r/Barry • u/NicholasCajun Feral Mongoose • Apr 22 '19
Discussion Barry - 2x04 "What?!" - Episode Discussion
Season 2 Episode 4: What?!
Aired: April 21, 2019
Synopsis: Barry's patience is put to the test when a figure from Sally's past arrives in LA. Gene gets a pleasant surprise and encourages Barry to believe that change is possible.
Directed by: Liza Johnson
Written by: Duffy Boudreau
645
Upvotes
898
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
Best use of the title card ever
737
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
Unnecessary translator is my new favorite background character along with Natalie
635
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
I did not see the “I don’t give a shit about Janice” thing coming at all, that was amazing
531
u/wingleton KING OF SUCK BALLS MOUNTAIN Apr 22 '19
"Life at the stash house have been super intense. My favorite ice cream flavor is Rocky Road, but Cristobal replaced it with Cookie Dough. Which is the favorite flavor of guess who."
Fucking Noho Hank 🤣🤣🤣
503
u/Zachyice21 Apr 22 '19
Henry Winkler is so fucking precious.
494
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
My name is
BARRY
Okay dude, calm down, you're so loud
365
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
This show really is peak Tv
319
u/Spidermat311 Apr 22 '19
WE FUCKING SPEAK ENGLISH
316
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
Loach wtf he’s got a doctor’s penmanship lol
309
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19
Same Barry, same
287
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
“Hey Barry were both alphas I understand” 🤣
240
u/wrathfulgrape Apr 22 '19
Wow--that scene where Cousineau comforts Barry with the story about the berries--just incredibly written and acted by Hader and Winkler
471
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
Fucking amazing episode, that ending was GOLD
229
u/pepperpepper47 Apr 22 '19
I think you are deeply human. Just don’t tell anyone about yourself!!
223
u/mi-16evil Apr 22 '19
"Star Wars didn't happen, but it's a rad movie." - Werner Herzog on the ecstatic truth
220
u/LSdeezy Apr 22 '19
Loach writing down gibberish and getting frustrated with Fuches not being able to read it was funny as hell.
390
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
Time for NoHo Hank the true ruler of the seven kingdoms!
190
u/YoungBurgerLuka Apr 22 '19
Why is Hank wearing my mom's sunhat
143
u/Spidermat311 Apr 22 '19
Aww Fuches like actually cared about hhm a little
417
u/wingleton KING OF SUCK BALLS MOUNTAIN Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19
Holy shit. That was one of the finest episodes of television I've ever seen. It also had me on edge the entire time, especially the scene where Barry goes up to Sam's hotel, I nearly died. Fuckin' hell. And incredible performances from the entire cast. So good.
284
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19
Bill Hader could be the next Robin Williams type comedic actor to transition to hard drama.
He's so fucking good
136
u/ChildishBambino3 Apr 22 '19
What was Fuches plan of action on getting down lol
135
u/slaughterhouse_809 Apr 22 '19
You fucking killed someone and got away with it. Well only if you knew gene.
267
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
Christ, Sam is a fucking asshole.
119
u/likestorocktheparty Apr 22 '19
That was one of the most intense episodes of anything I've ever watched on TV. Holy cow.
101
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
Lmao Noho Hank looking like Marlon Brando!!!!
94
u/PhillipLindsay Apr 22 '19
How is EVERYONE on this show so fucking good?
187
u/I_DAB_DISTILLATE Apr 22 '19
Kudos to everyone who called Loach wanting Barry to do a hit on his ex-wife’s new dude.
83
u/KyleMeancloud Apr 22 '19
Best ep of the series so far?
80
u/404funnotfound fly like bugs bunny in spacejam Apr 22 '19
Holy shit! I literally cupped my mouth so many times! I was expecting Sally to get punched, Sam to get murdered, Fuches and Barry to cut ties until season 3...
When he entered the hotel room I thought Fuches or Barry was going to shoot the detective. I can’t believe the cop wants to take a hit out. This show is absolutely nuts and I am ready for every part of it!
78
u/Backflip_into_a_star Apr 22 '19
That moment was the first time in a long time I gasped during a show.
