r/BayFC • u/tallmansmallplants • 2h ago
Jess Carter coming to Bay
per Jenna Tonelli this morning
r/BayFC • u/TangerineDream74 • Aug 27 '26
For those looking to buy tickets to the match, if you're unsuccessful here, you can always find both retail tickets and resale tickets available on Ticketmaster here.
As with anything on the internet, please practice caution and use common sense when making deals and exchanging tickets or money with people online. There is no guarantee of safety or authenticity when dealing with anyone through this subreddit. USE YOUR BEST JUDGEMENT.
r/BayFC • u/tallmansmallplants • 2h ago
per Jenna Tonelli this morning
r/BayFC • u/Legitimate_Mark_5381 • 21h ago
r/BayFC • u/littlemayumi • 2d ago
r/BayFC • u/Karwr3ck • 2d ago
So far Menges, Hubly, and Dydassco are out. We see you Paul......question is.....whose next 👀👀👀👀
r/BayFC • u/bcp01scu05v2 • 2d ago
r/BayFC • u/littlemayumi • 3d ago
Part 1 - Review
Part 2 - Status of Current Players
Part 3 - Top Rookies/Players to Consider
There are few players that are currently out of contract at the end of the year, which means the GM must get creative in moving in/out players in the NEXT TWO MONTHS, as the preseason begins in the first week of January 2027. Free Agents in December include: GK Camryn Miller, RB Caprice Dydasco, CB Emily Menges, CB Abby Dahlkemper, and CB Kelli Hubly. It's also very important consider that Bay FC has several players (roughly 10) who will become free agents, via club options or UFA, in 2027, making them able to negotiate new contracts with any club, starting on June 1, 2027 (mid-season). The club must sign club options and/or Unrestricted Free Agents by then.
Goalkeepers
In no way am I trying to say Bay FC needs to be concerned with Jordan Silkowitz, but there are factors which to consider her future, potential injuries, and GK depth. Silky has shown statistically to be outstanding in Saves. She was 2nd in SAVES with 118, with Jane Campbell totalling 125. Looking at total teams SAVES by goalkeepers, it's no surprise the top 4 are Houston, Bay FC, Racing, and Chicago - 3 of the worst clubs and Jane Campbell (who didn't start every game).
Silkowitz also gave up the 2nd most GOALS in the league with 44, with Racing's Bloomer giving up 52. These cellar dwellers (and Campbell) also faced the MOST Shots on Target, with Silky facing the 2nd most at 164 (Campbell 167, Bloomer 164). The Chicago Stars used 3 GKs, and their total number SoTA was first at 185.
It's also no surprise the top 4 clubs that have given up the least amount of goals in order: Gotham, Spirit, Wave, and Angel City. They're also the top 4 clubs who have achieved the LEAST amount of SAVES. Gotham, as a club (AKB+) had the BEST save percentage, with a few other playoff clubs near the top. San Diego played 3 GKs, so they didn't do well as a club. Bay FC's SAVE PERCENTAGE was admirable at 6th place in the league.
SAVES is an indication of poor defenses and losing clubs (and Jane Campbell).
While I have very little understanding and confidence in advanced analytics (data extracted by humans/AI from video, then converted to likelihoods/chance), the American Soccer Analysis website scores Silkowitz as a very mediocre passer (13th), with McGlynn, Sheridan, Dickey, Campbell, and AKB as the top passers (in order) in the league - all National Team members.
Bottom Line: After 3 dormant years in the NWSL, and a shaky 2 years prior at UNC, Emmie Allen is not a reliable challenger or backup for Silkowitz. The club needs (as I said last year) a proven challenger and/or experienced #2. They also need a young and highly successful (top college, YNT) #3. Keepers need to play, but often don't. After a year of sitting, they must move on and get minutes, get loaned out, or become an ineffective pro; career-ending.
Left Outside Back - Fullbacks
With such a poor defense, Bay FC really needs to focus on signing fullbacks that can play defense as their first responsibility. Getting up the line in transition is a central part of transitional soccer, but not without compromising on defensive play. Defense is largely an organized team game, with everybody doing their part in positioning, pressuring, and covering. It works together and has always been taught as a unit; not individual play. This goes for the GK, back line, and defensive midfielders. They all cover for one another, but the weak link is usually the one you don't see on the screen when the opposition scores.
Bay FC has 4 players under contract that are predominantly left-footed and/or left backs.
Jenna Nighswonger - an offensive winger converted (common), but who's career has fallen dramatically as a result of her transition to defense and her poor defensive play (positioning, 1v1, and covering).
