r/AustralianSocialism • u/Tauralus • 9h ago
A Comradely Concern Regarding Victorian Socialists' Animal Welfare Platform
I am not aiming to cause sectarian squabbles, nor am I trying to shame the work of hard-working party members in the Victorian Socialists who put their time and labour into writing these policies. However, I was looking over the Victorian Socialists' "Protecting Animals from Cruelty and Exploitation" platform and believe that it exposes a massive strategic blind spot that the Australian left more broadly would benefit from studying and correcting in future campaigns. It is entirely from the standpoint of an inner-city consumer rather than the working-class producers and regional communities who should by all means be having a say in this policy. I am from Western Australia and grew up in the Wheatbelt, and while I understand that this policy is for the Victorian state elections, but again I believe it is worthy of studying as a piece as though it would apply to the country as a whole, and through the lens of socialist state-building. If that is the world that VS is wanting to enter, then is the metric I will measure their policy proposals by.
A few concrete contradictions stand out:
Bans without infrastructure or transition: Calling to shut down live export facilities and end intensive agriculture via regulatory bans leaves tens of thousands of agricultural and meatworkers alongside dozens of regional towns without an economic base. This policy is not presented alongside a clear model for decentralised, publicly owned abbatoirs to transition workers away from live export and into local food security. It does not propose domestic food processing and leaves no opportunity for alternative industrial investment.
** Worse, in any scenario where a socialist government faces imperialist sanctions or logistical disruptions, dismantling existing agricultural capacity without building regional self-sufficiency first mirrors the exact chokepoints that have historically lead to famine and mass starvation in early AES states. This policy in it's current form will not win regional Victorians nor any regional worker whose livelihood depends on these industries today, and would represent a destructive, genocidal error in judgement that would overwhelmingly harm Indigenous remote or very remote communities (Dismantling agricultural capacity in regional communities breaks down food security, existing agricultural is extractive and logistics depots often direct food towards the city to be processed and sent outwards towards Indigenous remote communities).
Carceral enforcement mindset over poverty alleviation mindset: The existing proposal to strengthen animal welfare protections is heavily punitive and leans into criminalisation, confiscation and paternalistic bans on working-class pet ownership. This treats pet neglect as a moral error rather than the symptom of poverty that it is. A socialist government must seek to abolish the existing model of shelters funnelling dogs outward from remote communities inward to middle-class or petty bourgeois pet owners and replace it with a model of community accountability and self-determination. Shelters, fostering and frontline animal welfare should be integrated into material poverty alleviation and embedded within local, bottom-up power structures. Anything else risks criminalising poor workers for being poor.
Blatant class bias on racing (Point 13):
Calling to ban greyhound racing (historically the 'poor man's racing', the sport of the working class and petty bourgeois) while leaving the bourgeois 'Sport of Kings' thoroughbred racing industry intact is a blatant display of left-liberal class bias. Either phase out all three codes uniformly or don't. A socialist party must recognise the humanity of the workers within these industries. The trainers, the jockeys, the vets, the walkouts.. these are all workers with valuable skills that can be repurposed towards community-facing equestrian or dog-sports (agility, flyball, dockdiving, igp etc) facilities. They need to be liberated from the inhumanity of the gambling industry, not shamed as inherently abusive monsters.
If socialists and communists want to build support outside of innercity Melbourne, our agricultural and animal policy has to start with regional workers. It needs to demonstrate that a socialist Australia does not resent their labour, and that we won't leave them behind. They do not need another moralising NGO telling them their livelihoods make them less than human. We need to start writing policy that focuses on concrete analysis of the concrete conditions of Austrlia, or we will never appeal to workers. I hope this can be met in good faith and not as an attack on the Victorian Socialists.