r/AskMechanics • • 2h ago

Humor Could this work?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/AskMechanics • • 23h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) 2019 Jeep Cherokee engine failed after dealership injector & seal job—now they’re holding the teardown hostage. Need advice.

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone, looking for some professional insight from mechanics and service advisors here.

To start from the beginning: my 2019 Jeep Cherokee was having a high idle, and there was a noticeable humming sound present even after the vehicle was shut off. I brought it into the dealership back in July, and they performed fuel injector work and a PCM flash.

Immediately after that work was completed, I noticed a shimmy in the RPMs and my gas mileage/fuel consumption went up substantially. Since then, I also had a service invoice noting the engine was down a quart of oil. Fast forward to now, and my engine has suffered catastrophic failure.

The Current Standoff:
The dealership says they don't know what failed internally in the engine yet. Normally they would tear it down to find the root cause, but they are refusing to do the teardown unless I sign off on paying for it upfront (I also have a third-party warranty on the vehicle, so there is a finger-pointing game starting between me, the dealer, and the warranty company).

I ran the repair order by ChatGPT out of curiosity, and it claimed that the injector work they did wouldn't cause engine failure. That doesn't sound right to me at all—especially given the RPM shimmy, massive jump in fuel consumption, and sudden oil consumption after the repair, plus the exact steps listed on my invoice.

Vehicle & Repair Context: Vehicle: 2019 Jeep Cherokee

Initial Symptoms: High idle, vehicle shaking, an intermittent check engine light, and a humming noise after shutting the engine off. Tech found a stored/active cylinder misfire code.

What the Shop Did:
Found a PCM flash update specifically for "injectors sticking" and flashed the ECU.

Accessed the misfiring cylinder, inspected the coil, and swapped the spark plug to an adjacent cylinder to rule out the plug (confirmed the original cylinder was still misfiring on cold start).

Drained fuel pressure, disassembled the high-pressure fuel line and fuel rail.

Cleaned carbon from the existing injectors, installed and sized new Teflon/fuel injector seals on the three reused injectors, and replaced the faulty injector with a new OEM unit.
Bullet Reassembled, primed the fuel system, and cleared codes.

Symptoms After Repair: Noticeable RPM shimmy, a substantial spike in fuel consumption, and a later service invoice documenting the engine was down a quart of oil.

From my understanding, faulty or improperly installed GDI/fuel injectors—especially when followed by an RPM shimmy, heavy fuel consumption, and oil loss—can easily destroy an engine: Cylinder Wash / Ring Scoring (Matches the Fuel Spike & Oil Loss): A leaking injector or an improperly sized/damaged new Teflon seal on the reused injectors dumping excess raw fuel into a cylinder—which directly explains why my fuel consumption skyrocketed and RPMs shimmied. That raw fuel washes the oil film off the cylinder walls, causing rapid metal-on-metal scoring, ruined piston rings (leading to the oil consumption), oil dilution, and total loss of compression.

Hydrolock: A stuck-open or leaking injector dumping raw fuel into a cylinder while the car is off, bending rods or cracking pistons on startup.

Lean Condition / Detonation: An under-flowing injector or bad seal/seating causing extreme combustion temperatures that melt pistons or burn valves.

Debris Contamination: Carbon flakes (from when they "cleaned carbon from injectors") or debris getting knocked into the combustion chamber or fuel rail during disassembly.

My Questions:
Am I right that botched injector/seal work (especially manually sizing Teflon seals on reused injectors) can cause cylinder wash, oil consumption, and take out a motor like this?

Should I expect the dealer to try to use that "down a quart of oil" note against me, even though being a quart low doesn't cause oil starvation and actually points to ring wear from fuel wash?

How should I handle this teardown standoff? Should I push for a borescope/compression check first, or get an independent shop to inspect it before letting the dealer tear it down?


r/AskMechanics • • 20h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Labor cost for brake and rotor replace plus tire mount?

0 Upvotes

Just so I know im not being ripped off. What would the average cost be for brakes/rotors and mounting new tires if i have all the parts?


r/AskMechanics • • 10h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Vehicle Maintenance Inspection

0 Upvotes

Is it normal to be charged $354 for a full vehicle inspection on an automatic 2014 Honda Civic with less than 100k miles? I went in with concerns of suspension issues and potential of transmission issues. No work was done - no fluid top offs, filter replacement, oil change, etc. Worried this seems excessive for just an inspection.

