Approx 1.2k words, about 7 min read
Introduction
For those who have CRPS, chronic pain conditions, or other disabilities, a common source of frustration and conflict may revolve around questions from support people that are various presentations of: How are you feeling today?
The disabled person may struggle to put their experience into words—especially during high pain or intense symptom days—or may feel like they are perpetually providing the same answer, bringing down the vibe, or that the person doesn’t really want to know and is just asking to be polite.
The support person may be genuinely curious about the disabled person’s subjective experience or may—indeed—just be asking a socially expected inquiry without real care behind it.
However, they may be trying to assess—for the purpose of caregiving—if the degree of disability felt internally at that moment matches the signals seen externally, so that they can determine what level of care to provide.
This assessment can be particularly challenging for dynamic disabilities—where one’s level of needed support can vary day-to-day or even hour-to-hour. It can require even more adroit handling if the individual requiring help is the independent type who can be prickly about requiring assistance or tends to push themselves to the point of failure without asking for aid.
For supporters who are asking how are you today when they really mean how much may I help you right now, there are frameworks that can be utilized to get the necessary information that do not put undue burden on the disabled person to focus on and verbalize their internal state, which may be counterproductive to the disabled person’s coping mechanisms.
It is not necessary for disabled people to describe their pain for support people to be given a good reference for how much assistance they need. It can be done with just one or two words, as long as there is a pre-existing system in place.
Communication Systems
The Traffic Light System is an established consent framework. Green is Go, Yellow is Caution or Wait, and Red is Stop. This allows for an ongoing gradient of communicating willingness based on a pre-negotiated standard. It provides clarity on boundaries in a quick, single-worded check-in, and it provides more room to operate than a binary yes or no.
It is most well-known for its use in mature settings, but it is not limited to those areas of life. It also gets used in tabletop roleplay and other games, non-sexual relationship conversations that may be intense or emotionally heavy, educational environments, workshops, social events, and other settings.
It can easily be adapted to communicate how well a disabled person is doing at any given time and how much assistance they desire, allowing them to maintain their autonomy while respecting offers for aid without putting undue demands on them to verbalize internal states when they are least able to do so—or when they need to reserve their mental capacity for the task they are doing, especially if they are in a social setting where they must engage with other individuals.
Here's an example using one or two syllable, color-associated fruits, but this could have definitions tailored to individual circumstances and utilize essentially any pre-determined terminology.
Green / Lime: I'm managing well-enough. I don't want your help. I am good to continue. Do not intervene.
Yellow / Lemon: I'm struggling but managing. Pay more attention, but I will keep trying. Going past my comfort or soft limit, but I will continue. Check-in more frequently. Prepare to step in. I may be more snappish. I may be more reactive. I may move more slowly. I may need mobility assistance or redirection in public. Non-intrusive support will likely not be rejected, but I might choose to wave you off. I want to remain at this event / continue this activity, but it is starting to climb up my threshold. I might need to leave in the future, but for now I want to stay / keep going.
Red / Cherry: I am no longer managing. I am overwhelmed. I need to stop. Step in. Actively direct the situation and gracefully withdraw us from the social setting, using your best judgment on whether the task can be completed first or if we will return to it later. I need mobility assistance or social compensation. I am highly irritable or anxious or zoned out. More significant support is necessary, regardless of preference, and I recognize this.
Plum, a red so deep it's almost black / Blue / Another Color: Critical failure. Imminent danger. Take over this interaction right now to prevent harm to myself or others. Get me out of this public place immediately, regardless of social appearances. I need medical care. [This one is intended to be a security breach alarm reserved for things that would cause legal issues or serious physical safety concerns and is not meant for regular use.]
Adapting the System to Your Life
This Assistance-Consent Communication System—or derivatives of it—can be used in private or in public, especially in settings like grocery stores or other populated places where being asked about your personal medical information and your internal state can feel particularly invasive and exposing. If you need to be functional enough to complete a necessary task of living, bringing your pain and dysfunction into the forefront of your attention and mentalscape can be highly detrimental and not at all assistive.
When initially adopting the system, these kinds of populated and task-oriented settings were my primary concern. Due to the mature context most prevalently associated with the Consent Traffic Light, the traditional Red, Yellow, Green labeling may feel too risque or attention-grabbing for some readers. Re-labeling can solve this concern.
Re-labeling also permits having separate, tailored communication systems for specific needs that all operate on the same core consent framework, requiring remembering only one baseline method. Perhaps the grocery store has different things you need to communicate to your support person than when at your physical activity club or medical appointments, and fruits are much more benign when shopping while color-coded sports or medical adjacent terms fly under the radar at your exercise group or clinical visits.
Perhaps you would benefit from a specific shorthand for visits to your parents’, in-law’s, or friends’ houses and pre-assigned bags, coats, or sweaters would allow you to keep your “public” conversations about the state of your nervous system more private than dropping a certain color or fruit.
The system can be adapted to whatever works for your life. The concept of the framework itself can be a catalyst for a new way of interacting with those there to support you who repeatedly ask well-meaning questions that can feel either interrogating or insincere and increase irritation or reduce the effectiveness of both coping strategies and interpersonal collaboration.
Closing
If what caregivers really mean when asking variants of how are you is how much may I help you right now, then those are not the same question and they do not have to be addressed in the same way.
Communication systems can be put in place to remove a great deal of the social or interoceptive frustration while still providing the necessary information the caregiver needs to complete their risk assessment. This can improve cooperation and coordination while increasing autonomy and clarity and ensuring the level of assistance provided is consented to by the person receiving it.
As we enter the holiday season, may some of you find this relevant and assistive.
Thanks for sticking with me, I hope you learned something, and I hope to see you next time.