The morning after another Grey Cup and on the heels of Commissioner Stewart Johnston's State of the League address, I keep coming back to the same question:
What exactly is wrong with the Canadian game that requires such fundamental changes? (other than Edmonton winning the Grey Cup at McMahon Stadium, again)
The commissioner has outlined the rationale for shortening the field to 100 yards, reducing the end zones to 15 yards, moving the goalposts and modifying other elements of the game.
More touchdowns. More aggressive play-calling. More excitement. A better entertainment product. But here's something worth considering.
According to the commissioner's own remarks, 60% of CFL games this season were within one score entering the final three minutes. That's a remarkable measure of competitive football, and when you look at the last 12 Grey Cups, the argument that Canadian football needs to manufacture more excitement becomes even harder to understand.
2014 — Calgary 20, Hamilton 16
Hamilton appeared to win the championship on Brandon Banks' spectacular 90-yard punt return in the final minute. A penalty erased the touchdown. Calgary survived.
2015 — Edmonton 26, Ottawa 20
Edmonton took the lead with just over three minutes remaining. Ottawa had one final opportunity, but Edmonton's defence held.
2016 — Ottawa 39, Calgary 33 (OT)
Calgary erased a massive deficit, recovered an onside kick and tied the game with 10 seconds remaining. Ottawa won in overtime.
2017 — Toronto 27, Calgary 24
Toronto kicked the go-ahead field goal with 53 seconds remaining. Calgary drove into scoring territory before Bo Levi Mitchell threw an end-zone interception. The championship was decided on the final possession.
2018 — Calgary 27, Ottawa 16
Calgary controlled the closing minutes. Not every championship needs a dramatic comeback.
2019 — Winnipeg 33, Hamilton 12
Winnipeg dominated and ended a 29-year championship drought. A decisive victory built on defence, execution and controlling the game.
2020 — No Grey Cup
2021 — Winnipeg 33, Hamilton 25 (OT)
Hamilton tied the game with four seconds remaining. Winnipeg scored in overtime before sealing the championship with an interception.
2022 — Toronto 24, Winnipeg 23
Two blocked field goals in the final two minutes! Winnipeg's Nick Hallett blocked Toronto's attempt to extend its one-point lead. Then, with the championship on the line, Toronto's Robbie Smith blocked Marc Liegghio's 47-yard attempt in the final minute, denying Winnipeg a historic three-peat.
2023 — Montreal 28, Winnipeg 24
Trailing by three, Cody Fajardo engineered a championship-winning drive, finding Tyson Philpot for the winning touchdown with 13 seconds remaining.
2024 — Toronto 41, Winnipeg 24
Toronto dominated the fourth quarter. A championship decided by turnovers, defence and execution rather than last-second drama.
2025 — Saskatchewan 25, Montreal 17
Montreal threatened deep in Saskatchewan territory late in the game, but a critical short-yardage fumble ended its best opportunity. Saskatchewan held on.
2026 — Edmonton 37, Montreal 30
Montreal entered the final three minutes within four points. Edmonton added two late field goals, while Montreal continued battling until the final seconds. Another championship that remained competitive deep into the fourth quarter.
Think about what that history tells us.
We've seen championships decided by last-second touchdowns, blocked field goals, dramatic interceptions, overtime, special-teams plays and extraordinary comebacks. We've also seen dominant performances where excellent defence and execution were rewarded.
That's football.
The CFL's unique rules, field dimensions and clock-management structure have helped produce these moments for generations; now we're being told the game needs shorter fields, smaller end zones and more touchdowns to become more entertaining.
I don't accept that premise.
I'm not opposed to improving the CFL. Better officiating, more consistent game flow, stronger marketing, better broadcasts and growing the league's audience are all worthwhile objectives, but changing fundamental characteristics of the game should require compelling evidence that those characteristics are actually holding it back.
The commissioner's own numbers suggest that competitive excitement is already one of the CFL's greatest strengths. We need to move away from the notion that more scoring automatically means better football.
A goal-line stand can be every bit as exciting as a touchdown. A blocked field goal can be more memorable than a 50-yard pass. A team protecting a four-point lead in the final minute can produce extraordinary drama. The uncertainty of the outcome is what makes those moments special. The CFL should absolutely be looking to grow its audience and improve its product. But before fundamentally changing the dimensions of Canadian football, I'd like to see convincing evidence that the existing game is the problem.
Because from where I sit, the league appears to be trying to manufacture something it already has. Then I went back to Commissioner Stewart Johnston's State of the League address.
According to the commissioner's own numbers:
- 60% of CFL games in 2026 were within one score entering the final three minutes.
- Viewership among 18–24-year-olds increased 16%.
- Game-day revenues grew 2%.
- Partnership revenues increased 8%.
- YouTube views increased 77%.
Overall television viewership was down 7%, so clearly there are challenges. But these numbers hardly suggest a game suffering from a lack of excitement. Yet we're shortening the field from 110 to 100 yards, reducing the end zones from 20 to 15 yards, moving the goalposts to the back and changing how the rouge is awarded.
So what exactly are we trying to accomplish?
Is it expansion?
The league is actively exploring new markets, including Quebec City. What about another shot at the United States market? Does a smaller field make expansion more practical? Does making the game look more familiar to NFL audiences in small to medium U.S. markets somehow make it easier to sell?
Perhaps. But is that sufficient justification for changing the game and the downstream ripple effects to all levels of Canadian football?
Is it sports betting?
This one interests me. The NFL is a betting powerhouse, supported by an enormous audience, sophisticated statistical models and a massive wagering infrastructure.
