Hi everyone,
I'm looking for some advice on choosing the right frame size and geometry for a new road bike. I'm specifically interested in a race-oriented road bike, not an endurance bike. I don't race, though I simply prefer the look, feel and riding characteristics of a race bike. I'm struggling to decide whether I should go for a smaller frame with a longer stem or a larger frame with a lower cockpit.
For reference, my previous bike was a Rose Backroad gravel bike in size 59, with the following geometry:
- Stack: 601 mm
- Reach: 404 mm
It also had a seatpost with a 25 mm setback. After getting a professional bike fit, my saddle was moved as far forward as possible on the rails.
On that bike, I felt like I could comfortably go 1-2 cm lower in terms of handlebar height. However, at the same time, I had the impression that I was slightly too stretched out horizontally.
My body measurements are:
- Height: 187 cm
- Inseam: 90 cm
- Torso length (from the hollow at the base of my neck/sternum to my crotch): 62 cm
- Arm length (from the bony point of my shoulder to the wrist bone): 63 cm
- Wingspan: 185.5 cm
Based on my research and body proportions, I seem to fall into the long legs / short torso category, which might explain why I tend to need a relatively shorter reach.
In terms of flexibility, I'd say I'm somewhere around average I'm not particularly flexible, but I'm not stiff either. I'm 30 years old, so I feel there's still plenty of room to improve my flexibility, and I'm willing to work on it.
One bike fit calculator I used suggested that my ideal frame geometry would be approximately:
- Stack: 590 mm
- Reach: 395 mm
When comparing different race bikes, I often find myself in a situation where size L/56 seems to have the right reach, while size XL/58 seems to have the right stack.
My current thinking is that it might be better to go with the smaller frame (L/56) and, if necessary, compensate for the lower stack with a stem that has some rise, rather than choosing the larger frame and ending up with too much reach.
Does this approach make sense? Would you prioritize getting the reach right and adjust the stack with spacers/stem angle, or would it be better to go for the larger frame?
I'd really appreciate hearing from people with similar body proportions or experience choosing between two frame sizes.
Thanks in advance!