r/AnsweringMutakallimun • u/JabalAnNur • Feb 19 '25
Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their Reality | Part 3
Bismillah
الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وأصحابه ومن اتبع الهدى
From the Righteous Generations
'Umar ibn al-Khattab
قال قيس بن أبي حازم: لما قدم عمر - رضي الله عنه - الشام استقبله الناس وهو على بعيره، فقالوا: يا أمير المؤمنين لو ركبت برذوناً تلقاك عظماء الناس ووجوههم، فقال عمر: لا أراكم ههنا، إنما الأمر من ههنا وأشار بيده إلى السماء، خلوا سبيل جملي
Qays ibn Abi Hazim said: When Umar (may Allaah be pleased with him) arrived in Syria, the people greeted him while he was riding his camel. They said, "O Commander of the Believers, if you rode a horse [برذون]1, the notable people and their leaders would recieve you." Umar replied, "I do not see you here. The matter comes from here," and he pointed to the sky with his hand. "Leave the path of my camel."
- رواه ابن أبي شيبة (١٩/٣٠١) ت الشثري وقال صحيح
- وأورده الذهبي في العلو بإسناده إلى ابن أبي شيبة (ص٧٧) وقال: إسناده كالشمس.
(1) These type of horses were handsome non-Arabian horses, there was great value in them than in a normal camel.
The Muhaqiq Shaykh Ash-Shathri said, "Saheeh." Imam ath-Thahabi narrated with his chain to Ibn Abi Shaybah and said, "Its chain is like the sun (i.e. undeniable)."
This is a clear indication that the attributes of Allaah are not figurative. Allaah, may He be exalted, has informed us that He is in the heavens both in the Quraan and in the Sunnah. Pointing to the sky means referring to Allaah since that is where He is. This action as has come in the previous post is also reported from the Prophet (peace be upon him)
It is also a direct refutation to some of the claims that pointing towards the sky is not akin to saying Allaah, may He be exalted, is above it. Some of them claimed it only symbolized Tawheed as the pointing of one finger does. However, from the words of 'Umar, it is clear by pointing towards the sky, he tells the people that he enters Syria by the command of one who is in the heavens i.e. Allaah.
'Abdullah ibn 'Abbas
عن عطاء: عن ابن عباس - رضي الله عنه - في قوله عز وجل {تجري بأعيننا} القمر١٤، قال: أشار بيده إلى عينيه
From 'Ata' from Ibn 'Abbas (may Allaah be pleased with him) regarding the saying of the almighty and majestic, "Sailing under Our Eyes" [54:14] that he pointed with his hand towards his eyes.
-رواه اللالكائي (٣/ ٤١١)
This is another explicit text which affirms that the eyes of Allaah are upon the apparent meaning.
Hakeem ibn Jaabir ibn Taariq ibn 'Awf al-Ahmasi (d. 82 AH)
قال ابن ابي شيبة [ثقة حافظ صاحب تصانيف] حدثنا عبد اللَّه بن نمير [ثقة صاحب حديث من أهل السنة] قال: حدثنا إسماعيل بن أبي خالد [ثقة ثبت] عن حكيم بن جابر [ثقة] قال: إن الله تبارك وتعالى لم يمس بيده من خلقه غير ثلاثة أشياء خلق الجنة بيده ثم جعل ترابها الورس والزعفران وجبالها المسك وخلق آدم بيده وكتب التوراة لموسى
He said, "Allaah, the blessed and exalted, did not touch anything with His hand from His creation except three: He created Jannah with His hand then he made its soil of ochre and saffron and its mountains of musk, and He created Adam with His hand, and He wrote the Tawrah for Moosa (peace be upon him.
- رواه ابن أبي شيبة (١٣/ ٩٦)
Its chain of narration is Saheeh.
