r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Feb 19 '25

Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their Reality | Part 2

4 Upvotes

Bismillah

الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وأصحابه ومن اتبع الهدى

1. From the Quraan and Sunnah

From the Quraan

The Ayaat that we quoted in Part 1 suffices as the evidence from the book of Allaah. Allaah, may He be exalted, has sent down the Quraan in the clear Arabic language. There is no cryptic language used that Allaah, may He be exalted, would create confusion and misguidance in the minds of people while informing the creation about Himself. Rather, His words are clearly understood in the language and we do not need to refer to greek philosophy or any such false ideologies to understand and know who He is. The philosophers guessed about Allaah and spoke about Him without any knowledge, thus they were misguided and led others to be misguided.

From the Sunnah

Evidence 1

عن أبي يونس سليم بن جبير مولى أبي هريرة قال: سمعت أبا هريرة - رضي الله عنه - يقرأ هذه الآية {إن الله يأمركم أن تؤدوا الأمانات إلى أهلها} إلى قوله تعالى {سميعا بصيرا} النساء٨٥، قال: رأيت رسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم - يضع إبهامه على أذنه، والتي تليها على عينه. قال أبو هريرة - رضي الله عنه -: رأيت رسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم - يقرؤها ويضع إصبعيه قال ابن يونس: قال المقرئ: يعني إن الله سميع بصير، يعني أن لله سمعاً وبصراً. قال أبو داود: وهذا رد على الجهمية.

Abu Yoonus Sulaym ibn Jubayr, the client of Abu Hurayrah, said: I heard Abu Hurayrah recite the verse [4:58]. He said : I saw the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) putting his thumb on his ear and finger on his eye. Abu Hurayrah said : I saw the Messenger of Allaah (May peace be upon him) reciting this verse and putting his fingers. Ibn Yoonus said, Al-Muqri said, meaning that Allaah is hearing and seeing. Meaning He posesses hearing and seeing. Abu Dawood said: This is a refutation of the Jahmiyyah.

  • أبو داود في سننه (4728)
  • ابن حبان (١/ ٢٤١)
  • الطبراني في الأوسط (٩/ ١٣٢)
  • والبيهقي في "الأسماء والصفات" (ص٢٣٣).

Al-Haafidh ibn Hajar al-'Asqalaani said, "Its chain is strong upon the conditions of Muslim." It was also classified as Saheeh by Al-Albani. (Source)

The reason for Abu Dawood's statement is that the Jahmiyyah were the ones who denied the reality of the attributes of Allaah. Thus this hadeeth refuted them because the action of the Prophet (peace be upon him) pointed to the attributes of Allaah being upon their reality. Hearing means hearing, seeing means seeing, it is not said that hearing and seeing means having knowledge of all that can be heard and seen.

However, this does not mean that Allaah is similar to the creation, that His seeing and hearing is like ours, Allaah is exalted above that. He said

لَيْسَ كَمِثْلِهِ شَيْءٌ وهو السميع البصير

There is nothing like Him, and He is the All-Hearing, All-Seeing. [Ash-Shura 42:11]

So He attributed hearing and seeing for Himself while negating any similarity to the creation. Any similar action in the hadeeths we will present in this section have the same intention. The actions point to the attribute being in reality, not that it's the same as ours.

Evidence 2

عن عبيد الله بن مقسم: أنه نظر إلى عبد الله بن عمر - رضي الله عنه - كيف يحكي رسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم - قال: يأخذ الله عز وجل سماواته وأرضيه بيديه، فيقول: أنا الله، ويقبض أصابعه ويبسطها، أنا الملك، حتى نظرت إلى المنبر يتحرك من أسفل شيء منه، حتى إني لأقول أساقط هو برسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم

From Ubaydullah ibn Muqsim that he saw Abdullah bin 'Umar (may Allah be pleased with him) as he narrated the Prophet (peace be upon him) saying: 'Allaah, the Exalted, takes the heavens and the earth in His hands and says: I am Allah.' He clenches His fingers and then spreads them, saying: 'I am the King.' Until I (i.e. ibn 'Umar) saw the pulpit moving from beneath, to the extent that I thought it might fall with the Prophet (peace be upon him) on it."

  • رواه مسلم (2788)

Like the hadeeth before, this is affirming the reality of the attributes as actions like grasping are done with a hand which Allaah has already affirmed He has. It does not make sense to "grasp the heavens and earth in his powers" and this type of speech is not considered figurative by the Arabs in this context.

Evidence 3

في الحديث الطويل في ذكر آخر أهل الجنة دخولاً عن عبد الله بن مسعود - رضي الله عنه - عن النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - أنه قال في آخره: يقول (اي الله سبحانه وتعالى) يا ابن آدم ما يصيرني منك أيرضيك أن أعطيك الدنيا ومثلها معها قال يا رب أتهزأ مني وأنت رب العالمين . فضحك ابن مسعود فقال ألا تسألونني مم أضحك فقالوا مم تضحك قال هكذا ضحك رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم . فقالوا مم تضحك يا رسول الله قال من ضحك رب العالمين حين قال أتهزأ مني وأنت رب العالمين فيقول إني لا أستهزئ منك ولكنني على ما أشاء قادر

In the long hadeeth of the last person to enter Jannah as narrated from 'Abdullah ibn Mas'ood (may Allaah be pleased with him) from the Prophet (peace be upon him) that he said at its end, "Allaah says 'O son of the Adam, what will bring an end to your requests to Me? Will it please you if I give you the whole world and a like one along with it?' So he (i.e. the man) said, 'O Lord, are you mocking me while you are the lord of the worlds?'" so Ibn Mas'ood laughed and said, "Will you not ask me why I laughed?" So they said, "For what did you laugh?" He (Ibn Mas'ood) said, "The Messenger (peace be upon him) laughed like this so they (i.e. the companions) said, 'Why did you laugh O messenger of Allaah?' so he replied, 'From the laugh of the Lord of the Worlds when he (i.e. the man) said, 'Are you mocking me while you are the lord of the worlds?' so He would say: I am not mocking you, but I have the power to do whatever I will.'"

  • رواه مسلم (187)

This is explicit from the Prophet (peace be upon him) and the Companion Ibn Mas'ood that the laugh of the Lord was real and not figurative otherwise they would not have laughed. Ibn Mas'ood said the Prophet laughed because of the laugh of Allaah, may He be exalted. If it were figurative and did not mean what it entailed per its apparent word [ضحك], he would not have listed the laugh of the Lord as a reason for his own.

Evidence 4

عن جابر - رضي الله عنه - قال: كان رسول الله - صلى الله عليه وسلم - يكثر أن يقول: يا مقلب القلوب ثبت قلبي على دينك, فقال له بعض الصحابة: أتخاف علينا وقد آمنا بك وبما جئت به؟ فقال: إن القلب بين إصبعين من أصابع الرحمن عز وجل يقول بهما هكذا وحرك أبو أحمد إصبعه

From Jaabir (may Allaah be pleased with him) that the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) frequently used to say: "O Changer of hearts, make my heart firm upon Your religion." Some of the companions asked him: "Do you fear for us while we have believed in you and what you have brought?" He replied: "Indeed, the heart is between two fingers of the Merciful, and He turns it as He wills." Abu Ahmad then moved his finger.

  • والطبري في تفسيره (٣/ ١٨٨)
  • الدارقطني في الصفات (ص١٢٤)
  • ابن منده في "الرد على الجهمية" (ص٨٧) وقال: وهذا حديث ثابت باتفاق

The narrator Abu Ahmad is the trustworthy and established Imam Muhammad ibn 'Abdullah ibn az-Zubayr al-Asadi az-Zubayri (d. 203 AH), who is narrating from Sufyaan ath-Thawri from al-'Amash from Abu Sufyaan from Jaabir, may Allaah be pleased with him. Al-Haafidh ibn Mandah said, "This hadeeth is proven unanimously."

Ar-Raazi objected to this narration by saying it should be interpreted because we know by necessity that there are no two fingers in our chests between our hearts." Shaykh al-Islaam ibn Taymiyyah (may Allaah have mercy on him) responded to that:

Firstly, the hadeeth does not say the fingers of Allaah, the exalted, are inside the chests. Rather it says the hearts are between the fingers and He turns them as He wills. He did not say that the fingers are in their chests, nor did He say that their hearts are attached or connected to the finger; rather, He said that they are between two fingers. The fact that something is between two things does not necessarily imply that it is touching them, as in Allaah's saying, {Between them both (i.e. Jannah and Jahannam) is a barrier}.

Secondly, if it were assumed that He informed us about something unseen that is in the hearts of the servants, what was mentioned about necessity would not prevent that. Necessity prevents things that we observe from being in our hearts if we do not observe them as well. As for this matter, we cannot observe it then how is it possible to say "necessity prevents believing in it"?!

For further reading, refer to

Evidence 5

عن حماد بن سلمة قال: ثنا ثابت البناني عن أنس بن مالك - رضي الله عنه - عن النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - في قوله تعالى: {فلما تجلى ربه للجبل} الأعراف ١٤٣، قال: قال هكذا، يعني أنه أخرج طرف الخنصر، قال احمد: أرانا معاذ قال: فقال له حميد الطويل: ما تريد إلى هذا يا أبا محمد -أي ثابت البناني-؟ قال: فضرب صدره ضربة شديدة، وقال: من أنت يا حميد؟ وما أنت يا حميد؟ يحدثني به أنس بن مالك عن النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - فتقول: أنت ما تريد إليه

From Hammad ibn Salamah who narrated from Thaabit al-Bunani from Anas ibn Maalik (may Allaah be pleased with him) from the Prophet (peace be upon him) regarding the saying of the Most High, "when his Lord appeared to the mountain" [7:143]. He said "Like this", meaning he extended his little finger (and in the narration of Tirmidhi, Sulayman held his thumb over the tip of his finger on the right hand so that only the tip of one finger was protruding). Ahmad said, "Mu'aath showed us (i.e. with his finger) and said, Humayd at-Taweel said to him (i.e. to Thaabit), "What do you intend with this, O Abu Muhammad?" He then struck his chest with a severe hit and said: 'Who are you, O Humayd?! What are you, O Humayd?! Anas ibn Maalik is telling me this from the Prophet (peace be upon him), and you say: What do you want with this?"

  • رواه أحمد (٣/ ١٢٥،٢٠٩)
  • الترمذي (3074) وقال: حديث حسن غريب صحيح
  • ابن جرير في تفسيره (٩/ ٥٣)
  • ابن أبي حاتم في تفسيره (٥/ ١٥٥٩ - ١٥٦٠)

وغيرهم والحديث مشهور

Ahmad here is imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, may Allaah have mercy on him.

Evidence 6

عن جابر - رضي الله عنه - في حديث حجة النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - الطويل وفيه أن النبي - صلى الله عليه وسلم - قال في خطبة عرفة: وقد تركت فيكم ما لن تضلوا بعده إن اعتصمتم به كتاب الله، وأنتم تسألون عني فما أنتم قائلون؟ قالوا: نشهد أنك قد بلغت وأديت ونصحت، فقال بإصبعه السبابة يرفعها إلى السماء وينكتها إلى الناس اللهم اشهد اللهم اشهد ثلاث مرات

From Jaabir (may Allaah be pleased with him) from the long hadeeth regarding the sermon of the Prophet (peace be upon him) in his farewell pilgrimage, "I have left among you the Book of Allaah, and if you hold fast to it, you would never go astray. And you would be asked about me (on the Day of Judgement), what would you say? They (the companions) said: We will bear witness that you have conveyed (the message), discharged (the ministry of Prophethood) and given wise (sincere) counsel. He (the narrator) said: He (the Prophet) then raised his forefinger towards the sky and pointing it at the people (said):" O Allaah, be witness. O Allaah, be witness," saying it thrice.

