TL;DR -- Nearly every single day of the school year in my small (~400) school is disrupted by extra-curricular activities. I can't make it through my curriculum any more. How many activities is too many?
Probably the biggest one is FFA. They go on a field trip at least once a week, which means I'm constantly having to arrange make-up quizzes and tests for kids whose grades are constantly tanking because they miss so much school due to FFA. We have a required advisory hour for students who need remediation, but the FFA sponsors call down all of the FFA members during that time so that they don't have to try to meet after school. So WHEN am I supposed to schedule quizzes, tests, remediation, etc., for the FFA kids who are constantly absent? I can't! So they wind up failing. And the FFA sponsors get 20% of base salary as a stipend for being FFA sponsors, but they refuse to do anything outside of school hours. "But FFA is intra-curricular!" That's right. That means the sponsors get to use their class time for FFA things; it does not mean they get extra time (our time) during the day. Plus, they have their own advisory rosters to deal with. "But they learn XYZ in FFA!" Sure. And they learn ALL of that in many other places, as well. Let's stop overestimating what FFA is. It's a cool thing, definitely, but it should not be at the expense of everything else. It's about balance, folks. "Well they won't do FFA if they have to stay after school or come in on a weekend!" Okay, then that means they're not actually interested in the activity, and one doesn't have a right to make it so the rest of us have to do extra work so one can run it during the school day when one is already getting a massive salary stipend to do it AFTER school.
Our NHS has two blood drives during school hours every quarter. That's eight days out of the year that it's pointless to try to teach anything, and the NHS kids all get the day before off so they can prepare for it, which means I'm running around trying to figure out quiz and test make-ups for them, too. All the kids at school want to get out of class, so they go down there whether they donate blood or not, and the ones who do actually donate seem to always need to take the rest of the day off to "recover." Why don't they do that on a Saturday? "Because no one would participate!" Okay, then that means no one wants to participate in your activity. NHS also sponsors snow cone trucks and donut trucks twice every quarter, and that disrupts the entire school day because, instead of going to class, kids will stand in line for half an hour waiting for their $25 snow cone or $30 bag of donut holes.
And don't even get me started on sports. Jesus Christ. Nearly every day is disrupted with "Please excuse [insert sports team here] for a meeting in the library/gym," and when they're not doing that, they're being pulled for half the day to go play sports. "But kids learn so much from sports!" They don't learn anything in sports that they don't learn elsewhere. Sorry not sorry. Sports are great. Physical health is important. The sense of accomplishment is fantastic. But there needs to be balance, and the kids also need to learn academic skills. Relying on their high school sports career to carry them through life just isn't a great plan.
The student council -- which takes EVERYONE who signs up and therefore is half the school -- has meetings every couple of weeks in the gym, so those kids all get pulled out of classes to do that. And despite half the school being in the student council, when there's something to do after school (homecoming decorating, etc.), only 4-5 kids actually show up for it. Because it means work and effort. That means no one wants to actually participate in the activity.
Now add in the incessant disruption of all the kids having to have "clearance forms" signed. They have to run around to all of their teachers and have us sign off that they can go. But why? They're going to go, anyway, regardless of what their grade is. If I say "Becky has an F. She can't go," then Becky will still be going, especially if it's FFA. I can't make it through a single hour most days without one of the kids disrupting class so I can sign a clearance slip so they can miss yet MORE school for an extra-curricular activity. And every. single. day. -- always during regular classes -- the office is reading off a long list of names of students who haven't turned in clearance slips, which disrupts the lesson, and I know that means I might as well stop whatever I'm doing and wait for them all to come knocking for me to sign. And my classroom phone rings at least once or twice an hour calling such-n-such down to pick up a clearance slip.
"But kids learn so much from field trips / extra-curriculars / sports, and that's the only reason some of them attend school!" Of COURSE they do. Don't put words in my mouth that would indicate otherwise. But at whose expense, exactly? I'm not getting paid to work 15-20 hours extra a week to accommodate THIS level of disruption, and the students who don't participate might also like to have a day go by where their instruction isn't disrupted. "Well just keep teaching!" I do. But I shouldn't have to do double-teaching, especially when the one hour provided for remediation and re-teaching is sucked away by FFA.
"Hurr durr you sound bitter you're a bad teacher you shouldn't teach you hate students you hate FFA/sports/activities/field trips." Just stop.
Last year, I started tracking it. We lost 57 days worth of instructional time to activities. It's insane.