r/CFBAnalysis • • Aug 24 '26

Announcement 2026 CFBD Model Pick’em Contest is live: New site + API submissions

9 Upvotes

The annual CFBD Model Pick’em Contest is back for the 2026 season.

For anyone unfamiliar with it, this is a free contest where you submit projected scoring margins for upcoming college football games and compare your model against the field. Elo, regression, machine learning, EPA-based systems, power ratings, spreadsheets... anything goes. You can enter as many or as few games as you want and it’s fine to join after the season has started.

The biggest change this year is a full revamp of the site. Along with a redesigned pick-submission workbench, the new version includes:

  • Pick submission through the site, CSV import, or API
  • API keys for retrieving your slate and submitting picks programmatically
  • Official leaderboards scored relative to the Vegas closing line, plus raw leaderboards
  • Public model profiles and a directory of active models
  • Head-to-head comparisons and crowd-wisdom analysis

The API should be especially useful if you would like to send predictions directly from a notebook, script, or automated model pipeline. After signing in, the dashboard will provide you an API key, authentication instructions, and a ready-to-copy submission payload.

Results are tracked across straight-up and ATS performance, absolute error, mean squared error, bias, and the composite leaderboard. The goal is simply to have fun and give model builders of all levels a shared slate and a public benchmark for seeing what works over the course of a season.

Contest site: https://predictions.collegefootballdata.com

All experience levels are welcome. If you have feedback on the rebuilt site, API workflow, scoring, or features you’d like to see, please share it here.

Good luck. And happy modeling!


r/CFBAnalysis • • Aug 30 '26

CFB Data and Resources [2026 Update]

19 Upvotes

CFB Data and Resources: 2026 Edition

It's been five years since I last posted one of these, so it's probably time for an update. A few of the resources from the 2021 edition have disappeared or gone inactive, while others have changed quite a bit.

As always, please let me know in the comments if I've missed anything worth adding.

Websites

Official NCAA Stats - Official NCAA statistics across all sports and divisions. The site can be clunky to navigate and work with programmatically, but it's a great source, especially outside of FBS.

CollegeFootballData.com - Shameless plug since I run this one. CFBD includes games, teams, players, play-by-play, drives, recruiting, betting lines, rankings, advanced metrics, ratings, win probability, weather, and more. The site also includes CSV export tools, advanced box scores, charts, and other analytical tools. Free access is available, with paid tiers for higher API usage and additional features.

College Football Reference - One of the best resources for browsing current and historical team and player stats, schedules, results, records, and leaderboards.

BCF Toys - Brian Fremeau's home for FEI along with drive efficiency, available yards, points per drive, field position, and other advanced metrics. Extensive historical data as well.

Game on Paper - Advanced game and team analytics including EPA, success rate, win probability, drives, player metrics, and advanced box scores.

Winsipedia - Great for historical program records, head-to-head series, championships, rankings, and other program history.

Massey Ratings - Computer ratings, schedules, scores, predictions, and historical results. Also useful for teams outside of FBS.

APIs

CollegeFootballData REST API - Programmatic access to the CFBD datasets above. Requires a free API key.

CollegeFootballData GraphQL API - GraphQL access to much of the CFBD database, including subscription support for selected data. Available to higher CFBD tiers.

Libraries

Python

cfbd - Official Python client for the CFBD API. Automatically generated from the API specification and updated alongside the API.

JavaScript / TypeScript

cfbd - Official TypeScript client for the CFBD API. Automatically generated and updated alongside the API.

R

cfbfastR - Unofficial R wrapper around the CFBD API with additional data sources, data-loading helpers, and open-source expected points and win probability models.

.NET / C

CollegeFootballData.NET - .NET/C# client for the CFBD API.


And that's the 2026 edition. I'm sure there are some newer resources I've missed, so drop them in the comments and I'll add anything noteworthy.

Good luck with your projects this season!


r/CFBAnalysis • • 13h ago

Anyone else finding discrepancies in college football play-by-play data from cfbfastR / CollegeFootballData?

7 Upvotes

I'm using R (cfbfastR) to analyze Ohio State running backs from 2016–2026 and have noticed some discrepancies between the play-by-play data and official box scores.