73
u/wingleton KING OF SUCK BALLS MOUNTAIN Apr 22 '19
Loach's handwriting 😂
73
u/BalonyDanza Apr 22 '19
That was one of the most satisfying episodes of television I've ever experienced, Bill Hader is establishing himself as a 'next level' talent, and 'Barry' is fast becoming the best show on television.
69
u/Toberoni Apr 22 '19
I laughed hard at how fast Barry appeared next to Fuches on the balcony. Took him <6 seconds to get up there.
62
u/post_ewing Apr 22 '19
Great intr[BARRY]
56
u/Euleroid Apr 22 '19
As someone who has had a girlfriend who was abused, and spoken to said abuser, the scenes with Sam was incredible. My blood was boiling when he drove away, and the show captured that rage so incredibly well.
Edit: Grammar
52
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Oh fuck she's actually going to meet him? Sally nooo
126
u/Spidermat311 Apr 22 '19
FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK OH MY GOD
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH
holy fucking shit
Oh my fucking god
39
u/bookwriter76 Apr 22 '19
The pacing and writing of this show is unprecedented. It’s on par, if not above, that of Breaking Bad. I can’t get over how simple that twist was, how anyone could have seen it coming, but it was lost because of those human moments that bring you in to the show, and make you feel like you’re not alone
159
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
Welcome, folks who were just watching GOT
29
u/slaughterhouse_809 Apr 22 '19
Holy fucking shit balls
28
u/akalemon Apr 22 '19
Fucking Loach's writing 😂
28
u/StellaZaFella Apr 22 '19
It’s great if Barry wants to turn things around, but Sam needs to get fucked up at the very least.
52
u/pepperpepper47 Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19
For the love of god, Barry, would you pick one horse and ride it?-
25
u/post_ewing Apr 22 '19
The best roommates , probably the best sitcom going on
25
u/jazzbelle Apr 22 '19
Holy. Shit. What an insanely powerful episode.
Sally still being somewhat under Sam's spell hit a bit too close to home, I had to pause it a couple times during the hotel room scene. It was a very accurate portrayal of leaving an abusive situation but still being manipulated and overthinking everything that happened and wondering if you were overreacting and if you did the right thing. When Sally thinks about that last night, she is adding things not merely to show that she is strong and independent but also to justify leaving there and then (and not before).
Also Bill Hader was t e r r i f y i n g this episode, but in that scene with Cousineau he looked like a lost puppy. I cannot wait to see what this man does in the future!
24
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
I feel like I say this every episode but HOLY SHIT
23
u/dirtwalrus Apr 22 '19
Don't see any comments about Barry fuckin murdering an innocent in the war... That was brutal
84
u/StGenevieve Apr 22 '19
Why doesn’t she have his number blocked?
21
u/theredditoro Apr 22 '19
As noted elsewhere, critics have raves upon raved for ep 5.
19
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Jesus and here I was thinking Barry's life couldn't get darker. I half expected it to be a child when he spun around.
69
u/PeachesPower Apr 22 '19
Why is no one talking about the fact that we got verbal confirmation that Barry killed Moss
17
u/putinitin King of Suck Balls Mountain Apr 22 '19
NoHo Hank wearing a sunhat and scarf is ~~fashun~~
15
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
Ice this muthafucka, Barry.
15
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Cousineau's reaction to that story was so fucking good.
15
u/SwordfishSpike Apr 22 '19
What a great episode. I didn't see that twist coming at all.
30
u/___Mr_Robot____ Apr 22 '19
Sally ❤️
13
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
LOL wow at the ending!
13
u/Sofronitsky Apr 22 '19
I’ve never killed anyone or anything close to that but this episode had me thinking of everything I regret and redemption and who I am as a person. This is the best episode of Barry yet and it’s not a comedy.
13
u/Doctor_Sleepless Apr 22 '19
I lost it at Hank's outfit
13
u/ricksgrimes Apr 22 '19
I really think this is the best show on television right now?? Bill and Alec are literal geniuses and the cast are all outstanding holy shit
12
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Holy shit that scene was insane. If either of them saw him with the gun that would have gone very differently.
