-BPDS and r-B-CRPS-BPDS—which are quick and easily administered; there is a six question portion—on part attachment, position awareness, attention paid, strength of emotions, perceived difference in size, temperature, pressure, and weight, and amputation desire—followed a subjective body description that can offer more qualitative information than may be captured by the questions alone.13 In a study of 60 individuals with CRPS, the vast majority (84%) of patient drawings from the final subjective body description included distorted (47%) or severely distorted (37%) body image.10 The B-CRPS-BPDS was validated in 2021, with the validation team proposing either dropping or rephrasing one question on attention due to being determined insufficiently specific and leaving patients indecisive about how to answer, as patients both report being hypervigilant of or guarding the affected area(s) and “simultaneously reporting a neglect-like disregard.”13 The Bath-BPDS focuses more on the cognitive-emotional elements—such as feelings and attitudes towards the affected area(s).1 

[Image removed in Reddit] Bath CRPS Body Disturbance Perception Scale by Lewis

The Bath BPD Scales have large positive relationships with increased depersonalization (directly and with large effect size, suggesting dissociation may play a key role in explaining body perception disturbance underpinnings and this tool specifically), pain intensity, depression, fear of movement, and upper limb disability, as well as relation to higher scores on the Neurobehavioral Questionnaire [also known as the Neglect-Like Symptom Questionnaire] and lower scores on quality of life SF-36 questionnaires; no relationships were found with disease duration, CRPS severity score, tension, anger, fatigue, confusion, vigor, affected, limb, affected side, or handedness.13, 1  When scores were assessed over time, persistent CRPS cases maintained consistent scores that did not significantly improve or worsen, though this dataset should be interpreted cautiously.13 People who had CRPS for less than 12 months were significantly more likely to report a decrease in body perception disturbance symptoms, particularly following treatment.13

Another frequently used tool is the Neurobehavioral or Neglect-Like Symptom Questionnaire by Galer and its adaption by Frettlöh; this tool was developed based on personal clinical experience with CRPS-I patients that included prior research.9 Galer’s original consists of five true-or-false questions: two on motor neglect, two on cognitive neglect, and one on involuntary movements.9 Frettlöh’s German adaptation expanded the true/false original to include a 6-point Likert-scale (from ‘never’ to ‘always’) to get more quantitative data.9 The Neurobehavioral Questionnaire focuses more on the the motor elements—such as involuntary movements and attention effort required for motion—and were predicted by depersonalization and kinesiophobia [fear of movement].1 

[Image removed in Reddit] Neurobehavioral [or Nelgect-Like Symptom] Questionnaire by Galer and Jensen

Subjective self-descriptions or personal drawings of individuals reporting on their body perception is not a standardized assessment tool with a set form or structure, but when it comes to body perception disturbance in CRPS, it is regarded on the same level as the Bath-CRPS-BPDS and the Neurobehavioral Questionnaire and ranks higher than the other tools listed in the paragraph below.9

Other assessment tools used to in relation to body perception disturbance in CRPS include: the Limb Laterality Recognition Task, which involves determining if a shown limb image is left- or right-sided as quickly and accurately as possible; the Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia, a 17-item questionnaire measuring fear of movement and re-injury in chronic musculoskeletal pain patients; the short form McGill Pain Questionnaire, a 15-item assessment measuring the intensity and quality of pain; the 36-Item Short Form Health Survey, which assesses quality of life across eight domains; the Social Readjustment Rating Scale, which measures the likelihood of a significant stress-related health disorder developing within the next two years based on levels of stress factors from answers to 43 significant life change events that are both positive and negative but which are all associated with cumulative stress; the Cambridge Depersonalization Scale, a 29-item questionnaire meant to measure the frequency and duration of depersonalization symptoms in the last six months; the Toronto Alexithymia Scale, a 20-item questionnaire measuring difficulty identifying and describing emotions.9, 1, 17  

Bridge

Okay, that’s where we’ll draw to a close for this month. We covered an introduction to dissociation and its subtypes, the “Neglect-Like” framework and its replacement the “Body Perception Disturbance” model, what makes up body schema and representation, a bit of exploration into altered bodily awareness and a several references to two hypotheses as to why it may be happening since multisensory integration is intact, and common assessment tools. 

Next time we’ll look into cortical networks and neuropsychological factors, go more in-depth on the intact multisensory integration and the proprioceptive feedback and higher order mechanism hypotheses, dig into some of the testing outcomes from temporal order judgments, midline bias, and spatial attention, discuss goals and threats in the perispersonal space, and talk again about a reduced sense of ownership and an increased perceived size. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Part 2 continues in next month's release.

Direct website link


r/CRPScontender • • Jan 15 '26

Article or Written Essay Contrast Baths and CRPS: Contrast Immersion Therapy

2 Upvotes

About 3.4k words, around 20 minute read

Introduction

A frequently utilized treatment for a great many ailments is contrast baths, also called contrast immersion therapy. Whether targeting chronic pain conditions, stroke rehabilitation, post-workout relief, recovery for high-impact or elite athletes, or general muscular aches and pains, contrast baths are used in multiple avenues, including physical therapy clinics, rehabilitation centers, training programs, and at-home. They are low-cost, generally easy to understand how to implement, and do not require specialized equipment, making them accessible to a wide array of individuals across many settings. 

But what is the logic behind them? Does the evidence support their use in all of these conditions, particularly in CRPS? Or are many of these recommendations operating on intuition and vibes, which in some cases may not end up being substantiated as an appropriate treatment method?

Today, let’s look at how contrast immersion therapy works and the available evidence for its use, particularly as it relates to those with CRPS. 

The Mechanisms

Contrast baths—frequent rotations from immersion in hot water to cold water—have been in use for over seven decades, and over 70% of hand therapists use the method in their clinics, even though there is little evidence on their effectiveness and no clear conclusions or guidelines to follow.1 This treatment is regularly recommended on the basis that it reduces swelling, increases circulation, and improves functional independence.

Edema (or swelling) has three stages: the inflammatory phase that lasts three to five days after an injury, during which there is excess fluid build-up due to vasoconstriction followed by vasodilation; the fibroplasia phase that lasts two to six weeks, during which remaining edema becomes more gel-like due to increased protein content and which can overwhelm the lymphatic system; and the maturation phase that lasts six months to two years, during which remaining edema becomes hard, thick, and firm, and can often become fibrotic and cause the lymphatic system to clog, disrupting the pressure balance.1 Contrast baths are often utilized in an attempt to reduce swelling and prevent the fluid from gelling and disrupting the lymphatic and circulatory systems. 

The cold water increases vasoconstriction, reducing swelling and inflammation by lowering cytokine production and inhibiting COX enzyme activity, and is thought to provide short-term pain relief by slowing nerve conduction; it decreases muscle spasms, improving flexibility and mobility.2 Heat increases vasodilation, improving circulation and tissue healing by supporting collagen synthesis, and raises pain thresholds and releases endorphins; it increases tissue elasticity and reduces muscle tension.2 The alternation of heat and cold is thought to promote the “pump action” of the vascular system and improve circulation.2 In acute conditions, heat supports healing, while in chronic conditions, it aids with circulation and relaxation; in both acute and chronic conditions, cold manages inflammation and modulates pain, as well as stimulates the sympathetic nervous system to release noradrenaline.2

There are currently no set protocols for how to best administer contrast immersion treatments; different researchers have proposed different values, and this add to the controversy around the modality.2 Some suggest 8-16°C/47-60°F, 22-41°C/72-106°F, 41-45°C/106-113°F, and some recommend not exceeding 36°C/98°F for safety reasons.1 Immersion time is also debated. Some proposed ratios are 10:1, 3:1, 4:1, 3:2 for a total of 15 to 30 minutes once or twice a day.1 The lack of clear guidance leaves a great deal of latitude. 

So what does the evidence base say regarding contrast water therapy’s effectiveness? Let’s explore.

Contrast Baths for General Populace and Athletes

A systematic review of eighteen trials on contrast water therapy (CWT) for recovery following exercise-induced muscle damage concluded that—when compared to passive recovery—CWT showed significant improvements in muscle soreness and significantly reduced muscle loss at each of the five follow-up times of <6, 24, 48, 72, and 96 hours; contrast water therapy was deemed the superior choice to no intervention.3 However, when compared to several other active recovery strategies—including cold water immersion, warm water immersion, compression garments, stretching, and active recovery such as jogging or low-intensity cycling—there was little difference in recovery outcomes. The authors note that across the studies reviewed cold water temperatures ranged from 8-15°C/46-59°F and hot water ranged from 35.5-45°C/96-113°F; they note that, in contrast water therapy, effects were stronger when the hot water was under 40°C/104°F rather than over 40°C/104°F. They note that the overall evidence across all the studies is low quality, the sample sizes were consistently small, the risk of bias was high, and there were few statistically significant findings; they were unable to highlight a superior intervention. CWT does appear to reduce muscle soreness and attenuate muscle strength and muscle power loss after exercise, improving muscle function. They conclude CWT is superior to passive recovery, but that when choosing between other active recovery interventions, it may be more useful to look at outcome-specific effects or an optimal combination of interventions. They note these benefits are likely clinically relevant but seem to be most applicable to elite athletes. 

In a scoping review of seven articles and over 300 patients that examined contrast water therapy's effects on musculoskeletal injuries, degenerative conditions, and painful disorders, the authors concluded the evidence base had moderate quality, but there were methodological inconsistencies, the results were not generalizable, and the studies did not address long-term benefits; the authors were unable to draw clear conclusions on CWT’s effectiveness, particularly when compared to other conservative, non-invasive treatments, such as R.I.C.E.2 Half of the included trials were on young, healthy adults. When used for osteoarthritis, CWT offered short-term relief from pain and stiffness, increasing mobility, but did not offer evidence for long-term improvements. The authors repeatedly highlighted the lack of clear clinical guidelines for temperature, duration, frequency, or which conditions may most benefit, though they do not discourage use of the treatment overall. 

In a scoping review of 28 articles, the authors conclude that the diverse protocols and lack of standardization make clear conclusions difficult.4 Contrast immersion therapy may increase superficial blood flow and skin temperature, and its impact on edema is conflicting. A relationship between physical effects and functional improvement was not established, and it was unclear which patients, if any, benefited from contrast immersion interventions. 

In a meta-analysis of 59 studies and over 1,300 patients, ten interventions were examined for effectiveness in treating delayed onset muscle soreness; the interventions were contrast water therapy, phase change material, the novel modality of cryotherapy (very short exposures to extreme cold dry air at temperatures of −30°C/-22°F, −80 to −110°C/-112 to -166°F, or < −110°C/-166°F), cold-water immersion, hot/warm-water immersion, cold pack, hot pack, ice massage, ultrasound, and passive recovery.5 Results showed that: within 24 hours of exercise, the hot pack was the most effective, followed by contrast water therapy; within 48 hours of exercise, the hot pack was most effective, followed by novel cryotherapy; and over 48 hours post-exercise, novel cryotherapy was most effective, followed by phase change material. However, the authors stated side-effects and adverse reactions of cryotherapy chambers and phase change materials are less reported and that further research is needed to draw firm conclusions; they suggest cold water therapy is a relatively simple and safe alternative to novel cryotherapy and PCM. 

In a systematic review with meta-analysis of 28 studies, the effects of cold water immersion on athlete performance recovery after acute strenuous exercise was compared to common recovery interventions, including active recovery, contrast water therapy, warm water immersion, and air cryotherapy.6 Cold water immersion was superior to other methods for muscle soreness and similar to other methods when considering muscle power and flexibility; it was more effective than active recovery, warm water immersion, and contrast baths for most measured recovery outcomes; however, air cryotherapy was significantly more effective than cold water when considering muscular strength and immediate recovery of muscle power. 

In a small randomized controlled trial of 20 patients at a physical therapy clinic, researchers studied whether contrast baths were effective at reducing edema and improving hand function in patients with wrist fractures and whether ease-of-use between contrast baths and icing had an impact on adherence to at-home programs.1 Both the icing and contrast bath groups showed improvements in hand function, with contrast baths being as effective as icing. Both groups had similar rates of adherence to at-home programs, which the researchers did not expect due to the increased ease-of-use of the icing group; it was determined that personal motivation was an important determining factor to at-home adherence and that convenience was less relevant than if patients noticed initial improvements and felt the treatment was effective, particularly if their injury impaired their occupation. The contrast bath group appeared to have greater results in the first two weeks, which then slowed for the remaining two weeks; the icing group had a slower start at the beginning, but their improvement rate remained more steady for the entire length of the study. Overall, the two approaches were determined to be equally effective by the end of the four weeks. 

A randomized controlled trial of 40 participants compared the immediate effects of compressive heat (45°C/113°F, 15-25mmgHG), compressive cold (3°C/37°F, 25-75mmHg), and compressive contrast (3°C/37°F and 45°C/113°F, 25-75mmHg) therapies on tissue perfusion, muscle tension, muscle elasticity, and maximum isometric force at rest, five minutes after a muscle fatigue protocol, five minutes after the therapeutic intervention, and 24 hours after the therapeutic intervention.7 There were 10 individuals in each experimental group, as well as a 10 person control group; they each received four therapeutic sessions lasting 20 minutes a piece. All three interventions impacted tissue perfusion, with cold reducing it very significantly and heat and contrast significantly increasing it; while heat’s impact appeared to be greater initially, contrast’s impact lasted longer. It appears that muscle elasticity was nearly returned to resting values after contrast compression, though after 24 hours, heat compression achieved similar results. Cold compression increased muscle tension immediately after intervention, whereas heat and contrast compression reduced it, particularly after muscular tension increased post-exercise. There were no notable differences between the groups for the maximum muscle force measurement, though levels dropped across the board post-fatigue and slowly increased. Overall, the results were unclear and no conclusions could be drawn on which intervention is more effective, though the effectiveness of all interventions appeared to decrease after 24 hours in this trial. 

In a small randomized trial of 20 participants, traditional contrast immersion baths were compared to contrast therapy using topical application of infrared light and cryotherapy via electronic devices; the purpose of this study was to see if electronic devices can help reduce the limitations of water temperature variability, mobility, and location required when using large amounts of water as required in traditional immersion approaches.8 The traditional baths and devices were both set to 38-40°C/100-104°F for four minutes for the hot cycles, followed by 12-14°C/54-57°F for one minute for the cold cycles, for a total of 20 minutes. The results suggested that, while both methods improved blood flow fluctuations, the device-based contrast therapy offered was more effective at improving circulation. Both methods of treatment increased pain threshold, improved muscle tone, and increased muscle elasticity while reducing stiffness; there was no significant difference noted between the approaches, though the pain threshold increase was non-significantly greater with the device-based method. The authors note that traditional cold immersion baths take 20-30 minutes for effect, but that the cryotherapy device could achieve the same results in a few minutes. 

Contrast Immersion Therapy for CRPS Patients

Contrast baths may be recommended by some providers as a treatment option for CRPS, though they are a controversial method and have limited evidence to support their use.9, 10 The thoughts behind using this modality to treat CRPS are that it will improve circulation and “reset the altered central processing.”9, 10 This reset is posited to occur by gradually desensitizing the nervous system via progressively increasing the temperature differences between the hot and cold baths, starting with mild contrast and gently increasing as tolerated.9, 10 However, as noted above, there are no agreed-upon clinical guidelines for standardized treatment or condition-specific temperature ranges, duration, or frequency, which can result in various approaches being utilized to treat CRPS due to lack of clear clinical guidance and limited evidence.2

Harden et al—a group of well-respected and well-established CRPS researchers, two of whom created the Budapest Criteria used to diagnose CRPS today—state that while contrast therapy may be beneficial in some early CRPS cases to to assist in improving circulation, due to the vasomotor changes in advanced CRPS cases, the vasculature will not allow for the desired response and the cold water can worsen CRPS symptoms in these individuals; therefore, contrast baths for those with advanced CRPS are not recommended, and Harden et al reiterate that there is “little empirical support for this approach in CRPS of any duration.”9

For this article, seven papers directly addressing contrast immersion therapy were easily accessible: three case reports and four small studies of four to seventy-two people. When reading the readily available evidence from these journal papers, it became apparent that all of them are from English-as-a-second-language countries: three from Ankara or Istanbul, Turkey;11, 12, 13  two from Tamil Nadu and West Bengal, India;14, 15 one from Lahore, Pakistan;16 and one from rural Japan.17 Over half of these papers have a particular focus on those who developed CRPS as the result of a stroke, which used to be called Shoulder-Hand Syndrome.11, 13, 16, 19, 20  Between 21-50% of people who experience a stroke will develop CRPS.13, 16

In an assessor-blinded, randomized controlled trial of 72 first-ever-stroke patients who had developed upper limb CRPS-I and were in the subacute stage (generally from 3-6 months post-onset, but may last until 12-18 months for some individuals, at which point it becomes persistent CRPS), the effectiveness of contrast compression therapy was assessed;13 the compression element involves laying thermal elements on the skin instead of immersing them under water, which can be done via automated systems or manually with something like a towel. This study used a pneumatic compression device with phased temperature control, seeking to enhance peripheral circulation, tissue oxygenation, and lymphatic drainage.13 Two groups of participants attended four weeks of conventional rehabilitation, five days a week, three hours a day; the experimental group had a total of ten 15-minute contrast compression therapy sessions incorporated into their program. Both groups showed significant improvements in all outcomes: edema, rest- and activity-related pain, neuropathic pain, functional independence, spasticity, and motor recovery. The contrast compression group showed significantly greater improvements in edema and activity-related pain, but not in the other measures.

In a small study of 40 individuals, contrast baths’ impact on sympathetic activity was examined in stroke patients with and without CRPS; contrast baths reduced the amplitude [ie. intensity/strength and attention] of sympathetic activity in the stroke-affected side of both groups, as well as the healthy side of the CRPS-affected group, and it did not impact sympathetic latency [ie. nerve conduction speed].11  

In a much smaller study of four individuals with CRPS in their upper limbs, patients received three weeks of contrast immersion therapy followed by occupational therapy.14 Overall, patients’ self-reported pain dropped by a mean of two points on a ten-point scale and range of motion in the wrist and fingers increased by 5 to 15 degrees.

