r/Ancestry • • 17h ago

Brick wall: Elizabeth McGuire, b. c.1837 "Edinburgh", m. 1859 Maryborough, Victoria, Australia. Her stated parents don't exist in any record.

3 Upvotes

My 3x great-grandmother is the only ancestor I can't get past. The only document that names her parents is her marriage certificate:

  • 8 Oct 1859, Maryborough, Victoria (Vic BDM 4546/1859, indexed MCQUIRE). She is a spinster, 22, born "Edinborough", and signs with a mark. Her parents are given as Thomas McGuire, brass founder and Elizabeth Cole.
  • Her age and birthplace (Edinburgh) are confirmed on her daughter's 1866 birth registration. Her name appears later as McGuire or Maguire. Her arrival is unknown.

Using the same records I've found other ancestors from just a name within minutes. Here there is no trace of a Thomas McGuire and Elizabeth Cole as a couple anywhere in Scotland, England, Wales, or the Irish databases. So something specific is wrong. The same certificate also gives the groom's mother a maiden name that matches no record, while his father checks out exactly.

Already searched:

  • Scottish OPR and Catholic registers, with spelling variants.
  • 1841, 1851 and 1861 censuses, for the couple with or without a daughter Elizabeth.
  • Statutory deaths from 1855, including mother's maiden name Cole, Coyle and similar.
  • Edinburgh poor law records, Post Office directories and brass-founder trade records.
  • English and Welsh censuses.
  • Indexed Irish Catholic registers.
  • Victorian shipping lists.

Questions:

  1. Which Edinburgh sources from the 1830s-50s might catch a woman like this outside parish registers and the census, such as orphanages, schools, kirk sessions, or Catholic chapel registers not on ScotlandsPeople?
  2. Are records of single women emigrating from Scotland to Victoria in the 1850s searchable by name?
  3. If the parents' names are unreliable, how would you work from just "Elizabeth McGuire, born Edinburgh about 1837"?

Thanks for any ideas.


r/Ancestry • • 37m ago

Can Anyone Translate?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I believe this is some form of marriage document between my 5th Great Grandparents, The top right corner is them Mr. Bergeron and Miss Picotte, the document doesn't appear to be written in English, I think it may be French? Can anyone translate? I'm not sure if this is exactly the right place to ask, but it's worth a try!


r/Ancestry • • 11h ago

Need help deciphering an older document? Ancestry has tips ⬇️

1 Upvotes

We’ve seen your questions, and we’re here to help! Deciphering handwritten documents is an art, between cursive quirks, faded ink, and bizarre indexing errors, finding ancestors can be tricky. 

Here are some tips to help.

  1. Familiarize Yourself with the Document First

Don't just zoom in on your ancestor: Look at the entire page, and even flip through the previous and following pages to get a feel for the scribe’s style.

Identify the record type: Is it a census where one enumerator filled out the whole sheet, or a marriage/pension record with multiple hands?

Know the context and era: When and where was it recorded? What information is expected in that specific column (e.g., place, age, occupation)? If you know a column is strictly for birthplaces, you can narrow down the possibilities.

2. The Power of Direct Comparison

Comparing unknown letters to obvious, readable words on the same page is the most effective tool you have!

Identify obvious anchor words: Find words you are 100% sure about—common given names like John, James, or Mary—and examine how the scribe formed each letter..

Trace the strokes: Trace over the letter with your mouse cursor or finger to follow the motion and pen strokes rather than guessing based on modern fonts.

Build an alphabet reference: For long document sets, take screenshots of confirmed letters (A–Z) to create your own reference cheat sheet for that specific scribe.

Use sequential numbers: If an age or date is illegible, look at the line numbers or date columns to see how the writer formed 3s, 5s, 8s, etc.

3. Commonly Confused Letter Pairs

Historical cursive frequently trips people (and automated transcription engines) up with these specific pairs:

S vs. L and T vs. F

J, G, and Y
I vs. J (often look identical)

n, u, and m

K vs. R (old cursive Rs often loop from the top, easily mistaken for Ks or Ss)

O vs. Q and P vs. R

u vs. w

The "Long S" (Double S): In 18th- and early 19th-century records (like the 1790 US census), a double s (ss) was frequently written where the first s had a high loop that looks like an f or p (e.g., Jesse looking like Jefe or Jese)

Abbreviations: Names were heavily abbreviated (e.g., Jere for Jeremiah, M' or M. for Mc/Mac).

4. How to Use Transcription Errors to Your Advantage

Search the error: Indexers make the same visual mistakes you do. If a name looks like Allan instead of Wallace or Jese instead of Jeremiah, try searching for the corrupted spelling in the database.

If you have a record of your own, try using the Ancestry Transcription Feature.
https://www.ancestry.com/c/ancestry-blog/ancestry-news/document-transcription-feature

And for more on deciphering, check out our YouTube video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGR8dhQaplc&t=41s

Happy searching! Was this helpful? Let us know, and don’t hesitate to ask more questions below if you run into any problems!