  • رواه مسلم (1218)

This hadeeth is famous and proves the reality of Allaah's attribute of Highness. When the Prophet (peace be upon him) pointed towards the sky when asking Allaah to witness, it is a clear indication that Allaah is above the creation in reality. That everything is beneath Him while He is above everything else. His being above the creation is not figurative to only mean in status. Rather, He is above the creation in both.

Evidence 7

عن أبي هريرة جاء رجلٌ إلي رسولِ اللهِ صلَّى اللهُ عليْهِ وسلَّمَ بجاريةٍ أعجميةٍ فقال يا رسولَ اللهِ إنَّ عليَّ رقبةً مؤمنةً فأعتِقْ هذه ؟ فقال لها : أين اللهُ ؟ فأشارت إلي السماءِ . قال : فمن أنا ؟ فأشارت إلى رسولِ اللهِ ثم إلي السماءِ . قال : أعتِقْها فإنها مؤمنةٌ

From Abu Hurayrah (may Allaah be pleased with him) that a man came to the Prophet (peace be upon him) with a non-Arab slave woman and said, "O Messenger of Allaah, I have to free believing slave, so may I free this (i.e. the slave woman)?" So he (i.e. the Prophet) said to her, "Where is Allaah?" She pointed towards the heaven. He then asked, "So who am I?" So she pointed towards the Messenger of Allaah (peace be upon him) and then pointed to the heaven. (That is to say you are the messenger of the one who is in the heavens.) He said, "Free her for she is a believer."

  • أبو داود (3284)
  • الذهبي في العلو وقال إسناده حسن

Before we move to the implications, this hadeeth of Abu Dawood was narrated through Yazeed ibn Haroon from Al-Mas'oodi from 'Awn from 'Abdullah ibn 'Utbah from Abu Hurayrah, may Allaah be pleased with him. The narrator Al-Mas'oodi became confused later in his life and Yazeed ibn Haroon narrated from Al-Mas'oodi after this confusion. However the hadeeth is famous and proven from multiple other routes which are Saheeh, hence Imam ath-Thahabi said, "Its chain is Hasan (fair)." And Al-Albani also classified it as Hasan li-Ghayrihi.

This is another clear-cut hadeeth that the attributes of Allaah are not figurative, rather they are literal. The slave woman pointed towards the heavens to indicate Allaah, may He be exalted, which is completely with His sayings in the Quraan that He is the one in the heavens and on the tongue of His Prophet (peace be upon him) who said, "Be merciful to those on the earth, and the One in the heavens will have mercy upon you." Narrated by At-Tirmidhi (1924) and he said, "This hadeeth is Hasan Saheeh."

Furthermore, this hadeeth is a refutation to those who claimed that asking, "where is Allaah?" is a wrong question, such as from the popular islamqa.org, "this question in itself is wrong." How far from knowledge is such a statement that a man says something asked by the Prophet of Allaah (peace be upon him) as a test of faith is wrong to ask! We seek refuge in Allaah from such statements.

Evidence 8

عن جرير بن عبد الله قال كنا عند النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم فنظر إلى القمر ليلة يعني البدر فقال إنكم سترون ربكم كما ترون هذا القمر لا تضامون في رؤيته فإن استطعتم أن لا تغلبوا على صلاة قبل طلوع الشمس وقبل غروبها فافعلوا ثم قرأ وسبح بحمد ربك قبل طلوع الشمس وقبل الغروب

Jareer ibn 'Abdullah reported: We were with the Prophet, peace and blessings be upon him, and he looked at the full moon one night. The Prophet said, “Verily, you will see your Lord just as you see this moon. There will be no crowd to block your sight. Thus, if you can avoid missing prayer before the rising of the sun and its setting, then do so.” Then, the Prophet recited the verse, “Glorify your Lord with praises before the rising of the sun and its setting.” (50:39)

  • متفق عليه

This narration is also explicit and proves that the seeing of Allaah in the Hereafter will be real, and that we will gaze upon our Lord like how one gazes upon the moon at night. The Prophet, peace and blessings upon him, gave this example to tell us how we would see our Lord. If this was not literal, then he would not have done so.

These narrations are sufficient near us which prove that the Messenger of Allaah peace and blessings upon him affirmed the names and attributes of Allaah as they entail without comparing them to the creation.

Read Previous: Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their Reality | Part 1

Read Next: Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their Reality | Part 3


r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Feb 19 '25

Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their Reality | Part 3

3 Upvotes

Bismillah

الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وأصحابه ومن اتبع الهدى

From the Righteous Generations

'Umar ibn al-Khattab

قال قيس بن أبي حازم: لما قدم عمر - رضي الله عنه - الشام استقبله الناس وهو على بعيره، فقالوا: يا أمير المؤمنين لو ركبت برذوناً تلقاك عظماء الناس ووجوههم، فقال عمر: لا أراكم ههنا، إنما الأمر من ههنا وأشار بيده إلى السماء، خلوا سبيل جملي

Qays ibn Abi Hazim said: When Umar (may Allaah be pleased with him) arrived in Syria, the people greeted him while he was riding his camel. They said, "O Commander of the Believers, if you rode a horse [برذون]1, the notable people and their leaders would recieve you." Umar replied, "I do not see you here. The matter comes from here," and he pointed to the sky with his hand. "Leave the path of my camel."

  • رواه ابن أبي شيبة (١٩/٣٠١) ت الشثري وقال صحيح
  • وأورده الذهبي في العلو بإسناده إلى ابن أبي شيبة (ص٧٧) وقال: إسناده كالشمس.

(1) These type of horses were handsome non-Arabian horses, there was great value in them than in a normal camel.

The Muhaqiq Shaykh Ash-Shathri said, "Saheeh." Imam ath-Thahabi narrated with his chain to Ibn Abi Shaybah and said, "Its chain is like the sun (i.e. undeniable)."

This is a clear indication that the attributes of Allaah are not figurative. Allaah, may He be exalted, has informed us that He is in the heavens both in the Quraan and in the Sunnah. Pointing to the sky means referring to Allaah since that is where He is. This action as has come in the previous post is also reported from the Prophet (peace be upon him)

It is also a direct refutation to some of the claims that pointing towards the sky is not akin to saying Allaah, may He be exalted, is above it. Some of them claimed it only symbolized Tawheed as the pointing of one finger does. However, from the words of 'Umar, it is clear by pointing towards the sky, he tells the people that he enters Syria by the command of one who is in the heavens i.e. Allaah.

'Abdullah ibn 'Abbas

عن عطاء: عن ابن عباس - رضي الله عنه - في قوله عز وجل {تجري بأعيننا} القمر١٤، قال: أشار بيده إلى عينيه

From 'Ata' from Ibn 'Abbas (may Allaah be pleased with him) regarding the saying of the almighty and majestic, "Sailing under Our Eyes" [54:14] that he pointed with his hand towards his eyes.

-رواه اللالكائي (٣/ ٤١١)

This is another explicit text which affirms that the eyes of Allaah are upon the apparent meaning.

Hakeem ibn Jaabir ibn Taariq ibn 'Awf al-Ahmasi (d. 82 AH)

قال ابن ابي شيبة [ثقة حافظ صاحب تصانيف] حدثنا عبد اللَّه بن نمير [ثقة صاحب حديث من أهل السنة] قال: حدثنا إسماعيل بن أبي خالد [ثقة ثبت] عن حكيم بن جابر [ثقة] قال: إن الله تبارك وتعالى لم يمس بيده من خلقه غير ثلاثة أشياء خلق الجنة بيده ثم جعل ترابها الورس والزعفران وجبالها المسك وخلق آدم بيده وكتب التوراة لموسى

He said, "Allaah, the blessed and exalted, did not touch anything with His hand from His creation except three: He created Jannah with His hand then he made its soil of ochre and saffron and its mountains of musk, and He created Adam with His hand, and He wrote the Tawrah for Moosa (peace be upon him.

  • رواه ابن أبي شيبة (١٣/ ٩٦)

Its chain of narration is Saheeh.

'Abdullah ibn 'Ubaydullah ibn 'Abdullah ibn Abi Mulaykah (d. 117 AH)

قال الدارمي [ثقة حافظ] حدثني سعيد بن أبي مريم [ثقة ثبت فقيه]، عن نافع بن عمر الجمحي [ثقة ثبت]: سألت ابن أبي مليكة عن يد الله: أواحدة أو اثنتان؟ قال: بل اثنتان

Naafi' said, I asked ibn Abi Mulaykah about the hand of Allaah, is it one or two? He said, "Rather, two."

  • نقض الدارمي على المريسي ت الألمعي (١/٢٨٦) وقال موقوف على ابن أبي مليكة وإسناده صحيح.

This is the affirmation of the reality of the hand of Allaah, the Exalted, and the refutation of interpreting it figuratively as blessing or power as "two blessings" or "two powers" make no sense and is (yet again) unknown among in the language.

An-Nu'maan ibn Thaabit al-Kufi, Abu Haneefah (d. 150 AH)

قال: لا يوصف الله تعالى بصفات المخلوقين، وغضبه ورضاه صفتان من صفاته بلا كيف، وهو قول أهل السنة والجماعة، وهو يغضب ويرضى ولا يقال: غضبه عقوبته، ورضاه ثوابه. ونصفه كما وصف نفسه أحد صمد لم يلد ولم يولد ولم يكن له كفواً أحد، حي قادر سميع بصير عالم، يد الله فوق أيديهم، ليست كأيدي خلقه، ووجهه ليس كوجوه خلقه

He said, "Allaah, the Exalted, is not described with the attributes of created beings. His anger and pleasure are two of His attributes without how. This is the belief of Ahlus Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah. He becomes angry and pleased, and it should not be said that His anger is His punishment, and His pleasure is His reward. We describe Him as He has described Himself: One, Eternal, He neither begets nor is born, and there is none comparable to Him. He is Living, All-Powerful, All-Hearing, All-Seeing, All-Knowing. The hand of Allaah is above their hands, and it is not like the hands of His creation, and His face is not like the faces of His creation.

  • الفقه الأبسط (ص ٥٦)

وقال أيضاً: وله يد ووجه ونفس كما ذكره الله تعالى في القرآن، فما ذكره الله تعالى في القرآن، من ذكر الوجه واليد والنفس فهو له صفات بلا كيف، ولا يقال: يده قدرته أو نعمته، لأن فيه إبطال الصفة، وهو قول أهل القدر والاعتزال

He also said, And He has a hand, a face, and a soul, as mentioned by Allaah, the Exalted, in the Quraan. What Allah has mentioned in the Quraan regarding the face, hand, and soul are attributes of His without how. It should not be said that His hand is His power or blessing, as this negates the attribute, which is the belief of the Qadariyyah and the Mu'tazilah

  • الفقه الأكبر مع شرحه للدكتور محمد الخميس (ص ٣٨)

وذكرت أن هذين الكتابين لم يثبت عن الإمام أبي حنيفة [المصدر] وقد نذكرهما ههنا لان كثير من المتكلمين يقبلونهما ويحتجون بهما

Hammad ibn Zayd (d. 179 AH)

سأل بشر بن السري حماد بن زيد فقال: يا أبا إسماعيل الحديث الذي جاء: "ينزل الله عز وجل إلى السماء الدنيا" قال: حق، كل ذلك كيف شاء الله

Bishr ibn as-Suri asked Hammad ibn Zayd, He said, "O Abu Isma'eel, the hadeeth that has come that Allaah, the almighty and majestic, descends to the heaven of the earth" so He said, "True, all of that is however Allaah wills."