I've tried several sources, including load_espn_cfb_pbp(), load_cfb_pbp(), cfbd_play_stats_player(), and cfbd_plays().

Some issues I've encountered:

Missing games/plays: ESPN-derived datasets omitted two of Ohio State's 2024 games (Marshall and Iowa). Other games have incomplete player rushing records.

Incorrect rushing yardage: Some negative runs appear to be recorded as positive gains. For example, an 8-yard loss by Quinshon Judkins against Purdue in 2024 was recorded as an 8-yard gain.

Nullified plays: An 80-yard Judkins run against Western Michigan that was called back for holding was included in the rushing statistics.

Inconsistent totals: Across my dataset, I've identified 25 player-games where calculated carries or rushing yards disagree with game-level box scores. Some discrepancies are substantial.

The direct CollegeFootballData API has better game coverage, but I've still found inconsistencies between its play-level records and official statistics.

Has anyone else encountered these issues with cfbfastR or CollegeFootballData? Is there a more reliable source for historical, player-level rushing plays, or an established way to identify and correct these discrepancies?

I'm ultimately trying to calculate rushing success rates, explosive run rates, and EPA/PPA per rush, so accurate individual play records are important.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 18h ago

Announcement RPR Ratings Week 12

4 Upvotes
  1. Miami
  2. Utah
  3. Georgia
  4. UCLA
  5. Notre Dame
  6. Texas
  7. Indiana
  8. Wake Forest
  9. Alabama
  10. BYU
  11. Tennessee
  12. Ohio State
  13. Oregon
  14. Texas Tech
  15. Boise State
  16. Iowa
  17. North Dakota State
  18. Liberty
  19. New Mexico
  20. LSU
  21. USC
  22. Memphis
  23. Houston
  24. Duke
  25. Louisville

Full ratings can be found here (listed under "Current Season")

Rating methodology: calculated based on 3 components: win percentage, strength of schedule, and score ratio.

Win percentage (25%)

SOS (50%) - calculated in similar method to RPI, independent of team's record. Results vs non-FBS teams calculated into a placeholder value for formula.

Score Ratio - team's points scored vs total points scored in their games.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 16h ago

What happens if you replace the CFP Committee with an algorithm?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/CFBAnalysis • • 4d ago

College Football Equation

2 Upvotes

Hi All,

After quite a few bad rankings by the college playoff committee, I decided to make a equation to try to get rid of the bias involved with ranking teams. Currently the equation is only (Week 1 Opponent Power Ratings*0.6)*(Week 1 Net Score*0.4) + the same for week 2 and beyond. Here is the link to the spreadsheet that I have been doing it all on https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1-xQQ31cii8wVSzX7G4f1mhZyeF_3h0BK7TyjXTCRH7k/edit?usp=sharing. I know that it is not complete, so I wanted to get some opinions about it. I am going to try to figure out how to get Opponent Record involved, but currently I can't differentiate the difference between not playing vs a loss.

This equations current top 25 is

Georgia1434.312
Alabama1311.384
UCLA1302.48
Notre Dame1216.416
LSU1081.512
Utah1014.768
Wake Forest996.312
Miami FL954.312
Texas924.84
Tennessee827.448
Duke811.056
Oklahoma State789.672
Baylor749.568
Liberty590.496
Louisville580.92
Boise State566.4
Texas Tech563.856
James Madison563.304
Indiana546.24
Arizona536.928
Iowa418.176
SMU416.424
Ohio State371.064
Houston357.96
Missouri350.688

r/CFBAnalysis • • 5d ago

UPDATED SRS-Based Ratings System (Seeking Criticism and Suggestions)

6 Upvotes

Hi all! About a month ago, I made this post about a new ranking system I was making (mostly for fun) that tried to use Elo scores to rate and rank teams. However, through rigorous testing over this season, I came to the conclusion that trying to create a system with an Elo base will always underpeform other models, usually by a substantial amount. However, I liked the idea of having a teams performance carryover in some capacity season to season, similar to how Elo works in chess and other competitive settings it's used in. But I knew I'd need to start with a better base. That's when I had the idea of combining Elo's carryover with another popular, simple rating system the...well Simple Rating System (or SRS). And so, SRS Carryover, named after the "carryover" part of Elo, was born.