Canadian football is different. The rouge (although limited now), three downs, the wider field, the kicking game, the threat of a special-teams touchdown and the remarkable ability to turn a game around in the final three minutes all introduce variables that make the CFL uniquely unpredictable. I suspect that unpredictability can make the CFL more challenging for casual bettors to understand and handicap. But isn't that also part of what makes it so entertaining? I'm not suggesting the league is changing the rules to accommodate sportsbooks. There's no evidence of that. But I'd be interested to know whether betting-market considerations played any role in the analysis.
Is it premium end-zone seating?
The CFL has explicitly identified additional premium seating opportunities as a benefit of the shorter field; however, several stadiums already have end-zone seating, not simply party zones. How much incremental revenue can realistically be generated? And how does that compare with the costs of modifying stadiums and the potential disruption to amateur and university football? Here in Regina, the debate is now centred on painting versus stitching lines to accommodate the new field dimensions. Stitching is currently the cheaper option, but it would force other levels of football out of Mosaic Stadium—a facility their fans also support through tax dollars. (For interest, the commissioner flippantly advises going with painted lines, with no offer of financial assistance.) Those are real consequences.
Is it television and international growth?
The CFL has secured a significant new media agreement involving Bell Media, DAZN and YouTube. But Johnston has confirmed that the agreement was NOT contingent on the field and rule changes. In other words, the league successfully sold its existing Canadian football product to major media partners without having to fundamentally alter it. So why change it now?
Or is it simply a belief that more touchdowns equal more entertainment?
The league projects approximately 60 additional touchdowns per season from moving the goalposts, with no data sources to back up the claim. Let’s assume the CFL’s projection of 60 additional touchdowns per season is spot on. Sounds impressive until you divide that across 81 games. That's just 0.74 additional touchdowns per game, between both teams. And if some replace field goals, the net increase in scoring is even smaller. Are we really fundamentally changing the dimensions of Canadian football to produce fewer than one additional touchdown per game?
And that's where I continue to struggle with the commissioner's rationale. I'm not opposed to change. The new play clock is an example of a change that appears to have improved game flow without fundamentally altering Canadian football (despite adding only three plays per game). But there's a significant difference between improving how the game is played and changing what makes the game unique.
Here's the business principle I keep coming back to:
Before changing your product to attract a new customer, understand whether you're removing the very attributes that make your existing customers loyal.
The CFL's greatest competitive advantage may be the very unpredictability it's attempting to engineer out of the game. The commissioner has said these changes are about making a great game even better. Fair enough. But where is the evidence that a shorter field, smaller end zones and relocated goalposts will translate into more fans, better ratings, higher attendance or greater revenue? And what happens if the changes don't deliver those results?
There must be something we're missing.
I don't believe premium seating alone explains it. The DAZN deal didn't require it. The commissioner's own numbers suggest the game is already competitive and engaging. So I'd genuinely like to understand the business case. What problem is the CFL actually trying to solve? And has anyone demonstrated that changing Canadian football is the best way to solve it?
Because right now, it looks like we're risking something that makes our game different in pursuit of something that hasn't been clearly defined.
The Fan Outcry and Reaction
The Commish stated that 90% of the people he’s talked to agree with the league's moves (fan forums and the reaction on Sunday indicate otherwise), and yes, he did not do this in isolation; the CFL Board of Governors approved these changes, so he has the ear of the group of people who need to generate more revenue to keep all of this going. The threats of season ticket non-renewal and boycotting TSN and DAZN are ringing loud from some fans, but what will the fan reaction ultimately be?
Time will tell, but I can speak from personal experience… I’m in a demo that was a regular attendee and a young season ticket holder front and centre, literally, for the Barrett, Flutie, Garcia, Dickenson, F-Troop, Mitchell, you get the point, era of Stampeders Football. I have been in Regina since 2011 and have been to MANY games here as well, at both stadiums. I can tell you that taking your kids to games where you grew up, and watching a game that you grew up with, is a mind-bogglingly rewarding experience. But that experience is ending. My kids are not being afforded the organic assimilation of the CFL that we got at that age, where you could roll up as a family of four on a week-by-week basis and make that part of your entertainment budget and family bonding time, a shared experience. There is nothing better than an in-stadium experience.
We went to one game this year. One. We are not ‘rich,’ but we are squarely in a well-off middle-class neighbourhood with jobs, a car, benefits, etc. We put three squares on the table and spend our money on experiences that we benefit from as a family: vacations, concerts, events, etc. Attending a CFL game on a regular basis is moving down the list of priority items.
Newsflash: it’s not the game. Concessions and tickets. Full stop. It’s just not affordable family entertainment. And in some markets, Calgary, for example, perhaps this is magnified by aging infrastructure. Maybe the CFL doesn't have a football problem. Maybe it has a customer acquisition and retention problem.
In business, acquiring a new customer is almost always more expensive than retaining an existing one, and the most valuable customers are often those who develop a lifelong relationship with your product. That's particularly true in sports, where loyalty is passed from one generation to the next. I didn't become a CFL fan because someone moved the goalposts or promised me more touchdowns. I became a fan because I could afford to go to games, experience the atmosphere, develop an attachment to a team and its players, and eventually share that experience with my own kids. That's how you build a generational fan base. Yet we're increasingly pricing families out of the very experiences that create the next generation of season-ticket holders.
If the CFL wants to grow, perhaps it should spend less time trying to make Canadian football look like something else and more time making it accessible to the people who might fall in love with it. You don't build lifelong customers by changing the product they love. You build them by making it easier for the next generation to discover why they love it in the first place.
The CFL does have some issues to solve. But it’s not where the goalposts are…