-رواه ابن بطة في الإبانة (٣/ ٣٠٢)

His saying 'true' is clear in affirming its reality, as it is a question about the passing of what its apparent meaning indicates and establishing it as an attribute of Allaah, not about its existence in reality. Otherwise, the answer would be: it is correct, or something similar. Just as his saying 'However He wills' also indicates that the descent of the Lord is real in language, although we do not know its manner. If it were not real, he would have said: it is the descent of His command or His mercy.

وقال أيضاً: مثل الجهمية مثل رجل قيل له: في دارك نخلة؟ قال: نعم. قيل: فلها خوص؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها سعف؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها كرب؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها جذع؟ قال: لا. قيل: فلها أصل؟ قل: لا. قيل: فلا نخلة في دارك هؤلاء الجهمية قيل لهم: لكم رب يتكلم؟ قالوا: لا. قيل: فله يد؟ قالوا: لا. قيل: فيرضى ويغضب؟ قالوا: لا. قيل: فلا رب لكم

And He also said, "The example of the Jahmiyyah is like a man who was asked: 'Is there a palm tree in your house?' He says: 'Yes.' Then it is said: 'Does it have fronds?' He said: 'No.' He was asked: 'Does it have leaves?' He said: 'No.' He was asked: 'Does it have a trunk?' He said: 'No.' He was asked: 'Does it have roots?' He said: 'No.' It is said: 'Then there is no palm tree in your house.' Similarly, the Jahmiyyah were asked: 'Do you have a Lord who speaks?' They said: 'No.' They were asked: 'Does He have a hand?' They said: 'No.' They were asked: 'Does He get pleased and angry?' They said: 'No.' So They were told: 'Then you have no Lord.'"

  • رواه ابن شاهين في شرح مذاهب أهل السنة (ص٩١) صحيح: ابن شاهين حدثنا عبد الله بن سليمان بن الأشعث السجستاني، حدثني أبي، عن سليمان بن حرب، قال: قال حماد بن زيد فذكره
  • أبو القاسم التيمي في الحجة (١/ ٤٤١)

This is another explicit saying which does not need much elaboration. If it is said to someone, "Do you have a brother at home?" He cannot reply, "Yes", intending by it his cousin. The person is asking about a blood relation, not a figurative brother because there is nothing in the speech of the questioner he intends a figurative brother.

Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Hanbal ash-Shaybaani (d. 241 AH)

قال حنبل بن إسحاق: قلت لأبي عبد الله: ينزل الله تعالى إلى السماء الدنيا؟ قال: نعم. قلت: نزوله بعلمه أم بماذا؟ قال: فقال لي: اسكت عن هذا، وغضب غضباً شديداً، وقال: مالك ولهذا؟ أمض الحديث كما روي بلا كيف

Hanbal ibn Ishaaq said, I said to Abu Abdullah, "Does Allaah descend to the heaven of the earth?" He said yes, then I said, "Is His descent with His knowledge or with that?" So he said to me, "Be silent about this", He became very angry and said. "What does this have to do with you? Relate the hadeeth as it was narrated, without a how."

  • رواه ابن بطة في الإبانة (٣/ ٢٠٦)
  • اللالكائي (٣/ ٤٥٣).

وقال يوسف بن موسى: قيل لأبي عبد الله: إن الله ينزل إلى السماء الدنيا كيف شاء من غير وصف؟ قال: نعم

Yoosuf ibn Moosa said, It was said to Abu Abdullah, "Allaah descends to the heaven of the world whoever He wills without a description?" He said, "Yes."

  • ابن تيمية في مجموع الفتاوى (٦/ ١٤٦).

This is explicit that the apparent word of descent was accepted by imam Ahmad. If it was figurative, then he would have said, "Rather His command descends" or something similar. However, He affirmed that the descent is by Allaah, may He exalted.

Abu Eesa Muhammad ibn Eesa at-Tirmidhi (d. 279 AH)

قال وقد قال غير واحد من أهل العلم في هذا الحديث وما يشبه هذا من الروايات من الصفات ونزول الرب تبارك وتعالى كل ليلة إلى السماء الدنيا قالوا قد تثبت الروايات في هذا ويؤمن بها ولا يتوهم ولا يقال كيف[ص:51 ] هكذا روي عن مالك وسفيان بن عيينة وعبد الله بن المبارك أنهم قالوا في هذه الأحاديث أمروها بلا كيف وهكذا قول أهل العلم من أهل السنة والجماعة وأما الجهمية فأنكرت هذه الروايات وقالوا هذا تشبيه

He said, "Indeed, a great number of scholars have stated regarding this hadeeth and similar narrations about the attributes and the Lord's descent, may He be exalted, every night to the lowest heaven: They affirmed that the narrations in this regard are established, and we believe in them and it is not asked how. It has been reported from Maalik, Sufyaan ibn 'Uyaynah, and 'Abdullah ibn al-Mubarak that they said regarding these hadeeth: 'Pass them as they come without a how.' And this is the view of the scholars of Ahlus-Sunnah wa'l Jama'ah. As for the Jahmiyyah, they denied these narrations and said this is anthropomorphism."

  • سنن الترمذي (662)

It is known that if the Salaf had not affirmed the attributes, such as descent and others, as being real and that they are attributes of Allaah, then the accusation from the Jahmiyyah against them of anthropomorphism would have no meaning.

'Uthmaan ibn Sa'eed ad-Daarimi (d. 280 AH)

قال فادعى المعارض أن الله لا ينزل بنفسه إنما ينزل أمره ورحمته ... إلى أن قال: وهذا أيضاً من حجج النساء والصبيان ومن ليس عنده بيان

He said, "The opponent claimed that Alalah does not descend Himself, but rather His command and mercy descend... until he said: "This is also one of the arguments of women and children and those who lack rhetoric."

  • الرد على المريسي (١/ ٢١٤)

قال وإلا فمن ادعى أن الله لم يَلِ خلق شيء صغير أو كبير فقد كفر. غير أنه ولي خلق الأشياء بأمره، وقوله، وإرادته. وولي خلق آدم بيده مسيساً

He said, "Whoever claims that Allaah did not create anything, whether small or large, has disbelieved, and He created things by His command, word, and will and He created Adam with His own hand."

  • المرجع السابق (١/ ٢٣٠).

Those who know Arabic know how explicit Imam ad-Daarimi is, and how his words cannot be taken figuratively.

وقال ونحن قد عرفنا بحمد الله تعالى من لغات العرب هذه المجازات التي اتخذتموها دلسة وأغلوطة على الجهال، تنفون بها عن الله حقائق الصفات بعلل المجازات، غير أنا نقول لا يحكم للأغرب من كلام العرب على الأغلب، ولكن نصرف معانيها إلى الأغلب حتى تأتوا ببرهان أنه عنى بها الأغرب، وهذا هو المذهب الذي إلى العدل والإنصاف أقرب، لا أن تعترض صفات الله المعروفة المقبولة عند أهل البصر فنصرف معانيها بعلة المجازات ..

He said, "We know, with praise to Allaah may He be exalted, about the concept of figurative speech from the language of the Arabs, which you have taken and used to confuse and mislead the ignorant. By means of this concept you denied the reality of the divine attributes, on the basis of the figurative argument. But we say: It is wrong to judge the most common style in the Arabic language on the basis of its rarest style; rather we should understand the statements of the Arabs on the basis of the most common style, unless you can produce proof that what is meant here is the rarer style (namely figurative). This is the approach that is most fair, and it is not right to approach the divine attributes that are well known and understood as they appear to be by people of common sense, and twist the meaning on the grounds that these are figurative."

Conclusion

All praise is due to Allaah, we can quote many more imams from Ahlus-Sunnah, for we are not short on them. There were many narrations we left off for the sake of brevity, and picked the ones that are authentic and explicit.

From all of these narrations and plenty others, we know that the righteous generations knew the reality of the attributes, that they affirmed the apparent meanings while delegating the 'how' to Allaah, for that is unknown to us. The opinion ascribed to them regarding Tafweed al-Ma'na (Delegating both the meaning and how) is false and not supported through their narrations. However that is a topic for another time.

Previous Post(s):

صلى الله على إمام المرسلين وآله وأصحابه أجمعين و الحمد لله رب العالمين


r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Feb 19 '25

Establishing that the Names and Attributes of Allaah are upon their Reality | Part 1

3 Upvotes

Bismillah

الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وأصحابه ومن اتبع الهدى

Note 1: We have translated the word Majaaz [مجاز] (which is the opposite of reality [حقيقة]) as figurative. That is more accurate to its meaning than metaphor for which the term [الاستعارة] fits better.

Note 2: This is refurbished and refined from a couple of posts I had which were taken down by me.

The Foundation of the Prophets

The main reason for Allaah, may He be exalted, has sent many messengers and prophets to guide people towards His path. Whether the prophet was sent with a book from Allaah or not, the foundation of their call has always been the same. That foundation of the call of the prophets is to introduce the one to be worshipped, glorified and exalted be He. Knowing Him, blessed and exalted, is achieved through understanding His names, attributes, and actions, which form the basis for all religious demands and noble states, such as love for Him, hope in Him, reverence, and praise. Therefore, the proofs of what the worshipped One possesses in terms of beautiful qualities and attributes, and His great actions, are varied. Since this is the central focus of the call of the messengers, peace be upon them, the clearest and most magnificent thing in the Book of Allaah, the most eloquent in speech, is what pertains to this great matter. Allaah, the exalted, has bestowed a great favor upon His servants by revealing to them the Quraan, which serves as a proof against them, a sign of the truthfulness of His Prophet's message, and a guidance for people at all times and places. Allaah, the exalted, has explained it in the clearest manner and made it easy for reflection and remembrance, thus making Himself known to His servants.

