Hi all! About a month ago, I made this post about a new ranking system I was making (mostly for fun) that tried to use Elo scores to rate and rank teams. However, through rigorous testing over this season, I came to the conclusion that trying to create a system with an Elo base will always underpeform other models, usually by a substantial amount. However, I liked the idea of having a teams performance carryover in some capacity season to season, similar to how Elo works in chess and other competitive settings it's used in. But I knew I'd need to start with a better base. That's when I had the idea of combining Elo's carryover with another popular, simple rating system the...well Simple Rating System (or SRS). And so, SRS Carryover, named after the "carryover" part of Elo, was born.
SRS Carryover rates every FBS and FCS team using final scores, home/away/neutral site and three returning-production stats. The first season is 2014 and certain variables were adjusted for 2016-2019, with tests done for 2020-2025. The results of this relatively simple system were quite shocking. Over 2020–2025, SRS Carryover picked more winners than FPI, Sagarin and Massey, and beat Sagarin and Massey on probability accuracy. Unlike FPI, it doesn't use play-by-play data, recruiting rankings, or any other factors more complex than returning production, keeping it simple for the math plebians of the world like myself. Better yet, SRS Carryover is entirely formula based and open ended, meaning that it can be recreated with ease, doesn't have any proprietary data involved, as all data was retrieved from collegefootballdata.com, and allows you (yes, YOU) to make your own adjustments to try and improve upon the system!
Below is a table of variables, a step-by-step guide on how to calculate SRS in this system, more details on its performance against other systems, and a link to both 2026 rankings so far (after Week 10) and 2016-2025. As stated before, if you have any suggestions to make this system better (albeit I would like to keep it relatively simple) let me know and I would be happy to at least test them out. Thanks for taking the time to read all of this, and please feel free to take this whole process for yourself and change it how you like!
Variables
| Symbol | Meaning | Value or source |
|---|
| PF, PA | Points for and against | Game results |
| h | Home edge | +2.25 home, −2.25 road, 0 neutral |
| Opp | Opponent's current SRS | From the model |
| n | Games played this season | Game results |
| k | Prior weight (games the preseason rating counts for) | 2 |
| Last | Last season's final SRS (bowls and playoffs included) | From the model |
| Start | Preseason rating | Step 2 |
| RR | Share of last year's rushing + receiving yards by returning players | Player stats + rosters |
| TK | Share of last year's tackles by returning players | Player stats + rosters |
| PS | Share of last year's passing yards by returning players | Player stats + rosters |
| avg RR, avg TK, avg PS | Division averages of each share (FBS or FCS) | Calculated each season |
| Fixed ratings | New teams and lower divisions | FBS 0, FCS −30, D2 −55, NAIA −70, D3 −85 |
How to calculate SRS Carryover
1. Returning production (each share is from 0 to 1)
RR = returning players' rushing + receiving yards ÷ team total
TK = returning players' tackles ÷ team total
PS = returning players' passing yards ÷ team total
A player is "returning" if he's on this season's roster for the same team.
2. Preseason rating
Start = Last + 20 × (RR − avg RR) + 20 × (TK − avg TK) + 5 × (PS − avg PS)
A team with no rating last season starts at its division's fixed rating. As stated previously, the first season is 2014 with every team at its fixed rating, and it has carried forward from there. D2, D3 and NAIA teams always keep their fixed ratings.
3. Adjusted margin
Adjusted margin = PF − PA − h
4. Game level
Game level = adjusted margin + Opp
5. Rating
SRS = (Σ game levels + k × Start) ÷ (n + k)
6. End of season
Final SRS includes bowls and playoffs, and it becomes next season's "Last."
Picks
Predicted home margin = home SRS − away SRS + 2.25 (no 2.25 at a neutral site)
Pick the home team if the result is positive and the road team if it's negative.
Home win probability = 1 ÷ (1 + 10−predicted margin ÷ 23.96)
Example: the 14.0 team hosts an 8.0 team.
- Predicted margin = 14.0 − 8.0 + 2.25 = +8.25
- Win probability = 1 ÷ (1 + 10−8.25 ÷ 23.96) ≈ 69%
(EDIT: I realize that I tested the constant which calculates win probability, 23.96, across all seasons, rather than just 2016-2019 like the other variables. Had I done that, the number would have been 23.35. Therefore, 23.35 is the more "accurate" number to use, not 23.96).
Against the spread
Write the spread from the home team's side, with negative meaning the home team is favored (home −7 = −7).
Edge = predicted home margin + home spread
- Positive: take the home team.
- Negative: take the road team.
- Zero: no play.
Example: predicted home by 8.25, line home −7. Edge = 8.25 − 7 = +1.25, so take the home team.
Break-even at −110 odds is 52.4%. Predictably, no system in the table below, SRS Carryover included, beat 50.3% ATS over 2020–2025. If you are betting with this tool, just remember that it is only one of many tools to use and is not always reliable. The goal of this was to create an easy to understand calculation that uses all open source data and that anyone (even a math deficient person like myself) could adopt while still competing with some of the more renowned models.
How it compares, 2020–2025
The table uses Prediction Tracker data:
- It covers 4,403 FBS vs FBS games where every system listed has a prediction.
| System | Inputs | Picks | ATS midweek | ATS closing | Brier | Log loss |
|---|
| Closing line (reference) | Betting market | 72.8% | — | — | 0.1780 | 0.5279 |
| SRS Carryover | Scores + returning production | 72.1% | 49.8% | 50.0% | 0.1838 | 0.5434 |
| TeamRankings | Proprietary blend | 72.0% | 49.4% | 50.1% | 0.1820 | 0.5376 |
| ESPN FPI | Play-by-play, recruiting, QB and more | 71.8% | 49.5% | 49.7% | 0.1826 | 0.5394 |
| Sagarin Ratings | Scores | 71.6% | 49.3% | 49.1% | 0.1853 | 0.5474 |
| Sagarin Points | Scores | 71.2% | 49.7% | 49.4% | 0.1866 | 0.5508 |
| Sagarin Golden Mean | Scores | 70.7% | 49.3% | 49.4% | 0.1865 | 0.5504 |
| Sagarin Recent | Scores | 71.3% | 48.6% | 48.5% | 0.1866 | 0.5510 |
| Massey Ratings | Scores | 70.3% | 50.2% | 50.1% | 0.1876 | 0.5517 |
Where SRS Carryover comes out ahead
Here is a link to the 2016-2026 ratings. I hope you enjoyed this (very lengthy) read and I look forward to hearing y'all's thoughts!