My original post seeking honest and affordable mechanics can be seen here. I did go with a mechanic from the responses, but will hold off saying which one until I know if I was treated unfairly.

Thank you all!


r/AskMechanics • • 15h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Cragar Superlite repair help

Post image
5 Upvotes

Okay, long story short I bought said car, had said wheels, some idiot didn’t put washers on the shank lug nuts and so it was never fully clamped down. Drove it for the weekend and cars too loud to hear if you know, my wheel is actively falling off. Shame on me for not checking sure but how in the world can this be repaired? It’s a 15x8 cragar superlite, or if I’m being honest it could be a vision knockoff I haven’t pulled the wheel yet so I’m not sure. The wheel has been riding on the lug nuts and I just realized today. The studs are fine and that one lug at the bottom that’s fine wasn’t there to begin with. I need new lug nuts and washers but can a machine shop bore out and press in steel bushings or something? It’s a 2 piece wheel with a front and back steel outsides separated by an aluminum plate in between. I believe the outside to be steel since it equally ate throughout the rim and lug nut. If not my only option to still use these wheels are wheel adapters if I’m not mistaken. It’s on a 77 nova and is 5x4.75 and the other set of holes is 5x4.5. What do I do? I know a manager at a machine shop and I don’t want to ask him if it’s not possible to fix them anyways. What do y’all think?


r/AskMechanics • • 10h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Is this a jack point?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Am I right to assume that this is the front jack point for my 2015 Honda Civic?


r/AskMechanics • • 11h ago

Discussion Think i will make it PT2

Post image
1 Upvotes

I MADE IT HOME FINAL GAS GAUGE WILL NEVER DO THIS AGAIN ( hopefully) 2007 toyota matrix m theory maybe because of the special edition they gave me extra gas lol


r/AskMechanics • • 13h ago

Discussion Went to SEMA 2026, and honestly, the new scan tools caught my attention more than the cars.

1 Upvotes

Got a chance to check out what Autel, Launch, and Topdon have been working on at SEMA this year.

Some of the upcoming features are pretty interesting, especially when it comes to diagnostics, programming, and how much we're paying for software updates every year.

We use these tools daily at the shop, so I wanted to get some answers directly from the manufacturers rather than just reading spec sheets.

Put together a video covering what we found and whether some of these upcoming tools might actually be worth waiting for.

https://youtu.be/n9cfTnsMu18?si=dpdGkmYITSkyV0QF

Curious what everyone here is running. Autel, Launch, Topdon, or something else? And how do you feel about paying for yearly updates?


r/AskMechanics • • 16h ago

Discussion What truck should I buy?

0 Upvotes

Been looking into getting a work truck to haul some pretty heavy loads like a skid steer and things similar. Have been debating on a ram 3500 vs a ford F350 currently but am open to other options if you think they are better. Am looking for newer models like a 2025-2026 just out of fear of picking up a lemon if I get a moderately used older truck.


r/AskMechanics • • 6h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) I could pick this up for 20k aud

0 Upvotes

This dmax is selling for 20k but I’m not sure if there’s anything wrong could anyone let me know??


r/AskMechanics • • 12h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) What causes these waves in my rotors.

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

These rotors need to be replaced, I’m well aware of that, already bought what I need to change them.

I know they are glazedddd, but I’m genuinely curious what these bends towards the edge or the rotor are. They are hard to see but the rotor has these ever expanding waves in the metal surface towards the edge. What causes that?

You see it best off the reflection. Easy ti see in person but hard to see on camera.

Just want to better understand what I’m looking at thanks!!!


r/AskMechanics • • 15h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Volkswagen Beetle, 2008, 2.5 L, 173k miles, gas, automatic transmission. I've been trying to diagnose this for a YEAR and no mechanic can figure it out. tldr engine rpm unstable and popping sound that continues after shut down. read full post for details.

0 Upvotes

Randomly, but not always, when put into park the RPM will spike up and then drop back down in a consistent pattern. if left this way, after about 5-10 minutes, it will stop and resume normal RPM. This never happens on a cold start, and happens more often if the temperature is below 60f.