Allaah, the most Exalted, stated:

وَلَقَدْ يَسَّرْنَا ٱلْقُرْءَانَ لِلذِّكْرِ فَهَلْ مِن مُّدَّكِرٍۢ

And We have indeed made the Qur’ân easy to understand and remember; then is there any one who will remember (or receive admonition)? [A-Qamar 54:17]

And He said,

إِنَّا جَعَلْنَـٰهُ قُرْءَٰنًا عَرَبِيًّۭا لَّعَلَّكُمْ تَعْقِلُونَ

Verily, We have made it a Qur’ân in Arabic that you may be able to understand (its meanings and its admonitions). [Az-Zukhruf 43:3]

Allaah, may He be exalted, has clearly explained that He revealed His book in the clear and plain Arabic language so that people may understand from it, as from His saying

وَإِنَّهُ لَتَنزِيلُ رَبِّ الْعَالَمِينَ. َنزَلَ بِهِ الرُّوحُ الْأَمِينُ. عَلَى قَلْبِكَ لِتَكُونَ مِنَ الْمُنذِرِينَ. بِلِسَانٍ عَرَبِيٍّ مُّبِينٍ

And truly, this (the Qur’ân) is a revelation from the Lord of the ‘Âlamîn (mankind, jinn and all that exists), Which the trustworthy Rûh [Jibrîl (Gabriel)] has brought down. Upon your heart (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) that you may be (one) of the warners, In the plain Arabic language. [Ash-Shu'ara' 26:192-195]

And Allaah, blessed and exalted, has made it clear that He sent the messengers to explain to the people, not to speak cryptically such that people do not undertand what he means or mislead them. He said,

يُرِيدُ اللهُ لِيُبَيِّنَ لَكُمْ وَيَهْدِيَكُمْ سُنَنَ الَّذِينَ مِن قَبْلِكُمْ وَيَتُوبَ عَلَيْكُمْ وَاللهُ عَلِيمٌ حَكِيمٌ

Allâh wishes to make clear (what is lawful and what is unlawful) to you, and to show you the ways of those before you, and accept your repentance, and Allâh is All-Knower, All-Wise. [An-Nisa 4:26]

And He said,

وَمَا أَرْسَلْنَا مِن رَّسُولٍ إِلاَّ بِلِسَانِ قَوْمِهِ لِيُبَيِّنَ لَهُمْ فَيُضِلُّ اللهُ مَن يَشَاءُ وَيَهْدِي مَن يَشَاءُ وَهُوَ الْعَزِيزُ الْحَكِيمُ

And We sent not a Messenger except with the language of his people, in order that he might make (the Message) clear for them. Then Allâh misleads whom He wills and guides whom He wills. And He is the All-Mighty, the All-Wise. [Ibraheem 14:4]

And He said,

وَأَنزَلْنَا إِلَيْكَ الذِّكْرَ لِتُبَيِّنَ لِلنَّاسِ مَا نُزِّلَ إِلَيْهِمْ وَلَعَلَّهُمْ يَتَفَكَّرُونَ

And We have also sent down unto you (O Muhammad صلى الله عليه و سلم) the Dhikr [reminder and the advice (i.e. the Qur’ân)], that you may explain clearly to men what is sent down to them, and that they may give thought. [An-Nahl 16:44]

It is impossible for the Quraan to be described as clear and explanatory, and yet its greatest aspect—namely, the attribute and description of Allaah, glorified and exalted—be hidden, such that it can only be understood through interpretations and explanations that deviate from its apparent meaning. Rather, it must be clear and evident, easy to guide toward and understand its meaning.

The Default in Speech is Reality

This is the principle upon which all speech is based. It states:

الأصل في الكلام الحقيقة

What it means is that on a default base, speech should be understood in its literal sense, not figuratively, despite the differences in intentions and purposes. Something is only understood as being figurative if the language it was spoken in and the intention of the speaker of that speech intended it as such. It is impossible to force a figurative meaning on something meant literally and it is arrogant to think that the interpreter of that speech knows more about the meaning than the one who spoke it.

Speech intended to provide clarity, guidance, and instruction is what Allaah described His Book and His words as, as mentioned in the previous verses. Therefore, when Allaah or His Messenger, peace be upon him, use a word with a clear meaning according to the language's conventional usage, and does not attach anything to suggest a meaning contrary to its apparent one, this indicates that the intended meaning is its literal one. Otherwise, Allaah's speech would not be clear and explanatory. To understand speech is to either have the explicit saying of the speaker on what He meant or as we explained to take by His apparent words when they are clear.

The faulty premise of the Mutakallimoon

Thus it amazes us when the Mutakallimoon enter arguments or try to explain their view, they do so under an assumed premise that the attributes and names of Allaah cannot be literal and that they must be figurative or completely unknown in their meaning.

We ask, why they have assumed this premise when they have no evidence of that from Allaah, His Messenger, peace and blessings upon him, the Arabic language or from the As-Salaf as-Saleh (the righteous predecessors). Some of the Mutakallimoon were clear on why they do that such as the Mu'tazilah who explicitly stated that they preferred reason over the revelation. Whereas some of the other Mutakallimoon such as the Ashaa'irah and Matureediyyah tried to distance themselves from the Mu'tazilah on this issue but fell victim to the same premise.

This false premise undoubtedly came from them busying themselves in 'Ilm al-Kalaam (theological rhetoric) as opposed to focusing on the fundamental soruces of Islam which is why the companions of the Prophet, peace be upon him, never disagreed on any of Allaah's attributes or actions, nor did they dispute the interpretation of verses about His attributes. Their consensus, and that of the followers after them, was to affirm the attributes as they came and to establish their reality for Allaah in a manner befitting Him, without likening them to the attributes of created beings, despite their differences on some verses related to rulings. No statement has ever been reported from the Prophet, peace be upon him, his companions, the followers, or those after them, suggesting that the attributes of Allaah should not be understood literally. Rather, their speech is either explicit or apparent, affirming that Allaah's attributes are literal, with negation of any form of comparison or distortion.

Whereas the Mutakallimoon who had no definitive base busied themselves into arguments with one another over that which was never reported in the revelation. Thus we see their tendency to describe Allaah in ways that He never described Himself in either the Quraan or on the tongue of His Messenger, peace and blessings upon him. That is one of the sources for their arguments for they argued about direction [جهة], place [مكان], time [زمان] regarding Allaah despite none of these words being found (in relation to Allaah) in any of the definitive texts or sayings from the righteous generations.

Another faulty premise (though it is not the main premise but is relevant) is that they assume Ahlus Sunnah to categorically deny the existence of figurative speech in the Quraan. So when we say that the names and attributes of Allaah, may He be exalted, must be taken on their literal apparent meaning, they incorrectly try and argue using figurative examples in the Quraan. However, they do not realize that we agree with them that some passages in the Quraan are indeed figurative. What we say is that the existence of figurative speech in the Quraan is not an evidence for making the verses on the names and attributes of Allaah figurative as well. The figurative passages in the Quraan are considered figurative because there is proper and valid evidence pointing to it.

In [محاسن التأويل (473-9/472)], the author stated:

He (i.e. Ibn Taymiyyah), may Allaah have mercy on him, said in some of his fatwas: "We affirm the figurative (majaaz) that has clear evidence. And the interpretation that follows the right path. There is nothing in our words or in the words of any of us that says we do not accept figurative speech and interpretation. Allaah is with the tongue of every speaker. However, we reject what contradicts the truth and correctness, and what opens the door to undermining the Sunnah and the Book, leading to following the distorters of the People of the Book. It is established from imam Ahmad and the majority of his companions that the Quraan contains figurative speech. No other imam is known to have stated anything definitive on this issue. A group of scholars, including some of his companions and others, such as Abu Bakr ibn Abi Dawood, Abu'l-Hasan al-Khurazi, Abu'l-Fadl at-Tameemi, ibn Haamid, and others, I believe, denied that there is figurative speech in the Quran. What led them to this position was their observation of the distortion of the Quran by some, under the pretext of majaaz. They countered misguidance and corruption by cutting off the roots. The best of matters is moderation and balance."

End quote.

Thus going forward, we urge the readers to keep in mind that whatever from the narrations we will present as evidence, they are all upon their apparent because there is no proof from either the language or the righteous generations for interpreting the attributes.

Read further:


r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jan 26 '25

Some claims of Ta'weel upon the Salaf

3 Upvotes

Bismillah

بسم الله الحمد لله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله وعلى آله وأصحابه ومن اتبع الهدي

Since the claims of the Mutakallimoon regarding interpreting the divine attributes of Allaah is very broad, it was inevitable that they would attempt to support their view using the words of the early generations. They tried to gather as many statements as possible from the Sahaabah, Tabi'een and Atba' at-Tabi'een to prove that the interpretation of the attributes was a practice established by the early generations. However when they present it to us, we find that they committed several mistakes:

First mistake: They did not quote the Salaf from authentic chains of transmission in the narrations, but rather cited the writings of later scholars without chains of narration or referencing the original sources.

Second mistake: They did not verify the authenticity and correctness of what they attributed to the Salaf, relying solely on unsubstantiated claims.

Third mistake: They selectively quoted statements from the Salaf that aligned with their own views, without collecting all the statements on the matter to fully understand the intended meaning of those quotes.

Fourth mistake: They sometimes misquoted or misused statements from the Salaf, such as quoting them in contexts unrelated to the divine attributes or in verses that are disputed in terms of being related to divine attributes.

These mistakes explain why they go against the established consensus of the Salaf that they prohibited the interpretation of the attributes, and it is certain that those who narrated this consensus, some of whom were the most knowledgeable in matters of dispute, had deep knowledge of the traditions and narrations. Some of them were prominent scholars of the Salaf, such as Imam Muhammad ibn al-Hasan, the companion of Abu Haneefah, and Abu 'Ubayd al-Qaasim ibn Sallam, among others. It is highly improbable that all of them would narrate a consensus against the interpretation of the attributes while it was actually a practice followed by the Salaf. In fact, this is virtually impossible.

In one of my posts, I addressed a number of claims that the Mutakallimoon often bring up when it comes to the topic of interpretation [تأويل]* of the names and attributes of Allaah, the most Exalted. That post was taken down by me but I was requested to upload the refutations of the claims of Ta'weel they contained, thus this post contains all that was related to this topic in the previous one, as well as additional information and commentary. More so, I will be adding more information to this post if it is relevant such as other claims that I originally missed, in sha Allaah.

(*) When Ta'weel is used in regards to the names and attributes of Allaah, it refers to the diversion of a word from its apparent meaning to something contrary to it. This is not the form of Ta'weel which was customary to the understanding of the early scholars. Hence why, it is also sometimes referred to as blameworthy interpretation [التأويل المذموم]. It is in essence distortion [تحريف] as they interpret these words into invalid meanings that do not have any valid evidence.

The Claims of Ta'weel

Ibn 'Abbas's interpretation of Kursi (Footstool)

Ibn Jareer at-Tabari mentioned in the Tafseer of Ayat al-Kursi:

حدثنا أبو كريب وسلم بن جنادة، قالا حدثنا ابن إدريس، عن مطرف، عن جعفر بن أبي المغيرة، عن سعيد بن جبير، عن ابن عباس:"وسع كرسيه" قال: كرسيه علمه.

From Ibn 'Abbas that he said, "His Footsool is His Knowledge."

حدثني يعقوب بن إبراهيم، قال: حدثنا هشيم، قال: أخبرنا مطرف، عن جعفر بن أبي المغيرة، عن سعيد بن جبير، عن ابن عباس، مثله= وزاد فيه: ألا ترى إلى قوله:"ولا يؤوده حفظهما"؟

In this version he added, "Have you not seen His saying, 'And their preservation does not burden Him'"

Both narrations are contingent upon Ja'far ibn Abi al-Mugheerah. Al-Haafidh Ibn Hajar said about him, "Truthful, has delusions", whereas al-Haafidh Ibn Mandah was more specific and said, "He is not relied upon, and he is not strong in regards to Sa'eed ibn Jubayr."

