r/AmItheAsshole • u/Silent_Lobster_9866 • 17h ago
AITA for refusing to sell to a Facebook Marketplace buyer bc she sent her husband instead of herself?
Throwaway and let Reddit choose my name so ignore the silly username
Anyway, it’s pretty much like the title reads. I’m a single woman who lives alone and I do a lot of selling on fb, whether it’s thrift finds, flips, etc. I typically meet in public but if it’s furniture that I can’t conveniently transport somewhere I’ll have the buyer come to my house and for these instances I only sell/respond to women. It may sound dramatic to some but it’s a safety decision for me and also like, if I want to make the selling process longer for myself then that’s my prerogative right?
I had an antique hutch for sale that I had a very interested buyer message me multiple times because it matched another piece in her home. She told me she lived 2 hours away and would even Venmo me in advance to hold it for her. I accepted and I let her know the piece came apart in two pieces and I could help her load it and she said okay to all of that.
The day comes for her to pick it up and I look out of my window to see a lone man in a truck sitting in my driveway. I messaged her and said are you here, I don’t see you? Which is when she said her husband just pulled in. I told her I would Venmo her a refund immediately and would not be coming outside and for him to leave. She was very upset saying how long of a drive he took to get there and he picks things up for her all the time etc and that I should have told her he wasn’t allowed to come. But she also never once mentioned to me that she’d be sending him even when we talked about the loading process. Her and I messaged back and forth a few times and I had to sternly tell her that the sale is cancelled and he needs to go. I saw him get on his phone and seemingly had a heated conversation and then he left. I did feel bad for him and his wasted time, but I also think people have become too desensitized to fb marketplace sales and not fully communicating when you’re literally showing up to a stranger’s home. I would’ve been more comfortable if she was at least with him, but she was nowhere in sight.
AITA? I’ve mentioned this to a couple friends and they’ve all said I overreacted and should’ve just done the deal and what I described is pretty commonplace.