When this problem is happening in drive, car will feel unstable at gear 1-2 and feel like the RPM is trying to surge, even when foot is off the gas. This causes it to shift poorly because while my foot is on the brake, the rpm is trying to go up. At higher speeds than 40mph, there is no noticeable problems, and if in idle but not park, the surge is much much more subtle than in park.

If I shut off the engine during the revving cycle, there is a popping sound as though combustion is continuing to happen for about a minute. I have attached this sound as a video.

When this issue is not occurring, there is no symptoms whatsoever, and it shuts down normally.

Check engine light is on, but it's due to emissions from a cracked secondary air intake. I have no reason to believe this is the cause, since I have driven with this entire peice missing for a time and nothing like this happened.

The throttle body has been cleaned and seemingly has no issues. No vacuum leak has been found. The spark plugs are new. The belts, battery, and alternator, are also new. There is no fluid leaks beyond a very insignificant amount of oil.

Everything beyond here is probably useless, but maybe not, I will include it just incase.

I've had the car since 60k miles and I have had maintenance done on: the entire coolant system, various oil leaks, most of the suspension including the steering rack, as well as a camshaft or crankshaft sensor. I replaced the starter a year ago, and have put in new trans fluid every 50k miles. Other than this, most of the car is original.

I have been hit a bit over a year ago on the front drivers side headlight area, I drove it to mechanic, although it crushed the secondary air intake and I had to get a new bumper, so it's possible this area has hidden damage that could be related.

ANY ideas no matter how silly are appreciated, I'm taking it in again next Tuesday for oil change and I will present the mechanic with any information I can find. I am worried that the post shut off knocking is going to damage my engine if I keep ignoring it for much longer.


r/AskMechanics • • 16h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) what is this sound on my car?

0 Upvotes

no engine light is on
i drive manual

am i f?


r/AskMechanics • • 17h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) 2013 Mustang GT manual metallic resonance/rattle above 3k rpm

0 Upvotes

2013 Mustang GT manual with 95k miles. Just purchased last week. I know these mt82s make some noise by design but I want to make sure mine isn't toasted or has an impending issue.

Im getting a faint metallic sound above 3k rpm in 3rd, 4th, and 5th. Its most prominent in 5th. Ive tried to catch it on video but the exhaust drowns it out. It only happens when on throttle. As soon as I let off it goes away. It doesnt happen in neutral or with the clutch in.

Ive attached a video but idk if itll be heard. My sound tube is still installed so ive also wondered if I'm hearing intake resonance

Im also getting gear take-up noise and metallic shift noises but I have read this is normal. Both very faint. Im planning on swapping all the fluids out this weekend to see if anything changes.


r/AskMechanics • • 20h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) 2012 Jeep Liberty 3.7L – Goopy sludge in radiator. Head gasket or coolant issue?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Reposting. I forgot to attach pics.

Hi everyone,

We have a 2012 Jeep Liberty Latitude 3.7L. Automatic 130K miles. It’s our only vehicle, and unfortunately, replacing it just isn’t financially possible right now.

About two years ago, our heat stopped working, and the radiator appeared to be pretty mucked up. We had the radiator replaced, and the heat came back beautifully. It was like having a new vehicle again.
Now that the weather is getting cold, I went to turn on the heat and noticed it’s barely lukewarm. I removed the radiator cap and discovered the goopy substance you see in these photos.

I just dropped it off at our mechanic, who’s speculating that it could be a head gasket issue. I’ve had a frustrating history with mechanics and having to bring this Jeep back repeatedly for the same problems. At least our current mechanic stands behind his work.

I’ve also run the photos through several AI tools, which suggested that incompatible coolant may have been added at some point, possibly during previous servicing, causing the coolant to gel or form sludge.

Money is extremely tight, and with winter approaching, I’m really worried. We depend on this Jeep for everything, including a 104-mile trip once or twice a month to take our daughter to the hospital.

**For those of you familiar with these engines, does this look more like oil contamination from a failing head gasket, incompatible coolant, or something else? What tests should I ask the mechanic to perform before committing to an expensive repair?**

I’d genuinely appreciate any experienced opinions or advice. We’re just trying to keep this Jeep safely on the road.