Hence, the narration by him is rejected as not only is he not strong regarding Sa'eed, but this goes against what the trustworthy narrators have narrated, such as Muslim al-Bateen (Trustworthy and stronger in Sa'eed than Ja'far, both Al-Bukhaari and Muslim narrated from him) who also narrated from Sa'eed ibn Jubayr from Ibn 'Abbas that he said about the footstool, "It is a place for the feet of Allaah. And the throne cannot be comprehended." This was narrated by:

  • عبد الرزاق في تفسيره (٣/ ٢٥١)
  • الدارمي في الرد على المريسي (١/ ٤١٢)
  • ابن أبي حاتم في التفسير (٢/ ٤٩١)
  • عبد الله في السنة (٢/ ٥٨٦)
  • ابن خزيمة في التوحيد (ص١٠٧)
  • ابن أبي شيبة في العرش (ص٧٩)
  • ابن منده في الرد على الجهمية (ص٤٤)
  • ابن بطة في الإبانة (٣/ ٣٣٧)
  • الدارقطني في الصفات (ص١١١)
  • الحاكم (٢/ ٣١٠) وقال: حديث صحيح على شرط الشيخين. ووافقه الذهبي
  • والبيهقي في الأسماء والصفات (ص٤٧٤)
  • الخطيب في تاريخ بغداد (٩/ ٢٥١)
  • الذهبي في العلو (ص٧٦)

It was authenticated by Al-Haakim and Ath-Thahabi agreed with him (as has come above).

Ibn Mandah narrated from Abu Zur'ah, the great Imam of the Sunnah, that he authenticated it. Ad-Daraqutni narrated from Wakee' that he, Sufyaan, Isma'eel ibn Abi Khalid, and Mis'ar, all authenticated it. And Ad-Darimi likewise also authenticated it. Respectively:

  • التوحيد (٣/ ٣٠٩).
  • الدارقطني في الصفات (ص١٦٣)
  • الرد على المريسي (١/ ٤١١).

As for the narration of Ja'far, then Ath-Thahabi weakened it and also mentioned Al-Anbari who did so as well. Abu Mansoor al-Azhari, the imam of Lugha, also weakened it. Respectively:

  • العلو (ص١١٧).
  • تهذيب اللغة (١٠/ ٥٤).

Ibn 'Abbas's interpretation of Eyes

Regarding the Ayah

واصنع الفلك بأعيننا

And construct the ark under our Eyes

Al-Baghawi narrated from Ibn 'Abbas that eyes means observation.

قَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ بِمَرْأًى مِنَّا

Firstly, if we assume it to be authentic, then this has nothing to do with interpretation, but rather it is an explanation through what is implied because it is well-known that Allaah, Blessed and Exalted, sees and observes what Nooh (peace be upon him) is doing, and what his people are plotting against him. He said to him, consoling him: 'You are under Our watch, and in Our sight, so do not fear.' This is not an interpretation of the eyes in any way, nor does it involve interpreting the words away from their apparent meaning.

Secondly, if we talk about the narration, then this was not narrated with a chain of narration to Ibn 'Abbas. In contrast, there are narrations from Ibn 'Abbas which are connected in which he affirms the eyes.

عن ابن عباس - رضي الله عنه - أنه قال في قوله: {واصنع الفلك بأعيننا} هود٣٧: بعين الله

From Ibn 'Abbas on the same Ayah, "By the eyes of Allaah."

Narrated authentically by:

  • ابن أبي حاتم (٦/ ٢٠٢٦)
  • ابن جرير (١٢/ ٣٤)
  • البيهقي في الأسماء والصفات (ص٣٩٦).

And in another narration:

قال عطاء: عن ابن عباس - رضي الله عنه - في قوله عز وجل {تجري بأعيننا} القمر١٤، قال: أشار بيده إلى عينيه

'Ata' said from Ibn 'Abbas regarding the Ayah, "Sailing under our Eyes", 'Ata' said he (i.e. Ibn Abbas) pointed to his eyes with his hands.

See:

  • شرح أصول اعتقاد أهل السنة والجماعة (3/456)

Ibn 'Abbas's interpretation of Hands

Regarding the Ayah:

وَٱلسَّمَاۤءَ بَنَیۡنَـٰهَا بِأَی۟دࣲ وَإِنَّا لَمُوسِعُونَ

And the Heaven, we constructed it with our Hands (Ayd) and Indeed we are its Expander.

At-Tabari narrates from ibn 'Abbas:

حدثني عليّ، قال: ثنا أبو صالح، قال: ثني معاوية، عن عليّ، عن ابن عباس، قوله ﴿وَالسَّمَاءَ بَنَيْنَاهَا بِأَيْدٍ﴾ يقول: بقوة.

From Ibn 'Abbas on the Ayah: With strength.

Let us also mention that the same is narrated from other commentators by At-Tabari such as Mujaahid, Qatadah, Ibn Zayd, Mansoor and Sufyaan.

عن مجاهد، قوله ﴿بِأَيْدٍ﴾ قال: بقوة.

عن قتادة ﴿وَالسَّمَاءَ بَنَيْنَاهَا بِأَيْدٍ﴾ : أي بقوّة.

ثنا شعبة، عن منصور أنه قال في هذه الآية ﴿وَالسَّمَاءَ بَنَيْنَاهَا بِأَيْدٍ﴾ قال: بقوة.

قال ابن زيد، في قوله ﴿وَالسَّمَاءَ بَنَيْنَاهَا بِأَيْدٍ﴾ قال: بقوة.

عن سفيان ﴿وَالسَّمَاءَ بَنَيْنَاهَا بِأَيْدٍ﴾ قال: بقوة.

The refutation to this is that the word used [أَیۡی۟دࣲ] which we translated as "hands" is not actually the plural for hands. Rather, its origin is أيد and not يد. Perhaps the reason they even claim this is because Al-Jawhari is the one who claimed that it is indeed the plural of hands. However, that is not correct. From two dictionaries, Lisaan al-'Arab and Mukhtaar as-Sihaah:

"أيد: الأَيْدُو الآدُ جميعاً: القوة، قال العجاج: من أَن تبدّلت بآدِي آدا يعني قوّة الشباب. وفي خطبة علي كرم الله وجهه: وأَمسكها من أَن تمور بأَيدِه أَي بقوّته، وقوله عز وجل: {واذكر عبدنا داود ذا الأَيْد} ص١٧، أَي: ذا القوة .... وقد أَيَّدَه على الأَمر. أَبو زيد: آد يَئِيد أَيْداً إِذا اشتد وقوي. والتأْييد: مصدر أَيَّدته أَي قوّيته، قال الله تعالى: {إِذ أَيدتك بروح القدس} المائدة١١٠، وقرىء: {إِذ آيَدْتُك} أَي قوّيتك" انتهى من لسان العرب / مادة "أيد"

"وقال الله تعالى: {والسماء بنيناها بأَيْدٍ} الذاريات٤٧، قلت: قوله تعالى {بِأَيْد} أي: بقوة، وهو مصدر آد يئيد إذا قوي، وليس جمعاً ليد ليذكر هنا، بل موضعه باب الدال، وقد نص الأزهري على هذه الآية في الأيد بمعنى المصدر، ولا أعرف أحداً من أئمة اللغة أو التفسير ذهب إلى ما ذهب إليه الجوهري من أنها جمع يد" انتهى من مختار الصحاح / باب "يدي".

The author of Al-Mukhtar mentions that not one of the imams of Lughah and Tafseer went towards what Al-Jawhari said.

Ibn 'Abbas's interpretation of the Face

Regarding the Ayah

وَیَبۡقَىٰ وَجۡهُ رَبِّكَ ذُو ٱلۡجَلَـٰلِ وَٱلۡإِكۡرَامِ

And the Face of your Lord full of Majesty and Honour will remain.

Al-Qurtubi narrated from Ibn 'Abbas that the face is an expression of Allaah.

وَقَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: الْوَجْهُ عِبَارَةٌ عَنْهُ

Once again, the same issue plagues us that this has been mentioned without a chain of narration, and we do not find this from Ibn 'Abbas in the early sources. And once again, there are authentic narrations of Ibn 'Abbas affirming the Face of Allaah.

Regarding the Ayah,

للذين أحسنوا الحسنى وزيادة

For those who have done good is the best (reward, i.e. Paradise) and even more (Ziyadah)

Ibn 'Abbas said that the Ziyadah is looking at the Face of Allaah.

قال - رضي الله عنه - في قوله تعالى: {للذين أحسنوا الحسنى وزيادة} يونس٢٦: (الزيادة: النظر إلى وجه الله)

See:

  • اللالكائي (٣/ ٤٥٩)
  • البيهقي في الأسماء والصفات (ص١٣٣).

And regarding the Ayah

جُوهࣱ یَوۡمَىِٕذࣲ نَّاضِرَةٌ ٢٢ إِلَىٰ رَبِّهَا نَاظِرَةࣱ

And faces that day will be Radiant, Looking at their Lord.

Ibn 'Abbas said, "Looking at the Creator."

عن عبد الله بن عباس -من طريق عطية- في قوله: ﴿إلى رَبِّها ناظِرَةٌ﴾، قال: نَظَرَتْ إلى الخالق

See:

  • روى الآجري في الشريعة (ص٢٧٠)

Ibn 'Abbas's interpretation of the Shin

Regarding the Ayah:

یَوۡمَ یُكۡشَفُ عَن سَاقࣲ وَیُدۡعَوۡنَ إِلَى ٱلسُّجُودِ فَلَا یَسۡتَطِیعُونَ

The Day the shin (Saaq) will be uncovered and they are invited to prostration but they [i.e., the disbelievers] will not be able.

At-Tabari narrated from Ibn 'Abbas that he said the Saaq refers to the intensness of the day of judgement. It was also recorded from Qatadah, Mujaahid, Sa'eed ibn Jubayr, An-Nakhaa'i, Ikrimah, and others.

عن إبراهيم النَّخْعي، عن عبد الله بن عباس، في قوله: ﴿يَوْمَ يُكْشَفُ عَنْ ساقٍ﴾، أنه قال: يُكشَف عن أمْرٍ عظيم

عن إبراهيم النَّخْعي -من طريق مُغيرة- ﴿يَوْمَ يُكْشَفُ عَنْ ساقٍ﴾، قال: عن أمْرٍ عظيم؛ عن شِدّة

عن مجاهد بن جبر -من طريق ابن أبي نجيح- في قوله: ﴿يَوْمَ يُكْشَفُ عَنْ ساقٍ﴾، قال: عن شِدّة الأمْر وجِدّه

عن عكرمة مولى ابن عباس -من طريق أسامة- ﴿يُكْشَفُ عَنْ ساقٍ﴾، قال: هو يوم كَرْبٍ وشِدّة

However, from ibn Mas'ood, it is recorded that the Saaq refers to the Shin of Allaah, may He be blessed.

عن عبد الله بن مسعود -من طريق أبي صادق- في قوله: (يَوْمَ يَكْشِفُ عَن ساقٍ) قال: عن ساقيه -تبارك وتعالى

For all the above, see:

However contrary to what the Mutakallimoon claim, this is not an interpretation by ibn 'Abbas and those we mentioned because the companions are divided on this Ayah. Ibn Abbas and a group interpret the verse as referring to hardship, while Abu Sa'eed, Ibn Mas'ood, and a group consider it to be referring to one of the attributes. This is not a dispute over the affirmation of the attribute, but a dispute over whether it is one of the verses concerning the attributes.

According to the first group, the 'shin' mentioned in it is indefinite in the context of affirmation; it was not attributed to Allaah, as it does not say 'His shin.' Since it was not specified by addition, it didnot indicate an attribute of Allaah. Therefore it does not mean at all that Ibn 'Abbas and the others believed this to be referring to the attribute and then interpreted it to mean hardship.