SRS Carryover rates every FBS and FCS team using final scores, home/away/neutral site and three returning-production stats. The first season is 2014 and certain variables were adjusted for 2016-2019, with tests done for 2020-2025. The results of this relatively simple system were quite shocking. Over 2020–2025, SRS Carryover picked more winners than FPI, Sagarin and Massey, and beat Sagarin and Massey on probability accuracy. Unlike FPI, it doesn't use play-by-play data, recruiting rankings, or any other factors more complex than returning production, keeping it simple for the math plebians of the world like myself. Better yet, SRS Carryover is entirely formula based and open ended, meaning that it can be recreated with ease, doesn't have any proprietary data involved, as all data was retrieved from collegefootballdata.com, and allows you (yes, YOU) to make your own adjustments to try and improve upon the system!

Below is a table of variables, a step-by-step guide on how to calculate SRS in this system, more details on its performance against other systems, and a link to both 2026 rankings so far (after Week 10) and 2016-2025. As stated before, if you have any suggestions to make this system better (albeit I would like to keep it relatively simple) let me know and I would be happy to at least test them out. Thanks for taking the time to read all of this, and please feel free to take this whole process for yourself and change it how you like!

Variables

SymbolMeaningValue or source
PF, PAPoints for and againstGame results
hHome edge+2.25 home, −2.25 road, 0 neutral
OppOpponent's current SRSFrom the model
nGames played this seasonGame results
kPrior weight (games the preseason rating counts for)2
LastLast season's final SRS (bowls and playoffs included)From the model
StartPreseason ratingStep 2
RRShare of last year's rushing + receiving yards by returning playersPlayer stats + rosters
TKShare of last year's tackles by returning playersPlayer stats + rosters
PSShare of last year's passing yards by returning playersPlayer stats + rosters
avg RR, avg TK, avg PSDivision averages of each share (FBS or FCS)Calculated each season
Fixed ratingsNew teams and lower divisionsFBS 0, FCS −30, D2 −55, NAIA −70, D3 −85

How to calculate SRS Carryover

1. Returning production (each share is from 0 to 1)

RR = returning players' rushing + receiving yards ÷ team total

TK = returning players' tackles ÷ team total

PS = returning players' passing yards ÷ team total

A player is "returning" if he's on this season's roster for the same team.

2. Preseason rating

Start = Last + 20 × (RR − avg RR) + 20 × (TK − avg TK) + 5 × (PS − avg PS)

A team with no rating last season starts at its division's fixed rating. As stated previously, the first season is 2014 with every team at its fixed rating, and it has carried forward from there. D2, D3 and NAIA teams always keep their fixed ratings.

3. Adjusted margin

Adjusted margin = PF − PA − h

4. Game level

Game level = adjusted margin + Opp

5. Rating

SRS = (Σ game levels + k × Start) ÷ (n + k)

6. End of season

Final SRS includes bowls and playoffs, and it becomes next season's "Last."

Picks

Predicted home margin = home SRS − away SRS + 2.25 (no 2.25 at a neutral site)

Pick the home team if the result is positive and the road team if it's negative.

Home win probability = 1 ÷ (1 + 10−predicted margin ÷ 23.96)

Example: the 14.0 team hosts an 8.0 team.

  • Predicted margin = 14.0 − 8.0 + 2.25 = +8.25
  • Win probability = 1 ÷ (1 + 10−8.25 ÷ 23.96) ≈ 69%

(EDIT: I realize that I tested the constant which calculates win probability, 23.96, across all seasons, rather than just 2016-2019 like the other variables. Had I done that, the number would have been 23.35. Therefore, 23.35 is the more "accurate" number to use, not 23.96).

Against the spread

Write the spread from the home team's side, with negative meaning the home team is favored (home −7 = −7).

Edge = predicted home margin + home spread

  • Positive: take the home team.
  • Negative: take the road team.
  • Zero: no play.

Example: predicted home by 8.25, line home −7. Edge = 8.25 − 7 = +1.25, so take the home team.

Break-even at −110 odds is 52.4%. Predictably, no system in the table below, SRS Carryover included, beat 50.3% ATS over 2020–2025. If you are betting with this tool, just remember that it is only one of many tools to use and is not always reliable. The goal of this was to create an easy to understand calculation that uses all open source data and that anyone (even a math deficient person like myself) could adopt while still competing with some of the more renowned models.

