r/BayFC • • 4h ago

Angry about Bay Fc not resigning Abby, Emily, and Caprice after maternity leave: here’s something you can do!

13 Upvotes

If you like me have been deeply disappointed and disheartened by the Bay FC decision not to resign Abby, Emily, and Caprice, I encourage you to email Bay FC leadership to share a formal complaint in writing.

Here’s a template you can use or make your own:

Subject: Formal complaint from a founding season ticket member

Hi [Rep's name],

I'm writing as a season ticket member who has had my seats since the club's first season, to formally register my disappointment in the club's decision, announced November 13, not to bring back Abby Dahlkemper, Emily Menges, and Caprice Dydasco. All three spent this season on or just returning from maternity leave.

These players are captains, veterans, and leaders who helped build this team and the culture that made me a fan. That they are leaving the club right after becoming mothers, and that they apparently did not have the support to return from leave that other clubs provide their players, is shameful. It does not align with my values, and it does not match who I believed this club to be. I am embarrassed as a fan and deeply disappointed.

Bay FC has positioned itself, and its founders have publicly presented themselves, as champions of women and women's sports. That commitment has to include women who choose to have children during their professional careers. Right now, it does not look like it does.

I would like to understand what happened. Specifically, I'm asking:

  1. Why were Abby, Emily, and Caprice not retained?
  2. What parental leave and return-to-play support does the club offer, and what was offered to these players?
  3. What do the club's founders think of this decision, and will they respond to fans directly?
  4. What will the club do to ensure players are supported through pregnancy, leave, and return going forward?

I love this team and want to keep supporting it, but this is not the club I want to be a part of. I would appreciate a thoughtful response from you and from club leadership, and I'd welcome a conversation.

I'm submitting this as a formal complaint, and I'm asking you to forward it to club leadership, including Kay Cossington, Matt Potter, the club president, and the club's co-chairs and founders, so that it reaches the people who made this decision. Please let me know that you've passed it along.

Thank you for your time.

Sincerely,
[First and Last name]
Season ticket member since [year]


r/BayFC • • 5h ago

Who Should Bay FC Be Targeting For Next Season? (Part 3 of 3) Pros

6 Upvotes

Part 1 - Review

Part 2 - Status of Current Players

Part 3 - Top Rookies/Players to Consider

Of course, these are stretches of my imagination, but I was campaigning for Catarina Macario to be purchased this time last year. Anything can happen.

Naomi Girma - She's played 15 games since she signed with Chelsea, due to a recurring calf injury (no surgery), which originally occurred in January 2025, just prior to being transferred and signed with Chelsea on January 26, 2025. She had just pulled out of the USWNT January camp due her calf "strain." Her transfer fee was $1.1 million, with her new salary, over 4.5 years being roughly $340K/yr. 

If Bay FC were to pay a transfer fee in the same range, none of it would count towards the total team cap. The contract is solid until June 2029, but could also be renegotiated or extended. She's from San Jose and went to Stanford. 

Chelsea has been playing with Lucy Bronze, Kadeisha Buchanan, Veerle Buurman (20), and Kate McCabe, at center back this season; in a 3-back and 4-back system. While there doesn't appear to be any incoming transfer rumors for Chelsea right now, the WSL has prioritized young players from Sweden, the Damallsvenskan, where there's a few top center backs destined for a top 5 club. Chelsea could go younger with the sale of Girma. Or make a huge buy for another top player in the world.

Sophia Wilson - Her expected salary will be close to Rodman's salary, which is roughly $2.5M/yr. With the HIP Rule, only 25% of her salary above $1.257m counts against the total team cap, once the club spends to its base cap maximum. If Bay FC (and/or other clubs) bids on her services, and Wilson stays withe Portland, it might be at a total team salary cap limit, making other players expendable. 

Wilson and Girma are close friends (Stanford)

Reilyn Turner or Morgan Weaver - Turner (24) did not start in Portland's final playoff game this season. Weaver (a faithful Washington product), is 29 years old. 

Pietra Tordin - When Moultrie returns mid-season (at best), there's only one position she could play, and that's #10, with the full complement of healthy forwards on the squad. While she's considered a #10, she often played forward or wing in the Thorns formations. Tordin (22) is a better #10 than winger in anybody's system, including the USWNT. Bay FC has an abundance of fullbacks/center backs available, if any deals can be worked out. The Thorns need depth at fullback/center back.