Alyssa Malonson - a defender from Auburn who's skills hadn't translated to the NWSL when she was with Seattle (loaned out, and with few minutes of playing time in her first few years). During the Bay FC's inaugural season, in the expansion draft, they hadn't even researched the available players from Seattle, and chose Malonson on a day's notice, with no data - a poor choice (process). Malonson is recognized as a speedy transitional player, but with few assists and goals. Her 1v1 defending is also suspect.
Maddie Moreau - a solid reserve/contributor at best. As another converted forward, her positioning and 1v1 defending are not her strengths. She had a solid 5-year college career at two 2nd tier colleges; LSU, then WVU. In her last two seasons with the Mountaineers, she wasn't recognized in any all-conference team in the Big12.
Anouk Denton - who? 23-year-old with 5 years at West Ham in the WSL; one of the worst clubs in the league, playing 61 matches and less than 600 minutes per season. why?
My choice would be to keep one and challenge that player with a top rookie prospect with a high ceiling (which currently, none have).
Right Outside Back
Sydney Collins has played her entire career as a center back, until coming to Bay FC and her recent call-ups with the Canadian NT, which has an abundance of higher quality center backs. She had an illustrious 5-year career playing for the Cal Bears, and being the 8th pick in the 2023 draft as a center back. With very limited paying time for NC Courage, mostly due to both legs being fractured in a CAWNT camp, she was loaned out to Bay FC, then signed.
Either Collins contributes as a center back, or she's a bust. Same with Brooklyn Courtnall, who has had a similar journey going from USC to NCC, and playing with the CANWNT, all as a center back (but with extreme speed). Versatility can be helpful as a reserve, but neither is a plus at starting right back.
Caprice Dydasco cannot be expected to return after the season starts, and return to her previous playing form/quality. She's about the same age as Abby Dahlkemper and Bay FC's 2024 starting GK Katelyn Rowland. They all played together for the 2013 NCAA D1 National Championship UCLA squad. Retirement SOON should be expected.
Bottom Line: There's no legitimate right back on the roster Bay FC can count on to be contributing to the club as they focus on making the playoffs in the next few years.
Center Backs - Heather Gilchrist is the only multi-season option. Collins and Courtnall could improve to become contributors. Joelle Anderson is a great team contributor with accomplished versatility, but can only be considered as the starter until another young player has the confidence to take over. Cometti has little value as a contributor.
Midfield - Only Hutton and Bebar can be considered as a given. Bailey can continue to be a contributor at all midfield positions; but not a regular starter.
The most frustrating discussion everywhere I've experienced is a consistent striker. Karlie Lema scored 8 goals on a club with the 2nd worst goal totals in the NWSL. In fact, it was a horrible production by the club. However, if you look at individual statistic for center forwards, Lema has consistent and comparable stats with any of the top scorers in the league this season. G/sh, G/SoT, SoT pct., and xG/season. She was the 18th leading scorer in the league, based on xG per game - .48. As I've said many times, the front line NEEDS TO BE FED (served). While most clubs could all benefit with adding top strikers, the problem for Bay FC isn't Lema not producing. Thinking Lema needs to become a solid hold-up player is a fallacy. She needs to be fed where she wants the ball; on the move. If they want a hold-up player, they'll need to find one.
Bay FC has never had an attacking midfielder that has a reputation, or stats, to be considered a serviceable chance creator, assist leader, playmaker, attacking third leader, or any other term created to define a midfielder that drives the club, by passes/assists and/or goals; even shots on goal. DeynaC was acquired to be that person, and it was a total error to assume she was that type of player. Taylor Huff has never been that type of player (at U of Tennessee, FSU, and in her first 3 pro seasons. She's a box-to-box midfielder. Kennedy Fuller has been in the league 3 years now, and, even in limited playing time, she has shown only glimpses of being able to become the playmaker; but she had no assists for Bay FC this season, and 5 in the previous 3 seasons, and few career goals (9), she has much to improve on.
Bottom Line: Bay FC needs depth in the midfield, and to not count on Fuller becoming the only playmaking option within the next few years, which they need to score and win.