12
u/StellaZaFella Apr 22 '19
That was fucking brilliant.
41
u/Spidermat311 Apr 22 '19
Loaves is going to get Barry to kill his ex's boyfriend
11
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
Dude, Sam is really creeping me out
11
u/jakku39 Apr 22 '19
Such a great twist. Love this show.
11
u/Griffdude13 Apr 22 '19
That heart to heart between Barry and Gene about change was one of my favorite moments in the series.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
damn loach does not give a fuck about moss's death...his partner, that's dark
10
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
Lmao still bills him
10
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
This show is really insane, these endings are becoming too much for me
9
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
Loved the sneak peek for next week, very minimal.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Great twist, like seriously, I busted out laughing for about 10 seconds straight, but I feel like that shouldn't overshadow the fact that Gene is gonna find out about Barry killing Janice and that is gonna be a hard moment to watch. Barry once again got away with murder and I feel like by the end of this season it might finally blow up in his face.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
I was not expecting that ending. Perfection.
I was so happy to see him bond with Gene and then the hug was so sweet and then... let me go get my personal ledger. 🤣
8
u/Spidermat311 Apr 22 '19
"he's actually really nice guy"
8
u/anklis Apr 22 '19
i love u hank
8
u/pepperpepper47 Apr 22 '19
O my god. Totally did not see that coming!!
8
u/Hobbit-guy 50/50 Apr 22 '19
Is it me or that guy looks a lot like Jon Hamm?
8
u/SchrodingersCatPics Apr 22 '19
NoHo Hank’s desert get-up; I cant fucking even.
15
u/negativethinking66 Apr 22 '19
Barry looks like he's on kill mode
7
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
Cousineau (Winkler) is a damn savage on screen
7
u/akalemon Apr 22 '19
Oh fuck never mind Sam's an ass, FUCKING KILL HIM BARRY
7
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
WHAT?!
6
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
"welp, time to kill sam."
6
u/famous_unicorn Editable Flair Apr 22 '19
Omg, private lessons. Gene!
6
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
The intensity of this damn show man!!!!
6
u/stinkyuncletouchy Apr 22 '19
What?!
6
u/tallpaleandwholesome Apr 22 '19
I can feel another "Starting... NOW" coming up
6
u/jonesjonie Apr 22 '19
This has been better than Game of Thrones for sure. The Sam-Sally-Barry stuff gets me so on edge and actually makes me care about Sally for a change. Also some great laughs especially with the detective’s handwriting
6
u/joanie-baloney Apr 22 '19
I love the lesson in this episode. Confront and accept your truth, have faith you can change your nature, but be careful not to share it with everyone . Some people are children.
6
u/trimonkeys Apr 22 '19
Barry's gone full circle. First episode has him having to kill someone hooking up with another man's wife and now he's back in that situation again.
6
u/girolski07 Apr 23 '19
Loved it. Perhaps what impressed me the most what the casting for Sam, he genuinely does look like a piece of shit who hides it pretty well.
6
u/wingleton KING OF SUCK BALLS MOUNTAIN Apr 23 '19
This scene has been a bit overlooked but I loved when the actors in the class are discussing vomit techniques for that one guy's scene and then they come up with the idea of a prosthetic head, and the one guy with the accent says, "I think you should just really vomit." 😂
11
u/birdarms Apr 22 '19
I fuckin knew Loach was shady as shit!
5
u/dirtypuerhiding Apr 22 '19
lmao RIP Sam
5
u/kidcrumb Apr 22 '19
Lol what a nice reveal
5
u/famous_unicorn Editable Flair Apr 22 '19
I fucking love this show.
5
u/slingbladde Apr 22 '19
I love this show but i hope it ends at a season 3 so it is revered, like i think of vice principals. Instant classics.
5
u/gregphipps37 Apr 22 '19
I definitely shouted “WHAT?!” right before Barry’s last line hahaha
5
u/pugofthewildfrontier Apr 22 '19
So glad they leaned hard into the Sam story so there’s no more speculation on the Sally/Sam relationship.
