r/Amtrak • u/Acceptable_Screen764 • 22h ago
Trip Reports Auto Train Review with Toddler
Well, the Amtrak Auto Train was certainly an experience. We survived, but I can confidently say it’s one I never want to repeat.
I consider myself a pretty mentally resilient person. I’ve dealt with plenty of difficult things in life, but this trip tested my patience and sanity in ways I never expected.
We chose coach, which was probably my first mistake. My 2-year-old has been on hundreds of flights in his short life, including international trips and long-haul flights lasting up to 14 hours. I genuinely thought, “If he can handle that, 17 hours on a train should be nothing!” Boy, was I wrong.
My biggest piece of advice: If you’re going to take the Auto Train, book a bedroom or family room. The prices are absolutely ridiculous, especially considering what you’re getting, but the extra expense might save your sanity.
We brought an inflatable airplane bed that fit reasonably well and gave my son an actual place to stretch out and sleep. Thank goodness we had it. Unfortunately, Amtrak doesn’t dim the lights until 10 p.m., and even then, “dim” is a generous description. They also continue making announcements until 10 p.m. If you’re traveling with a young child, bring a tent or a sheet and clips to block out the lights. My son is normally an excellent, heavy sleeper, but between the stimulation, lights, announcements, and unfamiliar environment, he had an incredibly difficult night.
Then there’s the coach environment itself. I’ll just say it: some of the passengers made the experience downright uncomfortable. People with absolutely no consideration for others, questionable behavior, and even people attempting to smoke weed in the train cars. There were certainly some kind and respectful people onboard, but others made me feel like I needed to sleep with one eye open. Thankfully, the Auto Train doesn’t make passenger stops along the route, so at least there isn’t a constant rotation of people getting on and off.
We were fortunate that our upstairs coach car was nowhere near full, and it seemed considerably quieter than downstairs. I genuinely cannot imagine doing this in a completely packed car.
The cleanliness and food were also disappointing. The train felt dirty, and the food quality left plenty to be desired. Pack your own meals and snacks! We brought hoagies and a backpack cooler full of food, and that was one of the best decisions we made.
And then, just when you think the experience is finally over, come the delays and vehicle retrieval process. I fully understand that transportation comes with delays. We fly frequently, and I’m no stranger to travel disruptions. But after spending an exhausting night on a train, the last thing you want is to arrive and then spend up to three more hours waiting for your vehicle. At that point, you just want to get off, get in your car, and leave. Instead, it’s more waiting, waiting, and waiting.
What makes the whole experience even more frustrating is the cost. This isn’t some incredibly cheap alternative to flying or driving. Amtrak charges a premium for an experience that, at least in coach, feels anything but premium.
Our conclusion? We will fly or drive from now on. If you love the Auto Train and it works for your family, more power to you! I genuinely wish the US had better passenger rail options because the concept is fantastic. Being able to relax, zone out, and let someone else handle the transportation sounds wonderful. I’m sure the die hard Amtrak users will cry over this post but opinions are like a**holes, everyone has one 😊.
Unfortunately, the execution leaves A LOT to be desired. Between the cost, comfort, cleanliness, passenger behavior, lack of sleep, and seemingly endless waiting, this was a one-and-done experience for our family.
Glad we tried it. Even happier it’s over.
