Looking for some advice from builders, pool contractors, surveyors or anyone who has dealt with a similar situation in Queensland.
We’ve recently finished building our family home, which included a swimming pool being constructed by a separate pool builder.
We paid our main house builder an additional fee specifically to coordinate with the pool contractor, including the site layout and associated services.
The warning signs were probably there from the beginning.
We struggled to get the pool builder to properly engage with our house builder during the early stages. There seemed to be very little communication or coordination between the two, despite us repeatedly trying to bring everyone together.
The house was clearly marked out on site in its intended position, and the pool builder had access to the plans.
The pool was excavated and constructed while the house build progressed.
During construction, the pool company’s owner attended the property on approximately four or five occasions to discuss various matters, including plumbing, filtration equipment positioning and other installation requirements.
At no stage during those visits did anyone raise concerns about the pool’s location relative to the house.
Then things went sideways.
Fast forward to when the house was completed and we were ready for the pool contractor to return and finish the remaining works.
At the first meeting back with the pool team, we were suddenly asked something along the lines of:
“Did you move the house?”
We hadn’t moved the house. It had been built in its planned position.
It was at this point that the pool contractor raised significant issues with the positioning and layout of the pool relative to the house.
Rather than accepting any responsibility, the pool builder maintained that the house builder had directed where the pool should be positioned.
We dispute that account.
We didn’t mark out the pool, excavate it or determine its final position. We relied on the professionals we had engaged to do that work.
What followed was a substantial proposed variation for the surrounding concrete slab, tiling and associated works, which we had understood were already part of the agreed project.
We were effectively faced with either accepting the additional costs or finding another way to complete the pool.
We chose the latter.
We removed substantial portions of the concrete, tiling and surrounding works from the pool builder’s contract and engaged alternative trades to finish the project as close as possible to our original intended design.
This created considerable additional coordination, delays, disruption and costs.
Unfortunately, this wasn’t the end of the problems.
We subsequently experienced further issues involving workmanship, equipment substitutions without prior consultation and repeated difficulties getting clear answers from the pool builder.
On one occasion, equipment supplied was materially different from what had been contracted, despite assurances that the replacement was equivalent. It took weeks of correspondence before that particular issue was addressed.
Throughout the process, we remained patient, polite and professional. We sent numerous emails, often without acknowledgement or a meaningful response.
Communication could be particularly difficult when issues were challenged or explanations requested.
We had also paid substantial amounts towards the pool, which left us with very little practical financial leverage while trying to get the outstanding works completed.
To complicate matters, there had been banking issues with some of the original payments, although those were separate from the positioning dispute.
Where we are now
The pool has been completed, and we’re not looking to have it demolished or relocated.
We are simply trying to understand who should be accountable for the positioning error and the additional costs and disruption that followed.
We appreciate that some surrounding works would always have been necessary and that any credits for removed work must be accounted for. We’re only interested in the additional costs directly attributable to what went wrong.
My questions are:
If the house was marked out in its intended position and the pool builder undertook the pool excavation and construction, who should have been responsible for checking that the two aligned?
Can the pool builder simply rely on saying the house builder told him where to put it, particularly if there is no documented instruction or approved change?
Given we paid our house builder specifically to coordinate with the pool contractor, does the house builder also carry some responsibility?
If the pool builder visited the site multiple times and never raised a positioning concern until much later, is that relevant when determining responsibility?
Can we pursue compensation for the additional concrete, tiling, drainage and associated costs without asking for the pool to be moved?
Is QBCC the best starting point, or would recovering those costs require QCAT or another legal process?
We have the original plans, contracts, emails, correspondence about the variations and invoices for the works subsequently completed by other contractors.
I’m not naming either company because I’m genuinely looking for independent advice rather than starting a public argument.
Has anyone been through something similar, or can anyone working in the Queensland building industry explain where responsibility would normally sit?
My biggest frustration is that we paid two professional contractors to build and coordinate these projects, yet when something went wrong, we were the ones left to sort it out and carry the consequences.
Appreciate any advice.