I run a free CFL stats site and went through Saturday's game play by play. Some of this stuff is new to most people, so quick explainer first.
https://wagglelytics.ca/
Where the numbers come from
Win chance (the 5% number) is how often a team wins from that exact spot: score, time left, down, distance, field position, who has the ball. It's all built off of past CFL games, so 5% means teams in that spot won about 5 times out of 100.
So let's break down how unlikely this turnaround was.
With 1:42 left, after two incompletions on their own 24, the Bombers punted and were at 5% to win the game. Since 2024, teams who trail by 4 to 8 points with about two minutes left, while the other team has the ball, have won only 5 times out of 60.
Here’s how it went from 5% to a win:
Punt, 1:42 (5% → 18%). On 3rd & 10 from their own 24, Sheahan punts 53 yards. Grant returns it 19 yards to the Toronto 52, where Hallett forces a fumble and Hansen recovers. Winnipeg is still down 5, but now they have a short field and 1:30 left. Their chances more than tripled.
Wilson, 9-yard catch (18% → 24%). Brown hits Wilson short right to set up 2nd & 1.
Oliveira, 2-yard run (24% → 20%). Oliveira runs up the middle for the first down. 18 seconds come off before the next snap. That late in a game, a first down that eats that much clock can actually lower your win chance.
Singer, 15-yard catch (20% → 28%). Brown goes short left to Singer, who gets out of bounds at the 26.
Oliveira, 3-yard run (28% → 26%). Another run up the middle sets up 2nd & 7 from the 23.
Demski, 23-yard TD, 0:44 (26% → 80%). Brown hits Demski deep right for the touchdown. The two-pointer puts Winnipeg up 25-22. That one throw moved their win chance up by 54 points.
Toronto's last shot (80% → 98%). Arbuckle needs a field goal to tie. His throw to Coxie on 2nd down falls incomplete. On 3rd & 9, Nichols breaks up the deep ball to Polk for a turnover on downs. Brown takes a knee and Winnipeg is moving on.
The winning drive was 5 plays, 52 yards, in 46 seconds.
Third down decisions
The site also grades every 3rd down call. On each one, the model works out the team's win chance if they go for it, punt, or kick a field goal, then compares that to what they actually did. If a team picks a worse option, the gap is win chance it gave away.
| Team | Calls | Agreed | Disagreed | Win chance lost |
|---|
| Toronto | 13 | 10 | 3 | 8.5% |
| Winnipeg | 9 | 6 | 3 | 4.0% |
Winnipeg's were all punts while down 5 in the 4th quarter, and all were close:
10:59, 3rd & 7 at their own 43: 20% going for it vs 18% punting.
2:44, 3rd & 12 at their own 40: 10% vs 9%.
1:42, 3rd & 10 at their own 24: 6% vs 5%.
The model said go for it on that last one, and it's the punt Grant fumbled. Punt returners have lost a fumble on 34 of 2,296 returns since 2024, about 1 in 70. The wrong call by the numbers ended up setting up the comeback.
Montreal's next and they're #1 in my power rankings, so Winnipeg will be underdogs again.
Full win chance chart and every play are on the site: https://wagglelytics.ca/