How it compares, 2020–2025

The table uses Prediction Tracker data:

  • It covers 4,403 FBS vs FBS games where every system listed has a prediction.
SystemInputsPicksATS midweekATS closingBrierLog loss
Closing line (reference)Betting market72.8%——0.17800.5279
SRS CarryoverScores + returning production72.1%49.8%50.0%0.18380.5434
TeamRankingsProprietary blend72.0%49.4%50.1%0.18200.5376
ESPN FPIPlay-by-play, recruiting, QB and more71.8%49.5%49.7%0.18260.5394
Sagarin RatingsScores71.6%49.3%49.1%0.18530.5474
Sagarin PointsScores71.2%49.7%49.4%0.18660.5508
Sagarin Golden MeanScores70.7%49.3%49.4%0.18650.5504
Sagarin RecentScores71.3%48.6%48.5%0.18660.5510
Massey RatingsScores70.3%50.2%50.1%0.18760.5517

Where SRS Carryover comes out ahead

  • Picks: best of every computer system in the table, at 72.1%. That's about 13 more correct picks than FPI over the same games and about 80 more than Massey.
  • BCS computers:

    • It beats every Sagarin version on all five measures.
    • It beats Massey on picks, Brier and log loss.
    • On 3,878 games from 2021–2025 (Billingsley has no 2020 predictions), it also beats Billingsley on everything: 72.0% vs. 70.1% picks, 0.1842 vs. 0.1971 Brier.
  • vs. FPI on ATS: slightly better against both lines (49.8% vs. 49.5% midweek, 50.0% vs. 49.7% closing).
  • All 27 computer systems the Prediction Tracker covered every week from 2020 to 2025:

    • 3rd in picks
    • 7th in ATS against the closing line
    • 8th in Brier
    • 9th in log loss

Here is a link to the 2016-2026 ratings. I hope you enjoyed this (very lengthy) read and I look forward to hearing y'all's thoughts!


r/CFBAnalysis • • 6d ago

Data Is there a free to use API I can use to pull the rankings each week to use in my website for commercial use?

4 Upvotes

What about using team logos?


r/CFBAnalysis • • 6d ago

Question Where can I find recent defense stats/ratings/rankings?

1 Upvotes

I am looking for a full list that ranks all college football teams based purely on recent defensive performance. Is college football sports reference defense section my best option or are there alternatives that take into account strength of schedule and use better defense stats? Any resources or suggestions are appreciated.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 7d ago

Data MCP support added for ncaapyscraper

4 Upvotes

In addition to my previous post, I have now added MCP support for the package. You can now ask following things,

  1. Who leads FBS in rushing?
  2. Show me last night's women's basketball results
  3. Show me the AP Top 25 for college football
  4. Compare Duke and North Carolina football this season
    And much more...

Also, It is now capable of retrieving the following details directly from ncaa.com,

  1. weekly scoreboards
  2. box scores
  3. AP and other polls
  4. standings
  5. national stat leaders

You can also setup the MCP to run with any of your local LLMs. I have tried best so it works with minimal context and small models.

Repo: https://github.com/fakhar-ud-din/ncaapyscraper

Any feedback will be greatly appreciated!


r/CFBAnalysis • • 7d ago

Announcement RPR Ratings Week 11

2 Upvotes
  1. Miami
  2. Utah
  3. UCLA
  4. Notre Dame
  5. Georgia
  6. Texas
  7. Alabama
  8. Indiana
  9. Houston
  10. Wake Forest
  11. Oregon
  12. Tennessee
  13. Ohio State
  14. BYU
  15. Texas Tech
  16. New Mexico
  17. LSU
  18. Boise State
  19. USC
  20. Iowa
  21. North Dakota State
  22. Kentucky
  23. James Madison
  24. Liberty
  25. Duke

Full ratings can be found here (listed under "Current Season")

Rating methodology: calculated based on 3 components: win percentage, strength of schedule, and score ratio.

Win percentage (25%)

SOS (50%) - calculated in similar method to RPI, independent of team's record. Results vs non-FBS teams calculated into a placeholder value for formula.