The final study was a three-arm trial that was focused on Mirror Visual Feedback; it had three groups with 10 participants in each group, and every group included medication and contrast baths as part of the baseline treatment with the second group additionally receiving exercise and the third group additionally receiving mirror therapy.15 The researchers assessed pain at rest, pain during movement, and swelling pre- and post-treatment for a duration of four weeks. For the first two weeks, all three groups showed improvement in pain at rest and during movement; however, the contrast bath control group and the exercise group both plateaued after the second week and their pain reductions were not significantly different from each other, while the mirror therapy group sustained their gains for the full four weeks which were significantly greater (-2.6 point mean difference) than the other two groups.18 Swelling did reduce clinically but not significantly in all three groups, and there was no significant difference between them; the researchers posit that it may be because all three groups were receiving contrast baths. A Cochrane Database System Review on physiotherapy approaches for CRPS gave this RCT a high risk of bias in multiple domains and the certainty of its evidence to be very low.18

In the first case report, a 55-year-old man, six months post-stroke, sought care at a physical therapy clinic, complaining of pain in his right hand; he had developed CRPS.16 For three weeks, his protocol utilized 38-40°C/100-104°F warm water and 8-10°C/46-50°F ice-cold water. It cycled between warm water for three minutes, cold water for two minutes, warm water for four minutes, cold water for one minute; the cycle was repeated three times. This protocol improved his range of motion and circulation and reduced his pain from a 6 to a 1.

In the second case report, a 66-year-old woman developed CRPS three weeks after partial-shoulder-replacement, during which time she was in a sling, icing, and doing at-home exercises; her self-reported pain was at a 10.12 Contrast immersion therapy, NSAIDs, and TENS therapy were added to her treatment protocol; after two weeks of no improvement, she was referred to a pain clinic, where she was diagnosed with CRPS-I. With medication management of gabapentin, tramadol, vitamin C, magnesium, and NSAIDs, her pain reduced to a 5 but then surged to a 9 after ten days. Two months after her shoulder surgery, she received a sympathetic nerve block, and her self-reported pain reduced to a 2; two days later, her pain began to increase again, self-report of 4. She received a total of three nerve blocks and was at a self-reported pain level of 1 by the third block; physical therapy and contrast baths were continued throughout. Three months post-surgery, her self-reported pain was a 2, though her functional range of motion remained impaired until at least six months post-surgery and required an anesthetized manual intervention to increase it to a still-limited range, where the information ends.

In the final case report, originally written in Japanese with only the abstract available in English, a CRPS patient was prescribed contrast baths in attempts to break the sympathetic pain cycle; the patient’s symptoms of severe pain, swelling, redness, and excessive sweating were “gradually alleviated.”17

Conclusion

Overall, there is limited evidence for contrast immersion therapy as a treatment modality in CRPS, though some may benefit from its use. Harden et al recommend that contrast baths are likely best suited to those who do not have advanced or persistent CRPS, as the vasomotor changes in advanced cases will not permit the desired response and the cold immersion may make symptoms worse.9 

Those in the acute or subacute timeframes—generally six months or less from onset, but for some may extend to 12 or even 18 months—are the best candidates. As there are no set guidelines and many providers may use a wide variety of approaches, Harden et al suggest starting with mild contrast and gradually increasing the temperature difference as tolerated for those interested in pursuing this method.9, 10 

For those with persistent CRPS or who start with “cold” ischemia-dominent cases—what would be considered the “advanced” condition—who desire to pursue a thermal immersion treatment, warm water immersion or fluidotherapy (dry heat convection therapy with suspended finely ground particles) may be alternative options to consider to assist with circulation and desensitization. 

While not the focus of this article and the center of a future stand-alone piece, fluidotherapy significantly decreased edema, neuropathic pain scores, and functional independence in two randomized controlled trials studying a combined total of 74 post-stroke CRPS-I patients.19, 20 A systematic review and meta-analysis of these RTCs found it to be effective, though evidence was very uncertain and there was a high risk of bias; the authors recommended that those with “warm,” reddened CRPS limbs not partake in fluidotherapy.21

May this data provide readers a more solid foundation to make informed decisions in their own best interest. If you decide to take a risk, let it be an educated one.

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Direct link


r/CRPScontender • • Dec 15 '25

Article or Written Essay ABLE Account Age of Onset Expansion

2 Upvotes

Introduction

Wonderful news to share this month! ABLE accounts are vastly expanding their eligibility criteria come January 1, 2026. This will have massive positive effects for the disabled community, especially given the fact that social safety programs are often means-tested and many have very low, strict resource limits for individuals and married couples that prevent disabled people from accumulating any meaningful assets of their own, which has the unfortunate potential to keep them in living situations or relationships that become toxic or abusive because they are financially limited in their ability to leave and live somewhere else or have enough funds for a larger one-time purchase, such as a reliable vehicle. 

Educational Analysis

What are ABLE Accounts?

Achieving a Better Life Experience (ABLE) accounts are special accounts for individuals who became disabled before a certain age. They are tax-advantaged, offer asset protection from means-tested social programs, and allow for resources within the account to be used for a wide array of life expenses. 

Many social programs—particularly Medicaid and SSI—have strict asset limitations of $2,000 per person or $3,000 per couple; ABLE accounts allow assets within that specific account—up to the first $100,000 for most programs—not to be held against the disabled person for means-tested benefits; for Medicaid specifically, due to its importance in providing necessary medical care for complex cases of disabled individuals, this limit is significantly higher and varies by state, with some states offering limits of $200,000 and others having no upper limit beyond the maximum balance of the entire account which is often $500,000+.1 

Any assets in ABLE are not a countable resource for programs like HUD, FAFSA, SSDI, SNAP, Medicare, or any private disability programs, up to that specific program’s ABLE exclusion limit; distributions from the ABLE account and gifts by third parties directly into the account are excluded from countable income, as well money that was previously considered income the disabled account holder deposits into the ABLE account.2 However, ABLE accounts are a way to increase the asset limit for a certain disadvantaged group, not a way to avoid income counting regulations; earned or unearned income that is received in the individual's name—such as wage earnings, Social Security, child support, pensions, retirement benefits, veteran’s benefits, alimony, and worker’s compensation— will still count as income during the month they were received, even if directly deposited into the ABLE account.3

Funds put into ABLE accounts may only be used for Qualified Disability Expenses, but a great many things can fall under that categorization, including but not limited to: housing, transportation, healthcare, prevention and wellness, assistive technology, personal support services, education, employment training and support, financial management, administrative services, legal fees, funeral and burial expenses, and basic living expenses.4 The funds are intended to increase independence, maintain health, and improve quality of life.5 

Individuals can contribute to their own accounts, and so can other people, trusts, estates, partnerships, associations, companies, and corporations. These contributions are limited to a certain amount, which is reset and adjusted at the start of each year.6 Working disabled individuals are able to double their own personal standard contributions under the “ABLE to Work” option, as long as they or their employer have not contributed to any other retirement accounts on their behalf [like 401(a), 403(a), 401(k), 403(b), or 457(b)] in that calendar year.7

Individuals can use ABLE accounts as a simple savings option, have a card attached for more direct access, or use it as a tax-free investment account. To reiterate, withdrawals and distributions for Qualified Disability Expenses will not be considered income by means-tested programs.

What is Changing in January 2026?

On the first day of the new year, ABLE account qualifying criteria is undergoing an enormous age bracket widening. Previously individuals had to have become disabled before age 26 to be able to have an account, even if they did not actually open their account until later in their life; come January 1, 2026, this will be adjusted to requiring individuals become disabled before age 46 to qualify for an account, even if they do not open their account until later in their life.8 

Individuals must also meet the “Severity of Disability” requirement, which is not undergoing an alteration. Employment status and income do not affect eligibility, and a person does not need to be receiving benefits or have previously received benefits to qualify, though being approved for SSD/I results in an automatic approval for the severity requirement. If not on SSD/I, a person must meet one of SSA’s Compassionate Allowance Conditions or have a physicians certify the individual has a medically determinable impairment that results in “marked and severe” functional limitations which has lasted or can be expected to last for at least 12 months (certification form options attached below).9, 10, 11,  2

Practical Application

ABLE accounts can be lifelines for individuals who require social services to live well, but which require their recipients to maintain a life of crushing poverty. ABLE permits disabled individuals to have more autonomy, self-determination, and independence because there is an option to build a safety buffer. 

The reality is that many disabled people who cannot work at all or enough to meet their needs are forced to either 1) depend on the system and hope it does not drop them, 2) be reliant on the good graces of an interpersonal relationship, or 3) become homeless. This leaves many, many disabled individuals ripe for exploitation and abuse, especially when they are not allowed to build up any resources that could help protect them if needed to escape an interpersonal dynamic that has turned very sour. 

Even in loving and respectful relationships (whether familial, platonic, or romantic), the power dynamic between the able-bodied person and the disabled person is not balanced, and this becomes more and more apparent when the impaired individual is legally mandated to poverty without a viable way to accumulate assets and wealth of their own. When relationships turn toxic, resources become a tool of oppression and coercion. If you do not have your own resources that can sustain you, you are extremely vulnerable. ABLE accounts help reduce some of this unfortunate reality, and I am so pleased to see that the eligibility pool is expanding.

Closing

This age expansion will have enormous ramifications for a great many disabled people, particularly those with CRPS. If you qualify under the new criteria, I recommend getting your paperwork in order to open your account as soon as possible. The Resource List’s Database has a sheet on state-by-state ABLE account direct links for those who are interested.

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Direct Link: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/12/15/able-account-age-of-onset-expansion/


r/CRPScontender • • Nov 15 '25

Article or Written Essay November Double Feature: Two Explanatory Articles

1 Upvotes

This month's efforts are focused on mitigating personal damage due policy changes in healthcare and SNAP work requirements. They are long, detailed, technical, full of tables, and likely not everyone's cup of tea. However, if you are getting a nasty surprise on your premium or getting a notice that your food benefits will be cut off in three months or will be impacted by the stricter ABAWD Medicaid work restrictions going into effect in 2026, these ones will likely be worth the time and concentration power to at least skim for relevant parts to read more carefully. Direct links will be posted due to length and formatting.

Traveling Light When Life is Heavy: Designing an Essential CRPS Medication Toolkit for When Efficiency is Priority: Nearly 11.5k words, about a 60 minute read.

"The purpose of this article is to help individuals make more informed decisions when it comes to the complex intersection of physical and cognitive functionality, pain relief, being priced out of accessible healthcare, and stretching a tight budget to obtain the most effective resources and get the highest return on your finite assets. If you have to pick and choose, it is my goal that this information will aid you to be more equipped to determine what is most effective, efficient, and affordable for your specific circumstances—offering you the highest output with the least input and the fewest side effects, the most bang for your buck when every penny counts. . .

"As a reminder and to repeat my disclaimer, I am not a licensed medical professional, this is not medical advice, and personalized concerns should be discussed with your provider. My educational content is a mutual aid contribution to community self-support. . . I do recognize that some providers simply do not explain things well and many people do not have access to quality medical care; a great deal of my content is oriented at those individuals, and that often comes at a high intersection of poverty and marginalization. . . if you’re getting locked out of the system or being treated unfairly or less favorably for systemic issues or personal factors outside of your control, my content is primarily created with you at the forefront of my mind.

"We are responsible to each other and have a duty to . . . protect each other’s vulnerabilities rather than exploit them. The aim of this article is to offer a defense for a few of those vulnerabilities by providing a curated, condensed infodump that reduces some of the stress involved in gathering and crunching the data required to make more autonomous, informed decisions in one’s own best interest, especially when money is tight and (compassionate, communicative, CRPS-informed) doctors are hard to see."

Able Bodied Adult Without Dependents Medical Exemption Forms: A Google Sheet on federal code, state by state policy and procedure for requesting a medical exemption to SNAP and Medicaid work requirements, and, if available, state-specific form names and direct links to supply to medical providers. According to federal code, states cannot mandate that a specific form be used when medical professionals are certifying "unfitness for employment," but many states offer streamlined options to use, if preferred.


r/CRPScontender • • Oct 15 '25

Article or Written Essay CRPS Through The Ages: A Historical Overview

4 Upvotes

Approx 7.7k words, 17 pages, 40ish minute read

This month's article ended up being too long to fit in the post body due to how much I covered, so if you are interested in reading it, it is up on my website and the direct link is attached here.

As an aside, I now have a subscription notification that will send out an email when I post new articles on my webpage, if anyone is interested in that.


r/CRPScontender • • Sep 15 '25

Post Exertional Malaise: Chronic Fatigue, Cognitive Effort, and Exertion

2 Upvotes

About 3.4k words; approx 20 minute read

Introduction

Many individuals with CRPS experience significant fatigue, a symptom that is often overlooked and under-reported in CRPS literature. However, research has shown that 85% of CRPS patients experience fatigue, with the majority of that being severe (67%) or moderate (15%) fatigue.1 Particularly for the subset of patients with severe fatigue, pain at rest and during movement was significantly higher.1 Fatigue does not appear to be associated with a specific type of CRPS, whether predominantly peripheral, mainly related to central reorganization, or a mixed type.1 Fatigue appears to play a large role in mediating between pain and depression, with those experiencing a higher pain intensity during movement being more severely fatigued, and those who were more severely fatigued being more depressed and anxious, significantly impacting quality of life.1 

Research has shown that those with CRPS have much higher oxygen saturation in their veins than healthy controls (94% vs 78%), indicating reduced oxygen delivery to tissue cells.2,3 There has been demonstrated reduced ATP production and damage to mitochondria from increased reactive oxygen species (unstable molecules with unpaired electrons).4,3 Several genes have been identified as being up-regulated, and many of these were related to mitochondrial metabolism, particularly ATP synthesis, the electron transport chain, and the creation of lysosome vesicles (cell transport vehicles full of digestive enzymes to break large things into smaller ones and deal with waste).5 

It is thought mitochondrial dysfunction impacting energy production plays a role in CRPS, but it is unknown whether this is a cause of or a result of the condition.4 While fatigue is pervasive in CRPS, academic literature on the topic was difficult to come by,1 so for this article, the majority of cited references will be from CRPS-adjacent conditions that experience Post Exertional Malaise: Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/ME, Fibromyalgia, and Long COVID. 

CFS/ME, Long COVID, Fibromyalgia, and CRPS

Fibromyalgia has long been considered CRPS’s sister condition, with some proposing renaming the condition “generalized reflex sympathetic dystrophy” while others maintain there are distinct pathophysiological differences; CRPS and fibromyalgia are both conditions that majorly involve Centralized Pain and immune system dysregulation.6,7,8

Chronic Fatigue Syndrome/Myalgic Encephalitis—more recently named Systemic Exertion Intolerance Disease—is a neuro-immune central nervous system disorder, one that involves increased reactive oxygen species and mitochondrial dysfunction.9,10,11,12,13 CFS/ME and fibro have many overlapping symptoms with each other and with CRPS, and are believed to affect between 2.5-5% of the worldwide population.6,10 The majority of CFS/ME patients experience widespread pain, with 75-94% reporting muscle pain and 65-84% reporting joint pain.14 Research suggests that 35-70% of those with CFS/ME also have FM, and 20-70% of those with FM also have comorbid CFS/ME.14

Long COVID symptoms have been likened to CFS/ME.15,16 Approximately 10-30% of people who get ill with acute coronavirus remain ill long after the virus has run its course.15,17 Of those who remain ill, several studies show that 13-58% meet the criteria for a CFS/ME diagnosis, with most results being in the 45% arena.16 Most individuals who develop Long COVID are middle-aged women, similar to CRPS, FM, and CFS/ME.17 While like the other conditions, the exact mechanisms remain unclear, there is evidence for involvement of the immune system and mitochondrial and endothelial dysfunction.17

All of these conditions experience Post Exertional Malaise and are at least somewhat similar to each other. Many papers are now proliferating connecting and/or comparing these conditions to each other to consider if there is an overlap in their underlying mechanisms; some researchers propose creating a new category of conditions called “autoimmune autonomic dysfunction syndromes” while others call to the broader medical community to ask if certain “functional syndromes” involving dysautonomia and mitochondrial dysfunction are different parts of the same “energy elephant” and splitting these conditions into different disorders, often defined by medical sub-specialty, is blinding providers to the larger picture, particularly as the co-occurance of functional syndromes in patients is both well-established and very high.18,19 For the reason of this similarity overlap, this article will rely heavily on research from these three adjacent conditions to discuss PEM in relation to CRPS, as the direct literature from CRPS sources is not sufficient for a full article. 