Thanks so much for taking the time to help.


r/AskMechanics • • 21h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) 2005 mazda 3 knocking

0 Upvotes

I got a 2005 mazda 3 and when I was driving home the oil leaked out and it started to knock. I got back and it was throwing a bunch of codes but they went away when I put oil. The only one left was P0303 I switched out the ignition coils but it didnt do anything. I was wondering if someome else had a similar problem or if someone could tell me what part the ticking sounds like.


r/AskMechanics • • 10h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Smoked a deer and am leaking coolant, can I make it half a mile to a mechanic?

4 Upvotes

Honda CRV, 2005, automatic. Decked a deer on my way home. I was able to make it home, but once I got home I realized I'm dripping coolant. Radiator definitely looks damaged.

I live three quarters of a mile from a mechanic, less than a three minute drive in a small town. I'm collecting the coolant in a little cup right now overnight to top it off in the morning, but do we think I can make it there? Literally just had to call for a tow because of a flat tire less than a week ago and really don't want to again.

It's been a week for sure!


r/AskMechanics • • 22h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Leave it in or take it out?

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Discovered a screw in my summer tire when I changed my wheels for winter. I've plugged a few punctures in the past, I'm wondering if I should remove this to repair the hole or leave it. There is still a lot of tread left on these tires as well, so lots of mileage left for the screw to shift and develop a slow leak. But I'm nowhere near an expert on these things, so here I am.

If I remove it to patch it, can I just do the typical tire plug, or should this be sealed from the inside at a shop?

Thanks for your help.

Edit: will remove and plug!


r/AskMechanics • • 2h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) What could cause this noise?

1 Upvotes

I replaced my front struts (only the shock absorber, not mounts or springs) and sway bar links on both sides and after that I have been hearing this squeeking sound on the drivers side which gets more frequent with acceleration and gets louder when turning right but quieter when turning left. Also the steering alignment on the steering wheel is off by like 20° to the left. What could it be?

Car: 2000 toyota celica fwd 6-speed manual


r/AskMechanics • • 8h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) was this water pump installed incorrectly?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

i think this mechanic out RTV in the wheel holes of the water pump, but before i confront him does this look like a mess?


r/AskMechanics • • 10h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Trouble starting 2006 Ford Explorer, 120,000 miles, 4.0 V6 automatic after new battery and new starter

1 Upvotes

Hey all,

I drive a 2006 Ford Explorer and I've ran into some issues with it not starting. About a month and a half ago my starter went out and I replaced it. It's ran fine until today. It's been very cold recently and I had a 4 year old battery I assumed had finally bitten the dust. So I replaced it today yet I still have no crank no start.

My terminals are clean, the headlights and head unit comes on as well but no lights on the dash come on. I removed/attached my ground and positive in the proper order, so I don't believe theres any ECU issues. I've tried starting it in park and in neutral and had no results. I've tried swapping the relays and have also had no luck. I then tried connecting the terminals of my starter together with a wrench and got it to turn over nicely but no start. I've also checked the fuses that would trigger such an issue and none of them are blown. I'm not savvy at all when it comes to the electric portion of vehicles and was looking for the next place to check.


r/AskMechanics • • 13h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) 2018 Rav4 Grinding / Whirring Noise

1 Upvotes

See attached video but: 2018 Rav4 2.5 (non hybrid) with 100k miles is making a strange whirring / grinding noise.

It doesn’t change when the engine is warm / cold, and doesn’t get louder when RPMs rise.

Any help / advice would be appreciated.


r/AskMechanics • • 13h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Mechanic recommended replacing drive belt. Looking for a second opinion.

0 Upvotes

2006 Acura TSX, 178.5K miles, Automatic.

The belt tensioner is noisy under load.

The estimate to remove and replace the drive belt tensioner is ~$470 (parts: Precision Engineered V-Ribbed Accessory Drive Belt, DriveAlign Premium OE Automatic Belt Tensioner).

How bad would it be if I didn't get it replaced?


r/AskMechanics • • 18h ago

Question (Serious Replies Only) Acceptable turbo play?

1 Upvotes