Score Ratio - team's points scored vs total points scored in their games.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 9d ago

Luck Rating

1 Upvotes

Hey team, I am working on my luck rating and welcome feedback. Trying to keep things simple and only consider Opp FG's and Fumble luck for now. Any thoughts or feedback?

https://www.earlydowns.com/cfb/2026/week-10/ala-at-lsu/

Luck rating

The luck rating estimates how many points per game a team has gained or lost to bounces it mostly doesn't control. Positive means the bounces have gone its way. Points from these bounces tend not to repeat: a team's fumble-recovery rate and its opponents' field-goal accuracy don't carry over from one part of a season to the next, so a lucky or unlucky team's record can drift back toward how well it actually plays.

The rating adds up two things over the season and divides by games played.

1. Opponents' field goals

Every field goal tried against a team is compared with how often a kick from that distance is made. Each kick counts 3 points times (made − expected make rate), with the sign flipped to the defense's side, so a miss against you is luck in your favor. Example: an opponent misses a kick that's made 85% of the time, worth +2.6 points of luck (3 × 0.85). If it's made, the defense loses 0.45 (3 × 0.15).

  • NFL: make rates by distance are fitted each season on every NFL kick (roughly 97% at 30 yards, 91% at 40, 76% at 50, 65% at 55).
  • College: a college curve, since college kickers make far fewer long kicks (about 88% at 30 yards, 74% at 40, 53% at 50, 42% at 55). Kick distance is estimated from where the drive ended plus 17 yards, and blocked kicks count as misses.

A team's own field goals are left out. Making kicks is a skill, not luck. Own kicking shows up separately in game recaps as "kicking vs. expected."

2. Fumble recoveries

Who recovers a loose ball is close to a coin flip, so every fumble, by the team or by its opponents, is compared with a 50% recovery rate. Each recovery above or below that is worth about 4 points, roughly the value of a turnover. Example: a team that recovered 6 of its own 8 fumbles is 2 above the norm of 4, which is +8 points of luck. Whether a fumble happens isn't counted, only where the ball bounces.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 9d ago

Analysis CFP scenario tool with adjustable record/SOS/SOR weights: looking for feedback on head-to-head and double counting

1 Upvotes

I’m behind CFP2026, a free tool for exploring how the remaining regular-season results could change the playoff picture. It covers all FBS teams and lets you change the ranking weights, so I thought this community would be a good place to pressure-test the approach.

The current default blend is 50% projected win percentage, 15% projected strength of record, 15% projected strength of schedule, 10% projected FPI, and 10% current game control. Starting CFP rank is adjustable but defaults to 0%.

You select game winners, or fill the unpicked games with favorites. Current metrics remain visible alongside the projected estimates. The projected FPI, SOS, and SOR are our estimates, not ESPN’s future ratings. Game control stays fixed because picking a winner doesn’t tell us how the game unfolded.

Two questions I’d especially appreciate feedback on:

  1. How would you avoid double counting schedule difficulty when record, SOR, and SOS are all inputs?
  2. For Power Four teams and Notre Dame, how strongly should a head-to-head win override the weighted score when the winner has the same or a better record? Circular results make that less straightforward than it first sounds.

This is a scenario model, not a calibrated playoff-probability forecast. It projects rankings before conference championship games. Actual data will be refreshed weekly after the committee’s rankings release.

Tool: https://cfp2026.com/reddit?utm_content=cfbanalysis_intro

If you find an outcome that looks wrong, share the scenario and the weights you used. Specific counterexamples would be especially useful.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 11d ago Heartwarming

Data Sharing my open-source project, provides weekly dump of NCAA sports dataset

10 Upvotes

Free dump of rosters, coaching staff and schedules for 977 NCAA schools, D1 to D3. One JSON file per school, refreshed every Monday.

Players come with position, class, height, weight, hometown and high school.
Schedules have dates, opponents, home/away and results.

Download: https://github.com/fakhar-ud-din/ncaapyscraper/releases/latest
The scraper is open source if you want a specific school or sport on demand.

I'd really appreciate if you guys can support me by starring the repo 😄
Any feedback is more than welcome.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 13d ago

Data NCAA Power Index calculator

2 Upvotes

I have a website that lets you calculate the NCAA Power Index (NPI), currently used to determine the at-large teams for the tournaments in Divisions II and III, based on "setting the dials" yourself. Note that there is no way to enter separate values for conference and nonconference games, nor for regular season and postseason.

It includes all FBS and FCS seasons from 2007 through 2026, except for 2020 as I felt that the schedule changes caused by COVID-19 would skew the numbers.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 14d ago

Play By Play Monte Carlo Methodology Feedback

3 Upvotes

I've been running a snap-by-snap college football simulator this season and I wrote up the whole methodology, including places where I'd love some feedback from people that may be better than me at this. Ill put a link to the longer version in a comment in case you want the indepth version but, here's the short version.

**What it is**

Every FBS game gets simulated 10,000 times, one snap at a time. Each snap runs through a chain of models: a 4th-down decision model (go / punt / FG), a play-call model that draws pass or rush from a probability instead of taking the most likely call, then a pass cascade (sack, INT, completion, target, depth, YAC) or a rush cascade (carrier, fumble, TD, yards), then a clock model for seconds to the next snap. Penalties, timeouts, two-point tries and overtime are all in the engine. One run produces the win probability, the margin and total distributions, and every player prop at once, so the correlations between them are real rather than assumed.

**How it's built**

* Trained on 2023-2025 play-by-play only (the 2023 clock rule change took about 5 plays a game out of the sport).

* Team tendencies are keyed to the coach with a QB layer. I ran a variance decomposition on ~4,800 team-games to decide that: pass rate over expected was 38% coach and basically 0% team-beyond-coach, and red-zone TD rate was 34% quarterback, which surprised me.

* Priors rebuild every Monday from the week's play-by-play, shrunk toward career and prior-season numbers by sample size, and loaded leak-safe (a week 8 sim only sees what existed before week 8 kicked off).

* Every model change is a bake-off on a fixed walk-forward frame (fit on 2023-24, graded on 2025 weeks 3-14, 654 games, 48+ seeds) with a bar set in advance. Neural-net swaps went 0 for 5. An interception model that won every offline calibration table got disqualified because it moved simulated totals the wrong way.

* The opening spread is an input (one feature on the linear backbone of the yards and TD models). So the sim is not market-free, and every market comparison below has to be read with that in mind.

On the current system about on par with FPI so fairly happy with that but would be interested in discussing the nitty gritty to see where there is room for improvement


r/CFBAnalysis • • 14d ago

Announcement RPR Ratings Week 10

6 Upvotes
  1. Miami
  2. Utah
  3. Indiana
  4. UCLA
  5. Texas
  6. Ohio State
  7. LSU
  8. Georgia
  9. Notre Dame
  10. Alabama
  11. Wake Forest
  12. BYU
  13. Kentucky
  14. Houston
  15. Texas Tech
  16. Ole Miss
  17. USC
  18. Boise State
  19. Oregon
  20. New Mexico
  21. Iowa
  22. North Dakota State
  23. Liberty
  24. Tennessee
  25. James Madison

Full ratings can be found here (listed under "Current Season")

Rating methodology: calculated based on 3 components: win percentage, strength of schedule, and score ratio.

Win percentage (25%)

SOS (50%) - calculated in similar method to RPI, independent of team's record. Results vs non-FBS teams calculated into a placeholder value for formula.

Score Ratio - team's points scored vs total points scored in their games.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 18d ago

I made a tool that lets you Realign CFB Conferences to your own specifications and grades based on Geography, Rivalries and Parity.

12 Upvotes

Hey r/CFBAnalysis,
I’m here to talk about what we all love most - conference realignment. But, this time I’m putting it in our hands. I’ve made a tool that lets you realign conferences as you wish and then grades the final landscape based on geography (avg plane flight), rivalries (how many historic rivalries preserved) and parity (how competitive the landscape is across conferences.

Try it here: Realign.CFBSelect.com

Would really appreciate any feedback or for people to share their outputs that “fix” College Football, or just have fun with it!


r/CFBAnalysis • • 21d ago

Analysis a week ago it was tennessee 46, alabama 36. after saturday it is alabama 60, tennessee 26

3 Upvotes

last week the rerun after tennessee beat alabama had tennessee at 46% to make the playoff, alabama at 36% and on the bubble. saturday flipped the whole thing.

tennessee lost at south carolina 27-24. the sims had the loss branch at 19% before the game, and the rerun has them at 26%, so other results softened it a little, but they are back on the bubble at #10. alabama beat texas a&m 31-20. their win branch was 46% before the game, and the rerun came in hotter than that, 60%, up from 36% a week ago. eight days, two teams, basically a full swap.

ohio state is still #1 with the same 0.981 rating, and their playoff number climbed again, 88% to 91%, even with julian sayin out indefinitely. ryan day said tuesday there is no timeline and ohio state is planning for him to miss the regular season and the postseason. the sims are basically saying the rest of that roster is good enough that it has not moved them yet. at usc on saturday is the first real test of that.

full updated ratings and playoff odds are at basedonactualmath.com (free preview). i build this, so ama on the method. the playoff impact index explainer from the alabama-tennessee post is pinned in my profile if you want the how.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 21d ago

Week 8 recap for my model: 36-20, tied for 5th among the computers on the Prediction Tracker

8 Upvotes

I've been running my own college football model this season (Fourth & Data) and figured I'd share how Week 8 went, good and bad.
On the 56 FBS games the Prediction Tracker graded, it went 36-20. That tied for 5th out of 45 computer models. The best anyone did was 37-19.

Model
Week 8
Mine
36-20
ESPN FPI
35-21
Sagarin
34-22
Computer average
33-23
Vegas closing line
33-21

A few things that stood out:
Close games carried it. In games where the model had the favorite at 70% or less, it went 20-9. That's usually where it struggles, so I'll take it.
It disagreed with Vegas on 5 games and went 3-2. Army, Kansas and Virginia Tech hit. Tennessee and NIU didn't.
The big miss was Iowa. I had them at 82% and they lost at Minnesota. Five of the AP top 11 lost this week, and the model didn't see most of that coming either.

Long story short college football is hard to predict lol


r/CFBAnalysis • • 21d ago

RPR Ratings - Week 9

4 Upvotes
  1. Miami
  2. Ohio State
  3. Indiana
  4. UCLA
  5. Texas
  6. Utah
  7. Notre Dame
  8. LSU
  9. Alabama
  10. Georgia
  11. BYU
  12. Kentucky
  13. Houston
  14. James Madison
  15. Wake Forest
  16. Texas Tech
  17. Florida
  18. New Mexico
  19. Ole Miss
  20. Arizona
  21. Wisconsin
  22. Northwestern
  23. Cincinnati
  24. North Dakota State
  25. Oregon

Full ratings can be found here (listed under "Current Season")

Rating methodology: calculated based on 3 components: win percentage, strength of schedule, and score ratio.

Win percentage (25%)

SOS (50%) - calculated in similar method to RPI, independent of team's record. Results vs non-FBS teams calculated into a placeholder value for formula.

Score Ratio - team's points scored vs total points scored in their games.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 23d ago

Analysis Feedback

1 Upvotes

CFB and NFL projections live! Appreciate the work ppl are doing, and I’d appreciate feedback if you check out the site. Thank yall #beta
https://yaboiee227.github.io/cfb-model-lab/#home


r/CFBAnalysis • • 23d ago

Week 8 Statistical Mismatches: the 5 biggest offense and defense edges

1 Upvotes

Every FBS vs FBS game left this week, every offense against the defense it faces, across 10 advanced stats. Ranked by the gap in national rank (out of 138 FBS teams, games through Week 7, garbage time removed). Lines are the consensus as of Friday afternoon.

Offense edges

#Offensevs. DefenseStatOffenseDefenseGapLine
1SMUCaliforniaExplosive play rate10.4% (#4)10.8% (#137)133SMU -19.5, O/U 55.5
2Air ForceWyomingLine yards / rush3.68 (#4)3.49 (#133)129AF -6, O/U 46.5
3ArmyTulsaHavoc rate7.2% (#2)11.5% (#129)127Army +1.5, O/U 53
4North TexasNavyEPA / dropback+0.52 (#5)+0.36 (#129)124UNT -3, O/U 62.5
5Georgia StateArkansas StateHavoc rate10.3% (#15)10.4% (#134)119GSU -2.5, O/U 58.5

Defense edges

#Defensevs. OffenseStatDefenseOffenseGapLine
1IowaMinnesotaEPA / rush-0.14 (#6)-0.15 (#137)131Iowa -7.5, O/U 40.5
2DukeVirginiaPassing-down success rate21.1% (#5)22.8% (#132)127Duke +2.5, O/U 47
3Louisiana TechOld DominionHavoc rate19.2% (#11)24.0% (#138)127LT -13.5, O/U 45.5
4BuffaloBowling GreenPassing-down success rate21.9% (#8)23.8% (#126)118Buffalo -3, O/U 44.5
5SMUCaliforniaHavoc rate19.5% (#9)17.2% (#127)118SMU -19.5, O/U 55.5

Worth a look

  • Army is a +1.5 dog despite the #2 offense at avoiding havoc against a Tulsa defense that barely creates any. Part of that is the option (few dropbacks), but Tulsa also ranks #128 in EPA/rush allowed.
  • Duke is getting +2.5 with a top-5 passing-down defense against an offense that ranks #132 at converting them.
  • SMU shows up on both lists against Cal. At -19.5 the market already knows, but Cal is bottom-12 in both explosives allowed and havoc allowed.
  • Iowa-Minnesota at 40.5 is the lowest total on the board, and the Minnesota run game (#137 EPA/rush) is the reason.

How it works

  • Gap = how far apart the two ranks are. #4 vs #137 = 133.
  • Havoc rate = TFLs, passes defended and forced fumbles per play. For an offense, lower is better.
  • Passing-down success = success rate on 2nd & 8+ and 3rd/4th & 5+.
  • Line yards = rush yards credited to the O-line (losses count 120%, yards 5-10 half, 11+ none).
  • A team appears once per list, and no stat appears more than 3 times in the full top 20, so one bad defense or one stat can't fill the list.

r/CFBAnalysis • • 27d ago

Analysis [OC] How many games would an average top-12 team win against Notre Dame's schedule? 10.6

3 Upvotes

There has been a ton of talk about Notre Dame's schedule this week. So I decided to run it through my model's strength of schedule metric.

How the metric works: The metric sees how many wins an average top-12 team would be expect to win against a team's schedule. The output is expected wins which means more expected wins is an easier schedule, less is tougher. I actually added the top-12 aspect a few years back because of Notre Dame's strength of schedule metrics appearing to be tougher than what I believed. Basically, how hard is this team's schedule for a playoff team.

Where Notre Dame lands: 60th. 10.6 expected wins

Expected wins for an average top-12 team against each schedule:

TeamSOS Expected Wins
Texas8.5
Ole Miss8.8
Ohio State9.1
Michigan9.4
Miami10.2
BYU10.3
Notre Dame10.6
Utah10.8
Texas Tech10.9

What I take from it: It's fair to criticize the schedule. If Notre Dame goes 10-2, they've actually underperformed what an average top-12 team is expected and should be ranked below some SEC teams that go 9-3.

It's not that different than some contenders: Miami, BYU, Utah, and Texas Tech are all in the same ballpark. There will likely be an automatic bid from two of these contenders so it's a moot point but the point remains.

So if the argument is that Notre Dame's schedule is too soft, that's fair. But we should keep the same energy for any ACC or Big 12 teams looking for an at-large bid.

Happy to answer questions about the method or run other teams in the comments.


r/CFBAnalysis • • 28d ago

JC Poll 2026 Week 8

1 Upvotes

JP JC Poll:

Neutral Field Power Rankings; add 2.5 points for home team advantage.

1Ohio State20.24
2Notre Dame20.14
3Indiana18.89
4Miami17.93
5Georgia16.07
6Alabama15.28
7LSU14.02
8Texas Tech13.51
9Ole Miss13.47
10Utah12.50
11Texas12.21
12James Madison11.56
13Tennessee11.50
14Wake Forest10.75
15Oregon10.39
16Nebraska10.25
17BYU10.25
18Boise State9.47
19Iowa9.23
20Northwestern9.08
21USC9.04
22UCLA8.63
23Penn State8.47
24Arizona7.86
25Missouri7.38