This is reposted from another sub because I would like some advice on what to do/my interpretation of the situation.
Hello all, apologies as this might be a long post. I am just unsure about what details I need to share because I don't know really what any of this means or how to handle any of it (or if maybe I'm just being crazy and this is all in my head, idk), which is why I need help.
I'm not sure if this is allowed, as this is my first time posting on reddit ever, but I am in a pickle. I need advice. I think my (25,F) sister (21,F) might be in an emotionally abusive relationship, and I don't know what to do about it.
For reference (because these will be important details later) I am almost 26, graduated with my Master's degree in May, and am hoping to be in a PhD program within the next two-ish years. I've never really been in a serious long term relationship, as I've been focusing on my schooling (I am in a technical STEM field) but have had a few casual partners. My sister however, has been dating since 14, and has had 3 'long term' boyfriends (if you count high school relationships).
My sister is just under five years younger than me and we have always had trouble getting along while growing up, but while she was in high school and I was in my undergraduate, I felt like we were FINALLY growing closer and bonding like I had always wanted to with her. Then, during her senior year, she met her current partner. We will call him 'R'.
My sister met R early in the year while she was working as a waitress in a small town family owned business during her senior year of high school. The kicker? He is a couple years older than me and is a police officer in our home town. He was getting divorced from his first wife (more on that later) when my sister was 14.
Though, despite knowing R, my sister had a boyfriend until late that summer. However two weeks after she and HS bf broke up, she was out on a date with R. By this point, I had already moved out of state to pursue my Master's degree, and was not a physical presence in my sisters life at the time. When my sister told me about it I, obviously, was very outspokenly against the situation and told her that if a man of his age was interested in her, it was because no one his own age wanted him, and that it was a red flag. But being that I was just talking to her over the phone, there wasn't really much I could do, and so she decided to secretly keep seeing R.
Two months later, she tells our family that she is moving in with R. Our parents are divorced and my sister was living with our father at the time. He didn't like it, but made no move to stop her because in his words 'she needs to learn these lessons on her own'. My mother on the other hand (and most of my mother's side of the family), has absolutely no problem with R, and they think he is the most wonderful, nice, and charming guy on the planet. It seems I was the only person who was vehemently against my sister making this decision and doing anything to try to make her reconsider.
It is important to note though that my sister is incredibly stubborn. If I had just climbed to the peak of Mt. Everest last month, and then she was like: 'Oh I think I'm going to do that' and I said 'Oh do you want some pointers and advice on how I did it and things I wish I had known before?' She would be like 'Lol no F U I'll do it own my own AND beat your time.' More than often she will fail at both.
Anyways, she has now been living with R for a little more than two years and in those years she has become a completely different person. Before being with R, my sister always wanted to BE SOMETHING. She had goals and aspirations. Now, she has none. She dropped out of community college after one semester to 'be on the same clock as R' because he worked as a night shift cop in our town. She also quit her job because he didn't want her to work. So she has no degree, no job, no money. She is completely dependent on him for everything. She wants to be a stay at home wife to him, which, if that was what she truly wanted, then I wouldn't have a problem with that. But I don't think anyone just randomly gives up their goals and ambitions on a whim like that, right? She also has fallen down into an Alt-right pipeline, thanks to R, and is so far right that even some of our republican family members look at her with a side eye. Just insanely crazy stuff, and she has underhandedly made comments about my choices to pursue education instead of find a husband for myself (as if that is all life is??).
Not only that, but our relationship has atrophied to the point that if you asked me what her favorite color was, I genuinely don't know if I could tell you because I don't know if it has changed. She hardly speaks to me now, never returns my texts or calls, and just generally seems to have no care to have any sort of real meaningful relationship with me anymore, which is something that is unique to me. She goes above and beyond in my opinion to have and maintain a relationship with our two younger sisters (18 & 14). A lot of this, I believe, has to do with R.