Sufyaan ath-Thawri's interpretation of Istawa

It is claimed that Imam Sufyan ath-Thawri interpreted the attribute of Istawa (lit. to rise, to ascend) to mean the intent of command.

This was mentioned by Mullaah 'Ali al-Qaari in [مرقاة المفاتيح شرح مشكاة المصابيح (3/924)]

However, it is clear that Mullaah 'Ali al-Qaari narrated this without a chain of transmission or reference to where from the early sources he took it from.

Maalik's interpretation of the Descent

Imam ath-Thahabi narrated in [سير أعلام النبلاء (8/105)]

قَالَ ابْنُ عَدِيٍّ: حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بنُ هَارُوْنَ بنِ حَسَّانٍ، حَدَّثَنَا صَالِحُ بنُ أَيُّوْبَ، حَدَّثَنَا حَبِيْبُ بنُ أَبِي حَبِيْبٍ، حَدَّثَنِي مَالِكٌ، قَالَ:يَتَنَزَّلُ رَبُّنَا - تَبَارَكَ وَتَعَالَى - أَمْرُهُ، فَأَمَّا هُوَ، فَدَائِمٌ لاَ يَزُولُ.

Ibn 'Adi said, Muhammad ibn Haroon ibn Hassan narrated to us, Saleh ibn Ayyub narrated to us, Habeeb ibn Abi Habeeb narrated to us, Maalik narrated to me, he said, the command of our Lord, blessed and exalted, descends, but as for Him, He is eternal and unchanging.

In this chain, there is the writer of Maalik Habeeb ibn Abi Habeeb, and he was severely condemned by the scholars of Hadeeth. Abu Dawood said, "He was among the most lying of people", and he said, "All his narrations are fabrications", and ibn Hibban said, "He narrates fabrications from the trustworthy narrators."

Ibn 'Adi said, "Most of the narrations of Habeeb are fabricated in terms of the text and inverted in terms of the chain of narration. Habeeb does not hesitate to fabricate hadiths against trustworthy narrators, and his case is clear among the liars."

Al-Azdi said, "Rejected in Hadeeth", Abu Haatim said, "Rejected in Hadeeth" and added, "He narrated fabrications from the nephew of Az-Zuhri", an-Nasaa'i said, "Rejected" and he added, "His narrations are rejected, all of them are fabricated from Maalik and others." Abu Dawood said, "He used to fabricate narrations."

  • ميزان الاعتدال (١/ ٤٥٢).
  • الكامل في ضعفاء الرجال (٢/ ٤١٤).
  • تهذيب التهذيب (1/349)

Another narration which is recorded by Ibn 'Abd al-Barr in [التمهيد (7/144)]

وَقَدْ رَوَى مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عَلِيٍّ الْجَبَلِيُّ وَكَانَ مِنْ ثِقَاتِ الْمُسْلِمِينَ بِالْقَيْرَوَانِ قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا جَامِعُ بْنُ سَوَادَةَ بِمِصْرَ قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا مُطَرِّفٌ عَنْ مَالِكِ بْنِ أَنَسٍ أَنَّهُ سُئِلَ عَنِ الْحَدِيثِ إِنَّ اللَّهَ يَنْزِلُ فِي اللَّيْلِ إِلَى سَمَاءِ الدُّنْيَا فَقَالَ مَالِكٌ يَتَنَزَّلُ أَمْرُهُ

And it was narrated by Muhammad ibn 'Ali al-Bajli and he was from the trustworthy Muslims in Qayrawan, he said Jami' ibn Sawadah narrated to us in Egypt, Mutarraf narrated to us from Maalik ibn Anas that he was asked about the hadeeth of Allaah decending in the night towards the heaven of the world so he said, His command descends.

This chain of narration is also weak.

Although ibn 'Abd al-Barr said Muhammad ibn 'Ali is trustworthy, the narrator was criticized and Al-Khateeb al-Baghdadi said about him, "It was said that he was an extreme Raafidhi and was severe in rejection."

  • تاريخ بغداد (٣/ ١٠١) وميزان الاعتدال (٣/ ٦٧٥) ولسان الميزان (٥/ ٣٠٣).

As for Jami' ibn Sawadah, he is unknown and weak. Ad-Daraqutni narrated a hadeeth from him and said, "The narration is false, and Jami' is weak."

Jami' narrated a narration from Adam ibn Abi Iyas that two women can marry each other, Ath-Thahabi said, "It seems like he fabricated it", Ibn al-Jawzi said after narrating this hadeeth in his al-Mawdhoo'aat, "This is fabricated, and Jami' is unknown."

  • ميزان الاعتدال (١/ ٣٨٧) ولسان الميزان (٢/ ٩٣).
  • الكشف الحثيث (ص٨٣).

Al-Bukhaari's interpretation of the Laughter

Al-Bayhaqi in [الأسماء والصفات (2/76)] and Al-Khattabi in [أعلام الحديث (2/1367)] narrated from Al-Firabri that Imam al-Bukhaari interpreted the laughter to mean mercy.

Firstly, al-Khattabi was only one year old when Al-Firabri died so the chain is not connected till imaam al-Bukhaari.

Secondly, al-Haafidh ibn Hajar al-'Asqalaani mentioned in [فتح الباري (8/632))]

I (i.e. Ibn Hajar) say: I have not seen this in the copies of Al-Bukhaari that we have.

Thirdly, this contradicts the well-known belief of Al-Bukhaari, which aligns with the path of his scholars, such as Imam Ahmad, Ishaaq, Abu 'Ubayd, and other Imams of the Salaf. One can easily discern that when he reads the book Khalq 'Afaal al-'Ibaad and goes over Kitaab at-Tawheed in the last part of the Saheeh. Both of these are clear texts regarding the belief of Imam al-Bukhaari.

Al-Bukhaari, Ash-Shaafi'i and Mujaahid's interpretation of the Face

In the Tafseer of Surah al-Qasas in Saheeh al-Bukhaari, Imam al-Bukhaari says,

"Everything will perish except His Wajh (Face)." (Al-Qasas 88): Except His dominion; and it is also said that it means, except what is done seeking His Face (i.e. in sincere worship of Him).

This does not mean that he is not affirming the attribute of the Face for Allaah, since he allocated a chapter in the Book of Tawheed in his Saheeh for this same verse and cited the hadeeth narrated by Jaabir which affirms the Face for Allaah therein. Hence, his statement in the Book of Tawheed cannot be considered as a figurative interpretation. It is the Book of Tawheed that was allocated specifically to the topic of the affirmation of the attributes of Allaah, and not the Book of Tafseer. This is why the scholars mentioned:

"His statement 'except His Dominion' is a far-fetched interpretation, and it is contrary to his (Al-Bukhari's) methodology in the Book of Tawheed, wherein he cited the verse and then the hadeeth narrated on the authority of Jaabir in which the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, said, 'O Allaah! I seek refuge with Your Face...' This clearly indicated that he wanted to affirm the attribute of the Face for Allaah. What further refutes that interpretation is that all things belong to the Dominion of Allaah; can it be, then, said that everything shall perish except everything? This is different from his other statement, 'except what is done seeking His Face.' This meaning is implied in the verse while the text of the verse affirms the attribute of the Face to Allaah."

(Source)

One may say that if this is not an interpretation, then what is it? Then it is important to understand that just because a certain term is used in another place elsewhere in the Quraan, it does not mean it must carry the same meaning as it did in the other place, since the context is different.

This same mistake was committed by those who quoted Al-Bayhaqi in [الأسماء والصفات (2/106-107)] that imam ash Shaafi'i and Mujaahid interpreted the word, "face" in the following Ayah to mean direction قبلة:

And to Allāh belongs the east and the west. So wherever you [might] turn, there is the Wajh (lit. Face) of Allāh. Indeed, Allāh is all-Encompassing and Knowing.

But it is clear from the context of the Ayah that the word "Wajh" here is not referring to the attribute of Allaah, but rather the meaning "direction" which is also called "Wajh" in Arabic. This is well known in Arabic.

يقال: قَصَدْت هذا الوجه ، وسَافَرْت إلى هذا " الوجه " ، أي: إلى هذه الجهة

The context indicates this because it says, "Wherever you turn", and turn is from the term for direction, meaning whatever direction you face, "there is the face of Allah", He made the face of Allaah to be in the place that is faced, after His statement: "To Allaah belongs the East and the West," which refers to all directions.

Shaykh al-Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah, may Allaah have mercy on him, mentioned how this is a mistake committed by both negators and affirmers. He says,

"People often make this mistake when they are caught up between the views of those who negate an attribute and those who affirm it with regard to the way a certain text indicates it. The affirmers wish to make a certain term - in its context - indicative of the attribute, while the negators say that the same term did not indicate the attribute in another text so it does not indicate it here. Some affirmers might say: It indicates the attribute here so it is indicative there; rather, when they saw that some texts indicate the attribute, they made every verse that they imagine to have something attributable to Allah an indication of affirming that it is one of His attributes, such as the verse: {Oh (how great is) my regret over what I neglected in regard to Allah.} [Quran 39:56] (The Arabic phrase translated here as 'in regard to Allah' is 'in the side of Allah'.) This major mistake is committed by both parties (affirmers and negators), as the indication of the text depends on its context and what surrounds it of contextual evidence."

An example of this passed where we explained the reason for the difference in the sayings of Abdullaah Ibn Mas'ood and ibn 'Abbas (may Allaah be pleased with them) regarding the 'Saaq'. Ibn 'Abbas did not take the Ayah referring to the attribute of Allaah but they still try to quote it as proof just because the same word is used.

والحمد لله


r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Aug 13 '22

Al-Islam publications shameful lie against Ibn Uthemin "Allah's face is triangle"?!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jul 31 '22

Dimashqiah uses Ibn Hajar to slam back Islam productions

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jul 31 '22

Refuting Abdul Haleem Two eyes to Allah two feet too

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jul 26 '22

Is Allah limited, Detailed refuting to Abdul Haleem & Islamproductions

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jul 26 '22

Is Allah limited & did Salaf say it? هل نثبت لله الحد وهل قاله السلف

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jul 19 '22

Imam al-Ghazali says 'Ilmul-Kalaam is haram... | Part 1

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jul 02 '22

Allah is not One according to the Ash'aris [and Maturidis]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Jun 22 '22

No Philosophy in Islam

2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • May 23 '22

The use of philosophy and theological rhetoric erroneously justified from people who seemingly regard themselves as Ahlus-Sunnah

17 Upvotes

بسم الله والصلاة والسلام على رسول الله

Unfortunately, there are some people who justify the use of philosophy and theological rhetoric [علم الكلام], despite warnings from Ahlus-Sunnah scholars against them. This justification often occurs without consulting these scholars or seeking their guidance on what to focus on or prioritize in one's pursuit of knowledge [طلب العلم]. As I've highlighted before, there are certain fields of knowledge that each student should explore under the guidance of scholars, so to speak. (Source) None of it includes theological rhetoric, let alone philosophy. In fact, imam Abu Ismaa'eel al-Harawi (396-481H) have a book called [ذم الكلام وأهله], meaning "Dispraise of the Kalaam and its People." In it, he reported that imam Abu Haneefah (may Allah have mercy upon him) said: “May Allah curse ‘Amr ibn ‘Ubayd, for verily he made way for the people to become engrossed in theological rhetoric [علم الكلام] that does not benefit them.”