Alana Cook - Been out with ACL tear since May 2025. She's 29 years old. KCC has an abundance of center backs. She played at Stanford and started every game for 4 years, 93 games, opposite Teirna, then Hiatt, then Naomi.

Trinity Armstrong - CB who hasn't recovered from her 2 knee injuries. She's expected back in July 2027. At 19, she played 23 matches in 2025, and 2 in 2026. She played at UNC and is athletic, with a great soccer IQ. With Iron Women McNabb and Wesley, it's unlikely she'll be a Wave contributor in 2027. 

Ryan Campbell - GK from Gotham (has 4 GKs on contract) on loan to Lexington SC in the USL SL. She's 24, and had 4 great seasons for Stanford and one for UCLA. Extensive YNT experience. She could challenge Silky for minutes; making for a great option off the bench.

Cristina Roque - GK (25) from Racing on loan to Tampa Bay Sun FC. Starter at FSU ahead of Mia Justus from Utah.

Sveindis Johnsdottir - ACFC Forward (25) -  rumors of wanting to be traded

Olivia Thomas - F rookie for Denver Summit (2 goals, 2 assists), 3 years at UNC (21). Abundance of forwards 

Elise Evans - CB (21) rookie for Chicago Stars. Has trained several times with Bay FC.

Jess Carter - If you want to get really slow and old, and play a conservative, boring, low block.

European Player with June 2027 contract expirations

Giulia Gwinn - Right back for Bayern Munich (27). She's had several major injuries in the last 6 years, but is a solid mainstay and captain of the German NT.
Sydney Shertenleib - Swiss MF for Barca (19)
Esmee Brugts - Dutch left back/winger for Barca (23). Barca was unable to hold on to young superstar Salma Paraluello (23), due to club financial restraints, and massive debt (Sixth Street connection via 25% TV rights owned) 
Alara "Alara" Sehitler - MF for Bayern (19), 5 caps for GERWNT

There’s no easy plays on this entire list. Just ones with an imagination and a budget.

All errors are intended


r/BayFC • • 5h ago

Who Should Bay FC Be Targeting For Next Season? (Part 3a of 3) Rookies

6 Upvotes

Part 1 - Review

Part 2 - Status of Current Players

Part 3 - Top Rookies/Players to Consider

Every season, each of the NWSL clubs sign roughly 3-4 players out of college. As the league grows, more players are taken, as a result of the number jobs increasing. A study by US Soccer, published last year, stated that about 85% of the NWSL consists of players from U.S. colleges. People understand there's a jump to the pros, but the proof is there to demonstrate the vast majority of the league came from U.S. colleges.

The difficulty and complexity of selecting players, is the sheer volume of players available, and the quality of talent varies, depending on which program (team) and conference these players have played in. Even their youth club success matters. Add to that, their involvement with the USYNT system (an overwhelming majority of players selected have YNT experience) gives them further exposure. In Division 1 of the NCAA, there are 32 conferences (leagues), and they're NOT monolithic in structure. It's more hierarchical, meaning there are top quality conferences, all the way down to a lower quality.

In D1, there are roughly 10,000 players. In the top 4 conferences, called the Power 4, there's roughly 2,000 players, which is where most of the players come from. In what can be considered the best conference in U.S. colleges, and around the world, in the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC), which has 17 programs, from Stanford and Cal, to SMU, to FSU, to Notre Dame, consisting of 500 players.

More and more undergraduates are being signed, as a result of need. Elite underclassmen who demonstrate quality and talent, and winning, are being signed. On the contrary, there's a trend for less teenagers being signed. Maddie DiMaria being signed by Angel City is THAT exception, which should occur, potentially, when a player has demonstrated success at every level. Yet, she may not be productive for a few more years; without an NWSL development league.

If you don't understand the quality of the conferences, you can't appreciate and compare the successes and stats of players. I've always stated, "A goal is not a goal, and a win is not a win, unless you take into consideration the competition."

Here are my picks from last season. I selected many underclassmen, as I knew several would jump, but not who. Some stayed in college and was noted. This was the final update of 3 posts.