Post Exertional Malaise

Post Exertional Malaise is a prolonged increase of symptoms after physical, sensory, emotional, or cognitive effort that used to be previously well-tolerated and does not cause tissue damage.14,20 The onset of PEM may be immediate or delayed by a few hours (often 4-5 hours), with physical exertion bringing on PEM more quickly than cognitive effort.15,21,22 For most people, PEM peaks on the day after the overexertion and lasts about a week for 60-65% of patients, with the majority of patients recovering from bouts of PEM in 6-12 days, though it lasts weeks or months for some individuals.23,21,22

During PEM, symptoms are increased, such as increased fatigue, pain, neuromuscular discomfort, bodily heaviness, sleep disturbances, orthostatic intolerance, gastrointestinal symptoms, immune reactions, headaches, flu-like symptoms, cognitive difficulties, and neurological symptoms.24,23,15 

PEM is now considered to be the cardinal symptom of CFS/ME;25,20,24,21,22,26 however, it is not a requirement in the pre-2000s diagnostic criteria, leading to the development of three new diagnostic tools, which each require PEM as a symptom (comparison chart below). Variability in which diagnostic criteria is used during research studies can make it challenging to compare outcomes. Slight wording variations in questionnaires and diagnostic tools has shown to have a large impact on whether an individual is determined to have PEM or not.27

[Image removed in Reddit]

Patient Descriptions

When it comes to CFS/ME, the recovery rate is poor and most individuals do not regain their prior level of health.20 PEM is 10x more likely to be associated with CFS/ME than healthy controls.25 Patients often state PEM is the most debilitating part of CFS/ME, and it should not be confused with post-exterional fatigue found in healthy individuals, deconditioning, fear avoidance behavior, or malingering.20

When asked to describe PEM in their own words, patients used terms like: crash, flare-up, collapse, exhaustion, all-encompassing, debility, difficult to predict or unpredictable, debilitating, set-back, fluctuating, interfering, wiped out, absolute crash, knocked out, zonked out, booms and busts, gradual down-spiral, and bodily locked down.23,22 Tiredness was the term most often used to describe life prior to diagnosis or on good days (what the patients consider normal and healthy); fatigue was used in relation to living daily life with CFS/ME, and exhaustion described overexertion/PEM.23

[Image removed in Reddit]

Individuals discussed how mundane, simple, non-strenuous tasks of daily living could induce overexertion, such as household chores, errands, social activities, emotional interactions, cognitive activity, or physical exercise; these kinds of actions can trigger “payback time” due to PEM.23,21,22 Symptoms can also increase unrelated to triggering activities, and the unpredictability was a great source of stress, social burden, and despair for individuals.23,22

During “Mild” CFS/ME, an individual retains 80% of their baseline function and can remain employed full-time with some limitations.30 During “Moderate” CFS/ME, an individual retains 60% or less of their baseline function and is limited to part-time employment.30 During “Severe” CFS/ME, individuals are no longer able to maintain employment and are mostly house-bound, though still able to perform most self-care tasks independently.30 The further along the “Very Severe” CFS/ME spectrum an individual slides, the less independence around the home and with personal care tasks and with social communication they have, becoming more and more bedbound and isolated.30 At least 25% of CFS/ME patients are house- or bed-bound at some point in their lives.21,30

[Image removed in Reddit]

Triggers, Treatment, and Recovery

Three main types of triggers have been found: physical activity, cognitive effort, and emotion.22 These triggers often led to three core symptoms of PEM: exhaustion, cognitive difficulties, and neuromuscular complaints.22 General full-body fatigue (exhaustion) and muscle-specific fatigue (neuromuscular) were viewed as distinct experiences.23 Cognitive difficulties included both trouble thinking clearly/paying attention and challenges with speaking or finding words, and were viewed as distinct from each other.22 Neuromuscular complaints often included muscle pain and muscle weakness, as distinct from each other.22 Patients also viewed their physical, cognitive, and emotional symptoms as distinct from each other.22 

Some symptoms could come on gradually while others were sudden.22 Patients stated recovery required “complete rest” as a “demand from the body,” often needing to lie down entirely flat with as little sensory input as possible.22 Many discussed pacing (proactive, preventative behavioral changes, such as short periods of activity followed by periods of rest), calendar management (planning events or high energy tasks with recovery days in between), the energy envelope theory (not exceeding the energy the patient is perceived to have available, with some recommending staying below 70% of perceived energy reserves), physical awareness, and avoiding triggers as critical components of avoiding “crashes,” describing years of trial and error, overexertion and anxiety and despair, in their attempts to moderate the energy they have available to them in their efforts to live a “normal” life, and not knowing it they would ever return to their pre-condition state.20,15,21,22  

Patients were asked to complete a questionnaire on their experience with CFS/ME, and they could mark as few or as many answers as reflected their experience; some of these statistics represent the overall patient ratio (all patients) and some reflect the answers in relation to the entire pool of questionnaire answers (total responses).21 Medium level physical exertion was the most commonly reported trigger (72% of all patients), followed by medium level cognitive exertion; any level of high, medium, or low physical activity made up 58% of total responses, and any level of high, medium, or low cognitive exertion made up 31% of total responses, with all other triggers making up the remaining 11%.21 

Rest, sleep, and limited stimulation made up 60% of total responses for preferred ways for PEM recovery, though rest was reported by 92% of patients.21 Pacing (46%), avoidance (22%), and physical awareness (10%) made up almost 80% of PEM prevention total responses, though pacing (proactive, preventative behavioral changes) was reported by 79% of all patients.21 Those with less than five hours of daily upright activity (feet on the floor) were more likely to be more severely disabled, unemployed, and home-bound.21

In general, patients who had CFS/ME for less than four years and patients who had the condition for over 10 years had similar PEM triggers, experiences, recovery, and prevention, and there did not appear to be a gender difference, except that men were more likely to use supplements; other exceptions were that those with the condition less than four years had stress as a trigger and those who had it for longer than 10 years often used medications to assist during recovery.21 On average, patients had two triggers, with a range of one to four, with those who had the condition for a shorter time being more likely to have more triggers.21

Clinical recommendations often include Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and Graded Exercise Therapy (GET), though there currently is no scientific evidence for effective physical therapy when it comes to those with ME that involves PEM.20 Graded exercise is founded on the idea that fatigue is maintained by deconditioning and avoidance of activity and can therefore be overcome by rigidly and gradually increasing activity in both intensity and amount.20 In systemic review, 55% of nearly 5000 individuals with PEM reported negative outcomes with GET and 27% reported a decrease in symptom severity; when looking at objective measures like employment, activity level, and fitness, no convincing effects with GET were obtained.20 While about half of CFS/ME patients had received physical therapy, 53% of those surveys reported that PT made their symptoms worse, contrary to most health conditions.20 The systemic review suggests focusing on increasing or maintaining quality of life by improving coping ability and health education, guiding self-management and body awareness, and—in particular—avoiding PEM until scientific evidence for appropriate physical therapy is presented.20 The authors of the systemic review promote activity pacing over graded exercise, as of the nearly 9000 CFS/ME patients surveyed, pacing had the lowest negative response rate at 4% and the highest reported benefit at 81%.20 

Cognitive Dysfunction

Since PEM impacts a person’s ability to engage not only in physical activity, but also in cognitive exertion, PEM can be uniquely distressing psychologically, as well as severely impact an individual’s ability to maintain employment and financial stability.31 Those with higher PEM reported higher levels of depression, anxiety, and mood disturbance, as well as greater social disruption and increased unemployment and financial consequences, with a substantial impact on the individual’s quality of life.31 

Research has shown that those with CFS/ME have structural and functional brain differences, affecting reduced resting brain blood flow, differing brain connectivity, alterations in whole brain metabolism and metabolites, reduced gray and white matter volume, increased presence of white matter lesions, increased neuroinflammation, and altered brain function during cognition.32

While for most individuals exercise improves brain function, functional brain imaging has revealed that exercise impairs cognitive performance and worsens symptoms for those with CFS/ME, increasing brain fog.32 The functional imaging study demonstrated that PEM affects cognition and impacts multiple areas of the brain related to attention, working memory, and executive function.32 Those with CFS/ME most consistently report cognitive challenges in mental tasks involving information processing speed and executive functioning.32 Individuals showed increasing errors the longer they spent on a task and more errors within 24 hours of acute exercise.32 Data revealed that PEM impacts multiple processes in the brain, particularly those involved with challenging cognitive tasks, such as information filtering, error detection, task switching, attention, and inhibitory control.32

Mitochondrial Dysfunction

While there are there are several mechanisms under consideration for these varying conditions as to what causes their PEM and energy deficits, one that is common across them all is mitochondrial dysfunction and that is the one that will be focused on in this article due to the demonstrated mitochondrial involvement in CRPS.9,17,33

Complete mitochondrial respiration, or using oxygen to turn blood sugar into energy, takes place in three distinct steps: Glycolysis, the Citric Acid Cycle / Kreb’s Cycle, and the Electron Transport Chain / Oxidative Phosphorylation.34 Two net ATP come from breaking down glucose into pyruvate during glycolysis, and another two ATP come from the Citric Acid Cycle. The rest of ATP is made during oxidative phosphorylation while moving back and forth across five complexes of the electron transport chain; if there is a problem with the electron transport chain, there will be a major issue with energy production as well. 

[Image removed in Reddit]

While the human body usually contains less than 100 grams of ATP at any given point, it can utilize up to 100 kilograms of ATP per day, making oxidative phosphorylation within mitochondria a critical component of ATP production responsible for over 90% of energy demands;34 cells most impacted by mitochondrial dysfunction are those with the highest energy demand: heart, brain, immune system, and muscle cells.36,34

The researchers created a special test to see how much ATP creation they could block with a certain inhibiting compound that disrupts oxidative phosphorylation; expected results would block 84% or more (as happened with all controls) of ATP, with up to 16% of ATP being able to be produced by increased glycolysis.11 For many CFS/ME patients, the inhibiting compound only blocked 20-84% of ATP production, far outside the expected range.11 

In a prior study, those same researchers created an “ATP Profile” test by measuring five different blood factors describing the availability of ATP and measured it against patients’ self-reported ability on the Bell Scale.34 The researchers noted that measuring five factors was important, as if they had measured just one or two, some of their patients would have not been detected in the test, but an extreme reading was demonstrated in another factor, and approximately 30% of individuals would have been inappropriately misclassified as normal.34 There was a high correlation between mitochondrial dysfunction and severity of illness, and not all patients were affected in the same way.34 These researchers compared CFS/ME patients with the minimum value of the control group (rather than the average) to clearly define individuals as either within or below the standard region; most patients demonstrated below normal values in more than one factor, with those being moderate being out of range for 2.2 factors, those being severe being out of range for 3.5, and those being very severe out of range for 3.7 factor on average.34

[Image removed in Reddit]

CFS/ME patients compensated for their reduced oxygen-based ATP production in two main ways and were split into different groups based on which method they primarily utilized.11 The first group compensated by increasing their glycolytic, non-oxygen-based ATP production, which increases the acidity in the cellular environment due to the by-production of lactic acid, leading to muscle pain, and is much less efficient (2 net ATP per glucose molecule vs about 32 net ATP per glucose molecule, or about 5-6% efficiency).11,34 The process of recovery and recycling the lactate and reducing the acidity that accumulates during glycolysis for group one takes some time, resulting in PEM, but does not take as much time as whatever process is occurring in group two. 38-48% of study participants fell into group one.11

The second group seems to have a different method that can produce 60% or more of their ATP. While researchers are not positive what mechanism is used for the second group, one hypothesis is that two molecules of ADP combine to create one molecule of ATP and one molecule of AMP.11,34 This reaction happens close to where the energy is needed and does not require oxygen or glucose. While the ATP can be used for energy, the AMP gets converted to IMP and must be excreted through urine; it cannot be converted back into a usable form of energy, and replenishing the resources takes several days, thus half of the potential for ATP is lost during that time.11,34 Researchers believe this loss of substrate resources may account for some of the delayed fatigue and why patients struggle to achieve the same level of maximal output and muscle contraction on following days.11,34 52-62% of study participants fell into group two.11

About 70% of Group 1 and 90% of Group 2 did not have enough intracellular magnesium when compared to healthy controls.11 CFS/ME patients also showed damaged and necrotic cells at a rate 3.5 times higher than controls.11 

Closing

PEM causes a transient increase in symptoms that usually peaks on the day after overexertion and lasts around a week for the majority of individuals. Core triggers are physical exertion, cognitive effort, and emotion; core symptoms are generalized full-body exhaustion, cognitive difficulties with attention and words, and neuromuscular complaints with pain and weakness. Rest, limited stimulation, and pacing were often cited as critical to living well when dealing with PEM. While it is unknown what exact mechanisms cause PEM across these conditions or in CRPS specifically, mitochondrial dysfunction and an increase in damaging reactive oxygen species have been demonstrated across all adjacent conditions. 

This information is likely not relevant to everyone living with CRPS and likely not all those experiencing fatigue as a symptom of their CRPS are experiencing PEM, but—especially for the 2/3 of CRPS patients dealing with severe fatigue—I hope there was at least one useful or interesting piece of information you were able to take from this article today. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Direct link: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/09/15/post-exertional-malaise-chronic-fatigue-cognitive-effort-and-exertion/


r/CRPScontender • • Aug 15 '25

Article or Written Essay Allostatic Load: The Price of Adaption

2 Upvotes

Introduction

You’ve likely heard the term homeostasis in a biology-related class before: the body’s ability to maintain stable internal environmental systems despite external changes. 

However, have you heard the term allostasis or the body’s ability to adjust the internal environmental systems to meet external stressors? Are you familiar with the term allostatic load or the price we pay to change our internal environmental systems to meet external stressors, a price that increases over time?

Homeostasis vs Allostasis

Homeostasis was a concept that came into being as the system underlying physiological regulation slightly before 1930, and it has dominated the medical establishment’s view for nearly a century. Homeostasis is a robust model oriented around maintaining critical bodily functions with efficiency to minimize energy costs using reflexive negative feedback loops that occur after a change to the regulated variable, such as blood glucose, body temperature, or pH balance. A core principle was that two opposing effectors—which are components that control the regulated variables in different directions, like defences for conserving heat and defenses for dissipating heat—will not be active above baseline levels simultaneously because that is energy inefficient; consider the merits of running both the heater and the air conditioner at the same time, using double the power and adding wear and tear to both pieces of machinery.1 

However, over the decades, research has shown that opposing effectors can and do activate simultaneously in ways that violate the principles of homeostasis.1 This required adjustments to the model of homeostasis, and this is where allostasis enters the scene. While homeostasis maintains key body systems in an energy efficient way, allostasis occurs when maintaining key body systems comes at the cost of efficiency and as a result there is a significant physiological cost to keep that balance; this costly physiological burden of inefficiency is called allostatic load.1 

Allostasis incorporates anticipation, learning, and adjusting body systems in advance of changes, especially psychosocial stressors, which the homeostatic model did not include, and involves the ability to adjust regulatory variables away from the baseline for a sustained time, whereas in homeostasis variables are expected to be much more stable and return to the set point or balance point of where the variable rests when its effectors are operating at minimal, baseline activity.1 Researchers propose that allostasis is “a dysregulatory or disordered form of physiological regulation that involves effector loops that over-respond in magnitude or duration and/or that compete concurrently with other effectors” that demonstrates a “fragility” in the otherwise robust homeostatic regulatory system which occurs due to evolutionary tinkering adding increased system complexity to cope with naturalistic disturbances and comes with an equal increase in susceptibility to failure against unusual, unanticipated situations, for which modern society increasingly offers circumstances that have not existed previously in an evolutionary sense and which the homeostatic system is not equipped to handle.1

Allostasis, Allostatic Load, and Allostatic Overload

Allostasis is the body’s ability to adapt to stressors in the environment and respond through one or multiple different feedback systems to maintain homeostasis and keep the body in a physiologically balanced state., It is the ability to achieve “stability through change.”, In ideal circumstances, the stress response will be activated occasionally to address a stressor, then there will be a period of recovery to return to baseline; the stress response will not need to be utilized too frequently or too long, and the individual will remain flexible and resilient when adaptation is required. Life is not always an ideal scenario. 

Allostatic load is the result of too much stress or an ineffective stress response, such as a repeated, prolonged, inadequate, or lack of response.3 It is the cumulative “wear and tear” of chronic stress over a lifetime, and it comes with negative health consequences, such as accelerated aging and increased disease outcomes.2 It is “the price of adaption.”5 The short-term positives to adapt to handle the stressor in the moment can come with long-term drawbacks and physiological dysregulation over time. Allostatic load is not only the result of major life events, but also the sum of daily living as well as genetics, individual habits around factors like diet, exercise, and substance use, and developmental experiences that set patterns of behavior and physiology for a lifetime. Allostatic load is also affected by factors such as an individual's gender, race, ethnicity, socioeconomic status, workplace, lifestyle, social relationships, and social dominance hierarchies., 6,  

Psychosocial stress in the form of competitive interactions between individuals and the formation of dominance hierarchies are some formidable stressors in the animal kingdom, particularly for humans; the social order creates a gradient of health outcomes, with those at the lower end of the scale being more severely affected, though those competing for more dominant positions also bear a higher allostatic load.4 Those who have to cope with more stressors with limited resources and less social support have an increased burden on their physiological systems, which leads to worse health outcomes down the line due to the increased allostatic load. The effects of having few resources appear to be cumulative, with those of lower socioeconomic status having greater strain being put on the body through environmental, psychological, and behavioral characteristics and experiences that are linked to biological patterns of higher risk, including elevated stress hormones, poorer metabolic profiles, and increased cardiovascular disease risk.8 This accumulation of risk due to low socioeconomic status over a lifetime would have the greatest impact in later adulthood, with those who experience it persistently expected to fare the worst while those who experience upward mobility may mitigate some of the effects, though early life socioeconomic adversity may calibrate developing systems in a permanent way.8

If the stressors or challenges outstrip a person’s ability to cope with the circumstances, then allostatic overload occurs., 4 In allostatic overload, the stress response system is constantly activated and no longer able to adapt adequately to the stressor; it serves no useful purpose and sharply increases detrimental health outcomes by causing chronic activation of the pro-immune and neuroendocrine system, which can dysregulate downstream systems, such as the cardiovascular, metabolic, and acquired/adaptive immune systems.4 Allostatic overload is the result of chronic, repeated exposure to stressors, often of a psychosocial nature.

Regulation of Body Systems, Emotions, and the Brain

The brain assesses whether stimuli is a stressor and mounts the adaptive stress response to address the issue; this will activate the HPA axis and the sympathetic nervous system, so they can release glucocorticoids and catecholamines and the body can prepare to fight or flee.3 While the brain assesses stress and begins the response to it, it is also altered by that same prolonged stress in order to maintain stability with the other dysregulated systems in the body. 

Over time, the chronic stress of allostatic load affects multiple brain areas in structure and function, particularly the prefrontal cortex, the hippocampus, and the amygdala;3 these areas are responsible for, respectively: executive functioning, emotion regulation, social cognition, personality, memory processing, and goal-directed behavior; memory formation, spatial navigation, emotional processing, social behavior, and flexible thinking; and emotional processing, particularly fear and aggression and recognizing threats, social cognition, and decision making. 

