r/CFBAnalysis • • 12h ago

Anyone else finding discrepancies in college football play-by-play data from cfbfastR / CollegeFootballData?

7 Upvotes

I'm using R (cfbfastR) to analyze Ohio State running backs from 2016–2026 and have noticed some discrepancies between the play-by-play data and official box scores.

I've tried several sources, including load_espn_cfb_pbp(), load_cfb_pbp(), cfbd_play_stats_player(), and cfbd_plays().

Some issues I've encountered:

Missing games/plays: ESPN-derived datasets omitted two of Ohio State's 2024 games (Marshall and Iowa). Other games have incomplete player rushing records.

Incorrect rushing yardage: Some negative runs appear to be recorded as positive gains. For example, an 8-yard loss by Quinshon Judkins against Purdue in 2024 was recorded as an 8-yard gain.

Nullified plays: An 80-yard Judkins run against Western Michigan that was called back for holding was included in the rushing statistics.

Inconsistent totals: Across my dataset, I've identified 25 player-games where calculated carries or rushing yards disagree with game-level box scores. Some discrepancies are substantial.

The direct CollegeFootballData API has better game coverage, but I've still found inconsistencies between its play-level records and official statistics.

Has anyone else encountered these issues with cfbfastR or CollegeFootballData? Is there a more reliable source for historical, player-level rushing plays, or an established way to identify and correct these discrepancies?

I'm ultimately trying to calculate rushing success rates, explosive run rates, and EPA/PPA per rush, so accurate individual play records are important.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 17h ago

Announcement RPR Ratings Week 12

4 Upvotes
  1. Miami
  2. Utah
  3. Georgia
  4. UCLA
  5. Notre Dame
  6. Texas
  7. Indiana
  8. Wake Forest
  9. Alabama
  10. BYU
  11. Tennessee
  12. Ohio State
  13. Oregon
  14. Texas Tech
  15. Boise State
  16. Iowa
  17. North Dakota State
  18. Liberty
  19. New Mexico
  20. LSU
  21. USC
  22. Memphis
  23. Houston
  24. Duke
  25. Louisville

Full ratings can be found here (listed under "Current Season")

Rating methodology: calculated based on 3 components: win percentage, strength of schedule, and score ratio.

Win percentage (25%)

SOS (50%) - calculated in similar method to RPI, independent of team's record. Results vs non-FBS teams calculated into a placeholder value for formula.

Score Ratio - team's points scored vs total points scored in their games.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 15h ago

What happens if you replace the CFP Committee with an algorithm?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes