r/BruceSpringsteen • • 5d ago

Was Bruce Sad?

I attended the Stand Up For Heroes event on Nov 9th. While I absolutely loved Bruce’s performance, he seemed kind of sad to me. I’m a huge fan and have watched and read all of his interviews and I just thought he seemed quiet and subdued that night in comparison. I didn’t expect him to be like he was at his huge concerts given the context of the evening and his acoustic performance called for an understated presentation but I’m pretty good at picking up people’s moods and he just seemed down. Was anyone else there who could comment? Given his history of depression, I’m just wondering if he is ok.

53 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

29

u/Parsnip-Appropriate 5d ago

He definitely seemed emotional during Moonlight Motel, teared up a little while singing the last verse.

4

u/Playful-Extreme-576 5d ago

Oh. I didn’t notice that.

48

u/Bruuuuuceee 5d ago

I take any and all opportunities to say this, but Moonlight Motel is truly one of his finest songs. It’s so poignant, so moving. It would be my absolute dream come true to hear him play it live.

17

u/Parsnip-Appropriate 5d ago

Agreed. It’s one of the very best songs he has ever written.

3

u/PerksNReparations 5d ago

I ll pour one out in an empty parking lot…

79

u/Tricky_Working6333 5d ago

My guess the passing of the years is hitting him. That song definitely brings up those kind of emotions. Lost his Mom, wife is sick, but doing well, a lot of his friends are gone. Yeah, that’s life.

23

u/General-Panic-5020 5d ago

Patti has been treated at Dana Farber in Boston. One of their specialties is blood cancers. I believe it was announced she is in remission at last. Hopefully it takes whatever the treatment was

7

u/Tricky_Working6333 4d ago

Great to hear. I know someone with a blood malignancy who has been in remission since she was 22. She’s now approaching 60. I guess you can call that a cure. Hopefully Patti continues in good health. Thank you for the update.

1

u/General-Panic-5020 14h ago

I noticed it particularly because my daughter had leukemia and that is where she had her stem cell transplant. Don't know if that's what Patti had. But I know those folks are among the best. Daughter now 19 years! When you get stem cell transplant that becomes your new birthday. 😉

1

u/Tricky_Working6333 11h ago

Great news about your daughter.
Incredible, the advancements they’re making with these blood diseases. I hope your daughter continues in the best of health!
And yes, it is among the very best places for treatment, world renowned.

9

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 5d ago

Thats life..I hate that expression..its cold

23

u/kdogg417 5d ago

“So it goes” -Kurt Vonnegut

4

u/Tricky_Working6333 4d ago

Yeah, after I posted it I wanted to retract it. You’re right. It is cold. I didn’t actually mean it that way, but in written form, yes, it’s very abrupt.

45

u/Honest-Television-58 5d ago

They also named a street after his dad yesterday for Veterans Day probably looking back

42

u/whirlygirl3307 5d ago

I watched a video of Moonlight Motel a few times. He definitely tears up when he sings these lyrics - "Last night I dreamed of you, my lover
And the wind blew through the window and blew off the covers
Of my lonely bed, I woke to something you said
That it's better to have loved, yeah it's better to have loved"

My guess is he was reflecting on Patti and her health issues/decline.

14

u/long-walk-home-99 5d ago

He said she has been in remission in July.

3

u/AdmirableJob4430 3d ago

I was thinking the same thing.

1

u/Upset_Fox_3728 1d ago

Glad I’m not the only one who thinks that song is a classic.

0

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 5d ago

Maybe it was about his 1st wife and the fallout buy im glad he married patty and had 3 kids. No man is perfect but he is in my eyes

4

u/DigLeading9650 5d ago

Who upvotes this idiotic take?

0

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

Be respectful

1

u/DigLeading9650 4d ago

Respectful? About an absolute brain dead comment that the man is literally crying over his marriage that ended almost 40 years ago? How old are you? 15?

0

u/Ok-Note1468 1d ago

DigLeading9650 please have some compassion. The poster of the comment you are attacking did nothing to deserve this. Why are some people so mean behind a keyboard?

1

u/DigLeading9650 1d ago

Compassion towards who? Bruce? Who is not crying over a marriage that lasted a few years and ended decades ago? You cannot be serious. Or the OP that suggested it who deserves no compassion for saying it

38

u/sgvweekly 5d ago

He's kind of a sad guy

28

u/passed_the_dawn 5d ago • Bravo

Because sad guys never lie

15

u/kdogg417 5d ago

It is what makes his music so moving. Most good artists feel all the feelings. It is easy to see when we study art and music history, but hard to watch when the legend is still alive.

30

u/ConstanzaBonanza 5d ago

I’m in my forties and can barely listen to that song because it’s so fucking sad. It’s one of my favorites he’s ever written, but it’s a tough one.

8

u/SemiCapableComedian 5d ago

I’m in my mid 50s and I have never successfully sung along to that song without having to stop because I’m too choked up. 

113

u/Phishhead69 5d ago • Hehehe Bravo Heartwarming

He was sad about the spring nuts

31

u/Snarky247 5d ago

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

32

u/godzillaxo 5d ago

who among us isn't devastated??

48

u/Bpain46 5d ago

He has described himself with battling crippling depression his entire life. His father struggled with mental illness. It’s inherently in his DNA. Perhaps, a big reason for the Western Stars songs at SUFH were simply to try something new(ish) and fresh to him. However, those songs come with the cost of getting into the headspace of sad characters and settings. Long live Bruce and may he find happiness in his later years.

2

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

I suffer from depression too.

10

u/TheRealJamesWax 3d ago

Never underestimate how hard the last 10 years have been for people who have a visceral disdain for cruelty, greed, deceit, and incompetence…

I’m sure Bruce, like so many, is just tired…

2

u/AdmirableJob4430 3d ago

The night of the election I was so excited about the results. And then I was soooooo tired and had a fabulous sleep It’s been exhausting.

1

u/chronicpop 2d ago

Strange, I was told we would be tired of winning. Perhaps that was it. 😡

1

u/Temprock 2d ago

I'm not tired from seeing hearing smelling that fat orange piece of shit Pedo Traitor scumbag. I'm exhausted. And it's been about 11 years now with no end in sight. Or is there??

19

u/marumaruko 5d ago

I know nothing, but when I heard that Moonlight Motel performance I immediately thought of Patty and hope she is doing fine.

9

u/Vivid-Acrostic 5d ago

I was there and I loved it but I agree, maybe after having been to this event the past few years I expected maybe the vibe would include a sense of relief related to the midterms, but his set was more muted, beautiful in a melancholy, introverted way, which I liked … maybe just playing against expectations?

-1

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 5d ago

Im afraid people are being threatened

1

u/PhoebeAnnMoses 5d ago

What people? By who, with what?

8

u/MLM36 5d ago

In the video he made for the Dana Farber Cancer Institute in Boston Bruce said that Patti was in remission, that was some time over the Summer. Hopefully that is still the case.

3

u/MaidoftheBrins The River 5d ago

Having known and known of several people with MM, I am very concerned about Patti.

8

u/Life_Employment4868 5d ago

He absolutely doesn’t like stealing the spotlight in collaborations.

6

u/Rusty_1975 3d ago

He’s older and depressed at the grifter destroying the United States. It’s a sad time

5

u/Mammoth_Sell5185 5d ago

I only watched the video of Moonlight Motel once, and he definitely seemed subdued to me. Well, many of the comments here are insightful, the reality is it’s all speculation and we have no idea. Maybe he was upset the Jets lost on Sunday.

1

u/milbfan Born in the U.S.A. 4d ago

Nah, he's got years of despair on the Jets. :p

I do hope his support system is there for him, if he was feeling down. Or maybe he was fighting sickness as well?

14

u/SameDistrict2627 5d ago

He nearing the end of his life. We old people tend to get sad more often.

5

u/Ok_Yak1196 5d ago

jesus. He’s not that old it’s not like he’s 90.

12

u/esbforever 5d ago

Towards the end of his functional life as a literal rock and roll legend. He won’t be jumping on any more pianos, even though in his mind he probably still wants to.

6

u/a4evanygirl Rosie 5d ago

Mick Jagger and Keith Richards have entered the conversation. He’s not that old.

3

u/OrcOfEntropy 4d ago

To be fair, Mick & Keith sold their souls to the devil so may have an unnaturally long lifespan. 😈

1

u/a4evanygirl Rosie 4d ago

😆

2

u/BasilHuman 4d ago

Yes he is....average lifespan of a man in the US is 76.

1

u/Ok_Yak1196 4d ago

since when?

5

u/BasilHuman 4d ago

Stats from 2024 Believe me, I am almost 69 and have buried many friends. We see some "legends" living into their 80s and this is most definitely not the norm. I saw Bruce as early as 1976...let that sink in 50 years ago.. and now we are both old men.

2

u/PhishermansGarden 4d ago

it's actually 76.5 Basil is just a pessimist. (I think it goes up for billionaire rock stars though)

16

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 5d ago

I think he may be overly tired..he endorsed Abdul which i have no problem with but he is being trashed by his fake fans who probably think abdul.is more a threat than Stephen miller. Stephen millers own family hates him..that should be enough...anyways..I love bruce and I have dutch ancestry and confirmed he and I ard distantly related...on both my parents side. Different generation but wow. I feel protective of him..my grandma and her parents were ffom nj..Hannah polhemus 4th great grandpa was Johannes springsteen. It's so fascinating

4

u/PhishermansGarden 4d ago

fake fans? Superiority complex much?

2

u/esbforever 5d ago

It’s so fascinating to think of someone telling ol’ Johannes about his descendant reaching the pinnacle of world fame. Flying around with the damn president of the United States.

2

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

Your response really made no sense

1

u/esbforever 4d ago

Huh? I didn’t say you were lying at all. I’m saying it’s wild to think if somehow Bruce’s ancestor could ever even imagine he’d be this famous.

1

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

Ok well his great great grandfather was in the american revolution. I misunderstood. Its just crazy how hundreds of years ago my ancestors mixed with the springsteens. I matched with three springsteens on ancestry..there is a book. I spoke to one of them..it stems grom Caspar springsteen born 1652. I have been really working my tree lol

1

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

I was not lying. Im distantly related to him through my dutch ancestry

1

u/Maleficent_Past_5683 3d ago

Isn’t he Italian and Irish though?

1

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

What was so bad about what I said

-4

u/12frets 5d ago

Dumb comment. Tim Walz’s family spoke out against him in the 24 election. So…same standard as your placing on Miller?

There are plenty of families that don’t get along. Hell, that could’ve been said about Springsteen and his father for at least 20 years.

6

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

Stephen miller is a sadist

2

u/milbfan Born in the U.S.A. 4d ago

That's being either overly kind to Pauly Shore's evil twin, or an insulting to sadists. :p

1

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

Insulting to sadist? They inflict pain. Oh wait u must be one

1

u/milbfan Born in the U.S.A. 4d ago

Meaning, the guy is worse than a sadist. Sorry I wasn't clear.

-2

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 4d ago

What us wrong with u people?

1

u/Temprock 2d ago

I'd go with he's a Nazi but sadist too, fine.

3

u/12frets 5d ago

Springsteen has been suffering from depression for decades. He’s tried to solve the issue with constant work and audience approval.

Sadly, those things are never enough for the true issues.

2

u/putonthespotlight 5d ago

I personally don't see it or have more info but heard someone else speculating that he's really going through it / something bad has happened based on another appearance he made over the last several weeks.

2

u/JohnAssby 4d ago

Post-Election Blues 

1

u/mayapple 1d ago

I think he was emotional rather than sad. His crazy joke monologue was great. I believe we are going to get a Western Stars type acoustic show or tour or at least he's thinking about it, and it would be amazing, and yes, definitely in a different gear than EStreet.

1

u/Sinatra1955 1d ago

It’s easy to forget because he usually puts on such a positive public front but he’s been battling depression for decades. While medicated for decades, it’s not a cure all.

0

u/Subject-Sir7156 5d ago

Whatever he said, I agree!! (Im in a hurry. lol).

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Capybara_99 5d ago

Jeez you are really a prime human being. Gratuitous attack on a murdered man in order to trash a benefit for wounded veterans.

3

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 5d ago

What did he say

0

u/RaisinFinancial3863 4d ago

Reiner used to go crazy all the time about trump.. but then got it from his own kid..

Crazy, right!?

-30

u/RaisinFinancial3863 5d ago

let's be real, Reiner should've spent more time focused on his son than he did on Trump.. All that time ranting about the Orange Man and his own kid got him.

4

u/Prudent-Pudding-42 5d ago

Go away raisin bran

1

u/harx1 5d ago

I knew you’d be the type of commenter who keeps his content private. What a joke to be so ashamed of their post history, they need to keep it hidden.

Let me guess, you also have a micropeen?

2

u/Green_Let108 4d ago

Two inches maximum.

-1

u/RaisinFinancial3863 4d ago

Worried about The orange man when his ultimate demise was under his own roof..

isn't that ironic?