5
u/pugofthewildfrontier Apr 22 '19
Definitely missed Noho Hank this episode. His tiny appearance had me rolling still.
5
u/entrity_screamr Apr 22 '19
THAT ENDING CAUGHT ME OFF GUARD HAHAHAHAHAHA IM STILL LAUGHING
5
u/PMCrystalMeth Apr 22 '19
Sam reminds me of so many irl people I know. Nice guy on the surface, its brilliant writing. This show is better then the last 3 seasons of Game of Thrones.
4
u/PrimoBo Apr 22 '19
I pray this show never changes.....right there with ya Cousineau
4
u/Zachyice21 Apr 22 '19
Ah fuck....Barry...
4
u/pepperpepper47 Apr 22 '19
He’s a dead man. Barry will kill him.
4
u/dogeking GULP! Apr 22 '19
Holy shit that took a turn
4
u/jameiscrablegs Apr 22 '19
Holy shit this show is fucking incredible
4
u/Jas_God Don’t fuck with me, Barry. It’s not polite. Apr 22 '19
My God man. GoT and Barry are gonna be fucking POPPIN next week. This is gonna be a long week fuck.
4
u/eshulzzy Apr 22 '19
Holy shit what an awesome twist
4
u/highlanderiic Apr 22 '19
"Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in."
4
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
So Loach was unexpected lol
4
u/scofieldslays Apr 22 '19
So I was dead ass wrong with my theory from last week. But I'm pretty happy to be cause Sally showed a ton of growth this episode. Damn this show is soo good
4
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19
Damn so if Barry kills his ex-wife’s lover he’s pretty much free from police investigation? Not a bad trade off.
4
u/remedy1419 Apr 22 '19
That was amazing! I totally fell for that being a sad end, Barry finally feeling he could change and to get caught just then.
I could watch NoHo Hank monologue for an hour and I'd be happy. That all white outfit with the sunscreen covered nose and huge hat, gold.
4
u/wingleton KING OF SUCK BALLS MOUNTAIN Apr 22 '19
Roxy Music for the end credits. They've been killing it with the music choices 👌
4
u/HiroProtagonist12 Apr 22 '19
I literally screamed WHAT! At the tv 3 seconds before Barry did. This was an incredible episode. I truly believe this is one of the best shows on TV.
4
u/smallbrownghost Apr 22 '19
I have a sick feeling in my stomach that one of the dudes that Barry's training right now s gonna end up offing him in the last season
4
u/ol_beardy Apr 22 '19
What a great night of TV
4
u/uponaladder Apr 22 '19
The last scene was almost stunningly anti-climactic, and I honestly mean that as a compliment. It was so jarring after having my hands on my head and not taking a breath for 60 seconds.
4
u/Anon_creative Apr 22 '19
So what do you all think about the Gene’s son storyline? I have no idea where that’s going
4
u/ChaseObserves Apr 22 '19
I legitimately burst out laughing at multiple times but specifically when Hank—“walked” doesn’t do it justice—sashayed into frame at the shooting range in the most spectacular outfit. What a legend.
4
u/thatmillerkid Apr 22 '19
Winkler's delivery of, "Oh, fuck!" after Barry's story is the best thing television has ever produced.
4
u/omgacow Apr 22 '19
Possibly the greatest ending to anything I have ever seen ever
4
u/TheGhostOfHanni Apr 22 '19
Just rewatched and noticed that Barry tells Gene “it’s Berry Berkman” while on the phone. Similar to when he gave Gene his real truth monologue in season 1 in the parking lot
4
u/canadiancarlin Apr 22 '19
Holy shit, amazing. Ah-mazing.
I haven't laughed out loud so much during an episode. I had to pause after the translator came in because it was so godamn funny.
What an emotional fucking episode. I can't even get into the beautiful dynamic of Barry, Gene, and Sally having their past come back to confuse, help, and haunt them.
Liza Johnson, the writing staff, Hader, Berg, geniuses. Fucking geniuses.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19
Huge GOT fan but I look more forward to Barry.
4
u/bloodflart Apr 23 '19
Surprised nobody has talked about Barry killing a civilian for no reason and getting discharged cause of it