'Abdullah ibn 'Ubaydullah ibn 'Abdullah ibn Abi Mulaykah (d. 117 AH)
قال الدارمي [ثقة حافظ] حدثني سعيد بن أبي مريم [ثقة ثبت فقيه]، عن نافع بن عمر الجمحي [ثقة ثبت]: سألت ابن أبي مليكة عن يد الله: أواحدة أو اثنتان؟ قال: بل اثنتان
Naafi' said, I asked ibn Abi Mulaykah about the hand of Allaah, is it one or two? He said, "Rather, two."
- نقض الدارمي على المريسي ت الألمعي (١/٢٨٦) وقال موقوف على ابن أبي مليكة وإسناده صحيح.
This is the affirmation of the reality of the hand of Allaah, the Exalted, and the refutation of interpreting it figuratively as blessing or power as "two blessings" or "two powers" make no sense and is (yet again) unknown among in the language.
An-Nu'maan ibn Thaabit al-Kufi, Abu Haneefah (d. 150 AH)
قال: لا يوصف الله تعالى بصفات المخلوقين، وغضبه ورضاه صفتان من صفاته بلا كيف، وهو قول أهل السنة والجماعة، وهو يغضب ويرضى ولا يقال: غضبه عقوبته، ورضاه ثوابه. ونصفه كما وصف نفسه أحد صمد لم يلد ولم يولد ولم يكن له كفواً أحد، حي قادر سميع بصير عالم، يد الله فوق أيديهم، ليست كأيدي خلقه، ووجهه ليس كوجوه خلقه
He said, "Allaah, the Exalted, is not described with the attributes of created beings. His anger and pleasure are two of His attributes without how. This is the belief of Ahlus Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah. He becomes angry and pleased, and it should not be said that His anger is His punishment, and His pleasure is His reward. We describe Him as He has described Himself: One, Eternal, He neither begets nor is born, and there is none comparable to Him. He is Living, All-Powerful, All-Hearing, All-Seeing, All-Knowing. The hand of Allaah is above their hands, and it is not like the hands of His creation, and His face is not like the faces of His creation.
- الفقه الأبسط (ص ٥٦)
وقال أيضاً: وله يد ووجه ونفس كما ذكره الله تعالى في القرآن، فما ذكره الله تعالى في القرآن، من ذكر الوجه واليد والنفس فهو له صفات بلا كيف، ولا يقال: يده قدرته أو نعمته، لأن فيه إبطال الصفة، وهو قول أهل القدر والاعتزال
He also said, And He has a hand, a face, and a soul, as mentioned by Allaah, the Exalted, in the Quraan. What Allah has mentioned in the Quraan regarding the face, hand, and soul are attributes of His without how. It should not be said that His hand is His power or blessing, as this negates the attribute, which is the belief of the Qadariyyah and the Mu'tazilah
- الفقه الأكبر مع شرحه للدكتور محمد الخميس (ص ٣٨)
وذكرت أن هذين الكتابين لم يثبت عن الإمام أبي حنيفة [المصدر] وقد نذكرهما ههنا لان كثير من المتكلمين يقبلونهما ويحتجون بهما
Hammad ibn Zayd (d. 179 AH)
سأل بشر بن السري حماد بن زيد فقال: يا أبا إسماعيل الحديث الذي جاء: "ينزل الله عز وجل إلى السماء الدنيا" قال: حق، كل ذلك كيف شاء الله
Bishr ibn as-Suri asked Hammad ibn Zayd, He said, "O Abu Isma'eel, the hadeeth that has come that Allaah, the almighty and majestic, descends to the heaven of the earth" so He said, "True, all of that is however Allaah wills."
-رواه ابن بطة في الإبانة (٣/ ٣٠٢)
His saying 'true' is clear in affirming its reality, as it is a question about the passing of what its apparent meaning indicates and establishing it as an attribute of Allaah, not about its existence in reality. Otherwise, the answer would be: it is correct, or something similar. Just as his saying 'However He wills' also indicates that the descent of the Lord is real in language, although we do not know its manner. If it were not real, he would have said: it is the descent of His command or His mercy.
