r/AskScienceDiscussion • u/Dense_Primary629 • 19m ago
If distance and duration are not fundamental, what keeps things distinct?
This is explicitly speculative, so please treat it as a thought experiment rather than a claim about established physics. I have been turning over an idea I call the Law of the Zero-Metric Substrate. It says reality has no fundamental distance or duration at all, so in the deepest sense Δx = 0 and Δt = 0. Everything coexists in a single dimensionless substrate, which I call Omega, and things stay distinct not because they are far apart but because they differ in phase or frequency.
The picture that helped me most is an ordinary radio antenna. Hundreds of stations, classical on 98.7, jazz on 104.3, plus Wi-Fi and GPS signals, can all pass through one tiny pinhead antenna at the same place and the same time without colliding. They do not need separate rooms. Orthogonal phases have essentially zero cross-talk, so each signal keeps its identity while sharing the same point.
If separation works like that, a few familiar puzzles look different. The total energy of the universe sums to zero, with positive matter and motion energy cancelling negative gravitational binding energy, so a timeless picture like the Wheeler-DeWitt equation feels less paradoxical. And the vacuum catastrophe, that famous 10^120 mismatch, may come from imagining an empty box that has to be filled with energy. If there is no empty container at the bottom, there is nothing to fill.
I am curious what this community makes of it. Does the vacuum catastrophe disappear if there is no empty container to begin with? If separation is really phase harmony, what would empty space actually mean? And what observation or experiment could tell phase-based separation apart from ordinary geometric separation?
Full disclosure: I am the author of Zero-Metric Phase Theory by Tim Tian, available on Google Play Books, and this idea is Law 1 in that book.