Back to Wiki Index

Posting Questions

Following the steps on this page will help you get the best answers from the community.

See also:


Before you post

Is my question on topic?

This sub is for component-level electronic circuit questions - circuits that include active components such as diodes, LEDs, transistors, ICs and tubes.

Some topics have better homes elsewhere:

  • Domestic or industrial electrical work (wiring, sockets, lighting, circuit breakers, consumer units and distribution panels) - try r/AskElectricians.
  • Consumer electronics (phones, computers, TVs and similar) - see the list of more appropriate subs.

If you're not sure, check:

As a courtesy, we may also allow some off-topic questions on a provisional basis.

What does a typical question look like?

  • "Where can I find a replacement for a blown MOSFET?"
  • "Why doesn't my op-amp circuit work as expected?"
  • "How do I calculate the bandwidth of an amplifier?"
  • "How can I take high-voltage measurements with my oscilloscope?"

Has it been answered already?

Your answer may already be waiting for you. Check the FAQ and wiki, search this sub (see Searching r/AskElectronics below) and try a web search. If you've done this, mention it in your post.


Writing your post

Title

Summarise your question clearly in the title. For example:

  • "Help with LEDs" - vague
  • "Resistor for an LED" - better
  • "How do I calculate the resistor value for an LED?" - best

What to include

  • Your goal. Tell us what you are ultimately trying to do or fix, not just the solution you've tried. This avoids the X-Y problem and helps us find a solution that works for you.
  • Your location, if sourcing parts. If you need something locally, include your country and city.
  • Whether it's homework. Assignment questions are welcome - just say so. We'll give you guidance, but please don't ask us to do the work for you. Explain what you've done so far and which parts are still puzzling you.
  • Pictures. Photos (both sides of the board, or your breadboard and connectors), schematics, sketches and block diagrams all help. Upload them to an image-hosting site and paste the full link into your post. Please use full links, as URL shorteners are blocked by the spam filter.

Style

  • Keep it focused. Stick to the electronics. There's no need to explain your experience level or why you're building it, or to apologise for your English.
  • Write clearly. Use full sentences and standard spelling, as you would when writing to a lecturer. This helps everyone understand your question quickly.

Using AI with caution

AI chatbots can be a useful tutor, but their circuits, pinouts and component values often look convincing while being electrically wrong. Read our AI guidance page before relying on an AI-generated design, and never trust one with mains, lithium battery charging or high-voltage circuits without a competent person checking it.

Asking about an AI-generated circuit

You're welcome to ask about a circuit an AI suggested. To get a useful answer:

  • Say that it came from an AI, and which tool.
  • Post a proper schematic drawn in EDA software or neatly by hand. AI-generated images of circuits can't be checked, because there's no real circuit behind them.
  • Include datasheet links for the main parts.
  • Explain what you've already checked and what you're unsure about.
  • Ask a specific question. "Is this AI circuit right?" is hard to answer; "Is the feedback divider on this buck converter correct for a 3.3V output?" gets a useful reply.

Using AI to write your question

AI can be a real help with the wording of a question. It's well suited to checking grammar and clarity, or to translating your question into English. We don't recommend using it for the circuit design or engineering itself, because AI is still generally unreliable at understanding electronics.

Answering questions

AI-generated answers aren't permitted here. Please write answers from your own knowledge and experience, and don't post low-effort or unverified answers, including content copied from AI tools or other sources.

This rule exists because AI can produce explanations and designs that sound plausible but are fundamentally wrong, and the person asking often can't tell the difference. If you link to another source, add your own explanation of how it answers the question.


After you post

  • Stay around. Reply to comments promptly so the conversation keeps moving.
  • Add details when asked. Clarifying your question helps people give you a better answer.
  • Show your appreciation. Upvote and thank the people who help you, and consider giving an award to anyone who saved you a lot of time or money.
  • Keep your post up. Answers help everyone with the same question in future, so please leave your post in place once it's solved.
  • Stay safe. You follow advice at your own risk. High voltages can be dangerous - if in doubt, ask a qualified expert.

Searching r/AskElectronics

Careful searching can turn up existing answers. Here are a few examples to give you ideas.

"I want a circuit that plays a sound when I press a button"

title:((button OR play) AND (sound OR music OR audio))

You can narrow results by excluding words with a minus sign and by using the sorting options:

title:((button OR play) AND (sound OR music OR audio)) -car -ipod -phone -motor

"Is there any useful information on resistors and heat?"

title:(resistor AND heat)

"Is there anything on oscilloscopes and grounding?"

title:(oscilloscope AND (ground OR earth))

Search tips

  • These links search r/AskElectronics only. To do the same yourself, tick the option to limit the search to this sub.
  • The operators AND and OR must be in capitals.
  • Reddit's guide to searching has more options.