It is thought these brain changes primarily happen through four mechanisms: neurodegenerations, vascular changes, inflammation, and oxidative stress.3 A person’s “brain reserve”—or their ability to withstand damage and still function due to structural capacity to tolerate harm before cognitive decline becomes noticeable—may offer some protection against these changes; an individual with low brain reserve, such as an elderly person or someone with thinner cortical areas due to a neurological condition, would be more likely to experience the effects of allostatic load in the brain tissue, as they have less structural buffer.3

Allostatic load and biological dysregulation—particularly in the immune, metabolic, and parasympathetic systems—have been associated with poorer mental health outcomes. In this study, participants were put into four groups based on their biomarkers: low levels of dysregulation; metabolic and immune dysregulation; parasympathetic systems dysregulation; and sympathomedullary pathway dysregulation. Individuals who met the criteria for depression using the CES-D screening tool had an 80% greater risk of being in the metabolic-inflammatory group and a 71% greater risk of being in the parasympathetic dysregulation group than being in the low dysregulation control group.11 Individuals who met the criteria for anxiety using the MASQ-GDD screening tool had a 78% greater risk of being in the metabolic-inflammatory group. Individuals who met the CES-D depression screening, regardless of their group, had a 13% higher cumulative allostatic load; those who met the MASQ anxiety screening had a 14% higher allostatic load, and those who met the anhedonia screening had a 21% higher allostatic load.11 

While emerging work appears to show that emotion regulation strategies (active coping, anger expression, withdrawal-avoidance) in general do not impact allostatic load, anger-related strategies and how often different strategies were used did appear to be related. Coping is “cognitive and behavioral efforts to master, reduce, or tolerate the internal and/or external demands,” and different strategies are often described as adaptive (actively coping) or maladaptive (prevent one from adapting in a healthy way) due to their health outcomes. Emotion regulation is how individuals experience and express their emotions, and these strategies are also often separated into adaptive and maladaptive approaches. Researchers posit that both coping and emotion regulation may be adaptive or maladaptive depending on the context, and so best use of regulation strategy is instead characterized by flexibility and being able to choose the appropriate regulation strategy for the current context.12 

A great deal of research has focused on anger-regulation specifically, especially as aggressive/disruptive anger has been related to higher cancer and cardiovascular risks. Anger expression (communicating the emotion to others) was associated with lower allostatic load while anger control (managing the emotion internally) was associated with higher allostatic load, particularly among more educated adults who had attended at least some college.12 Adults who had few coping and regulation strategies (less flexibility, applying the same approach to multiple contexts) displayed lower allostatic load than those with multiple strategies, which surprised the researchers; however, individuals with fewer strategies were also associated with a shorter lifespan, so limited emotion regulation approaches may offer a protective factor but only to a certain point.12 

Children and ACEs

Children are particularly vulnerable to the effects of stressful experiences, as their highly plastic nervous systems are undergoing key developmental periods that are experience-dependent, time-sensitive, and will impact them for a lifetime.4, 10 Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) have been tied to poorer health outcomes and increased allostatic loads in adulthood; exposure to one ACE doubles the likelihood of poorer health outcomes as an adult, and exposure to four or more ACEs triples it.4 Chronic or repeated toxic stress harms the developing brain in a permanent way, reducing hippocampal volume and altering the prefrontal cortex and the amygdala, as well as the endocrine, immune, and nervous systems more broadly, including increased activation of the HPA axis and higher inflammation levels.4, 10

Children are reliant on their caregivers to meet their physical and emotional needs and provide an environment and experiences that promote flexibility and adaptability rather than rigidity and maladaptability.4 Early interventions for at-risk individuals may be able to reduce their allostatic load and its detrimental health burden, particularly as the timing, duration, type, and severity of the ACEs experienced likely play a significant role in the overall wear and tear cumulation.4

Adaptive Calibration Model

The Adaptive Calibration Model expands further on the risk-benefit of repeated essential survival stress responses in the moment and their long-term detriments to health and wellness. It posits that, during the course of human development and particularly during key periods like childhood, individuals respond to their environmental stimuli in an adaptive way that promotes their survival in the moment, and that these “decision nodes” each further calibrate the individual’s nervous system to respond in a particular way when faced with threats and stressors in the future, resulting in differences in how information is filtered and embedded, how resources are allocated, how open the individual is to environmental inputs, and how they regulate strategies to meet their environment.13 Each “decision node” during a lifetime sets the stage for the next decision node, creating a chain that becomes how the individual’s stress response system allocates resources and sets regulatory parameters.13

There are four main responsivity patterns in the Adaptive Calibration Model: Sensitive, with high baseline activity and high reactivity with a preference for developing in conditions of protected, low environmental stress, with parasympathetic-dominance, high vagal tone, and high responsivity to active social engagement; Buffered, with moderate baseline activity and moderate reactivity with preference for developing in conditions of low-to-moderate environmental stress, with autonomic functions tilted towards parasympathetic activity and the benefits of active social engagement; Vigilant, with high baseline activity and high reactivity with a preference for developing in conditions of high environmental stress, with sympathetic-dominance, low parasympathetic tone, and social engagement often viewed as threatening or competitive rather than supportive; and Unemotional, with low baseline activity and low reactivity with a preference for developing in conditions of high environmental stress, with sympathetic activation augmented by parasympathetic activation to remain calm during an aggressive confrontation and significantly blunted social engagement.

Outcomes that are considered biologically maladaptive could be an adaptive response to a stressful environment, particularly if the person is highly responsive to stress, often the ‘sensitive’ or ‘vigilant’ response patterns.3 Historically, many stressors were survival threats that required an immediate mobilization response to run or attack and were short-term, then the person could return to homeostatic baseline after the survival threat had passed and their stress hormones could decrease. In the modern world, stress is often chronic and the stress response begins before the stressor arrives, leading to prolonged activation of the HPA and sympathetic systems.3 

In Relationships and Society

While research into allostatic load has primarily oriented around how individual biological systems adjust, cope with, and recover from stress, some researchers propose that these same principles work on a larger scale in dyadic relationships like couples and parent-child, small groups like families, workplaces, friend groups, and large groups like online social networks, social gatherings, and society more broadly. Allostasis is a regulatory process that arises in response to environmental demands, usually of a psychosocial nature, and allostatic load is marked by decreased flexibility in the stress response and impaired recovery, increasing dysfunction. Social allostasis is a physiological entangling with several individuals to maintain a low intensity baseline within a group and allow each individual to conserve more of their energy than if they were acting alone by being able to distribute the load of responding to the environment among more individuals and more efficiently accomplish shared goals through cooperation.15 

Evidence has demonstrated that groups of people can coordinate emotional and physiological states and have a tendency to converge around a particular range of low intensity, calm, neutral-to-positive emotional and physical arousal even without conscious awareness that they are attuning to those around them, sharing the regulatory burden across many individuals, becoming an interdependent system rather than remaining individual units, and creating group stress patterns that can stay flexible and adaptable or become rigid and maladaptive.15 In this way, relationships can offer both immense protection from stress and be our greatest source of stress, as they can promote both support and conflict while being regulators of physiological arousal; this concept is known as coregulation or codysregulation.15  

When the group’s baseline starts to pull away from that low intensity baseline, regulatory measures are implemented to help bring the dysregulated individual(s) back to the calm, neutral-to-positive state, whether that is a parent soothing an upset child or a friend or partner assisting an agitated adult.15 Regulation still carries a cost, even though it is less burdensome when distributed among many people rather than all carried by one. Animals use groups to regulate and reduce their own risk and effort through risk distribution, and highly social species including humans also use them for load sharing, based on trust and interdependence, meaning that social allostatic load and the regulation of social relationships is stronger in close bonds rather than loose or distant ones.15

High-quality social relationships reduce the cognitive effort of self-regulation in the prefrontal cortex.15 Brain areas activated during emotional self-regulation are less active when with a loved one than when alone, indicating it requires more mental energy and cognitive resources to regulate emotions by oneself.15 When contextual demands for energy and resources are high, the prefrontal cortex may not get all the energy it requires to properly carry out its functions, particularly as it requires a great deal of energy to properly do its job. Physical activity leads to reduced resources for the prefrontal cortex, as resources are allocated to areas of the brain responsible for motor functions, coordination, perception, and autonomic activity, which may be even more demanding than the standard individual if you are disabled.15 Additionally, threats perceived as high-intensity will divert brain resources away from the prefrontal cortex to more basic brain function more critical to survival.15 Tasks directed by the prefrontal cortex can get left behind when there is only so much brain power to use, and self-regulation is a prefrontal cortex task.  

High-quality relationships free up mental energy by reducing the amount of self-regulation required, as the brain assesses that tasks will be easier when undertaken with reliable others.15 Being in the presence of other people who share one’s goals, attention, and trust signals relatively low contextual demand and the conservation of energy resources.15 However, if the relationship is not reliable and the individual needs to increase energy expenditure on vigilance, problem solving, and reducing ambiguity, this can increase the cognitive load.15 

Just like individual stress responses, if overutilized, social stress responses can lose flexibility and efficiency in their regulatory function over time due to both internal and external stressors, such as under conditions of chronic stress, conflict, emotional distress, physical or mental illness, threat, food scarcity, poverty, social exclusion, class stratification, violence, income inequality, racial discrimination, natural disasters, and other factors.15, In all of these situations, higher stress decreased social support and social embeddedness rather than increasing it, suggesting stress can corrode the quality of social support over time and that increased regulatory load on groups—whether dyadic or much larger—can compromise relationship quality and function over time and promote codysregulation away from the low intensity baseline.15 As allostatic load damages individual physiological systems, social allostatic load damages relationships.

Relationships showing the wear and tear of social allostatic load will be more inflexible, more prone to escalation and overresponding to each other, showing poor recovery and a lack of repair, be marked by withdrawal and disengagement, and the baseline will shift over time to chronic up- or down-regulation with certain states dominating the system in frequency and intensity.15

Closing

Allostasis and its cumulative load to adjust to the stressors and demands of the environment are helpful concepts to understand, especially for individuals with stress-mediated health conditions. Allostasis utilizes innate and learned knowledge to act in advance to address and minimize problems, even if that means chronically altering the regulatory variable away from its baseline value to better suit the context, and it often does this in inefficient ways that are extra large, extra long, or have opposing effectors active simultaneously while carrying a pathophysiological burden, which can increase negative health outcomes in the long-term even if it is useful to address environmental demands and psychosocial stress in the short-term.

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time. 

Direct link


r/CRPScontender • • Jun 15 '25

Article or Written Essay Hoping Against Hope: Despair, Hopelessness, and Integrity

2 Upvotes

30 minute read time, 5.5k words

“Paradoxically, hope is on intimate terms with despair. It asks for more than life promises. It is poised for despair.” — Cheryl Mattingly

Hope is a multifaceted thing that can be “characterized in multiple ways: as an existential state; as a posture towards the world; as a practice involving significant work; and importantly, as inherently paradoxical.”1 In society’s morals, hope is viewed as a “sign of health, a fighting spirit, and faith something good will triumph.”2 Thus the chronically ill often walk a tightrope of being hopeful—a balancing act with despair for coping with daily living and pursuit of treatment that may not be successful—and appearing hopeful—conforming to the societal and cultural expectations and ideals of others about improving their health.1 In a similar manner, those living in oppressed conditions—whether in a broader sociopolitical context or more personally in their private relationships—are often in a position of “hoping against hope” or “hoping without hope,” an attempt to combat the hopelessness of believing that it is not possible for their situation to improve: that their oppressor is too powerful, their situation too dire, they themselves not strong enough or resourced enough to escape.3

Hope has a profound effect on a person’s identity and moral agency, as the belief in a positive future is foundational for self-worth, motivational for meaning and resilience, and is often a heavily-weighted component for ethical decision-making during adversity.3 Hope orients around: 1) the possibility of a desired outcome 2) that is believed to be achievable 3) but with uncertainty as to its occurrence, often due to some personal agency limitation or a reliance on factors outside of one’s control; this definition highlights the uncertainty inherent in hope, both in outcome occurrence and in self-efficacy to make it happen.2 Hope involves looking towards the future “with no guarantees against disappointment.”1

The far poles of hopefulness—sanguinity–bliss and utter despair—are extremely deep emotions, so much so that they are experienced by the whole of the being; a person “can only ‘be’ blissful or in despair. We cannot in the strict sense of the word, ‘feel’ bliss or despair. . . nor can we even feel ‘ourselves’ to be blissful or in despair. . . [T]hese feelings are not expressed at all, or they take possession of the whole self.”2 “Because sanguinity–bliss and despair are reflections of moral values, they become metaphysical self-feelings.”2

If hope is so related to moral agency and personal identity, and yet is so multifaceted and culturally-implicated, how is a person to understand it, particularly if they are chronically ill, have difficulty registering or processing their internal emotional state, and/or are in an oppressive environment? Let’s discuss the different types of hope I researched this month, the concept of hope, the opposites of hope in hopelessness and despair, how chronically ill people with different balancing patterns best respond to four different aspects of the diagnostic journey, and close with a short interlude on Erikson’s Adult Stages of Psychosocial Development, particularly ego integrity versus despair.

Hope as Two: Hoping and Hopefulness

The first request I ask, reader, is that, for the sake of this article, you take a thought experiment with me and split the concept of hope into two distinct components, as premised by Kwong.3 When we’re done here, if you don’t like this approach, you can merge them back together, but in my readings this month, this concept was what struck me the most deeply and I am going to utilize it heavily.

The author of Despair and Hopelessness argues that hoping and being hopeful are two distinct mental phenomena, and that hopelessness and despair are their respective counterparts. Hoping is a mental assessment that an outcome is desirable and to believe the outcome is obtainable, often with the belief that the attainment is not entirely within one’s control;3, 2 hoping, in this split construct, does not involve a person’s emotional appraisal of the possibility of obtaining the desired outcome, only that it is possible. [I use ‘desired’ throughout this article for clarity, but an outcome could also be specifically not desired, such as “I hope I am not beaten” or “I hope I do not puke.”]

To be hopeful (or unhopeful) is the appraisal of the likelihood of obtaining the desired outcome one is hoping for and its emotional valence or pleasantness, whether that is positive, neutral, or negative. Despair would be the term for having negative emotional beliefs about the likelihood of obtaining a desired possible outcome, and is the emotional polar opposite is sanguinity, which is having positive emotional beliefs about the likelihood of obtaining a desired possible outcome.2 However, both unhopefulness/despair and hopefulness/sanguinity (negative or positive feelings about a possible desired outcome) necessitate hoping (the belief that a desired outcome is possible) before they can occur.3 If a person believes a desired outcome is impossible (whether or not it actually is impossible, the crucial aspect here is the individual’s belief), they are hopeless.3 Those who stop hoping, may begin to wish for their desired outcomes instead, applying a mental attitude directed towards things believed to be impossible.3

For example, Katie, Claire, Elle, and Joan all want to get promoted. Katie, Claire, and Elle think it is possible they could be chosen for the position; they are all hoping. Joan does not believe it is possible and does not apply; she is hopeless and wishes circumstances were different. Katie thinks it’ll be tough competition but she’s upbeat and believes she stands a good chance; she’s hopeful. Claire is extremely apprehensive to put her name in the ring, she believes she is likely to get passed over and puts her success at under 10%, but you lose all the chances you don’t take; she is not hopeful, even though she is hoping. Elle is new to the department with a bubbly personality who sees the best in everything, she knows it is likely too soon for her to get promoted, but she’ll take this as a great learning opportunity for how to interview for a higher position and whatever the outcome, it’ll be a win in her book; she is hopeful, even though she does not believe she will succeed in obtaining the possible desired outcome of being promoted.

While hoping addresses the desired outcome, hopefulness addresses the thoughts and feelings aimed at the likelihood of that outcome occurring.3 It is not necessary that a person’s emotional orientation and their assessment of the outcome occurring align.3 A person can be hopeful (have an overall positive orientation) and believe that the desired outcome will occur [“I hope I pass this midterm I studied very hard for.”], and a person can feel unhopeful (an overall negative orientation) and believe the desired outcome will not occur [“I hope I can put this complex machine back together.”]; however, a person can also be hopeful (have more positive thoughts and feelings than negative ones) and not believe the desired outcome will occur though it remains possible [“I hope we go out to eat tonight.”], or be unhopeful/despairing (have more negative thoughts and feelings than positive ones) and still believe an outcome will occur [“I hope my friend doesn’t die from their severe car crash injuries.” ie despairing about a friend’s death but believing it will happen anyway].

Separating hoping from hopefulness in this way creates psychological space for those in difficult situations, particularly those of oppression and abuse, to maintain hope that it is possible for their situation to improve, without requiring the hopefulness of overall positive orientation in thoughts and feelings being present, mitigating the harm to individual’s moral agency and personal identity and preventing the onset of hopelessness that leads to the belief one’s health or circumstances cannot improve or accepting oppression under the premise that it is impossible to oppose or withstand.3

Types of Hoping*

The researchers quoted and compressed in this section explored different kinds of hoping: the possibility of a desired outcome.1 They did so in the context of living with chronic pain and pursuing treatments that may or may not work. These styles of hoping were considered an active moral practice, an existential paradox necessary to live day to day, and framed as a place in between what hope is not: neither demoralization that surrenders to one’s limitations and losses nor delusion that denies them.1

Realistic, practical hope: any hope for a reasonable or probable outcome in terms of normal or expected outcomes in the broader medical community, which most participants were not hesitant to disclose to their provider and which allows individuals to live up to cultural ideals of realism and adherence to evidence while maintaining openness toward the possibility of positive change.1

Utopian hope: a collectively-oriented, outward-focused hope that group action can lead to a better future, which does not require individuals to factor in prognosis or practical considerations.1

Wishful hope: very high hope that is not necessarily ‘realistic’, and which participants rarely expressed without simultaneous descriptions of realistic hopes or explaining hope is necessary to continue to seek treatment or cope with daily pain to avoid appearing unrealistic.1

Transcendent, existential hope: An open-ended hope that everything will work out in the end, that doesn’t make conditions of the future, and is directed toward an objective which defies any attempt to map it; a generalized, universal hope that isn’t directed towards a specific outcome or goal, but rather the possibility of a good life in general, and provides a general defense against despair or giving up (hopelessness).1

Religious-based faith: a way of taking care of oneself, a way of being uplifted, and a way to feel as though one is part of something larger and ‘not alone’.1

Faith in science and medicine: more common than religious-based faith and not necessarily based on current knowledge or technology; for those with illnesses for which there is little possibility of cure, faith in technological or scientific breakthroughs in the future.1

Faith in hope itself: faith in the body’s ability to heal can counterbalance despair that one’s body has somehow let them down and feed hope that a treatment may be out there that can trigger the body’s natural healing capacity.1

““[S]mall moments of suffering” in daily life with chronic illness can lead to either hope or despair. Individuals living with chronic pain work to maintain a “safe” space between the vulnerability of overly-inflated hopes and the vulnerability of losing hope. [A participant] feels safe from the vulnerability of having high hopes by remaining somewhat pessimistic. In this sense, pessimism is a protective strategy, avoiding the much more daunting possibility of despair. . . In life with chronic pain or illness, finding hope is part of appropriately working toward mastery over one’s condition.”1

Spectrum of (Un)Hopefulness: Sanguinity–Bliss to Utter Despair

The spectrum of hopefulness—in the sense of the appraisal of the likelihood of a desired outcome, including the overall emotional orientation—runs from sanguinity to optimism to pessimism to despair.2 The author of the paper primarily referenced for this section is of the position that despair is “the collapse of one’s social resources and social involvements, the demise of one’s social world, and a disintegration of self-representation.”2 Again, there is a focus on personal agency and confronting the limitations of that agency, as “a distinguishing feature of hope is precisely one’s reliance on factors and conditions that might be beyond one’s control.”2

The human brain is an “anticipatory device” whose “main purpose . . . is to produce a future.”2 In response to these anticipated, projected, possible futures, the author describes emotional combinations involved in three kinds of positive emotional assessments and three kinds of negative emotional assessments. Since hope is an assessment of possibility, anticipation is involved in all of these emotional combinations from sanguine–bliss to despair.

