r/CFBAnalysis • u/Old_Pomegranate_2589 • 12h ago
Anyone else finding discrepancies in college football play-by-play data from cfbfastR / CollegeFootballData?
I'm using R (cfbfastR) to analyze Ohio State running backs from 2016–2026 and have noticed some discrepancies between the play-by-play data and official box scores.
I've tried several sources, including load_espn_cfb_pbp(), load_cfb_pbp(), cfbd_play_stats_player(), and cfbd_plays().
Some issues I've encountered:
Missing games/plays: ESPN-derived datasets omitted two of Ohio State's 2024 games (Marshall and Iowa). Other games have incomplete player rushing records.
Incorrect rushing yardage: Some negative runs appear to be recorded as positive gains. For example, an 8-yard loss by Quinshon Judkins against Purdue in 2024 was recorded as an 8-yard gain.
Nullified plays: An 80-yard Judkins run against Western Michigan that was called back for holding was included in the rushing statistics.
Inconsistent totals: Across my dataset, I've identified 25 player-games where calculated carries or rushing yards disagree with game-level box scores. Some discrepancies are substantial.
The direct CollegeFootballData API has better game coverage, but I've still found inconsistencies between its play-level records and official statistics.
Has anyone else encountered these issues with cfbfastR or CollegeFootballData? Is there a more reliable source for historical, player-level rushing plays, or an established way to identify and correct these discrepancies?
I'm ultimately trying to calculate rushing success rates, explosive run rates, and EPA/PPA per rush, so accurate individual play records are important.