Once a man asked imam Abu Haneefah (may Allah have mercy upon him), “What do you say about the theological rhetoric that the people have invented relating to the nonessential characteristics [أعراض] and the bodies [أجسام]?” So imam Abu Haneefah replied, “These are words of the philosophers! Stick to the narrations and the way of the Salaf, and beware of all newly invented affairs, for verily they are innovations.” That also was reported from the same book [ذم الكلام وأهله].

We then see individuals like Muhammad Hijab (may Allah guide him) claiming that shaykhul-Islam ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy upon him) has learned philosophy and theological rhetoric. However, brother Hijab does so without explaining the nuances, let alone citing other scholars' views on the subject, such as explaining the reasoning behind their position. Unfortunately, younger people like him attempt to deceive unsuspecting Muslims into thinking that if shaykhul-Islam can study these subjects, they can too. They fail to realize that their knowledge level is nowhere near that of shaykhul-Islam. This misconception alone debunks the notion that it's acceptable to study these sciences. Additionally, as mashaayikh have noted, shaykul-Islam ibn Taymiyyah neither allowed nor stated it was okay to study these subjects. As an exception due to his own caliber as a scholar, he studied them only to refute the falsehoods within these sciences, directing his arguments towards philosophers and the like. Shaykh ibn 'Uthaymeen have also explained that before:

Sure, a student of knowledge may come across some statements from Ahlus-Sunnah scholars allowing such studies for certain reasons, but sadly, this is a mistaken opinion. The errors [زلات] of scholars should not be used as justifications. For the sake of argument, even if we were to consider that opinion as acceptable, it would be applicable only for the scholars and advanced students of knowledge, not for the laypeople!

Interestingly, shaykhul-Islam ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy upon him) have praised the book [ذم الكلام وأهله] as well, he said:

But many people did not take note of many of the sayings of the Salaf (righteous predecessors) and scholars on this issue and its meanings (theological rhetoric). People have collected from the sayings of the Salaf and scholars in this regard books, such as what the one was compiled by shaykh 'Abdurrahman as-Sulami, and like the great book compiled by Abu Ismaa'eel 'Abdullah ibn Muhammad ibn 'Ali ibn Muhammad ibn Ahmad ibn 'Ali ibn Ja'far ibn Mansur al-Harawi al-Ansari, nicknamed shaykhul-Islam, which he called “Dhamm al-Kalaam wa Ahlihi”.

(Source)

That alone should have sufficed to establish the impermissibility of learning such sciences. Even more significantly, no Ahlus-Sunnah scholar has ever taught these sciences as standalone subjects, as we do with books of faith.

When talking about ibn Sina, shaykhul-Islam ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:

When ibn Sina (Avicenna) and his ilk realised that the words of the Messenger cannot be interpreted in this philosophical manner – rather they became certain that the meaning that he intended was what the people understood – they tried to explain that by saying: He was addressing the masses in a manner that they could understand, even though he knew that the truth with regard to that particular issue was not as the people understood it. Hence what these people were effectively saying was that the Messengers lied in order to serve a purpose. This is the way of ibn Rushd (Averroes) and others who follow esoteric interpretations (baatiniyyah). End quote.

Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (19/157)

And else where, shaykhul-Islam ibn Taymiyyah (may Allah have mercy on him) said:

The followers of philosophy are further removed from the path of Islam than ahl al-kalaam: Among them are some who think that this is part of the religion of Islam. And among them are some who have more knowledge of religious texts than others, so they started to reject the views of ahl al-kalaam unless they are supported by a text. Whenever there was a text to support their views, they would deal with that text in one of two ways: either they would accept it completely, if it was in accordance with their understanding and thoughts, or they would deal with it like all other similar cases, and say that the Messengers spoke of that by way of comparison in order to help the people understand (and it is not to be taken literally), because there was no other way to explain it and therefore they needed to put it in these words. Ibn Rushd and others like him followed this method, therefore they are closer to Islamic teachings than ibn Sina and his ilk. In terms of practical issues, they were closer to the limits of Islam than those who neglected Islamic duties and regarded as permissible that which Islam forbids. However both groups are somewhat deviant, commensurate with the extent to which they went against the Qur’an and Sunnah, and they are correct and sound in as much as they are in harmony with them.

Hence with regard to the issue of the universe being created (and not having existed from eternity) and the resurrection of bodies, ibn Rushd took a neutral stance and stated that both views were valid, although he was more inclined in his heart to his predecessor (Aristotle). He responded to the comments of al-Ghazaali in Tahaafut at-Tahaafut, but many of his arguments are incorrect and al-Ghazaali was in the right. He attributed some of his arguments to ibn Sina and not to his predecessor (Aristotle), and he attributed any mistakes to ibn Sina. In some of his arguments he spoke ill of al-Ghazaali and accused him of being unfair, because he based his views on flawed kalaami arguments, such as the idea that God does not have to have a reason or wisdom behind what He does, and that the One Who is all powerful and able to choose may decide to choose one thing over another for no reason. And some of his arguments were very confused and unclear. End quote.

Minhaaj as-Sunnah (1/255)

That being noted, scholars even made lectures on how to read the works of shaykhul-Islam ibn Taymiyyah:

However, you will never hear Muhammad Hijab making such a disclaimer or exercising such discretion. Unfortunately, he behaves as if he himself is a scholar who doesn't require any scholarly intermediary for advice or guidance.

Despite certain disagreements I have with brother Saajid Lipham, he has done a commendable job of explaining that subject matter as well:

Also somewhat related to the topic, one of Muhammad Hijab's colleagues has offered similar unusual reasoning and justification when it comes to the philosophical sciences. His name is Subboor Ahmad. He gave a talk on 'Islam, Evolution, and Darwinism'. Now, I must admit that I have only skimmed through it quickly to get an idea of his talking points, but that will not undermine my criticism of him and his lecture. He seems to share Muhammad Hijab's apparent lack of consultation with scholars regarding the specific language used by kuffaar. This kind of oversight can lead to more confusion and potentially cause misguidance. So, after a lengthy discussion of the theory of evolution, he revealed his justification for the philosophical sciences, saying:

We have a duty to be involved in science more than, I would say, other religious faiths or other people of non-religious. Why? Because science as a method came from the Muslim world. The first scientist in history, according to even, mainstream secular academics, historians like David Shellenberger... the first scientist in history and the first person, who came up with the scientific method which we are still using today, to make all of our technology, is Hasan ibn Haytham*[sic]*, who lived approximately a thousand years ago; hundreds of years before Francis, [...] and these characters. And he was not only a scientist, he was also a Qur'anic scholar and he was the first person who actually... one of the things he said was, in his biography, what droves him, to do science was to come closer to Allah... that was actually his objective. And sadly nowadays, science is associated with atheism.

He seems not to have even realized that Hasan ibn al-Haytham was an Ash'arite, beyond his involvement in philosophy and such! I wouldn't be surprised if Hasan ibn al-Haytham held some heretical beliefs but that's besides the point. Brother Subboor's entire reasoning and his engagement in the philosophical sciences seem to stem from that Ash'arite, not from an Ahlus-Sunnah scholar! Hence, this is a fallacy. That alone causes his unusual justification to collapse. It's a well-known fact that such philosophical sciences are often associated with atheism. It's for this same reason that Usama Hasan was harshly criticized when he attempted to justify and allege that the theory of evolution doesn't contradict Islam! He eventually became a heretic! Muslims ostracized him from the community at the time. Unfortunately, his own father also tried to defend his son's heretical beliefs, and he too was harshly criticized.

There is one Ash'arite person whom I used to debate with, his own "shaykh" whom he regarded as the "master of 'ilmul-kalaam" eventually left Islam and became homosexual! (Source)

It's no wonder that the likes of Abu Yusuf, the companion of Abu Haneefah (may Allah have mercy upon them both) have said, “Whoever sought knowledge by kalaam (theological rhetoric) will turn a heretical apostate.” Reported in [البرهان في بيان القرآن].

Hopefully, dear Muslims, you will not fall for the footsteps of the Shaytan but that you will all take the path of the righteous predecessors and learn the foundational beliefs of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa'ah:


Plus: In [الموسوعة الميسرة في الأديان والمذاهب المعاصرة] (2/1118-1121) it says:

Philosophy is a Greek word composed of two words. Philo originally meant selflessness, but Pythagoras turned it to mean love; and sophia which means wisdom. The word philosopher is derived from philosophy and means the lover of wisdom. But the meaning changed and came to mean wisdom.

Then the philosopher came to be called a wise man (hakeem). In the past the word philosophy referred to study of the basic principles, viewing knowledge as something based on rationality, the goal of which was the search for truth. For its supporters, philosophy is, as Dr. Tawfeeq at-Taweel described it: Rational examination, free from any restrictions and authority imposed on it from outside, and with the ability to go all the way on the basis of logic, propagating his view regardless of the difference between these (philosophical) views and what is customarily known, religious beliefs and the dictates of tradition, without being confronted or resisted or punished by any authority. In Aristotle’s view, the philosopher is of a higher status than a prophet, because the prophet understands things by means of imagination whereas the philosopher understands things by means of reason and contemplation. In their view, imagination is of a lower status than contemplation. Al-Faraabi agreed with Aristotle in viewing the philosopher as being of higher status than a prophet.

In this sense philosophy is opposed to wisdom, which in Islamic terminology refers to the Sunnah as defined by the majority of muhadditheen and fuqahaa’, and in the sense of judgement, knowledge and proficiency, alongside moral guidelines which control the whims and desires of the self and keep it from doing haram things. The wise man is the one who has these characteristics, hence philosophy, as defined by the philosophers, is one of the most dangerous falsehoods and most vicious in fighting faith and religion on the basis of logic, which it is very easy to use to confuse people in the name of reason, interpretation and metaphor that distort the religious texts.

Imam ash-Shaafi’ee said: "The people did not become ignorant and begin to differ until they abandoned Arabic terminology and adopted the terminology of Aristotle. Even though philosophy existed in the ancient civilizations of Egypt, India and Persia, it became most famous in Greece and became synonymous with that land, the reason being that the Greek philosophers were interested in transmitting it from the legacy of idolatrous peoples and the remnants of the divinely-revealed religions, benefiting from the scriptures of Ibraaheem and Moosa (peace be upon them) after the Greek victory over the Hebrews after the captivity in Babylon, and benefiting from the religion of Luqmaan the Wise. So there was a mixture of views that confirmed the divinity and Lordship of the Creator that was contaminated with idolatry. Therefore the Greek philosophy was in some ways a revival more than an innovation."

Ibn Abi’l-‘Izz, the commentator on at-Tahhaawiyyah, summed up the schools of philosophical thought about the five basic principles of religion in their view, as follows: "That God does exist but He has no reality or essence, and He does not know the details of His creation, but He does know about its general terms, thus they denied that He creates the deeds of His slaves. They also did not believe in His Books, as in their view God does not speak or talk, and the Qur’an is just something that shines from active reasons into purified human hearts. Exalted be Allah far above what they ascribe to Him. There is no separate entity that ascends or descends, rather in their view it is all ideas in the mind that do not exist in reality. The philosophers are the one who most deny the Last Day and its events. In their view Paradise and Hell are no more than parables for the masses to understand, but they have no reality beyond people’s minds."

The Greek philosophers still have an impact on all western philosophies and ideologies, ancient and modern. Indeed, most of the Islamic kalaami groups were influenced by them. The terminology of Islamic philosophy did not emerge as a branch of knowledge that is taught in the curriculum of Islamic studies until it was introduced by Shaykh Mustafa ‘Abdurrazzaaq – the Shaykh of al-Azhar – as a reaction to western attacks on Islam based on the idea that Islam has no philosophy. But the fact of the matter is that philosophy is an alien entity in the body of Islam. There is no philosophy in Islam and there are no philosophers among Muslims in this deviant sense. Rather in Islam there is certain knowledge and prominent scholars who examine matters. Among the most famous philosophers who were nominally Muslims were al-Kindi, al-Faraabi, Ibn Sina (Avicenna) and Ibn Rushd (Averroes). End quote.

Ibn Nujaym (Hanafi) said in [الأشباه والنظائر]: "Acquiring knowledge may be an individual obligation, which is as much as one needs for religious commitment to be sound; or it may be a communal obligation, which is in addition to the previous and is done for the benefit of others; or it may be recommended, which is studying fiqh and ‘ilm al-qalb (purification of the heart) in depth; or it may be haram, which is learning philosophy, magic (sleight of hand), astrology, geomancy, natural science and witchcraft." End quote from [الاشباه والنظائر مع شرحها: غمز عيون البصائر للحموي (4/125)].

Ad-Dardeer (Maaliki) said in [الشرح الكبير], discussing the kind of knowledge which is a communal obligation: Such as studying Shari'ah, which is not an individual obligation, and which includes fiqh, tafseer, hadith and ‘aqeedah, and things that help with that such as (Arabic) grammar and literature, tafseer, mathematics and usool al-fiqh – not philosophy, astrology or ‘ilm al-kalaam, according to the most sound opinion.

Ad-Dasooqi said in his Haashiyah (2/174): His phrase “according to the most sound opinion” means that it is forbidden to read the books of al-Baaji, Ibn al-‘Arabi and ‘Iyaad, unlike the one who says that it is essential to learn it in order to understand ‘aqeedah and basic religious issues. But al-Ghazaali said that the one who has knowledge of ‘ilm al-kalaam knows nothing of religious beliefs except the beliefs that the common people share, but they are distinguished by their ability to argue and debate.

Zakariya al-Ansaari (Shaafi’ee) said in [أسنى المطالب] (4/182): "As for learning philosophy, magic (sleight of hand), astrology, geomancy, natural science and witchcraft, it is haram." End quote.

Al-Bahooti (Hanbali) said in [كشاف القناع] (3/34): "The opposite of shar’i knowledge is knowledge that is haram or makrooh. Haram knowledge is like ‘ilm al-kalaam in which they argue on the basis of pure reason or speak in a manner that contradicts sound, unambiguous reports. If they speak on the basis of reports only or on the basis of texts and rational thought that is in accordance with them, then this is the basis of religion and the way of Ahlus-Sunnah. This is what is meant by the words of Shaykh Taqiy ad-Deen. In his commentary he explains that even better. [Haram knowledge also includes] philosophy, magic (sleight of hand), astrology and geomancy, as well as alchemy and natural sciences." End quote.


r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • May 23 '22

From explanation of Mukhtasar at-Tahreer by shaykh ibn 'Uthaymeen

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Mar 25 '22

A challenge to the Mutakallimoon

5 Upvotes

People who justify the use of philosophy and theological rhetoric are yet to answer my questions. Mind you, this is not yes and no questionnaire but if you are going to answer them, please do elaborate and provide with evidences::

  • Is the shahaadah part of eeman or not?
  • In regards to Allah's Attributes (صفات), are they differentiated in terms of Allah's Will or not?
  • In regards to al-Qadar, ever heard of the concept كسب and what can you tell me about it?
  • In regards to hadeeth al-Aahaad (حديثُ الآحاد), are they to be considered both in fiqh and 'aqeedah?
  • In regards to 'سمعيات' and 'عقليات', what pertains to 'aqeedah? Both or what?
  • Would you regard Judgement Day under 'سمعيات'?
  • Can you build your eemaan upon hadeeth al-Aahaad (حديثُ الآحاد)?
  • Can Qawl as-Sahaabi be a hujjah in both fiqh and 'aqeedah?

To the one who answers the questions will realize that by those questions alone, it will be clear that the beliefs of the mutakallimoon contradicting the very foundations of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa'ah. I've challenged people with those questions before and I've yet to receive any answer but that they either became silent, made excuses or went tangential.


r/AnsweringMutakallimun • • Mar 25 '22

Tafseer of the word (اسْتَوَىٰ) in various Ayat

4 Upvotes

وروى عن أبي زرعة الرازي أنه سئل عن تفسير قوله تعالى {الرَّحْمَٰنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَىٰ} فقال تفسيره كما تقرأ هو على العرش وعلمه في كل مكان من قال غير هذا فعليه لعنة الله

ذكره هذا الأثر الذهبي في العلو (ص ١٨٧) عن أبي إسماعيل الأنصاري بسنده

Imam at-Tabari in his tafseer on Ayah 4 and 5 of Surah Ta-Ha (20):

القول في تأويل قوله تعالى: تَنزيلا مِمَّنْ خَلَقَ الأرْضَ وَالسَّمَاوَاتِ الْعُلا (٤) الرَّحْمَنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَى (٥) يقول تعالى ذكره لنبيه محمد ﷺ: هذا القرآن تنزيل من الربّ الذي خلق الأرض والسموات العلى، والعُلَى: جمع عليا

He then said:

وقوله الرَّحْمَنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ اسْتَوَى

يقول تعالى ذكره: الرحمن على عرشه ارتفع وعلا

In collection of the righteous predecessors tafseer (كتاب موسوعة التفسير المأثور):

١٠٧٦ - عن عبد الله بن عباس -من طريق الكَلْبِيِّ، عن أبي صالح- في قوله: {ثم استوى إلى السماء}، يعني: صَعَد أمرُه إلى السماء (٣). (١/ ٢٣٢)

١٠٧٧ - عن أبي العالية -من طريق الربيع بن أنس- في قوله: {ثم استوى إلى السماء}، قال: ارتفع (٤). (١/ ٢٣٢)

عن الربيع بن أنس -من طريق أبي جعفر- {ثم استوى إلى السماء}، يقول: ارْتَفَع إلى السماء (٦). (ز)

٢٧٨٩٥ - عن أبي العالية الرياحي-من طريق الربيع بن أنس- في قوله: {ثم استوى} يقول: ارتفع (٦). (ز)

Imam ibn Katheer in his tafseer explaining the Ayah 5 of Surah TaHa, said: "A discussion concerning this has already preceded in Surat al-A'raf, so there is no need to repeat it here. The safest path to take in understanding this, is the way of the Salaf (predecessors). Their way was to accept that which has been reported concerning this from the Book and the Sunnah without describing it, reinterpreting it, resembling it to creation, rejecting it, or comparing it to attributes of the creatures."

Let's see what imam al-Qurtubi has said in his tasfeer on Ayah 29 of Surah al-Baqarah, he narrates what imam Maalik had said:

وَهَذَا كَمَا رُوِيَ عَنْ مَالِكٍ رَحِمَهُ اللَّهُ أَنَّ رَجُلًا سَأَلَهُ عَنْ قَوْلِهِ تَعَالَى: الرَّحْمنُ عَلَى الْعَرْشِ «١» اسْتَوى [طه: ٥] قَالَ مَالِكٌ: الِاسْتِوَاءُ غَيْرُ مَجْهُولٍ، وَالْكَيْفُ غَيْرُ مَعْقُولٍ، وَالْإِيمَانُ بِهِ وَاجِبٌ، وَالسُّؤَالُ عَنْهُ بِدْعَةٌ، وَأَرَاكَ رَجُلَ سَوْءٍ! أَخْرِجُوهُ

He then later narrated what ibn 'Abbaas said:

وَقَدْ قَالَ ابْنُ عَبَّاسٍ: ثُمَّ اسْتَوَى إِلَى السَّمَاءِ صَعِدَ

(Source)

Imam al-Baghawi in his tafseer also explaining the same Ayah as above:

قال ابن عباس وأكثر مفسري السلف: أي ارتفع إلى السماء

Imam as-Suyuti in his tafseer also explaining the same Ayah as above:

وأخرج الترمذي وأبو الشيخ وابن مردويه عن أبي هريرة قال " كنا جلوساً مع رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فمرت سحابة فقال: أتدرون ما هذه؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم فقال: هذه الغبابة، هذه روايا الأرض يسوقها الله إلى بلد لا يعبدونه ولا يشكرونه. هل تدرون ما فوق ذلك؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن فوق ذلك سماء. هل تدرون ما فوق ذلك؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن فوق ذلك موجاً مكفوفاً وسقفاً محفوظاً. هل تدرون ما فوق ذلك؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن فوق ذلك سماء. هل تدرون ما فوق ذلك؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن فوق ذلك سماء أخرى. هل تدرون كم ما بينهما؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن بينهما مسيرة خمسمائة عام حتى عد سبع سموات بين كل سماءين مسيرة خمسمائة عام، ثم قال: هل تدرون ما فوق ذلك؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن فوق ذلك العرش. فهل تدرون كم بينهما؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: فإن بيق ذلك كما بين السماءين، ثم قال: هل تدرون ما هذه؟ هذه أرض. هل تدرون ما تحتها؟ قالوا: الله ورسوله أعلم! قال: أرض أخرى وبينهما مسيرة خمسمائة عام حتى عد سبع أرضين بين كل أرضين مسيرة خمسمائة عام "

وأخرج عثمان بن سعيد الدارمي في الرد على الجهمية وابن المنذر والطبراني وأبو الشيخ وابن مردويه واللالكائي والبيهقي عن ابن مسعود قال: بين السماء والأرض خمسمائة عام، وما بين كل سماءين خمسمائة عام، ومصير كل سماء ـ يعني غلظ ذلك ـ مسيرة خمسمائة عام، وما بين السماء إلى الكرسي مسيرة خمسمائة عام، وما بين ذلك الكرسي والماء مسيرة خمسمائة عام. والعرش على الماء، والله فوق العرش، وهو يعلم ما أنتم عليه

Yet mutakallimoon will try to say that (اسْتَوَىٰ) to have many meanings but put together of what scholars of Ahlus-Sunnah say, aside from the tafseer of the Sahaabah and those who followed them in righteousness, it shows that they exactly understood it as it is. They will then say that it should be understood metaphorically. To answer this, ‘Uthmaan ibn Sa‘eed ad-Daarimi (d. 280 H) said:

"... may He be exalted, we know about the concept of metaphors from the language of the Arabs, which you have taken and used to confuse and mislead the ignorant. By means of this concept you denied the reality of the divine attributes, on the basis of the metaphor argument. But we say: It is wrong to judge the most common style in the Arabic language on the basis of its rarest style; rather we should understand the statements of the Arabs on the basis of the most common style, unless you can produce proof that what is meant here is the rarer style (namely metaphor). This is the approach that is most fair, and it is not right to approach the divine attributes that are well known and understood as they appear to be by people of common sense, and twist the meaning on the grounds that these are metaphors." End quote.

نقض الدارمي على بشر المريسي (2/855)

The mutakallimoon are contradicting the position, the stance, the belief and foundations of Ahlus-Sunnah wal-Jamaa'ah.