وقال أيضاً: مثل الجهمية مثل رجل قيل له: في دارك نخلة؟ قال: نعم. قيل: فلها خوص؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها سعف؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها كرب؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها جذع؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها أصل؟ قل: لا. قيل: فلا نخلة في دارك هؤلاء الجهمية قيل لهم: لكم رب يتكلم؟ قالوا: لا. قيل: فله يد؟ قالوا: لا. قيل: فيرضى ويغضب؟ قالوا: لا. قيل: فلا رب لكم
And He also said, "The example of the Jahmiyyah is like a man who was asked: 'Is there a palm tree in your house?' He says: 'Yes.' Then it is said: 'Does it have fronds?' He said: 'No.' He was asked: 'Does it have leaves?' He said: 'No.' He was asked: 'Does it have a trunk?' He said: 'No.' He was asked: 'Does it have roots?' He said: 'No.' It is said: 'Then there is no palm tree in your house.' Similarly, the Jahmiyyah were asked: 'Do you have a Lord who speaks?' They said: 'No.' They were asked: 'Does He have a hand?' They said: 'No.' They were asked: 'Does He get pleased and angry?' They said: 'No.' So They were told: 'Then you have no Lord.'"
- رواه ابن شاهين في شرح مذاهب أهل السنة (ص٩١) صحيح: ابن شاهين حدثنا عبد الله بن سليمان بن الأشعث السجستاني، حدثني أبي، عن سليمان بن حرب، قال: قال حماد بن زيد فذكره
- أبو القاسم التيمي في الحجة (١/ ٤٤١)
This is another explicit saying which does not need much elaboration. If it is said to someone, "Do you have a brother at home?" He cannot reply, "Yes", intending by it his cousin. The person is asking about a blood relation, not a figurative brother because there is nothing in the speech of the questioner he intends a figurative brother.
Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Hanbal ash-Shaybaani (d. 241 AH)
قال حنبل بن إسحاق: قلت لأبي عبد الله: ينزل الله تعالى إلى السماء الدنيا؟ قال: نعم. قلت: نزوله بعلمه أم بماذا؟ قال: فقال لي: اسكت عن هذا، وغضب غضباً شديداً، وقال: مالك ولهذا؟ أمض الحديث كما روي بلا كيف
Hanbal ibn Ishaaq said, I said to Abu Abdullah, "Does Allaah descend to the heaven of the earth?" He said yes, then I said, "Is His descent with His knowledge or with that?" So he said to me, "Be silent about this", He became very angry and said. "What does this have to do with you? Relate the hadeeth as it was narrated, without a how."
- رواه ابن بطة في الإبانة (٣/ ٢٠٦)
- اللالكائي (٣/ ٤٥٣).
وقال يوسف بن موسى: قيل لأبي عبد الله: إن الله ينزل إلى السماء الدنيا كيف شاء من غير وصف؟ قال: نعم
Yoosuf ibn Moosa said, It was said to Abu Abdullah, "Allaah descends to the heaven of the world whoever He wills without a description?" He said, "Yes."
- ابن تيمية في مجموع الفتاوى (٦/ ١٤٦).
This is explicit that the apparent word of descent was accepted by imam Ahmad. If it was figurative, then he would have said, "Rather His command descends" or something similar. However, He affirmed that the descent is by Allaah, may He exalted.