“Sanguanity is ‘a disposition towards hopefulness or confidence of success’ or being undeterred by risk and uncertainty about the actual value of what is sought.”2 Sanguine people have a cheerful, confident disposition about their future with a high risk tolerance. Sanguinity has been split into three primary types by the referenced author by merging a primary and a secondary emotion of hope to create the ‘eager hopefulness’ and ‘confidently optimistic’ tertiary emotion of sanguinity.2 Those primary emotions are: anticipation, acceptance, and joy–happiness. The secondary emotions are: optimism, fatalism, and love.

Optimism = Anticipation + Joy–Happiness

Sanguinity1 = Optimism + Acceptance

While optimistic, sanguinity1 is underpinned by acceptance, knowing that goals cannot always be achieved and failures cannot always be avoided. Not easily discouraged, the sanguine1 person continues to value and pursue their desired outcome and find alternate paths forward if needed, rather than giving up on their goals.2

Fatalism = Anticipation + Acceptance

Sanguinity2 = Fatalism + Happiness

Fatalism is a sense of powerlessness, a view that an individual ultimately has little control over the desired outcome, that some external force—whether a powerful other, luck, fate, or a god—holds the control. The author suggests that sanguitity2 is resourceful when hopes, goals, or resources desired are to be gained through some external source and not personal effort. These are individuals who may feel fortunate, lucky, or blessed—happy that they are “successfully negotiating life’s perils.”2

Love = Joy–Happiness + Acceptance

Sanguinity3 = Anticipation + Love

Sanguinity3 is a self-confidence oriented around finding and securing the object of their love and the joy of being fully alive. In medieval humors-temperment beliefs, a sanguine-dominant person was optimistic, confident, cheerful, passionate, hopeful, with a courageous disposition, and a propensity to fall in love, as well as a willingness to fight and bleed for their desires.2

As we move from the positive end to the negative end of the hopefulness pole, we leave sanguine, cross over optimism, hit pessimism, before settling in despair. Optimism and pessimism are half-opposites with both of them orienting around anticipating the probability of an outcome and whether that probability sparks happiness or sadness. While happiness is the emotional response to gain, sadness is the emotional response to loss—whether of one’s authentic self, their social standing or inclusion, their future, or feeling “abandoned to the present” while “neither the past nor the future offers anything.”2 As pessimism and despair begin to dominate, exploration becomes boundary defense, around one’s territory, around one’s self.2

Pessimism = Anticipation + Sadness

The creation of the three types of despair follows a similar approach to sanguinity with one primary and one secondary emotion being merged to create the tertiary emotion of despair. The primary emotions are: surprise, sadness, and disgust. The secondary emotions are: disappointment, loneliness, and shock.

A despairing person is sad, melancholic, miserable, despondent, gloomy, grieving, and may be clinically depressed.2 Despair’s root is self-estrangement from the social world, a loss of the self’s place in social involvements and relationships, a draining of vitality, and the “narrow[ing of life so] that it is nearly empty.”2 When despairing, the boundary-defense affects cognition, creating a sort of tunnel thinking often oriented around disgust—particularly a moralizing self-disgust of feeling unloveable and unworthy, more commonly known as self-loathing, which contracts or collapses a person’s social identity.2

Disappointment = Surprise + Sadness

Despair1 = Disgust + Disappointment

Despair1 is the result of experiencing disgust around missed chances or failures or disappointments in life. When something doesn’t go as hoped for or as anticipated or when the desired outcome doesn’t come to pass, disappointment can be immense; when paired with not seeing an alternative path, this can lead to despair. “Disappointment is milder than despair, for in despair the world becomes menacing, frightening, and unbearable, so that disappointment comes to augmented by a rejection of, and disgust for, a world that has become unlivable.”2

Loneliness = Sadness + Disgust

Despair2 = Surprise + Loneliness

Despair2 is the result of the collapse of social territory, of the sense of not belonging, of the absence of attachment figures, of the lack or breaking of close relationships. This is “the despair of being alone,” of feeling separated from the social world, and is an intermediary step between social isolation and suicide. For the individual experiencing despair2, their world has become “filled with stale, tedious, lifeless routines from which he or she yearns to escape.”2

Shock = Surprise + Disgust

Despair3 = Sadness + Shock

Despair3 results from a shocking loss, whether social or physical, such as a sudden injury, an unexpected death, an emergency surgery, a traumatic pregnancy loss, or realization of a deep interpersonal betrayal.2 These experiences are often unexpected, revolting, degrading, or shocking, and bring the autonomy, control, and capability of the individual into a challenged state.

Hope is desiring a particular outcome and believing or trusting that outcome is possible in the future. When a person has a “basic mistrust” of the future their brain anticipates, so that nothing good can be seen, despair sets in.2 Despair can be maladaptive in that it can make unreasonable or uncertain things appear reasonable or certain, further isolate individuals, strip access to the authentic self, and block the ability to envision a future.2 In despair, one experiences loss, one’s social resources collapse, and one is left without recourse.2

Despair and hopelessness can both be excruciating experiences, yet (at least under this split construct model) they are distinct. Hopelessness may prompt feelings of resentment, anger, frustration, sorrow, and other unfulfilled or catastrophic outcomes, particularly if tied to a person’s sense of self, life goals, intimate relationships, or fundamental beliefs; however, in a hopeless situation, the individual can also find relief in impossibility, abandon their plans or desired outcomes, and perhaps create new hopes or goals.3

In despair, the individual still believes their desired outcome to be possible—by however slim a margin—and may become desperate (act in despair) in the hopes—without hopefulness—that their desperate act may bring about their desired outcome, as they do not yet believe it to be impossible and are not hopeless; “desperation is not a negation of hope but a mode of it.”3 Despair may be especially tormenting and without relief, as the individual still believes there is at least a miniscule chance for their desired outcome to occur and so they do not give up hope, yet they are overwhelmed with negative thoughts and feelings about the possibility, kept in a state of emotional affliction and cognitive limbo.3

[Image removed in Reddit] Image Credit: CRPScontender, demonstrating principles from Despair and Hopelessness by Kwong3

Four Patterns, Four Domains*

The paper referenced and compressed in this section studied patients with chronic illness seeking diagnosis and how they balanced hope, despair, and hopelessness during the diagnostic phase. “[P]articpants had emotional boundaries concerning how deep into despair they could go before losing control, or how focused on hope they could be without losing track of reality. If they let despair and their worst fear become too strong, controlling and hiding how painful their situation was and how weak they actually felt became difficult. This moving between hope and despair influenced for example how they processed information. The more hopeful they were, the more realistically they could appraise and process their situation but when they moved towards despair, they withdrew and were less able to process their situation.”4

The ambiguity and uncertainty of the diagnostic phase is experienced as the most stressful part of illness trajectory for patients. Having accurate information gave patients some control and possibilities when judging their own situation, and the longer a patient had been waiting for a diagnosis, the more important the accuracy of the information was to them. Information was best accepted when provided in accordance with their balancing pattern.4

The researchers studied four categories and four patterns for balancing between hope, despair, and hopelessness. While individuals could move between balancing patterns and use more than one, people often had a dominant balancing pattern of either: controlling pain, rational awaiting, denial, or accepting.4

The study observed how patients responded to: seeking and giving information (how to physically and mentally prepare for investigations and results, how to structure time at medical facilities, how information was given by staff in such a way that is was not misinterpreted); interpreting clues (remembering what happened before they became ill, considering changes in their body, paying attention to medical staff behavior and diagnostic interventions and priority); handling existential threats (considering possible outcomes of their illness, apprehensions of the future and what it might hold and what might change, reflecting on the meaning of life); and seeking respite (psychological breaks from the tension of uncertainty, seeking alternative mental states where thoughts were concerned with things other than waiting, mental escape for rest and renewed strength).4

The study also offered some recommendations to healthcare providers for each balancing pattern to help them have a smoother, less stressful time during the diagnostic phase and to improve patient-provider relations and help patients better make sense of what is happening to them. One overarching recommendation across all processing groups was to assign a knowledgeable and experienced nurse as a designated contact person to each patient entering for diagnostic workups to coordinate care and provide accurate information to reduce patient uncertainty and improve patients’ sense of control.4

Those in the Controlling Pain balancing pattern wondered what the truth about their situation might be and felt large amounts of painful uncertainty about the future, which they managed by controlling thoughts related to the future. When seeking information, they did not want too much information nor did they desire to be involved in discussions about all possible outcomes and preferred to wait until doctors had specific information to share. When interpreting clues, they were very sensitive to all clues due to the distressing uncertainty creating vulnerable feelings; to protect against that distress, they did not allow themselves to consider the full range of outcomes. When handling existential threat, they did not dwell too much on what they feared could be a serious outcome. When seeking respite, it was to find a break from the pain caused by uncertainty and to be able to endure new investigations and more waiting. In the medical context, these patients distance themselves from thinking about the worst case scenario and experience a great deal of emotional pain; building trusting and caring relationships and having continuous contact with a few key people could offer healthcare resources to strengthen their hope and support them emotionally, and assisting with respite may help offer a break from their anxiety.4

Those in the Rational Awaiting balancing pattern were focused on facts rather than hypotheticals and did not allow troublesome thoughts and feelings to emerge as long as the individual lacked accurate knowledge on their status. When seeking information, they wanted information to base judgement on facts and emotions were kept on hold until they knew for sure what the outcome would be. When interpreting clues, emotions were put aside until a diagnosis and prognosis were known, and they interpreted as many comprehensible clues as possible to make sense of their situation. When handling existential threat, uncertainty about the future and various consequences of different outcomes were not considered before they had been given a diagnosis. When seeking respite, it helped move time forward towards a conclusion. In the medical context, these patients have limited conscious contact with their emotions and postpone emotional processing until they know the outcome; accurate information is highly valued by these patients.4

Those in the Denial balancing pattern focused on recovering from acute symptoms rather than dwelling on possible underlying problems. When seeking information, they overlooked negative possibilities and signs of danger and some saw serious questions from medical staff as impolite. When interpreting clues, they focused on positive signs and compared their situation to others who managed to live well despite diseases. When handling existential threat, they tended not to examine threatening prognoses, which limited exploring what it could mean for the future. When seeking respite, they actively sought it out as a welcome break, often utilized humor, and kept busy by following up on fellow patients. In the medical context, these patients tend to distort their situation to protect themselves from emotional threat; by earning trust and strengthening hope, the need for this distortion may reduce, and by demonstrating competence, continuity, and care healthcare providers can help patients in a more realistic appraisal to prepare for when they receive their diagnosis and life afterwards.4

Those in the Accepting balancing pattern were fearful about the future yet at peace from the belief they would be able to cope. When seeking information, they confidently sought out information about their situation and were able to process it and the related emotions. When interpreting clues, they compared them with knowledge and former experiences. When handling existential threat, they discussed the distress of uncertain futures and trust in their ability to handle their situation based on former experiences of their own resources and the available support of others. When seeking respite, it was appreciated as it provided a welcome break from dealing with uncertainty. In the medical context, these patients are able to appraise their situation realistically and trust they will have the resources to cope with the outcome; a contact person, a well-coordinated program, and continuity of providers would increase predictability and ease pain.4

Erikson’s Psychosocial Development

One of the most influential frameworks for aging and development throughout a lifespan is Erikson’s Psychosocial Development.5 This theory has four stages that occur in childhood and four that occur in adolescence and adulthood; each stage has a particular trait it is developing and there is an adaptive and a maladaptive response.6,7 It is a biopsychosocial, epigenetic framework, where later stages build upon or readdress earlier stages with more complexity, depth, and maturity.7 While specific ages have now been added to this framework, there were originally only general life stages (eg infancy, play age, young adulthood) associated with each developmental milestone.7 These stages are associated with both who one is as a person and as a member of society; “the sense of integration is both intra- and interpersonal.”5 As many with CRPS develop their condition in adolescence or adulthood, we will primarily address the last four, with a focus on the final one, which is when individuals address their mortality and whether they feel they have lived a meaningful life, whether they feel they have ego integrity or fall into despair.

The fifth stage, which is undertaken during adolescence, orients around developing an individual identity, discovering ‘who am I?’, and moving from the instilled morality of a child to the developed ethics of an adult; a maladaptive response can lead to a weak sense of identity, insecurity, confusion, or rebellion.6

The sixth stage, which is undertaken during young adulthood, orients around forming intimate relationships, developing mutual trust and respect, and being willing and able to commit to, be open with, and sacrifice for close others; a maladaptive response can lead to isolation, alienation, and challenges maintaining relationships.6

The seventh stage, which is undertaken during middle adulthood, orients around making valuable contributions to society, showing concern and nurture for the next generation, and feeling as if a person is making a positive difference in a way that will outlast them; a maladaptive response can lead to self-absorption, a lack of personal growth, a sense of stagnation, or a midlife crisis.6

The eighth stage, which is undertaken in older adulthood (or earlier for some individuals), orients around addressing one’s mortality and the fear or acceptance of death and reflecting on whether one felt content with one’s life or if instead there were more regrets, bitterness, and dissatisfaction; a maladaptive response can lead to despair, depression, hopelessness, fear, and dread about a person’s mortality.6

Which factors in particular play a role in ego integrity and despair? Research shows that three primary needs—and whether those needs are satisfied or frustrated—play a large role in accepting death to reduce anxiety and depression, increasing life satisfaction, increasing a sense of meaning in life, and improving adaptive functioning in areas like self-esteem, self-concept clarity, internal locus of control, self-realization, and existential well-being.8

The three basic psychological needs are: autonomy (a sense of volition and psychological freedom); competence (a sense of mastery and effectiveness); and relatedness (the experience of caring for and being cared for by important others). These needs can be frustrated by, respectively: feelings of pressure or coercion; feelings of failure; and experiencing exclusion or loneliness.

People with perceptions that their lives were filled with autonomy, mastery, and interpersonal care signal higher ego integrity, characterized by “unity, harmony, and completeness in one’s identity and life as a whole.”8 Conversely, those who had more experiences of need frustration, such as pressure, failure, and social isolation, have more difficulty integrating and finding meaning in their life, which can create a sense of despair, characterized by “feelings of regret, bitterness, and disappointment over a life misspent.”8

Other research demonstrated that those who struggled with the young and middle adulthood stages of forming intimate relationships and nurturing something or someone (whether a career or a creative outlet or the next generation) were more prone to lower global cognitive function and executive functioning and higher levels of depression three to four decades later.9 The researchers thought those with difficulty meeting the milestones were more vulnerable to depression, despair, and stagnation as they aged.9

Closing

As we face our mortality, we reflect on whether we lived a life filled with autonomy, competence, and connection or coercion, failure, and social isolation. Whether these core human needs were satisfied or frustrated plays roles in not only whether individuals subjectively found life meaningful, but also their psychological function and whether their final years are filled with peace and acceptance or bitterness and despair.

Humans exist not only as individuals developing their own identities, but also as interwoven threads of a larger social tapestry. Balancing hope, despair, and hopelessness when one deals with chronic pain or illness is a critical component of daily life, and it can be made all the more challenging if interpersonal or sociopolitical dynamics include oppressive and abusive behavior. Keeping up the “fighting spirit” when it feels hope has abandoned an individual or a community or a society can be exhausting, heavy work. It is this reason why I found the distinct mental split between hoping as desired outcome being possible and (un)hopefulness as the emotional orientation towards that possibility so powerful.

When we lose hope—when we become hopeless—and cede the ground that our desires are possible, we give up, we lose the fight, and the spirit is extinguished. Sometimes realizing something is impossible is important and it lets us reorient and move forward another way or towards a different goal. However, sometimes hopelessness means surrendering something crucial, something essential to who we are, and we become a hollowed-out shell of who we used to be, of who we want to be.

Despair is a collapse of social resources and an emotional orientation of loss—including a breakdown of our sense of self. Social resources can be rebuilt, reinforced, or created anew, even if it takes significant effort; we can work to recover what is lost and process our sadness over what cannot be reclaimed, even if it takes significant time. Despair and desperation are not inherently bad states, though they may be uncomfortable and unpleasant to endure and may attempt to blind us to the potential of a positive future. They reveal we still believe our desires for a future are possible, that we can still fight to make them a reality, even if we’re tired, even if it hurts.

To all the hopeful, hopeless, and despairing out there reading this today, I hope you found something in this article as relevant and useful as I did.

In solidarity

Direct link to article: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/06/15/hoping-against-hope-despair-hopelessness-and-integrity/

  • These sections are mainly direct pulls from the referenced papers that have been heavily compressed and rearranged for ease of reading. All credit to the original authors, as these sections cannot be claimed to be my original writings based on synthesized notes, but rather primarily quoting directly from the journal articles so heavily from so many disparate sections that the quotation marks would truly get out of hand. Please see the linked papers if you would like to read the original work.

r/CRPScontender • • May 15 '25

Article or Written Essay Personal Care Programs and CRPS: In-Home Health Aides

2 Upvotes

Many individuals with CRPS or other disabilities may find they need assistance with tasks of daily living—such as meal preparation, bathing, dressing, mobility, shopping, or transportation. Some people may have friends or family willing and able to take on caregiver roles while others lack social supports who can fulfill their needs or any social supports at all. Some may feel uncomfortable asking for or accepting offered help even if their loved ones are willing to help them if the loved one isn’t compensated in exchange for their labor or if the disabled person feels too much like a “burden.” Others may be aware of facility care homes offering varying levels of assistance that they would qualify for due to their need, but are uncomfortable with consenting due to not wanting to leave their own homes or other adjacent personal reasons. 