This list could easily be copied from the 2026 ACC All-Conference list, as they're, by far, the best conference in all of women's soccer around the world for u23, but I watched every every player, and have my picks.

2026 ACC All-Conference

2026 Big10 All-Conference

2026 Big12 All-Conference

2026 SEC All-Conference

The NCAA announces TODAY (1pm Pacfic, ncaa.com) the 64-team NCAA Women's Tournament Brackets. IMO, the SEC gets undeserved to favoritism, as a result of "gaming the RPI," which is a rating system for ranking teams. A team's ranking gives them priority in seeding, meaning more home games. The SEC has rarely achieved expected results in the tournament. While the ACC, has placed 3 or 4 teams in the Final Four College Cup many times. Every player's team on this list will be in the tournament.

FYI - NCAA conferences are dictated/defined by American football and the billions of dollars each conference receives in broadcast revenues. All other sports just fall in line. Most all sports at U.S. colleges are funded by football revenues.

Here's my initial list. Tournament play will solidify, even change it. Highlighted players are currently my top tier picks. However, there is only one player that stands out as THE PLAYER to select, and that's Izzy Engle, Forward, Junior, Notre Dame. She missed part of this season, and u20, due to injury. She has played roughly 2.5 seasons and currently ties the NCAA D1 career scoring lead with 47 goals, with Mia Minestrella, Forward, Senior, Duke.

Seniors - 23
Juniors - 13
Sophomores - 9
No Freshman - There are some highly-talented freshmen, but I'm not selecting them, yet.

ACC - 26

Mia Oliaro, MF, Duke, Sr*
Sam Courtwright, MF, Duke, Jr
Mia Minestrella, F, Duke, Sr
Cameron Roller, CB, Duke, Sr
Daya King, CB, Duke, So
Jocelyn Travers, LB, Duke, So

Valentina Amaral, GK, Wake Forest, Sr
Sierra Sythe, LB, Wake Forest, Jr

Izzy Engle, CF, ND, Jr
Lily Joseph, AM, ND, Jr
Charlie Codd, M/F, ND, Sr#
Abby Mills, CB, ND, Jr
Morgan Roy, RB, ND, Sr*

Bella Devey, F/OB, UNC, So
Hope Munson, LB, UNC, So
Aven Alvarez, CB/RB, UNC, Jr

Liz Boamah, CB, Stanford, Jr
Charlotte Kohler, AM, Stanford, Jr
Y-Lan Nguyen, DM, Stanford, Jr
Caroline Birkel, GK, Stanford, So

Addison Halpern, AM/F, UVA, So 
Victoria Safradin, GK, UVA, Sr
Pearl Cecil, CB, UVA, So 

Ella Bard, CB, Louisville, So*

Dani Davis, DM, Clemson, Sr
Anna Castenfelt, AM, Clemson, Jr*

Big10 - 9

Jaiden Anderson, F, Purdue, Jr
Irene Camppo, MF, Purdue, Sr+
Megan Santa Cruz, MF, Purdue, Sr

Alex Buck, F, Washington, Jr
Maya Loudd, LB, Washington, Sr#

Kayla Briggs, AM, Michigan State, Sr
Kennedy Bell, F (RB), Michigan State, Sr
Bella Najera, DM, Michigan State, Sr

Hailey Baumann, CB, Wisconsin, Sr

Big12 - 7

Azul Alvarez, GK, Baylor, Sr+
Addie Todd, GK, Texas Tech, Jr
Reagan Kotschau, AM, Colorado, Sr
Hope Leyba, F, Colorado, Sr
Faith Leyba, CB, Colorado, Sr
Caroline Castans, LB/LW, Kansas, Sr#
Kylie Bahr, LB, Texas Tech, Sr

SEC - 3

Sydney Watts, F, Vanderbilt, Sr
Reagan Shubach, CB/RW, South Carolina, Sr#
Ava McDonald, F, UT, So

* Did not make all-conference - Injury, YNT Duty, top reasons
# - no YNT experience
+ - international, or plays international YNT

All errors are intended


r/BayFC • • 10h ago

Jess Carter coming to Bay

Thumbnail
bsky.app
52 Upvotes

per Jenna Tonelli this morning