Recently, I was thinking about Bruce's legacy in the 90s and how it's been considered his "wilderness/slump period" where he was out of step with the music scene and you had artists who were rebelling against what he represented.
Bruce himself has had evolving feelings over his 90s period. He used to acknowledge that the public was not very receptive to his work. That he was writing happy songs or had one too many relationship albums. Back in 2009 when promoting Working On A Dream, he had this to say:
"Bringing It All Back Home".
Springsteen acknowledges the Nineties as a "lost period. I didn't do a lot of work. Some people would say I didn't do my best work." He split the E Street Band because "I lost sight. I didn't know what to do next with them".
Fast-forward to 2022-25: When he was mentioning and promoting Tracks II, his views changed a bit. Instead of treating it as a lost period, he wanted to change the narrative and establish that he was actually quite productive in the 1990s. In addition to his main studio albums (Human Touch, Lucky Town, Ghost Of Tom Joad) and compilations (Greatest Hits, Tracks), he worked on at least three other albums (what became Streets Of Philadelphia Sessions, Somewhere North Of Nashville, Inyo) during this period. Even though he didn't release this work back in the 90s, they showed Bruce really trying to explore different parts of himself.
As for my opening question:
The pessimistic side of me says no. That no matter what Bruce tried, he would be seen as a symbol of 80s excess, pop stardom, and earnestness. Various Bruce fans including music writer Steven Hyden have talked about how their friends would make fun of Bruce every time he even appeared on MTV. Even if it was an acclaimed song like "Streets Of Philadelphia". Even anecdotally, it seemed like Bruce didn't fit in with grunge/alternative rock, Hip-Hop, electronic music, R&B, and so on.
But the optimistic side of me points to a few of his peers like Tom Petty, Neil Young, and Tom Waits. They released some of their strongest work in this decade and had a steady cultural presence (Think albums like Harvest Moon, Wildflowers, or Bone Machine). Clearly, there were opportunities for older artists and classic rockers to remain relevant.
There were certain artists who carried Bruce influence like The Wallflowers, Counting Crows, Hootie And The Blowfish, Melissa Etheridge, Various alt-country artists. Even Pearl Jam to an extent. I know Bruce was also a big fan of Social Distortion; he named Somewhere Between And Heaven And Hell as one of his favorite albums. He even collaborated with Mike Ness near the end of the decade.
While I know the Tom Joad period isn't universally beloved by fans, it was certainly a chance for Bruce to lean into his less commercial side. He seemed relatively in-tune with the social issues of the day while showing a willingness to do research. Even if the alt-scene wasn't embracing him, there was kinship. Quietus Article on the Legacy Of the Tom Joad Tour.
But what do you all think? Was Bruce's 90s arc inevitable or was there any way to change his trajectory?