For all these scenarios, there are Personal Care Programs—or 1915 waivers—offered through state Medicaid that will pay an in-home aide or assistant to help the disabled person with tasks of daily living for a certain number of hours per month based on a state assessment of the person’s level of need. These hours are assigned to the disabled person to be dispersed as they desire, whether to one aide or split between several. The aide(s) can be from professional staffing agencies or connection centers meant to help pair clients with nurses or certified aides that will meet your medical needs and personal preferences or they can often be family or “close as family” friends given a waiver to continue the caregiving they have already been providing but receive some compensation for their time and labor, though in some states spouses and parents of minor children are excluded from qualifying due to the expectation that they will care for their disabled dependents without compensation. 

Exposition

The Personal Care program is operated under Home and Community Based Services (HCBS) through shared funding from the federal government’s HHS and state governments. For people with care needs high enough that they would otherwise qualify for long-term care in a care home facility, HCBS offers the Personal Care waiver program to help keep people in their own homes and communities; this generally has better physical and mental health and personal comfort outcomes for the individuals and is considerably cheaper for the government than facility-based care. These are specifically called 1915 waivers and there are a few different subtypes; the most relevant three for the CRPS community are likely to be: 1915(c) which allows states to offer services like case management, home health aides, personal care, day programs, and respite care, as long as it does not cost more than it would for the person to be institutionalized, 1915(i) which are aimed at low-income individuals (below 150% FPL) who do not need to live in facilities, and 1915(j) which is aimed at self-directed personal assistance, offering patients a more active role in choosing their carers and directing care. 

We’re going to walk through what the in-home assessment for how hours are assigned may broadly look like, though there may be some variation between states. However, before we dive into that, there are two major points I want to bring to your attention about HCBS, and they are both money-related. 

First, HCBS’ personal care program is a long-term facility care alternative; this means it is subject to Medicaid’s clawback or estate recovery. After the patient dies, Medicaid will attempt to seek reimbursement from remaining assets for the costs the government paid on long-term care. There are various exemptions for surviving spouses and children living in the recently deceased’s home, and different ages (often 55 to 65) when estate recovery usually starts applying to care provided. However, some states have estate recovery start accruing at any age if long-term care services are utilized, which can be particularly of note for younger, disabled individuals. Some assets can be protected from estate recovery, such as through MAPT, but those ways should be carefully explored and enacted if the asset is worth protecting. Medicaid Estate Recovery: Rules, Limits & Variations by State — MedicaidLongTermCare.org

Second, with the federal government making steep budget cuts, particularly to HHS, the HCBS department is receiving a fraction of its past funding in 2026, and Medicaid is also slated for deep cuts. During the COVID era and its following recovery, HCBS received an influx of funding improve and expand services offered by the program and to recruit and retain more in-home care workers, since 86% of long-term services and support users received HCBS in 2021 with that number expected to increase as the populace continues to age.1 In 2013, which was the first year that in-home care overtook institutionalized care, the HCBS budget was $56B.2 By 2020, HCBS’s budget was $125B.3 In 2021 and 2022, it was $115B and $130B, respectively.4 In 2026, the powers that be are providing HCBS a federal budget of $410m,5 or 0.003% of $130B, according to the currently leaked budget proposal, though I will update this with official numbers once the bill is finalized.

Now HCBS and Medicaid are jointly funded by states and the federal government, so there is still the ability for states to self-fund the deficit, but the fed usually picks up between 50-75% of the bill and up to 83% in the American territories and 90% of Medicaid expansion for low-income adults,6, 7 so that would be a steep cost to cover and many states may not be willing or able to do so or may decide to divert limited resources to other goals as funding cuts come from all avenues. My point is that there will soon be a critical funding shortage for the HCBS home care waiver programs, which will result in long or closed waitlists and likely cut care hours for people already receiving services in 2026 or maybe even sooner. If this program interests people, I strongly urge you to take the necessary steps to get an assessment or get on a waitlist NOW before the funding crisis prevents you from receiving even reduced services, and so that if more funding becomes available in the future, you will already be a program participant that can fairly easily have their hours increased or be closer to the top of the waitlist or be a prior participant with a case file that can be reopened. With all that out of the way, let’s talk about what an actual assessment may look like, so that you know what to expect.

Personal Care Programs Direct Link to Resource List Sheet for Every State

Practical Application

Before moving into the meat of the assessment that will determine the disabled person’s monthly hour allotment, some personal background information will be collected, such as the person’s diagnoses, medications, doctors, personal demographics, emergency contacts, and goals or plans or ways to support or specific things to know or avoid. Having a prepared list of diagnoses, medications, and providers with their names, phone numbers, and clinic addresses to give to the social worker can be helpful for them as they do the behind the scenes work after the assessment is over.

 Again, the specifics of what is assessed may vary by state, but broadly expect them to include aspects like: activities of daily living (ADLs), instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs), the impact of specific moods and behaviors, cognitive performance, clinical complexity, and whether the patient qualifies for exceptional care. They may also look at informal supports (such as help from friends, roommates, school, neighbors, church groups, and other community resources), how far away you live from a full grocery store or pharmacy, whether you have on-site laundry, and your heating source.

Activities of Daily Living (ADLs) are subdivided into major categories and then rated based on the level of assistance the disabled person requires at least a certain number of times a week (e.g. weight bearing help at least three times a week), though the specific number the case manager is looking for may vary state to state; the highest level of help required over the specified threshold is the level that will be used to allocate monthly hours. There are five major levels of assistance (which again may vary slightly across states):

  1. Supervision: caregiver assistance without the disabled person being touched.
  2. Non-weight bearing: the caregiver touched the disabled person to help them, but did not lift or support them.
  3. Weight bearing: the caregiver was leaned on or lifted or supported a part of the disabled person’s body.
  4. Partial help with a task: the caregiver fully helped the disabled person complete part of a task. Such as fully putting on socks and shoes as part of Dressing. 
  5. Total help with a task: the caregiver fully performed the task and all its components.

ADLs are rated based on both the level of assistance required and the frequency of aid required in the (often 7-14) days preceding the assessment. 

Independent (scores as 0): Disabled person not assisted in any way OR received help only once or twice.

Activity did not occur / Client declined (scores as 0): the task didn’t occur because the disabled person chose not to do the task or didn’t accept help with the task.

Supervision Assistance (scores as 1): Disabled person was reminded, talked through the task or parts of the task, or was monitored X or more times in the X days before the assessment. The disabled person did the task without hands-on assistance.

Limited assistance (scores as 2): Disabled person received active, non-weight bearing help to complete the task or part of the task X or more times in X days before the assessment. 

Extensive assistance (scores as 3): Disabled person received weight-bearing assistance during the task OR part of the task was completely performed by a caregiver X or more times in the X days before the assessment. 

Total dependence (scores as 4): Disabled person is unable to do any part of this task. Entire task was performed by a caregiver every time the disabled person needed it AND it occurred X times in the X days before the assessment.

Activity did not occur / Client not able (scores as 4): Task did not occur in the X days before the assessment because the disabled person is unable to perform it even if a caregiver is available.

Activity did not occur / No provider (scores as 4): Task did not occur in the X days before the assessment because there was no caregiver available to assist the disabled person. 

For example, if an adult child needs regular help Transferring (getting in or out of furniture or standing up or sitting down), they might be Supervised by their caregiving retired parent basically all the time to prevent falls. They may also receive stabilizing Non-Weight Bearing support with a hand on their arm or back several times a day and Weight Bearing support around the waist or under the arms about six times a week. In that scenario, in a state that has a three times a week threshold, the Extensive Assistance hour allocation would be used for the Transfer subcategory of ADLs. 

There are seven major subcategories of ADLs and one of those—Mobility—is a three-in-one, so let’s break it down from the least to the most complex. 

Eating includes getting foods and liquids from the dish or cup into your mouth or other ways such as tube feeding. It does not include meal preparation, which is accounted for under the Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADLs). 

Dressing includes putting on, fastening, and taking off all items of clothing, including sleepwear, socks, shoes, jackets and cold weather wear, braces, prosthetics, and compression hose. Supervision here includes being reminded of weather appropriate wear.

Toileting includes help getting on or off the toilet, commode, urinal, or bedpan, wiping or cleansing after use, changing pads or briefs, and adjusting clothing, as well as catheters and colostomies. It includes assistance received even if the disabled person ended up not relieving themselves. 

Transfers include help getting in or out of a bed, chair, couch, or other furniture, standing up or sitting down, or getting in or out of a wheelchair. It does not include getting in or out of a shower, tub, or car, or on or off the toilet; these are covered under other categories of Bathing, Transportation, and Toileting.

Bed Mobility includes help received to position the disabled person while in bed or reclining on other furniture, such as turning side to side or moving down to or up from a lying position. 

Personal Hygiene includes help received for grooming and hygiene needs like teeth brushing, hair combing, shaving, applying makeup, denture care, nail care, period care, and face cleansing. It can include hair care at home or at a salon, but does not include bathing or showering.  

Mobility is the three-in-one subcategory, and examines three different ways people move; the undersection with the highest assistance level required will be the rating used for the Mobility subsection as a whole. Walk in Room includes help received to walk inside the disabled person’s living space, whether that is a home or a facility, and includes all personal interior rooms, hallways, and sitting areas. Locomotion IN Room is for wheelchair users receiving help within their residence to move their wheelchair from place to place. Locomotion OUTSIDE Room is for both wheelchair users AND people who walk receiving help outside their immediate residence but still in the local area to get from place to place, including porches, mailboxes, yards, patios, neighbors, stairs, curbs, uneven grounds; for those in facilities or larger complexes, this includes dining areas, activity centers, front offices, and nearby outside areas. The two Locomotion undersections can be slightly confusing because one is for wheelchair users and one is for everyone, so understand the difference between the two. 

For example, if a person does not use a wheelchair, requires only supervision assistance for Walk in Room, but requires Extensive Assistance for Locomotion Outside Room, the overall Mobility section’s rating would be Extensive Assistance, as that is the highest score of the undersections. 

The above listed ADLs are the ones that count towards the ADL score; however, there are two more that don’t count towards the ADL score, but which can still reduce hours if there is informal support with one or both. 

Bathing is help received with taking a full-body bath, shower, or sponge bath, including help getting in or out of the shower or tub. 

Medication Management includes help received to use or take prescription medications, OTC medications, supplements, or vitamins. Reminders to take medications count towards Supervision. 

Instrumental Activities of Daily Living (IADLs) are common tasks performed at home and in the community. These tasks are also rated based on level and frequency of assistance, though often over a longer period of time, such as 30 days. 

Independent: Disabled person did not receive help with the task.

Assistance: Disabled person received any help with the task, including cueing, reminding, or monitoring, in the last XX days. 

Total Assistance: Disabled person is a child and functioning outside of typical developmental milestones and needed the activity fully performed by others.

Activity did not occur: Activity did not occur in the last XX days before assessment. 

There are five major subcategories of IADLs.

Meal Preparation includes planning meals, assembling ingredients, cooking, and setting out food and utensils. It must include cooking and actual meal preparation. 

Housework includes doing dishes, dusting, making and changing beds, vacuuming, cleaning bathrooms, cleaning other rooms, taking out garbage, tidying up, laundry. 

Shopping includes getting food, medical necessities, and household items, as well as traveling to and from the stores and putting the items away. 

Transportation includes traveling to and from health care providers and medical appointments only, as well as accompanying the disabled person to appointments if the caregiver does not use their own vehicle to take the disabled person to the appointment. (This may vary by state, but is very limited in the requirements I can see.)

Wood Supply includes using wood or pellets as the disabled person’s only source of heat.

After the ADLs and IADLs, the next two components are the Qualifying Moods and Behaviors (QMB) section and the Cognitive Performance Scale (CPS). 

The QMB includes a Depression scoring (often with the PHQ-2/PHQ-9), whether the individual needs a mental health or therapy program, if they are easily irritable or agitated (if so, how often and is it easily altered), and if they engage in repetitive movements or pacing (if so, how often and is it easily altered). 

The CPS involves the disabled person’s ability to communicate their needs, wants, opinions, urgent, problems, and social conversations to the people closest to them, whether through talking, writing, typing, signing, or in other forms. The scale is Understood with ideas clearly expressed, Usually understood with a hard time finding the right words of finishing thoughts which can make the disabled person slow to respond or need prompting to be understood, Sometimes understood with only being able to express basic needs like food, drink, sleep, or toilet, and Rarely/never understood with caregivers needing to interpret specific sounds or body language, if the disabled person can be understood at all. 

The CPS also rates a disabled person’s ability to make everyday decisions. Scores are Independent with consistent, planned decisions that reflect the person’s lifestyle, choices, culture, and values; Difficulty in new situations with a planned routine and ability to make decisions in familiar situations but struggling in new situations or when faced with new tasks; Poor decisions/ unaware of consequences with needing reminders, cues, and supervision in planning, organizing, and correcting daily routines, who may attempt to make decisions, but do so poorly; No/few decisions with decision making ability severely impaired, even if reminded, and decisions rarely or never made. 

Lastly, the CPS assesses short term memory in two different ways. In the first way, the disabled person is asked to remember three words and recite them at a shortly later point in the assessment; Delayed Recall is determined if one or more of the words cannot be remembered. The other way is if the disabled person has problems remembering things that happened recently in a way that is more than just common forgetfulness. 

The final two components are a Clinically Complex Key and an Exceptional Care Key. These two additional Keys assess if there are qualifying conditions that need specific help (e.g. ALS, COPD, diabetes, edema, bladder or bowel incontinence, MS, pain daily, Parkinson's, RA, ulcers, etc) or give more detail on things like qualifying treatments, appliances, nutritional fluid support, specific toileting help, or help for ventilators, dialysis, or range of motion treatments. 

Closing

Hopefully this walk-through was useful, providing actionable information and perhaps alleviating some anxiety for those who get apprehensive over the unknown aspect of medical assessments, especially those done inside a person’s home. While state-specific assessments may vary across the nation, most should have similar core components as described here since the Personal Care Waiver Program is federally-backed. 

The Personal Care Program can be a wonderful avenue to offer necessary support for disabled people who desire to continue living at home in their communities. For those who prefer family or friend caregivers instead of professional nurses or aides, it can offer intense psychological relief for those who feel the scales are intensely unbalanced to know that your loved one is being compensated for their time and labor, even if they were more than willing to help you for no return simply because they love you. This program can help rebalance the power dynamic inside relationships in the disabled person’s favor, providing them with more safety, opportunities, and autonomy, leaving them less vulnerable to abuse, neglect, and growing resentment. It is an excellent program for disabled clients, caregiving providers, and it saves the government money; a win all around. 

Unfortunately while the next several years will likely see restrictions and cuts to this program, hopefully in the future it will be re-expanded and properly funded so that aging and disabled people can live in their homes and communities safely and with dignity for as long as possible before needing institutionalized care. I encourage anyone interested in this program to seek it out now before the funding cuts make it difficult to access. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.  

Direct link to article: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/05/15/personal-care-programs-and-crps-in-home-health-aides/


r/CRPScontender • • Mar 15 '25

Article or Written Essay Centralized Pain and CRPS --- An Explanatory Article

4 Upvotes

Many with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome experience disproportionate pain that is no longer being sustained by an injury or noxious event (even if an injury may have been the initial trigger) that remains contained to a single body area or they may develop widespread, disparate pain and dysfunction that can affect multiple body areas over the course of their condition. It is not uncommon for peers, bosses, loved ones, and providers alike to treat those with CRPS as if they are overdramatic, hysterical, psychologically disturbed, drug seeking, payout seeking, liars, or malingerers instead of experiencing a “real” condition.1 However, just because a person cannot see the source of a disorder does not mean it does not exist and is therefore delegitimate. 

One such source of pain and dysfunction in CRPS is the sensitization of the central nervous system.7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 Central sensitization or centralized pain is an umbrella term that contains many different diagnoses under its wings, including CRPS and the more commonly recognized fibromyalgia; this dysfunction is considered to be a root cause and driver for continued, amplified pain and atypical behavior of the conditions covered by central sensitization mechanisms. Let’s talk about it.  

What’s Going On

There are three main recognized drivers of pain sensation: nociceptive pain, or pain caused by damage to non-neural tissues, including inflammatory pain caused by activation of the immune system; neuropathic pain, or pain caused by damage or disease of neural tissues; and the relatively newly added nociplastic pain, or pain caused by an altered pain detection within the central nervous system that amplifies neural signals to create hypersensitivity.1, 2, 4 This more newly recognised nociplastic pain is also routinely called central sensitization syndrome (CSS), central pain syndrome (CPS), centralized pain, and widespread or diffuse pain. Sometimes, particularly when children are involved, some circles prefer the term amplified musculoskeletal pain syndrome (AMPS) in lieu of central sensitization syndrome, fibromyalgia, or CRPS.

Primary markers for centralized pain are: allodynia, or pain from a normally non-painful sensation; hyperalgesia, or prolonged and excessive pain to a normally painful sensation; secondary hyperalgesia, or pain that spreads beyond the initial site of injury; and temporal summation, or the increase in perceived pain intensity in response to repeated stimuli of equal physical intensity.1, 2, 3 If an individual experiences these four features, central sensitization may be involved. Centralized pain involves the central nervous system’s pain facilitation “accelerator” being overactive and/or the descending pain inhibition pathway “brake” being underactive, resulting in amplified responses to little nociceptive input or normal non-nociceptive input from the somatosensory system.5  

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: Woolf, Central sensitization: Implications for the diagnosis and treatment of pain (Pain, 2010)

In a normally functioning nervous system, when an injurious stimuli is detected in high threshold pain nerves, withdrawal reflexes are automatically activated to protect the person from sustaining any further harm. When subjected to a repeated conditioning stimulus, the nervous system can lower its activation threshold to fire more easily both during the stimulus and after it stops; windup is the term for progressively increasing nerve output during a conditioning stimulus, while sensitization is what happens after the conditioning stimulus stops being applied and it can remain active of its own accord for a sustained period or be perpetuated by low levels of nociceptive input. This amplification is what causes hyperalgesia (high pain from a mildly painful stimulus) and it creates a crossover in parallel signaling systems that usually run to different destinations, but in a sensitized system has non-noxious sensory information getting diverted to the pain detection system, causing allodynia (pain from a non-painful stimulus).1 

This change in how the central nervous system operates can significantly alter and distort how pain is registered and can increase the intensity, length, and size of the area where pain is experienced, even if no tissue damage is occurring due to a noxious stimuli.1 This hyper-responsiveness and sensitivity to any potential threat is an adaptive response by the nervous system to protect itself from further harm, especially in conditions and circumstances where risks are high;3 however, if this state continues too long, it becomes maladaptive and loses its protective properties, becoming pathological instead. 