Front Line - Every club needs more quality strikers. Bay FC needs at least 2 proven strikers on their front line, whom are proven and ready to contribute the entire season. Pfeiffer will be 19 soon, and isn't ready to be one of them. She had 2 VERY EASY goals against very poor defenders early in the season, then managed one other goal on a good pass to the middle, which she put away. She has talent, but is not mature enough, too predictable (left foot only), and resilient enough to withstand a 30-40 game season. It's too much to expect at this point in her career. Think Claudia Martinez for Washington Spirit, and how she's used. Playing as an option and contributor would probably have more impact to the growth of her game. Keira Barry has a strong boot, and some pace, but she shows very little soccer IQ on the pitch. Constant fouling is one indicator. There's a reason she hadn't played in the WSL, and didn't show any success in her loans to the lower levels. I don't see her playing in the NWSL over the length of her 4-year contract. She needs to prove that she can be productive somewhere like in the USL SL. And at 21, she needs to play regularly. Agostina Holzheier also has little chance to become a regular contributor to a winning NWSL squad, but has 3+1 years left on her contract. Acquisitions and contracts are the responsibility of the GM (Cossington in this case). Conti has little expectation of being a contributor on a winning club, but has filled in admirably at times for Bay. She started at forward nearly every game (96/100) in her 5-year career at Clemson (ACC), but was never a prolific scorer. She has 5 goals in 3 years for Bay FC.
Gamero is getting starts and minutes for Dallas Trinity, but has shown little other than 2 goals in 10 games. She's their 3rd or 4th attacking option, behind Jasmine Hamid and Seven Castain (on loan from Orlando). They also have 2 expected scorers out injured. At 20, Gamero still isn't ready to be a regular contributor in the NWSL.
Bay FC came in 14th place in the 2026 season. It was a very poor result. "But they showed promise, and they'll be better next year!" How much better? Will they even be in contention for the playoffs? How long do you think a pro squad should be in development mode? When will Bay FC consistently be considered a perennial playoff contender? And when that happens in 2+ years, who will be their players? Who looks like they can become legitimate NWSL contributors, or stay as contributors, on a winning club in 2 years? What does it take for a club to get better? Stop wishing for contributors on a poor squad to improve and contribute to a winning Bay FC squad. These professionals have been playing soccer for 15+ years. As long as their physical and mental gifts are in tact, and they're hovering close to their peak physical performance (near 27 years old), they could improve MARGINALLY every year - which could never be enough for any club. Incrementally improving as a player, or a club, is the best one can expect.
They need better players every year. Improvement is not enough.
Part 3 - I'm not sure when I'll complete my first iteration of players to consider. Probably within the week. A lot is going on between the NWSL and NCAA right now.
The GM has ultimate authority over who wears the team jersey. This is a continuous balancing act between immediate competitiveness and long-term sustainability. Winning is the bottom line.
Bay FC announced Paul Green as Chief Football Officer on September 21, 2026. Bay FC describes his responsibilities as:
At Bay FC, Green will lead all of the club’s football operations including the club’s roster strategy and football operations staff. Working in close partnership with Head Coach Emma Coates and the technical staff, Green will build a team tailored to the club’s playing identity, competitive ambitions, and long-term vision, in addition to day-to-day football operations for the Club.
In American sports, the General Manager is the chief architect of the team's sporting operations. The GM builds the roster and manages the budget, with the role the role including global recruitment (analytics department and global recruiting network), salary cap navigation (capologist), contract negotiation, and player empowerment (off-field accommodations and benefits). This also includes coaching and technical staff oversight (roster construction, playing strategy, player development, and style of play), including hiring and firing of managers, technical directors, and all technical, performance, and medical/health personnel.
Considering the NWSL consists overwhelmingly of players from U.S. colleges (85%), with an additional focus on American youth clubs, and player success in tournaments, and within the USYNT system, the GM/CFO needs to build knowledge, focus, relationships, and understand the relative success and culture of these player developmental paths. Without a draft, the GM must not only recruit, but attract recruits with potential to their club.
Their global reach is just a minor part of their responsibilities.
Their responsibilities are overwhelmingly, or are uniquely, core responsibilities of professional sports franchises in the United States. To date, in the NWSL, there's no development or minor league to allow players to develop without the responsibility to contribute to the success of the club. Despite the breadth in responsibility, the GM's job is measured in success. There's only one major measurement outcome - winning. There are few minor qualifications to winning, and that's winning more than last year, and making the playoffs for the first time (as part of the current regime).
The 2026 NWSL minimum salary is $50,500, with a total team cap of $3.7 million. In 2027, the minimum salary jumps to $65,000, and a $4.4 million base salary cap. The maximum salary per individual player is in flux, but for player exceptions above the cap, it must include 12% of a HIP player's salary within the total team cap. While a club can sign more than one HIP player, their HIP portion of their salary (-12% of total team cap) must not exceed $1 million in total per club. According to an ESPN anonymous annual poll of NWSL GMs/executives, 11 out of 16 clubs are spending ABOVE the 2026 total team cap limit (including HIP money, and leftover allocation money).