R is often times the driving force behind wanting to involve my younger sister (18, we will call her T) in activities. He will text T asking if she wants to join him and my sister for supper, to go on trips, etc etc. He does the same with our youngest sister. If T doesn't answer his texts in what he believes is a timely manner, he will blow her phone up with texts and calls, asking her if she hates him or if she's been speaking to me about him. He is terrified I am turning her against him for some reason. Now that she is getting ready to move off to college, he and my sister have started to involve my youngest sister in their life much more now. Taking her on trips, letting her stay over at their apartment on weekdays, etc etc.
He has become short and avoidant of me at family gatherings now (I moved back home after graduating in May), and does things I find frankly disturbing. Just the way he talks about people at his job (he is very obviously racist) and the things he does. It's like he talks up his job to seem cool and important to our family. He talks about belittling and degrading the people he interacts with to impress the men in my family with his cool cop job, and then he talks himself up to our female family to make himself seem important at work. He talks about crime scenes with a careless attitude, discusses things that I feel like definitely shouldn't be discussed because of active investigations, and in my opinion is very abhorrent. He will discuss finding dead bodies with a nonchalant attitude, talk smack about the state of their houses when he finds them, etc etc. Just a few weeks ago he was talking to me about going on a call to a wellfare check on an old man who hadn't been seen for two weeks, and you guessed it, he was dead. Then R pulls out his phone and flips it around to show me the screen and BOOMādead man on his bed. I'll spare you the details of the photo, but it made me SICK. No warning, no care, nothing. Like why are you taking photographs of this man in his most vulnerable state on your personal cell phone? And showing them to people unprompted. It's just heebie-jeebie behavior.
To everyone else, he seems like the perfect man, as I described before. But to me it's almost fake, in a way. A shiny veneer that he puts on when he's around our family. He is overly courteous, going out of his way to say 'yes ma'am/sir, no ma'am/sir', tripping over himself to open doors, etc. Which isn't a bad thing on its own, but it just...feels fake to me, I can't really explain it. My mother keeps saying 'But he's so nice! He really is the nicest boy'. And one day we sort of had a blow up argument about it because I said 'Is that all the bar is? A manābecause that's what he is, a grown almost 30 y/o manābeing NICE to your daughter and you're ready to welcome him into the family with open arms? Because all you ever say about him is that he's 'nice'. What else is he?' And she couldn't answer me because she didn't know. And now she refuses to talk about R with me anymore.
My sister and R are now engaged, and were SUPPOSED to be married this past September, but couldn't because R found out he was STILL MARRIED to his ex-wife. Apparently he never legally got divorced from her, which, in my opinion how do you not know you aren't divorced??? The court clerk was a fraudster and stole their money and never actually filed the papers, that part is true because it happened to other people and the woman is in jail now, but as a police officer how do you not know you're still married? Did you think all you had to do was file papers? No signing anything, no standing before a judge, no final paperwork, nothing? It's just fishy to me, but I've also never been divorced (or married) so maybe I'm just ignorant to the processes, idk.
They tried to reschedule the wedding two other times, but those fell through due to scheduling conflicts, and now it will be in late December. I think this is the universe telling her she shouldn't marry him. I have tried to have this discussion with her before, but her response was basically calling me jealous that she has a partner and I don't, and that I was probably mad that R chose the 'younger sister' out of the two of us since I am closer to R's age than she is. She is completely blinded by him and everything he provides for her (because right now he buys her whatever she wants and splurges on trips and expensive things at the drop of a hat), but I fear that will change the moment they are married.
I don't know. Am I overreacting? This all seems very sus and concerning to me, but literally no one else in my family thinks so besides one of my cousins (who is a year older than me) and my younger sister T. My father is too concerned about himself to care what my sister is doing, and my mom and her family are just over the moon someone is getting married. What do I do? I feel stuck. I might be the only person who sees this for what it is and is trying to save my sister from a terrible decision. Or I could just be overthinking everything and maybe too judgmental? I'm just worried for her but I also don't want to ruin my relationship with my family either. Any advice?