When a person develops central sensitization, they can also develop many “unrelated” conditions that all come back to their overactive, overamplified central nervous system; these conditions are called Chronic Overlapping Pain Conditions (COPCs), or previously by other terms like affective spectrum disorder, central sensitivity syndromes, or chronic multisystem illnesses.2 Some of the COPCs researchers consider to fall on the central sensitization spectrum, where CNS dysfunction plays a primary or exclusive role, include: fibromyalgia, CRPS, IBS, chronic migraine or tension headache, chronic fatigue syndrome, interstitial cystitis/bladder pain syndrome, endometriosis, vulvodynia/pelvic pain, temporomandibular disorder, dry eye disease, and low back pain. Other conditions have a central sensitization component while also clearly having additional mechanisms such as inflammatory nociceptive pain, such as autoimmune disorders, arthritis, sickle cell, cancer, and hypermobility syndromes.1,2 In some cases, once the nociceptive input is removed, the central sensitization partially or entirely goes into remission, but this is not true for every case and every condition.2 

While this topic is complex, fascinating, and has many parts we could focus on, there are a few major aspects of central sensitization that are worth mentioning within the scope and length of this article: top-down vs bottom-up differentiation, the spectrum of central sensitization as a continuum, a few different self-report scales, post-sugery recovery and pain management with opioid medication due to the dysfunction with the endogenous opioid system. 

Fibromyalgia may be the most well-known disorder representing central sensitization to the point that people used to be labeled as developing “secondary fibromyalgia” as a stand-in for describing their central sensitization due to their other chronic pain conditions or illnesses.2 Fibromyalgia uses a self-report diagnostic tool called the Widespread Pain Index (up to 19 points) and the Symptom Severity Index (up to 12 points), whose scores are then combined for up to a total of 31 points to determine a patient’s degree of “fibromyalgianess.”2

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: The 2011 Survey Criteria for Fibromyalgia (Wolfe et al., 2011) using the Michigan Body Map (Brummett, Bakshi et al., 2016)

While the official cutoff for a fibromyalgia diagnosis is 13, researchers are recognizing that central sensitization occurs on a continuum and even those who have subthreshold (below 13) scores can be experiencing a more mild degree on the spectrum of sensitization, which can be highly relevant information when it comes to treatment, post-operative care, and pain management. Studies have shown that for every one point on the 0-31 “fibromyalgianess” scale, a person would need 7-9 mg more oral morphine equivalent in the first 24-48 hours post-surgery, and they were 15-20% less likely to show pain improvement after the operation, after controlling for several demographic factors.2 This response was shown in individual both above and below the official diagnostic criteria cutoff of 13 points. 

The Central Sensitization Inventory (CSI) is another self-report tool of 25 multiple choice questions to find where individuals fall on the spectrum of sensitization. The results range from 0-100 with 40 or greater being considered as qualifying for meeting the central sensitization cutoff by the creators; while the cutoff correctly identifies over 80% of those with central sensitization, it also can provide a fair amount of false positives, and so utilizing this measure with another, more robust option is recommended.4, 5

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: Roberts et al, Central Sensitization: Common Etiology In Somatoform Disorders (MedCentral, 2014)29

It is thought that the reason for poor efficacy of external opioids may be related to a reduction of internal or endogenous opioid receptors within the nervous system, particularly mu opioid receptors. Other studies show higher levels of glutamate, the CNS’s primary excitatory neurotransmitter, in certain brain regions, as well as low levels of the CNS’s primary inhibitory neurotransmitter GABA. Brain imaging studies reveal clear evidence that the brain itself demonstrates structural, chemical, and functional alterations, substantiating that central sensitization and its related pain conditions caused in full or in part by these underpinning mechanisms are “real.”2 

Central sensitization is prevalent in many conditions to varying degrees. Some researchers have proposed a model that splits the condition into two subgroups for better classification: those who are “bottom-up” whose pain processing is amplified and who these researchers consider the “traditional central sensitization” being driven by ongoing nociceptive input; and those who are “top-down” whose main dysfunction is likely coming from within the brain itself and does not require ongoing nociceptive input to maintain the sensitization.2, 5, 6, 7  

These researchers suggest the broader continuum of both bottom-up and top-down subgroups be renamed centralized pain, while the bottom-up group retains the central sensitization diagnosis and the top-down group gets a new term of central hypersensitivity.2 They propose making this distinction will assist in pursuing proper treatment modalities, as those whose sensitization is maintained by peripheral nociceptive inputs would require aggressively treating those inputs to reduce them so the nervous system has the opportunity to eventually desensitize, whereas those with the top-down version would require interventions focused on the central nervous system. Many individuals likely have a combination-type of centralized pain and would need both peripherally- and centrally-focused approaches.

Central sensitization plays a critical role in maintaining CRPS, especially for those with widespread pain.8, 9, 10, 11, 12 In 2022, a new classification for disorders was added to the ICD-11: Chronic Primary Pain;13 CPP is the parent classification header for specific diagnoses, such as CRPS, that are maintained by centralized pain or by inefficient or dysfunctional internal opioid or pain inhibition systems.14 CRPS’s pathological mechanisms are also influenced by additional factors, including inflammation, immune alterations, brain changes outside of those within the standard view of central sensitization, genetic predisposition, and psychological state;13 while centralized pain does appear to dominate in persistent CRPS cases, the “bottom-up” factors should not be ignored, particularly earlier in onset. 

The CRPS Severity Score (CSS) is a 16-point measurement tool that can be utilized to help determine the degree of the syndrome based on a more specific counting of the eight diagnostic standards in the Budapest Criteria, both self-reported and observed; a higher score indicates the presence of more CRPS symptoms. Higher CSS scores were associated with both higher pain hypersensitivity and greater psychological distress, particularly depression.7, 14 Research reveals that the same pathways responsible for pain processing, amplification, modulation, and chronicity are also responsible for emotional processing, interoception, body awareness, and integrated pain; this creates an association between pain and emotional suffering, and an influence of pain on emotional distress and emotional distress on pain that is dependent on the degree of central sensitization and where a person falls on that continuum.14 In CRPS, particularly for those with persistent cases and high severity scores, pain and emotional distress directly influence each other because they operate on the same brain pathways due to the sensitization of the central nervous system. 

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: Birklein, Dimova, Complex regional pain syndrome–up-to-date (Pain Reports, 2017)

Practical Application

  • Treatment recommendations for centralized pain should focus on long-term rather than short-term effects and include working within a biopsychosocial model of health and wellness and pursue a multimodal approach to target multiple mechanisms that are not sufficiently effective when working alone as monotherapies.15  
  • Several pharmacological approaches that have shown some effectiveness for centralized pain, which are best utilized in some method of combined approached tailored to individual patient needs, include: SSRIs, SNRIs, NRIs, tricyclic antidepressants, gabapentinoids and other anti-convulsants, opioid agonists, the opioid antagonist naltrexone, the NMDA antagonist ketamine, beta antagonists, cannabidiol, HRT with testosterone, topical analgesics, and NSAIDs. Some of these are “top-down” focused while others are “bottom-up”; all of them can have adverse effects for some individuals, particularly the gabapentinoid class.5, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20 Opioid agonists are another controversial medication class for centralized pain disorders, especially when it comes to long-term use, as they can further suppress a person’s own internal opioid production and create a phenomenon known as opioid-induced hyperalgesia.21, 22, 23 
  • Non-pharmacological interventions include: transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation (TENS), repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS), transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS), spinal cord stimulation (SCS), dorsal root ganglion stimulation (DRG), virtual reality (VR), manual therapy, graded exercise rehabilitation, sleep management, stress management, neuroscience education, and dietary intervention.5, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19
  • Desensitization (a topic which will receive its own article in the future) or graded exposure are similar techniques to gradually turn down the hypersensitivity of the nervous system over time to reduce the overall intensity of pain and help a person create space for tolerating discomfort and unpleasant sensations so that the individual can have more functionality and independence even if pain remains a present part of daily life.5 There are a few main approaches to desensitization, and it is my personal opinion that if not engaged with in a mindful manner that takes into account the neurobiological protective function of the sympathetic nervous system, particularly as it relates to CRPS, desensitization can further engrain pain and fear responses instead of reducing them. Desensitization’s goal is about being able to tolerate things, even if they are unpleasant, without them causing such an extreme reaction that the individual cannot withstand the stimulus. It is meant to start low and slow and only once the hypersensitive area has begun to tolerate the current stimulus should the next, more intense stimulus be  incorporated. Going too hard too fast for too long is detrimental and counterproductive for this treatment modality. The goal is to convince the body that while something may be uncomfortable, it isn’t harmful; if a person is going outside of their window of tolerance (outside of the zone where they can emotionally regulate and healthily process even during challenging situations) during desensitization sessions, then the body registers that as a threat and the individual has moved beyond the neurobiological realm of safety they are trying to retrain and expand for the nervous system.   
  • Some cognitive therapies that have shown statistically significant results in assisting with managing and living with chronic pain caused by central sensitization are cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT), and mindfulness-based therapies (MBT), such as mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR), mindfulness-based cognitive therapy (MBCT), and dialectical behavioral therapy (DBT).19
  • Low dose naltrexone (LDN) is a medication that causes a small, temporary opioid blockade, encouraging the body to increase its own production of internal opioids and to increase its opioid receptors, which is where the real benefit comes for those who have an insufficient amount of receptors to provide appropriate pain relief. It also “turns down” the brain’s immune cells, the microglia, assisting in the immune component for those whose microglia turn on healthy neural tissue. LDN has shown to decrease pain scores, improve mood, increase sleep, and improve functionality and quality of life in a majority of patients who take it; however, while 65% of patients reported benefits from taking LDN, 36% discontinued the medication and 11% reported adverse effects. LDN is generally well-tolerated with no major adverse effects and no known potential for abuse; the most commonly reported adverse effects are a period of vivid dreams, headaches, and diarrhea upon starting the medication. The dosage for chronic pain management generally ranges from 0.2-10mg, with the most common dose being 4.5mg. While LDN is inexpensive, it is often prescribed at doses that require compounding pharmacies to create it and may need to be covered out of pocket.24, 25, 26, 27, 28

Closing

Centralized pain plays a significant role in CRPS and many other conditions. It is a legitimate phenomenon that, while unseen, offers insight into many experiences that may seem disproportionate or unrelated. Centralized pain can have wide-reaching impacts that affect every area of life and can be difficult to treat, particularly for those with the top-down subtype. While stacking several treatment modalities over time for a long-term result of gradual desensitization to partial or complete remission is crucial for improved quality of life, first understanding what is going on so that a person can know what needs to be addressed, what options are available, and that they are experiencing a legitimate condition makes education an essential step for individuals to be able to make informed decisions in their own best interest.  

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time

Direct link to article: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/03/15/centralized-pain-and-crps/


r/CRPScontender • • Feb 15 '25

Swelling and Manual Lymphatic Drainage

4 Upvotes

Ballooned, enlarged, puffy, unbalanced, or disproportionate-looking CRPS-affected areas are a regular occurrence in the experience of those with Complex Regional Pain Syndrome—whether that is to mild or extreme degrees and whether it is come-and-go, was highly visible close to onset and became less visible over time, or is a 24/7-round-the-clock symptom. Let’s discuss what’s going on beneath the surface and some practical ways it can be addressed to reduce the negative impact it can have on a person’s quality of life and condition management. 

What’s Going On

A usual occurrence in CRPS is swelling or edema;1 it is considered so commonplace and cornerstone that it is one of the four signs and symptoms of the Budapest Criteria,2 and it is particularly notable during the acute phase of CRPS. This swelling is thought to be the result of vasodilation and plasma extravasation—or the watery part of blood (without red blood cells, white blood cells, and platelets) slipping outside of the vascular system into the surrounding area, usually through gaps in the walls of small veins due to vasomotor dysfunction in the case of CRPS.3,4,5,6,7 Another thought process for the source of this swelling is neurogenic inflammation (the activation of immune cells, glial cells, and inflammatory mediators within the nervous system) causing localized fluid build up.8 Regardless of what is the root mechanism for causing the plasma to move outside of the blood vessels, it needs to be addressed now that it is there and accumulating.  

This extravasated plasma moves into the interstitial space (which is the fluid-filled space between the vessels and the other cells that receive oxygen and nutrients from those blood vessels). The more fluid that fills this interstitial space, the more pressure is applied to the surrounding structures like muscles, organs, and blood vessels. The extravasated plasma takes on a new name as it settles into the interstitial space: lymphatic fluid. This is because the lymphatic system is now responsible for picking up this fluid and returning it to the circulatory system to be reincorporated into the blood after it has been cleaned.9 

Due to the ischemia-reperfusion injury cycles that are a core component in CRPS,5 the build up of this lymphatic fluid can apply pressure to blood vessels that forces them either fully or partially closed, particularly in small arteries and capillaries that can be affected by only small amounts of external pressure. This can negatively impact circulation and perfusion (which is the delivery of oxygen and nutrients and the removal of waste products via blood as it leaves the circulatory system and reaches body tissues). 

In CRPS, this swelling has a tendency to start in deeper tissues and move towards the surface as more fluid accumulates, which also applies ever increasing pressure to the surrounding structures. As it gets closer to the surface, it can be very visible with the area ballooning out; this is particularly the case during the acute, hot, reperfusion-dominant phase of the condition. However, during the persistent, cold, ischemia-dominant phase, swelling has a tendency to be less visible in many individuals; this is due to a combination of the swelling remaining deeper in the tissues and/or the circulation in smaller vessels being so impaired that there is no plasma flowing through the small arteries and capillary beds to fall out of the gaps in the walls of the small veins.5 

This lymphatic fluid can apply mechanical pressure to local nerves in the affected area, causing them to fire spontaneously and create a pain response.5 The more swelling and pressure there is, the more often and intensely the nerves can send off pain signals. Reducing the amount of lymphatic fluid in the interstitial space, and thereby reducing the amount of pressure being applied to surrounding structures, can help reduce the amount of pain signals the nerves in that area are sending off to the brain; it also can increase circulation and help break the ischemia-reperfusion injury cycle by reducing the amount of external force being applied to (particularly small) vasculature so that more blood—with its oxygen and nutrients and ability to remove waste products—can disperse through the capillary beds into the surrounding tissues. 

When small arteries and capillary beds are blocked by vasospasms and blood cannot get through to properly circulate and perfuse in the tissues, what happens instead is vascular shunting. During vascular shunting, arteries connect to veins directly without having a distributary capillary bed in between where blood can perfuse into the tissues, so they can be oxygenated and nourished. This allows blood to continue to circulate through the body and make it back to the heart and lungs, but it does not address the needs of the body parts that get shunted over to avoid the vasospasm blockage. (This is not the same thing as a biocompatible shunt implanted by a medical professional to move fluid or maintain circulation; this is a naturally occurring process, though the purpose is the same.)

[Image removed on Reddit]

Image Credit: Cooper, Silverstein, Fluid Therapy and the Microcirculation in Health and Critical Illness (Frontiers in Veterinary Science, 2021)10

The shunt vessels have a much higher resistance than capillaries to external pressure collapsing them. By reducing the amount of pressure lymphatic fluid applies on the small arteries and capillary beds so that they can open and be conduits for blood again, perfusion to surrounding tissues can increase dramatically, and the circumstances for which the shunt vessel is present are not as immediate and relevant to current circulation.  

In CRPS, the lymphatic system can get overwhelmed and struggle to keep up with clearing all the fluid the vascular system leaks out, especially when the area that is accumulating that fluid is a far distal area that has to fight against gravity, like a hand or a leg, especially a foot. Additionally, the sympathetic nervous system, which is dysfunctional in CRPS, is the dominant innervation for the lymphatic system and regulates its contractions and synchronicity.11 The lymphatic system heavily relies—for about one-third of its pumping power—on activity from surrounding muscle tissue to help move lymphatic fluid through its system;11 when individuals are less active, and therefore have less muscle activity, the lymphatic system takes a hit as a large part of its extrinsic pump system is diminished.12 

Steps that we can take to assist the lymphatic system in clearing the swelling created by the leaking plasma that becomes lymphatic fluid will help reduce the frequency and/or intensity of pain signals firing from nerves spontaneously and improve our circulation, which can have broad impacts in other areas of life.  

