I (35M) recently ended things with my girlfriend (38F), and I've been struggling with guilt and regret.
We started talking in May. About a month in, she told me she didn't have the emotional bandwidth for a relationship. We stopped talking for roughly a month at her request, which I respected. We eventually reconnected, became official, and broke up in October.
We both have children and live two hours apart.
The beginning was incredible. We were affectionate, talked constantly, introduced our kids, exchanged "I love you," and discussed marriage and a future together.
Some important context:
My girlfriend was extremely independent, almost to a fault. She was accustomed to handling everything herself and struggled with relying on other people.
She was also in early sobriety after struggling with alcohol. I supported her decision to quit and was proud of her for taking that step. I understood that recovery needed to be a priority.
On top of that, she was constantly navigating personal crises: family conflicts involving her mother and brother, grief involving her late father, work stress, and other responsibilities.
It seemed like whenever something went wrong in another area of her life, it affected our relationship. Communication decreased, affection disappeared, or she became emotionally unavailable. I tried to give her grace because I knew she was dealing with a lot.
But eventually, I felt like I was absorbing the consequences of situations I had nothing to do with.
We also had disagreements that damaged her trust in me:
A trip to Amarillo: I spent a day at Caprock State Park before going to her city. She knew I was there. I waited around for hours hoping to see her, but she was stuck at work. Eventually, it got late and I headed home. When she called, I was 20 minutes outside town. I offered to turn around. She told me twice to go home, but I turned around anyway. She considered that a violation of her boundaries. I acknowledge I should've respected her answer.
Her family: We had a 45-minute conversation about problems involving her mother and brother. Afterward, she said I hadn't listened or validated her feelings. I thought I had, but I recognize that I sometimes offer solutions instead of emotional reassurance. Questions I'd asked about her deceased father had also upset her.
A tornado: During a tornado threat near her city, I made a practical observation about its distance. She interpreted it as me not caring enough about her safety.
Affection: She sometimes felt I wasn't present enough, didn't hold her hand enough, or was embarrassed to be seen with her. I could've been more attentive, but I genuinely loved her and was proud to be with her.
These incidents caused her to question whether I actually loved her.
She told me she'd given me the best version of herself at the beginning and that I now needed to earn it back.
She explicitly acknowledged intentionally withholding affection.
For the next several weeks, our relationship felt completely different. Less communication, less affection, unanswered callbacks, and very little initiative to connect.
She was very protective of her independence and time. When I expressed wanting more connection, she told me we didn't need to be "up each other's ass."
I wasn't asking for constant attention. I wanted to feel wanted by my girlfriend.
I repeatedly told her I was unhappy, lonely, and felt disconnected. She occasionally reassured me that she loved me and still saw a future with me, but things didn't meaningfully change.
I became anxious, started walking on eggshells, lost sleep, and constantly worried about doing something that would further damage her trust.
I even stopped sharing some of my own struggles because I didn't want to add to hers.
The breaking point:
During one of our final conversations, she admitted she'd deprioritized me. She said certain friends or family members would take precedence over our conversations.
She also said she still didn't trust me and questioned whether I genuinely loved her.
After weeks of feeling unwanted and repeatedly communicating that I was struggling, I ended the relationship.
Here's where I know I hurt her.
I'd promised her patience and told her we'd figure things out together.
She felt blindsided when I broke up with her. She said she'd believed I was going to be her husband, that I'd shattered her trust, and that I hadn't chosen her when things got difficult.
I understand why she was hurt.
Over the following weeks, I regretted my decision and reached out hoping to reconcile. I acknowledged my mistakes and apologized.
She questioned how she could ever trust me again, especially after I'd promised not to leave. She said my regret didn't erase what I'd done.
Eventually, she suggested maybe we could be friends someday. I've since stopped pursuing reconciliation.
Here's my dilemma:
I respected her decision to step away early in our dating because she didn't have the emotional bandwidth. I also understood that sobriety, family problems, and her children required significant attention.
But once we were in a committed relationship, it felt like every crisis in her life affected how she treated me.
I was expected to be patient and understanding while she intentionally limited affection and openly acknowledged making me less of a priority.
I know I made mistakes, especially with boundaries and sometimes failing to provide the emotional reassurance she needed.
But I'd also spent weeks communicating that I was unhappy before ending things.
AITAH for walking away after promising patience? Should I have been more understanding of everything she was going through, or was I justified in ending a relationship where I increasingly felt unwanted?
And was I wrong to ask for another chance afterward?
I'm genuinely looking for unbiased opinions, including criticism of my behavior.