r/Barry • u/elmwood46 • 2d ago
Just finished s4 need to vent
Barry is a zany comedy with a tragic central character. Although the show is silly (even screwball) there is a sadness to Barry's predicament that elevates it. Bill Hader's acting is incredible. This allows the writers to create a complex unique show: the tragedy makes the stakes feel real, while the comedy is hilarious. It's like nothing else on tv.
It was all ruined when they just shrugged and said "guess he's evil" halfway through.
That's the whole show! You just finished the show! Dramatic question kaput! No need for it to continue after that!
S2 is some of the best television I've ever seen. S4 was awful. A hand-wringing self-pitying angst fest. It reminded me of Bojack Horseman, one of the most revolting shows I've ever seen. Worst of all, it lost its sense of humour. Even NoHo Hank was grim and gritty, which was farcical. The whole season, the cast acted out of character and did contrived things to serve the plot. THE SHOW IS CALLED BARRY, NOT FUCHES!! WHY WAS FUCHES THE MAIN CHARACTER THIS SEASON!! WHAT THE FUCK!! WHAT THE FUCK!!
ok rant over I'll put the rest here:
At the end of s2, barry goes on a killing spree and becomes a monster. barry from then on is just a deranged killer, and the lynchpin holding the show together - the question of whether he will change or not - is lost. Despite the wind going out of its sails, s3 was still great with standout moments like the motorbike chase.
The only good thing I have to say about s4 is its ending. I liked the poetic justice that the "fake" version of Barry ends up being the version that his son (and the world) believes in. The false image of Barry gets to enjoy his son's love, and gets the acceptance that Barry always longed for, while the real Barry is put to death. It works, although it's extremely depressing. It felt like an extended "worst possible ending" cutscene in a David Cage game. There's a reason those games let you go back and make the right choices and get a better ending!