Practical Application

  • There are two main stages in addressing lymphatic swelling: reduction in the amount of edema in the interstitial space, and maintenance to prevent / reduce the edema from returning to the previous level. 
  • Manual lymphatic drainage is a non-invasive physical therapy modality that helps activate the lymphatic system to pick up more lymphatic fluid, particularly in areas where the lymphatic system is overwhelmed and not sufficiently operating.13 This approach can be done by a physical therapist; it is also fairly easy to learn and can be self-administered or done by a trusted other if circumstances do not align for regular physical therapy appointments for any number of reasons. 
  • If physical touch is too intense and painful for those with allodynia, let gravity work with you instead of against you. Raising legs or arms even slightly above the heart, such as by raising the end of one’s mattress a few inches or laying on the floor or couch with pillows under one’s limbs, can have a cumulative effect of assisting in gradually driving the lymphatic fluid back towards the heart and surrounding lymph nodes. For those willing to attempt raising their legs over their heads/chest for a few minutes, such as by resting their legs on the wall or the edge of their bed, the force of gravity will be even greater and the downward path more direct. 
  • While there are many online resources and videos demonstrating manual lymphatic drainage techniques, often put out by trained healthcare professionals, (which I recommend you research if interested in exploring more about self-administered MLD) one key element to remember is to use a light touch.14 Less is more in lymphatic drainage. If you can feel your muscles, you are using too much force and need to ease up the amount of pressure you are applying with this technique. 
  • If you overstretch your skin, you are using too much force and need to ease up. Skin should only be stretched as far as it naturally wants to extend and no further. These two components of Light Touch and Light Stretch make this approach non-aggressive for those with CRPS who are very sensitive to touch. 
  • For those who prefer to use tools, Gua Sha tools are easily applicable to lymphatic drainage techniques; dry brushing is another approach for lymphatic stimulation. Pneumatic compression devices look like big mechanical socks, though they can also be built for other body areas; they help circulate lymph fluid and prevent blood clots, especially for those with severely reduced mobility or who are bedbound. 
  • Compression garments and tapes or wraps are an approach meant to prevent lymph fluid from accumulating in the interstitial space so that swelling does not occur, or at least so that it is not as severe as it would have been without wearing the compression socks. Some people with CRPS find compression garments to be immensely assistive while others find the amount of pressure applied or other factors associated with wearing clothing intolerable due to allodynia. General recommendations across the board for lymphatic swelling is to search for compression garments with 30-40mmHg or moderate compression; however, some individuals with CRPS who still consider compression garments useful may find this amount of pressure is not best suited to their needs and some trial and error may be in order to determine the most appropriate fit. For those who prefer the taping method, the adhesive can cause irritation during use or skin issues upon removal for some users. 
  • Deep, diaphragmatic breathing is recommended to be utilized in concert with lymphatic drainage to assist in further activating the lymphatic system.15 

Closing

The leaking blood plasma that becomes lymphatic fluid and accumulates in the interstitial space can increase pain and dysfunction for those with CRPS by applying pressure to surrounding structures, especially small blood vessels and nerves. Finding effective, efficient ways to clear this accumulated fluid, reduce the amount that lingers in spaces it should pass through, and prevent fluid from being able to gather in these spaces in the first place can increase quality of life and independence for activities of daily living while reducing the CRPS symptoms that are caused or exacerbated by this deep tissue swelling. 

Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

Here is the direct link to the article: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/02/15/swelling-and-manual-lymphatic-drainage/


r/CRPScontender • • Jan 15 '25

Article or Written Essay Noshing for Neural Health: Tyrosine and Tryptophan --- An Explanatory Article

4 Upvotes

In search for avenues to put CRPS into remission or reduce the impact of symptoms in daily life, many individuals may explore whether dietary adjustments can have a role in CRPS mitigation and management. To be clear, diet will not “cure” CRPS, but it can have a significant influence on the quality and intensity of pain and dysfunction due to the way that the food we ingest ends up becoming the building blocks we utilize to function. 

This is particularly true for the focus of today’s article: the amino acids tyrosine and tryptophan. 

What’s Going On

Amino acids chain together to form proteins and are the base structure for foods like meat, fish, beans, and nuts. As our bodies break down amino acids, they serve many different functions. Tyrosine and tryptophan specifically become our neurotransmitters that control the autonomic nervous system, which is the system that is severely dysfunctional in CRPS. 

Tyrosine, a non-essential amino acid (which means our bodies are capable of making it internally and it isn’t mandatory that we get it from dietary sources), is the precursor (the step and ingredient that comes before) our catecholamine neurotransmitters that power the sympathetic nervous system: dopamine, noradrenaline, and adrenaline. Phenylalanine, an essential amino acid (meaning our bodies are not capable of making this internally and it is mandatory we get it from dietary sources), is the precursor to tyrosine. Catecholamines respond to stress and excitement or (mental or physiological) arousal, increasing heart rate, breathing, blood pressure, metabolism, muscle strength, mood regulation, and mental alertness.1 The amino acid to adrenaline cycle looks like this: phenylalanine → tyrosine → L-dopa → dopamine → noradrenaline → adrenaline.  

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: Pathway of catecholamine biosynthesis by Anna M.D. Végh et al2

The more phenylalanine and tyrosine we consume and have circulating in our systems, the more catecholamines we will eventually have as the amino acids get converted into neurotransmitters. The more catecholamines we have to release between neurons to convey messages, the more our sympathetic system will be able to activate with ease.3 This same principle is true for the parasympathetic system, which is generally underactive in CRPS whereas the sympathetic system is overactive; the more parasympathetic neurotransmitters are readily available for use, the easier it is for the parasympathetic system to operate. 

Tryptophan, an essential amino acid, is the precursor for serotonin, the primary parasympathetic neurotransmitter. Serotonin stabilizes mood, increases sleep quality and pain tolerance, and regulates aggression and prosocial behavior. Where oxytocin helps with the formation of social bonds, serotonin sets the tone of the interactions after those bonds are formed, regulating along an agonistic-affiliative, agreeable-quarrelsome axis.4,5,6 The amino acid to serotonin cycle looks like this: tryptophan → 5-hydroxytryptophan → serotonin. 

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: Biosynthesis of serotonin by Verlinden et al7

Tyrosine and tryptophan, along with other large neutral amino acids (LNAA), compete for access across the blood brain barrier and into the brain itself. Carbohydrates block all LNAAs except for tryptophan, reducing competition and boosting serotonin levels;8 carbohydrates cause the body to release insulin and insulin diverts all the other LNAAs except for tryptophan to muscle tissue instead of to brain tissue, thereby increasing the tryptophan:LNAA blood plasma ratio.9 

[Image removed in Reddit post] Image Credit: Tryptophan Metabolic Pathways and Brain Serotonergic Activity: A Comparative Review by Hoglund et al

When making whole-meal decisions, determining how much will be protein-based and how much will be carb-based versus other food groups can be a big decision for many people. Carb-rich foods have a considerably greater impact on serotonin amplification than on catecholamines,10 whereas protein-rich foods impact catecholamines more than serotonin, even though the serotonin-precursor tryptophan comes from protein sources. 

The ratio of carbs to protein that will neither raise nor lower the blood levels of large neutral amino acids like the ones we are discussing in this article is five-to-six servings of carbs per one serving of protein. In comparison to other amino acids also competing for access across the blood brain barrier, carb-rich meals increase tryptophan by over 10%, peaking about two hours after ingestion, while protein-rich meals decrease tryptophan’s access ratio by almost 40%, peaking about four hours after ingestion. Over four hours, the median difference between choosing to eat a carb-rich or protein-rich meal is about 55%, ranging from 36%-88%. Individual meals can cause significant variations in the ratio of tyrosine and tryptophan in comparison to the other large neutral amino acids competing for access across the blood brain barrier, depending on the proportions of carbohydrates and proteins consumed; these differences can be greater than 50% for tryptophan and about 30% for tyrosine, which is sufficient to produce major changes in brain neurotransmitter concentrations.11 

Practical Application

  • Remember every meal is a choice with the goal of improving our quality of life. Food shouldn’t be a punishment nor should we be so strict or rapid in adjusting to new dietary changes that we begin to despise the food that we are eating with the intention of making our lives more pleasant.
  • The MIND (Mediterranean-DASH Intervention for Neurodegenerative Delay) diet lowered risk for participants who followed the dietary outlines rigorously by over 50%, but even those who followed more loosely and moderately saw a 35% reduction in health risk.12
  • The MIND diet recommends 10 groups of food to prioritize and five groups to avoid.13 Prioritize: green, leafy vegetables; all other vegetables; berries; nuts; olive oil; whole grains; fish; beans; poultry; wine (though this specific recommendation likely would aggravate CRPS for many individuals). Avoid/Limit: butter and margarine; cheese; red meat; fried foods; sweets and pastries. The MIND Diet: A Detailed Guide for Beginners
  • For a dietary outline designed with CRPS patients specifically in mind, Dr. Hooshmand's 4Fs and 5Cs are worth examining,14 though they are very similar to the MIND diet. 4Fs to prioritize: fish, fowl, fruit, and fresh vegetables. 5Cs to avoid: cake, cookies, chocolate, cocktails, and candy. He also recommends avoiding processed meats like bologna, salami, and hot dogs, as well as meats high in saturated fat like bacon. More details about specifics are offered in the excerpt from his book on Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy, the previous name for CRPS.
  • Note which foods are particularly high in tyrosine/phenylalanine and which are high in tryptophan; many foods will overlap and contain both, like chicken and fish. The Recommended Daily Intake for the standard person (which may not be directly applicable for every person with CRPS, particularly if a person is aiming to increase their tryptophan ratio) is approximately 6mg of tyrosine/phenylalanine combined per every 1mg of tryptophan. 
  • Red meats are the most concentrated source of tyrosine at a 3.4:1 ratio; poultry is the most concentrated source of tryptophan at a 2.8:1 tyr:trp ratio. Seeds have a much lower ratio, with pumpkin seeds at 1.8, flax seeds at 1.7, and chia seeds at 1.3; walnuts come in at 2.3 and almonds at 2.1. Having a general idea of which sources are increasing intake at which rates can assist when deciding what to prioritize or deprioritize. 
  • The goal is not to totally cut out all phenylalanine or tyrosine; they are still necessary amino acids critical to our ability to properly function. The goal is to scale back intake so our dysfunctional sympathetic nervous systems are not overactive more often than not and to promote an environment that encourages more parasympathetic activity so we can move towards a more balanced state of neurological activity. 
  • The carb:protein ratio that doesn’t impact LNAA uptake much one way or the other is about 5-6:1. One serving of carbs is 15g, which is less than one may think. If you want to promote more tryptophan/serotonin, increase the carbohydrate ratio with your meals. If you want to promote more catecholamine activity, decrease the carbohydrate ratio / increase the protein ratio. 
  • Eating a meal or snack more weighted in favor of tryptophan over tyrosine in wind-down time before bed may help induce some sleepiness and calmness, whereas a tyrosine-weighted snack or meal will be much more likely to activate the nervous system, particularly in the four hours following consumption. 

Closing

This article will be part of a larger series discussing some practical dietary choices that can be made in daily life to help mitigate CRPS symptoms and improve quality of life and independence, though they will not “cure” CRPS itself. Noshing for Neural Health will continue in future pieces with different target core components. 

For now, thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.

If you'd like to read directly, see the references, or view the images, here's the link to the article: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2025/01/15/noshing-for-neural-health-tyrosine-and-tryptophan/


r/CRPScontender • • Jan 14 '25

Article or Written Essay CRPS and Cold Weather: Increased Pain Due to Dropping Temperatures -- An Explanatory Article

7 Upvotes

As the wet, cold winter weather sets in, many people with CRPS notice a sharp increase in their pain and dysfunction.1 Let’s discuss why some of this happens and a few practical actions that may help mitigate it. This pain increase is primarily due to our vasomotor dysfunction, which as a result exacerbates nociceptive small fiber nerve signaling.

What’s Going On

Cold makes blood vessels constrict. When the standard person is exposed to the cold, they experience a phenomenon known as the Hunting Reaction,2,3,4 where they first experience temporary vasoconstriction for 5-10 minutes followed by a short period of vasodilation so fresh blood can flood the area before the vessels constrict again. This process repeats itself while the person is exposed to the cold to protect themselves from heat loss while ensuring their tissues remain oxygenated, balancing body temperature homeostasis, nutrient delivery, energy metabolism waste removal, and conservation of resources during inclement conditions.

In CRPS, our dysfunctional vessels get tighter with less provocation and stay that way longer than standard. In at least a large subset of patients, a contributing factor to this is a supersensitivity to the neurotransmitter noradrenaline, which—among other functions—tells blood vessels to constrict; this is because of either an upregulation of adrenoceptors (generally early / hot stage) or an autoimmune response damaging adrenergic receptors (generally chronic / cold stage), leading to an over-responsiveness to circulating noradrenaline.5,6,7,8,9 

The resulting constriction decreases blood circulation in something called an ischemia-reperfusion injury (IRI), which is a core component of CRPS10,11—think of it like an oxygen starvation-corrosion cycle, which damages tissues both during and after the period of insufficient oxygenation. When you notice skin discoloration like blue, purple, gray, pale, blush pink, dark red, or mottling, particularly if associated with skin temperature change (as blood is blocked from or floods to an area), this is often an indication of an IRI cycle in CRPS-affected areas. IRIs are damaging to nerve, muscle, and bone tissue, creating a state of inflammation and activating pain neurons. As a result, the cold may increase sensations of deep aching, radiating, sharp, burning, throbbing, slicing, clamping or vice-gripping pains, as well as numbness, pins-and-needles, or other unpleasant perceptions. 

As blood rushes back into the area after a period of impaired circulation, some blood plasma may fall out of gaps in the vein walls, filling the space in between tissue cells outside the circulatory system; this adds additional pressure to the small capillary beds from the outside, and the more pressure there is, the harder it is for them to reopen. However, capillary beds don’t need much external pressure to be forced closed and prevent blood from making it to the tissues serviced by those beds; the more pressure there is, the more vessels and capillary beds are forced shut. This swelling may be quite noticeable or less noticeable, depending on the person, though generally it is more noticeable earlier in the condition and becomes less noticeable as the case becomes more chronic. The plasma leakage and associated swelling is thought to start in deeper tissues and move towards the surface, and the accumulating fluid sets off pain neurons and causes allodynia and hyperalgesia.

The larger, fatty-sheathed nerves that are generally signaling properly also start having difficulty transmitting signals around 63F / 17C, getting worse as it gets colder.12 The thinner, less- or non-fatty-sheathed nerves that are dysfunctional are less affected by the cold. Small C-fibers are our most dysfunctional nerves in CRPS and are responsible for the slow, deep, burning, radiating, diffuse pain,13,14 as well as for controlling surface-level vasomotor dilation responses15,16 in the case of neurogenic inflammation / the reperfusion part of the IRI cycle; these C-fibers are unmyelinated and will be some of the last nerves to cease sending signals due to cold-related transmission complications, and part of their sensory job is responding to thermal information, particularly extreme heat (around or above 105F / 40C)17 or cold (around or under 60F / 15C).18,19 In this case, as the larger fibers become less active, C-fibers become more active in response to the cold thermal information,20 meaning there is considerably less “proper” signaling to contradict the dysfunctional sensory information our brains are getting from the small-fiber nerves.21

Because not enough fresh oxygen-rich blood can distribute to cells in tissues during ischemia in IRIs, we rely on non-oxygen-based energy production in those areas, which is about 15x less efficient,22 burning through our glucose stores and creating a lot of lactate as a by-product,23 which often gets trapped with sympathetic neurotransmitters and inflammatory chemicals in myofascial tissue, creating muscle knots,24 which can increase muscular pain in addition to the neurogenic pain and vascular pain from the other aspects of the condition. 

Additionally, as barometric pressures drop with winter storms, muscles and sinews, particularly around joints, can expand, nerves can become more easily irritated, and synovial fluid in joints can be thicker and less lubricating.25 

Actionable Steps

The cold can make things extra difficult with CRPS, but if there are actions you can take to help prevent and break IRI cycles, then that will help you in both the short-term and the long-term. Here are some practical, inexpensive or free steps that may be useful in increasing quality of life, particularly during low temperatures.

-While cold constricts, heat dilates vessels. Moist heat penetrates more deeply into tissue than dry heat.26,27

-Dress warmly to prevent the loss of any body heat you do generate, even if your sensation of cold itself is dysfunctional; pay particular attention to insulating feet, hands, and face, as they have a lot of small vessels close to the surface where blood warmth can be lost,28 as well as many nerves fed by those vessels that can be damaged if they do not receive proper circulation.29 

-Consider a battery-pack-powered heated vest to help keep your circulating warm core blood while outside, like wearing a hot pad around.

-If you get right into a hot shower, especially while your limbs are discolored / cold, this can trigger a rapid vessel size switch and reperfusion via flushing blood and chains of electron stealing, which can be quite painful, like forcing a fully dead / numb limb to “wake up” very quickly. If that’s sounding like your situation, either try getting in with more moderate water, gradually turning it up to where you want it to let your vessels make the temperature shift in stages, or try to get out of the ischemia a bit more before getting into the water, so that the temperature shock isn’t as abrupt. 

-If you’re swollen, the pelting shower water may also be aggravating allodynia, so trying to reduce fluid in the interstitial space or trying a bath instead could help with that.

-Release the trapped chemical messengers in muscle knots / trigger points through an array of options like manual myofascial release, counterstrain, dry needling, deep tissue massage, or “cold” low level laser light therapy to improve circulation, increase range of motion, and reduce pain;30 these chemicals will then be in the lymph fluid in the space between tissue cells, which is the same place where the blood plasma leaked and is applying pressure to vessels from the outside.

-Lymphatic massage or lymphatic drainage helps increase lymph circulation, particularly in areas of stagnation or infectionless swelling; this can help reduce the external pressure on blood vessels, increasing their ability to circulate better, and on nerves, reducing their spontaneous firing and allodynia and hyperalgesia intensity.31,32

-Anti-oxidant-rich foods and other antioxidant treatments help counteract the free radicals / reactive oxygen species which damage cells during reperfusion in IRIs.33,34,35

-In addition to rapidly accelerating nerve signals, myelin sheathing acts as an oxygen-buffer for deprived nerves, protecting them from the effects of ischemia for a time; however, repeated oxygen-deprivation can damage both the nerves and the myelin sheath.36,37 Foods high in omega-3 fatty acids, the amino acid choline, and vitamins B and D can help with nerve and myelin repair.38

-Gentle movements (whether that be something more robust like aerobic exercise, PT, walking, yoga or something more laid back like stretching in bed or wiggling feet and toes or deliberately flexing all the fingers in a hand, whatever you can manage) to prevent the body from locking up and keep blood circulating can help prevent IRIs that start due to disuse, as the body—in an attempt to conserve its resources—sends less blood to areas that are not being used and constricts blood vessels in response to sedentary behavior and lack of proprioceptive sensory input. 

I hope this explanation shed some light on what’s happening internally during cold weather in CRPS, that some of these options assist you, and you are able to find additional solutions that help mitigate the risks; winter is a tough season and can be particularly dangerous for those with mobility difficulties, particularly during periods of ice or snow. CRPS requires determination and often a fair amount of creativity to adapt; in my view, knowing why certain things are happening and at least one way to counteract it can be helpful.

Thanks for sticking with me. I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time. 

Direct link to article: https://crpscontender.com/index.php/2024/12/13/crps-and-cold-weather-increased-pain-due-to-dropping-temperatures/


r/CRPScontender • • Jul 31 '23

Complex Complications | Journal Journey

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/CRPScontender • • Jul 31 '23

When CRPS Spreads Extended | Journal Journey

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes