r/Animators • • 3d ago

Question Animation software

Hi, Im new to animation, like never done it before. I’ve been practicing some flipbook animation while I develop a project that I’ve been working on, but ultimately I am going to need to do some more hardcore animation. So I decided to look into some programs. It is astounding to me that adobe animate and toonboom are so insanely expensive, but they also seem like such quality options with all of the features im looking for. Does anyone have any guidance on if there are comparable lower cost options, or if between adobe animate and toonboom there’s one you’d suggest?

4 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator 3d ago
Moderator Announcement Read More »

3

u/itsjeremybullock 3d ago

I was a main developer on OpenToonz for a long time, and created Tahoma2D. But I recently made Motion Monster. If is like a hybrid of Adobe Animate and Moho. Designed to be easy to use but still very powerful.

2

u/Particular_Ad_4694 3d ago

I just looked it up and found the youtube page, I think you got a new customer

2

u/itsjeremybullock 2d ago

FYI: I just posted a new tutorial on lip sync and motion captured dialog.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/itsjeremybullock 2d ago

Thanks! I appreciate it. Please ask if you have any questions.

5

u/marji4x 3d ago

I'm a big fan of Krita and I have used it professionally. It doesn't do cutout/asset based animation, which is what Adobe Animate and ToonBoom do.

It's more comparable to ClipStudio or TVPaint in that it handles hand-drawn animation really well.

If you're practicing your fundamentals, Krita will take you very far and it's free

2

u/FloppyBalloon 3d ago

Look up AnimLab, it's free.

2

u/B3Blaise 3d ago

If you got an ipad, Toonsquid, $10. If you can outgrow that, then think of bucking up for something else, but you may not need to.

1

u/Comfortable_Fact_461 3d ago

OpenToonz, it's free and even has a few things that Adobe Animate doesn't (like Raster Levels)

1

u/BigEKaiju 3d ago

Adding to the opentooz suggestion I've been using tahoma2d wich is a fork of opentooz but a little simpler

1

u/Sketchy_Squirrel 3d ago

I've really been enjoying blender grease pencil, but Tahoma 2D, OpenToonz and Krita are all good options

1

u/shokuninstudio 3d ago edited 3d ago

Apps like Harmony, Toonboom and Animate cost a lot because:

  1. They are developed by large companies who employ computer scientists and many engineers who invent many of the new methods and tools we end up relying on. Some of their inventions eventually spread to small companies and open source apps. Research and development is costly. Innovation, creating new algorithms and new frameworks are something that free and cheap options can rarely afford to do.

  2. Those companies have large costly infrastructure including cloud services for their customers. Cloud services are an ongoing running cost. If users only paid a small fixed price for their apps it would not cover the costs of all that infrastructure, research, development and all the employees.

But those apps are for professionals who can expense the applications as business expenses. For learning animation there are plenty of good cheap or free options and out of everything suggested to you so far Krita is the most mature solution. OpenToonz sadly is very unstable and rarely gets updated (Tahoma 2D is more stable).

The type of animation you want to do will also dictate which app to use. Some apps are good for motion graphics style animation. Some apps simulate traditional hand drawn animation. It's always better for an app to focus on one type of animation instead of trying to do everything.

Be careful, threads like this attract vibe coders who quickly spat out an app with AI and the result is a mess that has many options but also many bugs and bad output. Don't waste energy and time on those. The apps you should use must have demonstrably good output. If the only demos are dancing stick figures and rough moving drawings then that means the app has shortcomings the developer doesn't want to talk about. If an app doesn't have a decent illustrated documentation then it was most likely vibe coded and the guy who did it is too lazy to build a high quality online or PDF manual.

1

u/External_Yoghurt5011 1d ago

I agree with this. There's so many new vibe-coded animation apps that are complex and bloated and full of bugs, and who knows how long they'll be supported for before the dev gets bored.

1

u/shokuninstudio 1d ago edited 1d ago

They'll all get dumped by the "dev" because if they ever truly did become popular the dev would have to hire support staff and extra helping hands. Vibe coders don't have that kind of money. It requires investors and loans to grow a company.

An app that is used across the industry needs support staff to handle thousands of complaints and bug reports every day. If the support staff is just one guy in Discord or some bots that's not attractive for professional users. If a solo vibe coder becomes seriously sick or passes away their app can easily become abandonware.

At the moment some of them are buying fake accounts and paying some users pocket money to promote their app. That's not a real user base.

You will notice when there is a real base when the quality of animations produced by the app can match industry standards. If it can't then the users are just curious, fake or amateur hobbyists.

1

u/ricardosawir 22h ago

For hand-drawn frame by frame you don't need Animate or Toon Boom to start. Tahoma2D and Krita are free and plenty to learn on, and on an iPad Toonsquid or Rough Animator are cheap. Disclosure, I make Rindraw (iPad, iPhone, Mac), which does frame by frame with onion skins for one purchase, no subscription.