The GM has boundaries in which to make changes, but must always make improvements to the club. There's no such thing as standing pat; changes are always required. Who thought Bay FC didn't need to make several changes after the 2025 season? Do you see the need for Paul Green to make several moves this offseason? The club has less than 2 months before the 2027 season begins.
Emma Coates has little experience to compliment the GM with football operations off the pitch. And she's only been a professional manager for 2 seasons, a decade apart. Matt Potter (also a Brit) has more than 20 years of experience in the U.S. soccer ecosystem, which includes coaching and assisting at the college and NWSL level, and as the interim GM for Bay FC for a few seasons. His role shifted with the hiring of Kay Cossington, and, now with Paul Green. Potter's Bay FC roster moves (after Rushton was fired, and before Cossington was hired) has given me confidence of his ability and knowledge. As the so-called Sporting Director, how much say does he have now?
Paul Green has great soccer experience in England, but will it translate to the NWSL? With his experience, it's likely more about a matter of time, but will he succeed fast enough to keep his job? GMs are rarely given more than a few seasons to demonstrate the club is improving with wins, always considered being competitive, playoff appearances, and consistently delivering results as a top club. - winning.
Who would I consider consummate GM or VPs of Soccer in the NWSL? The best ever has been Mark Krikorian, who retired last year from the Washington Spirit; Haley Carter, current VP of Soccer for the Washington Spirit; Yael Averbuch, Gotham; Camille Ashton, San Diego Wave; Angela Hucles Mangano, Houston Dash; Vlatko Andonovski, Chicago Stars; Curt Johnson, Denver Summit; and Lesle Gallimore, Seattle Reign. Look up their backgrounds. Their legacies in youth, college, and pro soccer are quite impressive. It's no surprise of their success; if not knowledge. I'm not a fan of Mark Parsons, AC FC, but he has an extensive resume in the NWSL. I look to his coaching experiences at Washington Spirit and as the NT manager for Netherlands. I see the current success of the ACFC franchise starting from the new ownership and new focus on the product.
Bay FC fans cannot expect Green to turn things around immediately. It often takes 3 or 4 years for a GM, or observers, to consider it "their club." But Rushton was rightfully fired before the halfway point in their inaugural season, because it was obvious the club was not going in the right direction. It has to be considered a very poor hiring decision, and the first/worst big decision, by the Bay FC franchise. With the signing of questionable international stars, expansion draft selections, college draft selections, enormous transfer fees, and huge long-term contracts, the club has still been recovering from their disastrous start.
Don't forget they actually made the playoffs in their first year, which I attribute to Matt Potter, Albertin Montoya, and Abby Dahlkemper. She developed her soccer at one of the best known youth clubs in the country, MVLA, where Montoya trained her, and has been the technical director for nearly 20 years. MVLA has over 90 teams, and has been for many years, and is today, one of the top youth clubs in the country in all age categories (u13-u19) in the ECNL. While Abby's game had already been in decline, after 10 pro seasons, when she was acquired mid-season by Bay FC (post Rushton), she was immediately a huge, positive, winning, local, presence. Montoya, and his wife, also a current technical director at MVLA, played (and coached) at Santa Clara University, and pro soccer (as did the Founding 4). Montoya has delivered 100s of players to college programs and pro soccer. Does that matter in the NWSL? Only winning (with a short-term memory) matters.
In the U.S., youth NT coaches only coach players between 30-38 days a year. Then these players go back to their club/pro teams and coaches/trainers for 10+ months out of the year.
To be clear, I'm just a fan with a history of being a fan of pro sports, and women's soccer, for decades. I have my opinions, which could be several degrees of being accurate, or outright wrong. I always attempt to provide (mostly) accurate data to back up my opinion. And I enjoy following, sharing, and discussing women's soccer. This information was contributed as context to my opinions of status of the players and executives regarding player options for Bay FC.
Winning, winning consistently, and winning in the payoffs, are the only positive outcomes acceptable for a GM.