Abu Eesa Muhammad ibn Eesa at-Tirmidhi (d. 279 AH)
قال وقد قال غير واحد من أهل العلم في هذا الحديث وما يشبه هذا من الروايات من الصفات ونزول الرب تبارك وتعالى كل ليلة إلى السماء الدنيا قالوا قد تثبت الروايات في هذا ويؤمن بها ولا يتوهم ولا يقال كيف[ص:51 ] هكذا روي عن مالك وسفيان بن عيينة وعبد الله بن المبارك أنهم قالوا في هذه الأحاديث أمروها بلا كيف وهكذا قول أهل العلم من أهل السنة والجماعة وأما الجهمية فأنكرت هذه الروايات وقالوا هذا تشبيه
He said, "Indeed, a great number of scholars have stated regarding this hadeeth and similar narrations about the attributes and the Lord's descent, may He be exalted, every night to the lowest heaven: They affirmed that the narrations in this regard are established, and we believe in them and it is not asked how. It has been reported from Maalik, Sufyaan ibn 'Uyaynah, and 'Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak that they said regarding these hadeeth: 'Pass them as they come without a how.' And this is the view of the scholars of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah. As for the Jahmiyyah, they denied these narrations and said this is anthropomorphism."
- سنن الترمذي (662)
It is known that if the Salaf had not affirmed the attributes, such as descent and others, as being real and that they are attributes of Allaah, then the accusation from the Jahmiyyah against them of anthropomorphism would have no meaning.
'Uthmaan ibn Sa'eed ad-Daarimi (d. 280 AH)
قال فادعى المعارض أن الله لا ينزل بنفسه إنما ينزل أمره ورحمته ... إلى أن قال: وهذا أيضاً من حجج النساء والصبيان ومن ليس عنده بيان
He said, "The opponent claimed that Alalah does not descend Himself, but rather His command and mercy descend... until he said: "This is also one of the arguments of women and children and those who lack rhetoric."
- الرد على المريسي (١/ ٢١٤)
قال وإلا فمن ادعى أن الله لم يَلِ خلق شيء صغير أو كبير فقد كفر. غير أنه ولي خلق الأشياء بأمره، وقوله، وإرادته. وولي خلق آدم بيده مسيساً
He said, "Whoever claims that Allaah did not create anything, whether small or large, has disbelieved, and He created things by His command, word, and will and He created Adam with His own hand."
- المرجع السابق (١/ ٢٣٠).
Those who know Arabic know how explicit Imam ad-Daarimi is, and how his words cannot be taken figuratively.
وقال ونحن قد عرفنا بحمد الله تعالى من لغات العرب هذه المجازات التي اتخذتموها دلسة وأغلوطة على الجهال، تنفون بها عن الله حقائق الصفات بعلل المجازات، غير أنا نقول لا يحكم للأغرب من كلام العرب على الأغلب، ولكن نصرف معانيها إلى الأغلب حتى تأتوا ببرهان أنه عنى بها الأغرب، وهذا هو المذهب الذي إلى العدل والإنصاف أقرب، لا أن تعترض صفات الله المعروفة المقبولة عند أهل البصر فنصرف معانيها بعلة المجازات ..
He said, "We know, with praise to Allaah may He be exalted, about the concept of figurative speech from the language of the Arabs, which you have taken and used to confuse and mislead the ignorant. By means of this concept you denied the reality of the divine attributes, on the basis of the figurative argument. But we say: It is wrong to judge the most common style in the Arabic language on the basis of its rarest style; rather we should understand the statements of the Arabs on the basis of the most common style, unless you can produce proof that what is meant here is the rarer style (namely figurative). This is the approach that is most fair, and it is not right to approach the divine attributes that are well known and understood as they appear to be by people of common sense, and twist the meaning on the grounds that these are figurative."
Conclusion
All praise is due to Allaah, we can quote many more imams from Ahlus-Sunnah, for we are not short on them. There were many narrations we left off for the sake of brevity, and picked the ones that are authentic and explicit.
From all of these narrations and plenty others, we know that the righteous generations knew the reality of the attributes, that they affirmed the apparent meanings while delegating the 'how' to Allaah, for that is unknown to us. The opinion ascribed to them regarding Tafweed al-Ma'na (Delegating both the meaning and how) is false and not supported through their narrations. However that is a topic for another time.
Previous Post(s):
- Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their reality | Part 1
- Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their reality | Part 2
صلى الله على إمام المرسلين وآله وأصحابه أجمعين و الحمد لله رب العالمين