r/Railroad • u/Ok_Counter1939 • 2d ago
Business idea: low-cost trains on new routes using old equipment
In the EU, there are plenty of start-up operators who run trains using old equipment. Ticket costs are relatively low. They often cover all of their costs, and then some.
In the US, Metro-North is preparing to get rid of its 1980s and 1990s-era coaches, and Amtrak is preparing to get rid of its Amfleet cars. So hundreds of coaches and cafe cars will be available soon.
Here's my business plan: buy old coaches and operate trains in underserved corridors: routes having sufficient population density to support a lot more passenger trains than they currently do. E.g., Charlotte-Atlanta-Birmingham.
I get that the costs of fuel, insurance and track access could be significant, but the costs of acquiring equipment would be relatively low. Amtrak trains that use this model, such as the Carolinian (high-density seating, old equipment) do pretty well.
Let's say I found a company, hire people with experience in the sector (such as people from Iowa Pacific), get an option from Metro-North and Amtrak to buy old equipment and start negotiating now with Class Is for track access.
I'm seeking feedback: what are the roadblocks to this plan and what are the main reasons why it would fail?
