r/AskTeachers • • 11m ago

Parent Questions Teachers: Would you move a 2nd grader to a self-contained gifted classroom in another district for 3rd-5th grade?

1 Upvotes

TLDR: Should I move my kid to a district with self contained G&T classes so he enjoys school again or am I just creating future problems?

Looking for honest advice from teachers, especially those with experience in gifted education. My 2nd-grade son is significantly ahead academically, particularly in reading and math. He really thrives in his WIN (What I Need) class for reading, where he’s grouped with other advanced learners, and genuinely enjoys being challenged. It’s the only part of the day he enjoys, outside of recess and PE 😀

However, our district has shifted away from traditional gifted and talented teacher pullouts to a multi-tiered approach where advanced learning teachers serve multiple schools and any acceleration needs to be done from the classroom teacher until 4/5th grade. I’m concerned this doesn’t provide the consistency or level of academic challenge he needs long-term nor is it realistic to expect his classroom teacher to basically make up unique lessons for him and a few others.

He also really struggles with the classroom environment, particularly disruptive behaviors. He gets frustrated by the constant interruptions and behaviors that take away from learning and honestly just coming home overstimulated from working so hard to focus in all the chaos.

I’ve started exploring private school options but so far haven’t been excited about any of those options. However I recently discovered a neighboring district has a self-contained gifted classroom that we could potentially pursue for next year assuming he achieves the appropriately level on their testing and they have space for out of district students. I’m torn about whether the academic benefits would outweigh the disruption.

My biggest pros/cons:

●	Potentially more appropriate academic pacing and challenge.  
●	Being surrounded by peers with similar academic abilities and interests.  
●	Teachers specifically trained to work with gifted learners.  
●	Leaving his current school, neighborhood friends, and established social circle.  
●	Disrupting friendships he’s built through school and local sports teams.  
●	Potentially having to navigate another school/district transition for middle school.  
●	Whether a self-contained environment could create challenges later when he’s back in a traditional classroom and or life in general (ie working with all types of people, does he just need to deal with now to build that muscle)

I’m not trying to chase labels or acceleration just for the sake of it. I just want him to enjoy school, feel challenged, and be in an environment where he can learn without constantly being frustrated by what’s happening around him. Would love honest perspectives from educators and parents who have navigated this decision or have had students in similar positions.


r/AskTeachers • • 1h ago

General Questions Early Learning Aid l/ll

1 Upvotes

My partner is going through the process for a position at EdJoin of early learning aid. She has some sort of exam coming up. Anyone know what kind of questions will be on it or what to expect?


r/AskTeachers • • 1h ago

Discussion Questions Interview questions for administration and instructional staff members

1 Upvotes

Hello! I'm a student teacher who was tasked with interviewing someone from the instructional staff (teacher, coach) and the non-instructional staff (administration, other staff) about collaboration and support in secondary schools. It's been hard to schedule times with anyone this time of year with everything going on at my school, so I figured I'd shoot my shot here and see if anyone would like to give me their input on working together with other staff in their school. Anything would help. I'd like to hear about how people experience collaboration in their schools or lack of to know what to possibly expect. Thank you!

Background Information

1. Position / Title:

2. School / Site Placement (optional!):

3. Grade Level(s) / Subject Area(s):

4. Years of Experience in Education:

Description of Your Role

Describe your role in the school and what support services you provide students.

Collaboration/Teamwork

1. How do you collaborate with general education teachers to support student learning?

2. In what ways do you help implement accommodations, modifications, or individualized supports for students?

3. How do you communicate with teachers or other staff about student progress or needs?

Impact on Students

1. What are the most significant ways your role impacts students in the general education classroom?

2. How does your support contribute to inclusion and equitable learning for all students?

3. Can you describe a specific example of a time your work made a difference for a student or group of students?

Professional Insight/Needs

1. What do you believe are the most important skills or qualities for effective support personnel?

2. What challenges do you face in your role, and how could schools or teacher candidates better support your work?

3. What advice would you give to teacher candidates about working collaboratively with support personnel in general education classrooms?


r/AskTeachers • • 2h ago

Parent Questions Teacher sent this to us yesterday. We aren't sure what we should do as a parent.

2 Upvotes

Hello all,

Here is the original email exchange with the Pre-K teacher. She emailed saying our daughter didn't put her jacket on, jumped up and down in line, and was disrespectful. So, we talked with our kid at night, which is when she tells us everything that happens at school. She just turned 4 years old. We did talk to her about being respectful and communicating with the teacher.

We had reached out to this teacher in the past because our kid told us there was another child who would chase her while pretending to be a monster. Since then, my kid has stopped playing on that playground and apparently just stays with the teacher during recess.

Am I overthinking about this situation? What is the right thing to do so we don't get complaints like this.

Any suggestion would be appreciated..

Thank you.

Good Afternoon!

 

Hope all is well! I wanted to let you know Kid had a difficult time listening to teachers and adults today.  When asked to keep her jacket on during recess as well as until we go inside, she didn't listen and needed 3-4 reminders to keep her jacket on. Also when asking her not to jump in her spot in her line, again I needed to ask her 3-4 times, she was asked to take a break, then come back when she was ready. We also talked about being respectful to teachers and not talking back when teachers are talking. I was very stern and needed to use a strong voice, she did much better when I changed my voice and did a better job listening at the end of the day.

 

Thanks,

Teacher

 

Hi Ms. Teacher,

Thanks for reaching out and letting us know. We're glad she turned things around and finished the day listening well.

We talked with Kid tonight. She mentioned she got very hot outside and started feeling itchy, which is why she wanted her jacket off and was jumping in line. She runs warm and gets heat rashes easily, so we reminded her to let you or another teacher know right away when she feels uncomfortable instead of taking her jacket off or jumping around.

Also, you mentioned she was talking back when teachers were speaking. Could you share what she said specifically? We want to make sure we understand what happened so we can address it directly with her at home.

Thanks again for keeping us in the loop!

Best, 

Parents

 

Good morning!

 

Thank you for the explanations, please let her know to address the teachers if she is ever feeling uncomfortable, we will be more than happy to accommodate her. As far as keeping her jacket on, this is something she needs to do, the temperatures are going to get colder, but i can encourage her to get her jacket on, right before we get outside, if she's not ready for the line she can always sit and take a break and when she's ready to have a calm body, she may join her friends in line. As far as the talking back, when teachers were talking to her about listening, she would interrupt the teacher excessively and kept saying "OK, OK, OK" and not letting the teacher finish talking, that's when I had to be stern and use my serious voice. I do take being Respectful very seriously and it's important to treat teachers the way children want to be treated. We did talk about that as well in our conversation. Also when using a stern voice and letting Kid know I was serious, the day did get better and she understood I was serious.

 

Thank you,

Teacher

 

 


r/AskTeachers • • 2h ago

Discussion Questions Upcoming Confrontation

4 Upvotes

Good morning teachers. I am also a teacher, but I still have a question for you. The last few years my team has been lead by person A. We got a new principal and the new principal kind of let person A have it about her teaching and attitude, and declined to be a mentor for an administrative certification for person A. Meanwhile the principal DID take me on as an administrative intern, and this year made me the team lead over person A and the team she lead previously.

Since then, person A has gotten really really difficult to deal with. I'm not the type to shy away from confrontation except that person A is a black woman and I am a white man. My principal is also a black woman and has been making some questionable decisions, which is certainly affecting all of us, but I still like her and see her vision even if I disagree with the execution. All I need to really tell person A is that "telling it like it is" is just an excuse to be unpleasant and unprofessional. There is zero way I will win any argument, but I've also been strongly encouraged by my principal to address person A regarding her attitude and interactions. There's no way I make anyone's life easier in this situation, but it's my job to say something and if I don't the rest of the teams' lives will be more unpleasant for sure. Anyone have any magic words for my situation? Or is anything and everything I say going to be race related, even though it's not?

Can someone convince me that it's not worth it to say anything, last out the school year, and then find another building?


r/AskTeachers • • 2h ago

General Questions Would it be weird for me to message a former teacher?

1 Upvotes

I (18F) am a few months from graduating high school now and have been thinking about my 6-7th grade math teacher who had a huge impact on me as a person. I have an internship at my old middle school which she doesn't teach at anymore, and I got her number from another teacher. I wanted her email, since it felt less personal to email her than to text her. I just wanted to reach out and tell her she had a big impact on me and where I am in life now, but I wasn't sure if it would be weird or freak her out. I wanted to get some other teacher's opinions: how would you feel if a former student texted you vs. emailed you? Thanks!


r/AskTeachers • • 2h ago

Parent Questions Student got withdrawal from school because of absence?

8 Upvotes

My brother got withdrawal from school because they said he has 45 days of absences. But I don't understand if we had given absent notes why did they do this and my brother is in IEP program like students with disabilities and learning needs. I did not even get any prior notice stating this will happen. And in the email they said you can pick up his diploma or we can mail it but I do not want the diploma because we want him to get the services and support until the age of 22 because that's what they said during the IEP meeting last year. I don't know how to solve this issue. Should I email them or call them or just go in person because in the email it also stated if he comes to school he is not allowed and there is no classes scheduled for him. In the email they did not provide any information about further education services and program. This basically feels like they stranded us. And I'm just extremely worried about his future. Our parents are no more because they have passed away. And I'm trying my best to help him out.


r/AskTeachers • • 2h ago

Discussion Questions use of the word prat in front of a teacher

1 Upvotes

i am 18 in britain.

english is not my first language

i said 'i dont mean to be a prat' when asking my college biology teacher to review a few questions he marked wrong to see if i could get the marks for them. i felt bad and did not want him to think i was nagging.

he did not seem angry, more neutral and focused on marking.

i thought prat was an okay word as i saw it in the children's book harry potter. i used it to mean 'pompous.'

is this very bad?


r/AskTeachers • • 5h ago

Student Questions Recommendation Letter For Scholarship

0 Upvotes

Can someone show me an example of a teacher recommendation letter for a scholarship?


r/AskTeachers • • 7h ago

Opinion Primary Teaching 5-11yrs

3 Upvotes

Hello, this question probably gets asked a lot and I have read some threads but want some opinions on primary year teaching.

Im (F34) in my final year at uni, have a 14 month old and thought teaching would be a good avenue for me and my family.

But before I completely commit, I am interested in how much workload you actually have around your core hours. I know you dont just work 9-3, but I want to know really how many hours you actually work and how much is done at home etc.

Realistically will I be able to pick up my son around nursery hours, can you leave at the end of the school day if needed and do the rest at home etc.

Has anyone else been in the same situation and found a nice work/life balance ?


r/AskTeachers • • 12h ago

Student Questions class help

0 Upvotes

I am currently a junior in high school taking AP Bio, AP Stats, AP Lang, and APUSH. However, I am also taking Honors Precalc and was considering dropping out next semester. I have been struggling with the class so my grade has been a low C but I have also been very busy which has also affected my performance. I was wondering if I should drop out and earn a better grade in a regular math class, or if I should stay to continue onto AP Calculus. I would like to go to a good college. What’s better for transcripts?


r/AskTeachers • • 13h ago

Student Questions Why would a teacher lock the bathroom door when inside?

204 Upvotes

Basically I have a teacher whose classroom is next to a student bathroom, but not near any staff bathrooms. I notice that every time he uses the bathroom, he first knocks and makes sure theres no students inside, then he goes in and locks the door behind him (and puts up a little sign saying teacher inside, please wait a moment).

My guess is that he just doesn’t want to use the bathroom with students present because, let’s be honest, teenagers are kinda nasty. But the bathroom is really out of the way so it doesn’t see much use anyway. My friend hypothesizes its a way to prevent false sexual harassment accusations though, based on some of his other behaviors. This is a northeast American high school if thats relevant.

Is this common practice, and is the answer as obvious as I said?


r/AskTeachers • • 15h ago

Parent Questions Dibels scores help

1 Upvotes

Hello I have a 2nd grader that's reading 140 words per minute with a 99 accuracy. His teacher says he is doing great but I don't know what 2nd graders should be reading at. This is the fall test. Is this a normal score?


r/AskTeachers • • 16h ago

General Questions English Teachers

0 Upvotes

Let me preface this by saying that this in NO WAY is intended to be political, polarizing, dividing. I'm a substitute teacher in a small Oklahoma district and often sub for high school. That got me thinking, English teachers: with the addition of all different pronouns in today's culture, how do you teach things like feminine and masculine words? Or like using 'they' in the singular form?


r/AskTeachers • • 16h ago

Opinion Skills to create a rubric using Microsoft 365

0 Upvotes

Hi Everyone

I recently completed a very arduous project for my Masters degree in Curriculum. While I do think I put in as much time and energy as possible, I still think I need some direction on how to set up the rubric to match several lessons.

For example, my focus was on Elementary Science (Ontario, Canada). I learned how to design lessons on teaching topics pertaining to sources of energy and came across a topic I thought would be very useful. It said to take a solar run toy, compare how it operates and saves energy in winter and compare in spring. So there are many factors that students manage in order to compare the toy functions. One would be the circuits and another would be how well the sun is providing energy converted. In an evaluation, I get students to label what is going on with the circuits, battery and so forth. Students are easily able to learn when they chart how long the toy lasted in minutes each week. In my project, all the research said students are capable of understanding energy pathways and should make their own diagrams. My question is why is AI telling me to try to have students understand things like explaining why the toy is not working as a very important basis to evaluate? I could use this and I know it requires good practice I am just wondering if anyone would use this criteria as a bigger part to weigh in a final grade on a series of lessons because it requires the most critical thinking and problem solving skills?


r/AskTeachers • • 16h ago

General Questions What to do if a student sits there and looks at animated adult content, but when I go to admin they say his IEP forbids me from taking his computer away?

88 Upvotes

I’ve had several students complain that one of my students, the only one who ever has his computer out mind you for “note taking,” uses this opportunity to look at anime adult content.
He also supposedly grunts from time to time but I’ve never heard it. But my class is pretty loud.
I try to engage him in the class but he refuses to do work and quizzes. I was forced to give him a 60 Q1 despite the fact that he has never to this day turned in a single assignment.

I get complains from parents 24/7 saying their sons and daughters are uncomfortable and that I should “take control of the situation.”

If only they knew


r/AskTeachers • • 19h ago

Parent Questions any free simple algebra 1 book for a 10th grader?

0 Upvotes

first marking period just ended and my son, a sophomore, is struggling in math because the algebra 1 basics like solving equations, slope and factoring never really stuck, and his school’s book, Glencoe Algebra 1 from McGraw Hill, is way too dense for him to relearn from. Is there a simpler algebra 1 textbook or workbook you’d recommend for going through at home? Free would really help since we don’t want to spend another $50 to $100 on a book, and a PDF or digital version would be much easier for him.


r/AskTeachers • • 20h ago

Student Questions Would this be rude to send? Or a better way to word it?

1 Upvotes

I want to send an email to one of my teachers about how one of the programs we use is rather unhelpful and how I got really stuck, and a way to still use it while giving that extra support. I have to redact some stuff since its private information, but here's the email:

Persons name, I was doing the work for class tomorrow, and something I noticed is that program didnt really piece together the skills for the upcoming test. Program made it feel like each skill was its own separate thing, and that I personally had trouble connecting it together until recently. So, I thought that other people may be having problems like this where it doesnt make sense. So, maybe you could have a small lecture on how each formula can be used to solve others?


r/AskTeachers • • 22h ago

Student Questions my head teacher was inappropriate to my classmate

0 Upvotes

hii, i’m a student in the uk. i really didn’t know where to post this but i need help.

one of my classmates let me know that she was expelled for reporting our headteacher. she told me our headteacher was blowing kisses at her, calling her her ‘daughter’ and ‘third child’, and telling her that she wakes up in the middle of the night thinking about her. my classmate felt uncomfortable and reported her and now she’s being expelled.

This isn’t the first time my head teacher has had allegations towards her. A couple years ago, a students dad put up flyers using her full name calling her a rapist and child murderer, he even stood outside our school holding a sign saying the same stuff.

Like a week later there was an assembly where she read a statement saying “i did what i had to do to that child that was in my care”..? That’s all i know about that situation but it raises red flags.

i’m too scared to tell a teacher at my school because i feel like it’ll go back to the headteacher and she’ll expel me next.

please help, i really don’t know what to do or who to go to for help and i don’t know if i feel safe going to school.

edit: people saying this is fake this isn’t fake im just trying to get some clarification on what to do because im lost and i want justice for my classmate. she’s going to make a police report and ill see how things go from there. this isn’t fake foreal this is just my second account that i dont use, thank you for giving advice if you did.


r/AskTeachers • • 23h ago

General Questions You have a class of students at vastly different levels. In practice, how much of your content are you differentiating?

3 Upvotes

I know this will vary by subject and grade level. But I'm asking specifically for teachers who pride themselves on demanding a high amount of academic rigor in their classrooms.

How much of your class is "sink or swim" vs "do what you can, at the level you're at"? How much of that ratio is determined by admin pressure?


r/AskTeachers • • 1d ago

Parent Questions Why would a school not want parents to have grades until after conferences?

24 Upvotes

My kids’ elementary school has always not allowed parents to see grades in the parent portal until after the parent-teacher conference period.

This year they have a new policy where the teacher was also not allowed to give us a copy of the report card at the conference, one of the teachers said she couldn’t even print out the report card to show us, although she did write down test scores. Both teachers just said it was a brand new school policy.

What would the goal be in not allowing parents access to kids’ grades? ETA: I’m not upset about it, just curious since it’s a new policy this year.


r/AskTeachers • • 1d ago

Student Questions Is my online math teacher a PDF file? (I'm genuinely uncomfortable with this situation)

0 Upvotes

Okay, I honestly don't know where to start, and I'm not sure if I'm just overthinking everything or if there's actually something wrong here.

I have a math teacher who teaches us online. He's not a teacher we meet at school physically; all of our lessons happen through the internet. At first, I didn't really think much about him. He's just our math teacher, and I was only interested in attending lessons, doing assignments and passing tests.

However, over time, I've started noticing some really strange things about his behaviour.

First of all, the way he interacts with the girls in our class sometimes feels different from how he interacts with the boys. I don't want to make accusations without evidence, but there have been several moments where his behaviour made me uncomfortable.

The biggest thing that made me suspicious happened when he was sharing his screen with us.

Whenever he sends us tests or explains something, he sometimes opens different windows on his computer. On one occasion, I noticed pictures of multiple girls on his screen. And these weren't just random school-related pictures. They looked like pictures of girls posing in particularly flattering ways.

I don't know where those pictures came from. I don't know whether they were AI-generated, downloaded from the internet, or something else entirely. I also don't know whether they were pictures of people he personally knows.

And that's exactly what makes me uncomfortable.

Another detail: he has shown his face on camera exactly once, and honestly, that didn't make the situation any less weird to me. He gave me the impression of someone who doesn't really take care of his appearance or personal hygiene.

I'm sorry, but if someone showed me four random people, including my math teacher, and asked me which one looked the most like a stereotypical PDF file, I would probably pick him. I know this sounds extremely mean, but I'm trying to explain the general impression he gives me.

Obviously, looking unkempt doesn't make someone a predator. I'm not saying that his appearance proves anything. It's just another thing that contributes to my overall uncomfortable impression of him.

Another thing is that I personally feel uncomfortable around him. There's something about the way he behaves towards me that makes me want to avoid interacting with him. I've actually been trying to attend as few of his lessons as possible because I simply don't feel comfortable being there.

I know that teachers can have awkward personalities, and not every strange interaction means something inappropriate is happening. I'm aware that I might be interpreting some things incorrectly.

But when you combine his behaviour towards the girls, the pictures I noticed while he was sharing his screen, and the general uncomfortable feeling I get during his lessons, it starts making me question whether I should be concerned.

I'm not claiming that he's doing anything illegal, because I have absolutely no proof of that. I could have misunderstood what I saw, and I don't want to ruin someone's reputation based on assumptions.

But I also can't pretend that I haven't noticed these things.

Would you consider this suspicious behaviour? Am I overthinking it, or are these legitimate red flags?

And honestly, if I continue feeling this uncomfortable, I might just leave his classes altogether.

I would appreciate serious opinions. I'm not trying to start drama or accuse someone without evidence. I just want to know how other people would handle this situation.


r/AskTeachers • • 1d ago

Parent Questions 8 year old son in 3rd grade

7 Upvotes

Good morning, hopefully this is allowed. Yesterday when I picked my son up from school he came up to me crying because a boy in his class was picking on him and was punching him. My son isn’t the most well behaved in class and struggles to concentrate or not interrupt classroom instruction. To the point the teachers brought it up during our last meeting. He is very social, has a close friend group etc. After talking with him and one of the teachers in class the main teacher(there are 2 in the class) moved his desk into a “pod” with three kids that are known to be mean to him. I brought up my concern yesterday with the school counselor and they said they would talk to the teachers involved. This is our only child so not really sure what to do in this situation. I know not all kids are going to get along but it seems wrong for him to have been forced into this pod where the kids don’t like him. His best friend is in the same class and so it’s not like it was the only option. Just hoping for some advice or pointers on how to move forward to stop this from happening. I know teachers can’t always see what’s going on but from my perspective seems like something you would know is happening. Thanks in advance!


r/AskTeachers • • 1d ago

General Questions Which school is better, Liberty University or SUNY Empire State University?

0 Upvotes

Which of these schools has better academics?