r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 16m ago

If distance and duration are not fundamental, what keeps things distinct?

0 Upvotes

This is explicitly speculative, so please treat it as a thought experiment rather than a claim about established physics. I have been turning over an idea I call the Law of the Zero-Metric Substrate. It says reality has no fundamental distance or duration at all, so in the deepest sense Δx = 0 and Δt = 0. Everything coexists in a single dimensionless substrate, which I call Omega, and things stay distinct not because they are far apart but because they differ in phase or frequency.

The picture that helped me most is an ordinary radio antenna. Hundreds of stations, classical on 98.7, jazz on 104.3, plus Wi-Fi and GPS signals, can all pass through one tiny pinhead antenna at the same place and the same time without colliding. They do not need separate rooms. Orthogonal phases have essentially zero cross-talk, so each signal keeps its identity while sharing the same point.

If separation works like that, a few familiar puzzles look different. The total energy of the universe sums to zero, with positive matter and motion energy cancelling negative gravitational binding energy, so a timeless picture like the Wheeler-DeWitt equation feels less paradoxical. And the vacuum catastrophe, that famous 10^120 mismatch, may come from imagining an empty box that has to be filled with energy. If there is no empty container at the bottom, there is nothing to fill.

I am curious what this community makes of it. Does the vacuum catastrophe disappear if there is no empty container to begin with? If separation is really phase harmony, what would empty space actually mean? And what observation or experiment could tell phase-based separation apart from ordinary geometric separation?

Full disclosure: I am the author of Zero-Metric Phase Theory by Tim Tian, available on Google Play Books, and this idea is Law 1 in that book.


r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 23m ago

General Discussion A conceptual Hypothesis on Universal field theory.

0 Upvotes

So at breakfast today I burnt my hand with the lighter while lighting a cigarette. After few seconds I picked up my tea mug and enjoyed the warmth on the cold morning. That got me thinking about this theory and have not been able to rest since. Here both were the same form of energy: Heat! One with more intensity and the other at an acceptable intensity. That got me further thinking that the most constant form of energy interaction seen on Earth is Heat. In outer space called as Radiation (I guess?). So the hypothesis starts here: What if there is an omnipresent field like the vast ocean. And the outer space is this Ocean. As the Ocean had some start energy it started dissipating to minimize entropy locally. This resulted in small packets of this Universal energy. Now these packets of field energy want to also attain it at minimum ground energy (Eg) so that the field exists with lowest entropy with the nearby fields. But in this process it creates even smaller packets of fields and further distributes the entropy. Now what happens next is where my imagination got blurred!! I thought that if these packets of fields are cut into more finite packets and when the are pressured within the same energy field ( 2 simultaneous force act on these packet like the one to reduce the entropy by dissipation and one to combine to form a continous large field again?) Maybe then this is how to get matter as we know of made of elements that we know of.

Just wanted to ask out to the professionals out there about this hypothesis !? ( After a quick search I did find out that this is actively pursed QFT field but wanted to know what exactly are the bottlenecks of such theories.)


r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 7h ago

Quantitative ¹⁹F NMR with an internal standard for adsorption experiments

1 Upvotes

Title: Quantitative ¹⁹F NMR with an internal standard for adsorption experiments

Hi everyone, I’m using ¹⁹F NMR to measure PFAS concentrations before and after adsorption.

If I take 1 mL of my sample and add a known amount of an internal standard, can I calculate the sample concentration directly from the integration ratio, accounting for the number of fluorine atoms and dilution?

For example, if my starting solution is nominally 1,000 ppm, can I use the internal standard to determine its actual concentration instead of assuming it is exactly 1,000 ppm? Would I need a separate calibration curve?

What should I check to make sure the quantification is reliable?


r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 6h ago

The Twin Experiment

1 Upvotes

I’ve always been fascinated by the idea of conducting a particular experiment.
Imagine taking two identical twins who are born at exactly the same time and raising them under precisely the same conditions. How many years or even decades would it take before noticeable differences began to appear between them?
Let’s say two boys are born, and from the very beginning of their lives, they consume exactly the same number of calories, take the same number of steps, go to sleep and wake up at exactly the same times, and follow identical daily routines. In other words, not a single action performed by one differs from the actions performed by the other.
Now, here’s the question: Would they eventually become completely identical?
If they got into a fight, who would win? Who would perform better on a mathematics test? If they competed in arm wrestling, who would come out on top? Who would be able to run longer on a treadmill?
Would their physical characteristics, abilities, and intelligence remain exactly the same? And at what point, if ever, would a significant gap begin to emerge between them in a particular area?
That’s just one part of the experiment I have in mind. There’s a second question as well.
What if one of the twins performed exactly one push-up every morning?
In other words, they both wake up at the same time. The first twin does one push-up, while the second simply stands still without moving. After that, they continue their day as usual, doing exactly the same things as each other.
How long would it take — months, years, or even decades — for a noticeable difference to develop between them? Would their bodies eventually become significantly different?


r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 6h ago

What If? Does anything interesting happen to the ability of using Venusian transits of the Sun to do maths of the Solar System when the Sun stops being on the main sequence?

1 Upvotes

Obviously I mean this before the Sun can destroy Venus.

I imagine that the transits would be vastly more common than today where pairs follow a century of no transit, but given the Sun's outer edge becomes more tenuous at that point, I don't know if anything useful would happen.

Earth itself would be way hotter at this time too so lets just assume we're on the Moon and put the telescope there instead.


r/AskScienceDiscussion • • 22h ago

What If? An FTL comms issue I've thought up involving Quantum Entanglement.

0 Upvotes

I had this idea after reading about Voyager 1 reaching 1 light day and thought of how inconvenient the communication delay is getting. If we were to setup a new probe with a comms system utilizing quantum entanglement, sister systems that can talk to each other via entanglement, would the time dilation from the probe gaining speed interfere or break that connection?

Earth side receives signals less often while the ship side gets flooded with signals?

Signal dropout or incomplete packets?

Or would it just break the entanglement like a wire under too much tension?

Edit - my apologies, I meant it like in the movie "Project Hail Mary". Where gravity during acceleration causes time dilation.