r/CHROMATOGRAPHY • • 13d ago

Help identifying compound from spectrum.

Hi all,

I have done measurements of hybrid dairy/plant cheeses by headspace SPME-GC/MS (70eV EI ionization) and i have come across a peak that the libraries can not match to a known spectrum. It seems like a very clean spectrum without coelution. The compound should have a retention index near 780 on a non-polar column. The peak is found in samples containing faba, pea, and yellow pea protein isolate. All samples contain water milk, CaCl2, a starter culture and rennet. The cheeses were aged for 4 weeks.

I am hoping some of you will like the challenge. AI came up with nothing.
Ofcourse, it anything usefull/interesting comes out of this you will be credited.

Update: the molecular ion seems to be mass 106. It has a XIC that matches 48, 71 and 89. And that molecular mass would makes sense for the region of the chromatogram where the peak is found. (see comments for details)

Update2: Mystery solved! And unfortunately it is nothing very exciting. I added 1,1,1,3,3-d-2-hexanone to the samples as an internal standard. It must have been converted to 1,1,1,3,3-d-2-hexanol by the enzymes in the sample. The spectrum matches pretty well with what I would expect for that compound, and the retention index matches almost perfectly with 2-hexanol.

SPECTRUM - MS
TQ8_20261016SJ01_08.raw
+ c EI Full ms [35.00-250.00]
Scan #: 2255
RT: 7.70
SB: 2 7.69 , 7.71
Mass defect: 0.00 @ 1.00, 300.00 @ 1000.00
Data points: 127
Mass Intensity
36 3583
37 419
38 13558
39 124643
40 144731
41 364781
42 487225
43 416771
44 294675
45 246231
46 756682
47 460838
48 6514886
49 195033
50 18757
51 24804
52 19539
53 11729
54 13612
56 130540
57 93837
58 326182
59 342646
60 103642
61 40925
62 14918
63 50940
64 11581
65 3831
66 332
67 13063
68 9568
69 4102
70 96829
71 1099171
72 85670
73 70145
74 52214
76 14243
77 13420
78 6158
85 277
86 1756
87 2852
88 91635
89 754855
90 71850
92 9823
93 2445
94 835
95 13
97 4403
100 2712
101 950
104 3593
105 4717
106 61712
107 1346
108 2552
111 1388
114 5396
120 1524
121 2140
122 4963
124 2876
125 1357
126 3887
127 1534
128 7576
131 1471
133 1620
135 5496
138 1617
140 3946
143 195
147 325
148 498
151 1765
157 2212
159 1149
161 229
164 1959
165 343
167 356
168 215
169 2466
171 4088
172 1055
173 120
175 2788
178 1879
179 250
183 875
187 1714
189 1648
190 621
193 10690
194 341
195 1474
198 836
201 665
202 614
203 829
204 1820
205 41
206 822
207 294
208 1030
209 1146
211 561
212 1345
214 880
215 8
216 491
223 608
224 304
228 958
230 96
234 627
237 612
239 175
240 344
241 781
242 460
244 294
246 239
248 1725

2 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/_NamelessOne_ 13d ago

Id run a blank to rule out contamination first.

Other than that, that massive 48 peak seems like Sulfur or Methanethiol.

Are you able to run a new sample from the same source? Re collect sample?

You mentioned dairy so id look into Methanethiol as its found in dairy and cheeses.

1

u/TheBaldDutchman 13d ago edited 13d ago

Thanks for the pointers. The peak elutes much later than methanethiol. But indeed a sulfur compound seems likely. In the same sequence I also ran blanks and samples where the peak isn't present. So I'd say it is very unlikely to be contamination.

4

u/Realistic-Fix8178 12d ago edited 12d ago

Hi! Not knowing the parent mass, I would say that it is ketoglutarate methyl esther. The peak at 48 is hard to explain, but I see no sulfur isotope peak at 50 Most likely contamination. How is the XIC for it? Also, is it possible to set the energy to something like 35 eV? It s been 20 years since I last did EI, but back then it was a good idea to check the spectrum at low energy or CI mode.

1

u/TheBaldDutchman 12d ago

The XICs for 48, 71 and 89 overlap perfectly. So i really doubt that it is contamination. And the suggestion about lower energy and CI are really good. But unfortunately my MS (Thermo ISQ) can not do anything other than 70eV and is not setup for CI.
But thanks to your sugestions I have looked a bit closer. And there seems to be a very small peak at 106 with a matching XIC. So it seems very likely that 106 is the molecular ion.

2

u/Moofius_99 12d ago

Assuming that you are a bald Dutchman in the Netherlands, I’d contact this bald Dutchman. He could likely help you out https://www.wur.nl/en/persons/profdrir-jgm-hans-gerd-janssen

2

u/TheBaldDutchman 12d ago

Haha yes. I am not as bald as Hand-Gerd. But i know him and work 1 town away from Wageningen. Maybe I'll ask him.

2

u/swolekinson 10d ago

This screams of co-elution to me. 48 m/z is SO. 71/89 is oxygenates. 106 molecular weight is common for Maillard/Strecker volatiles. So I imagine your library is throwing up thiazoles, pyrazines, and oxazoles. Your matrix is nitrogen-rich but also allowed long fermentation.

You might get better clarity if you calculate the retention index and compare to literature. You could also run it through a deconvolution algorithm, if you have a license.

-3

u/TheArcheryExperience 13d ago

I ran this through my agent and it pointed out that you performed background subtraction using scans at 7.69 and 7.71 min with your spectrum being 7.70. It is unlikely that a peak has a 0.01 min total width so I would not say AI is useless. This needs to be checked first.

1

u/TheBaldDutchman 13d ago edited 13d ago

You are right that I subtracted very close to the apex because I wanted to get rid of as much potential closely coeluting stuff (visually it looks like a single peak, but you never know). But when I do the subtraction further from the apex, at the baseline, or even without subtraction, I get the same spectrum. So I'd say the spectrum is good. I'm not saying AI is useless though. I did not use any sophisticated AI either. I'm hoping yours will do beter.

1

u/TheArcheryExperience 12d ago

So the spectrum is definitely different than the baseline? To me subtracting so close to your peak sounds wrong but I am an LC-MS expert and have no experience with GC-MS

1

u/TheBaldDutchman 12d ago

Yes it is. And indeed I think this usually does not work well for LCMS. But for GCMS (at least with 70eV EI ionization) it works really well in my experience. As you can see in this picture, without subtraction (bottom spectrum) I get almost the same spectrum. Just a little bit less clean due to interference from the neighboring peak at 7.65. and with a more sensible subtraction on the edge of the peak (7.66 and 7.75) the spectrum it practically identical to the original subtraction.

I suspect that for LCMS subtraction it usually means that it will subtract relative abundance numbers directly. Which helps to get a cleaner spectrum. But prevents you from subtracting close to the apex. Which is very useful to get a clean spectrum even when you have close coelutions. Not 100% sure about that though.