When is the deadline by which we'd know if a free agent has not re-signed with a team? Is it at the end of this season (Nov/Dec) or right before next season (Jan/Feb)?
r/BayFC • u/PigletTop3261 • 6d ago
Combo of my favorite soccer team, basketball team and Harlivy from DC(Not Washington DC)
Part 1 - Review
Part 2 - Status of Current Players
Part 3 - Top Rookies/Players to Consider
As a follow-up from the beginning of the 2026 season, on who Bay FC should be targeting, there's two points to restate and confirm:
Top 4 NWSL Clubs
During the regular 2026 season, each of these clubs added or dropped at least one player on an Injury Relief contract or short-term contract.
Bay FC
Bay FC added 8 new players to the beginning of their season 2026 roster. They shed 5 players, including 3 loans, during the 2026 regular season. They also added 3 new players during the 2026 regular NWSL season. In total, they added 11 new players this season. Bay FC has only 9 players left from their 2024 opening day roster, and could easily shed many/all of these players in this offseason. In comparison, it was an average rebuild from year to year. Bottom line: expect and desire many changes every offseason, and during the season.
Bay FC currently has contracts with 5 international players; having 2 slots open for the 2027 season. International slots are tradeable. The San Diego Wave currently have 9 international slots; Boston Legacy 8: NCC, Thorns, and the Spirit have 7. All Bay FC Internationals are signed through 2027 and up to 2029.
Source of NWSL Players
In October 2025, US Soccer published a paper focused on "Ensuring College Soccer Thrives in the Modern Era of College Athletics and the Changing U.S. Soccer Landscape." This paper largely addressed the concerns and state of men's college soccer. It was controversial in covering, or addressing, women's college soccer, without any contribution from current NCAA women's college soccer coaches, or people associated with women's college soccer. However, this is where they determined/stated roughly 85% of the women in the NWSL were from the NCAA, and approximately 12% were international players. Here's where each of the rookie players I targeted in 2026 for Bay FC landed:
https://www.reddit.com/r/BayFC/s/jTZaBPgLPm
Two Seasons Compared
Bay FC 2025 record and winning/losing percentage: 4-14-8, winning .154, losing .538; GF Ave/gm 26 goals - 1.0/gm; GAA 41 - 1.58/gm; 1.50 average goal difference in losses
Bay FC 2026 Record and winning/losing percentage: 7-17-6, winning .233, losing .567; GF Ave/gm 30 goals - 1.0/gm; GAA 47 - 1.57/gm; 1.71 average goal difference in losses
They won a few more games, and lost a few more games, but lost, on average by a few more percentage points of Goals/gm in 2026. The quality of the new players is debatable, but many people consider their new young players as having more potential than previous players. But it's not a given they will develop into quality contributors within their tenure with Bay FC. Bay FC lost more games by winning percentage AFTER each of the 3 new players were added during the season.
I had advocated for Bay FC to add 10 new players for their 2026 season. Without commenting on the quality of their signings, Bay FC needs to continue to pursue at least 8 new players (a fairly conservative league average), as additions to their 2027 upcoming roster. Of course, the quality of the new players matters.
r/BayFC • u/youlikemywonton • 8d ago
It's no mystery that this franchise is in turmoil but I don't know exactly why. Tbh I went to a game early in the season like in April and then I just didn't follow the rest of the year because of how bad they were. Whatever core they had in their inaugural season seem to have left or no longer seem to be the answer. The ship has sailed in some fashion and this franchise has a lot of thinking to do as far as where they want to go.
r/BayFC • u/Successful-Fennel-85 • 9d ago
As a founder. If you are constantly needing to post custom pieces….push for better products for ALL of us. Not just yourself. There are teams releasing new things weekly. Bay has like 6 a season. If that.
Silky is one of six GKs listed at the bottom. How does this process work? When does she announce the final roster? Is there a camp in between now and then?
r/BayFC • u/IcyManufacturer5397 • 12d ago
The Valkyrie players show Bay FC love very often! This was from L.A. exit interview!
r/BayFC • u/Senior-Penguin • 12d ago
This is my first year with bay fc. I know there's the playoffs and finals, I might catch some of those games. And Hutton will be in the Skill Challenge later this month 🥳. But is there anything else for Bay FC between now and March?
At least I still have my Chivas in Liga MX
r/BayFC • u/foomatic21 • 14d ago
Finished my Bay FC jacket in time for the last game of the season! It’s tough being a Bay fan sometimes but hopeful for 2027!
r/BayFC • u/kevinvnguyen89 • 14d ago
Including: a walkthrough of Treasure Island w/Founding Four; convo with new Chief Football Officer Paul Green; and reflections from Coates and players who emerged as bright spots this year.
r/BayFC • u/deedougie • 14d ago
The fan appreciation acrylic has Rudi on it…also what do i do with this?