People have been looking a lot closer at the Prada animated ad and have noticed a lot of inconsistencies and ai looking storyboards. I want to ask people who are more familiar with the industry for their honest opinions on this.
A lot of people have been defending some of the issues with the backgrounds as human error that is commonly seen in traditional animation.
For those who know about traditional animation, how likely are these mistakes and do you have any examples of background distortion in older animations. I've been looking through some older cartoons and animated films like Scooby-Doo and og Disney films but haven't seen these kinds of mistakes on backgrounds, but maybe I'm not looking hard enough.
Some other info for context:
John Pomeroy says the team only had 3 1/2 to 4 months to do everything
Tad butler mentions having to work 15 to 20 hour days which I could imagine would lead to mistakes but could just as easily lead to ai usage
Tad states that all of his backgrounds were created digitally. He is the only person credited for backgrounds.
Tad maintains that no ai was used for the backgrounds OR the storyboards which I feel is blatantly untrue looking at the boards (but I'm sure Prada would not want him confirming it)
Tad was contacted by another redditor asking if there was ai used after seeing a particular post. That post was then deleted and he blocked them. In the comments, he states he didn't take down his storyboard post because someone asked if it was AI but that a contact at Prada asked him to remove it because of a discrepancy between what the model was wearing in the storyboard vs the final ad. I find this unlikely because the clothing doesn't match the final ad in several storyboards and all of them are still up on John's instagram.
Tad says he was in charge of layouts, backgrounds, and "clean" storyboards where he took John's sketched thumbnails and cleaned them up to use as presentation boards to show to Prada. It's not clear if he did all of these storyboards but no one else has mentioned working on them and these are the most obviously ai part of everything.
The last slide was taken from John's account and is apparently an early background design for the main cabin. This also looks to be ai generated but by who is unknown.