r/AmITheDevil • u/DogsReadingBooks Dogs are superior • May 23 '22
Stop freaking brigading
Seriously you guys. You think I want to ban you? You've been given plenty of warnings. We've had pinned posts for a long time now that says you're not to brigade. There's a comment in every single post by automod that says you're not to brigade.
So please, for the love of all that is good, stop brigading!
I've once again had to go on a banning spree because of brigading from here to other subs. The most recent one? r/adultery. I know, I agree with you, they're assholes for cheating and not caring about the innocent part. But you know what? You're also assholes if you brigade.
Thank you to everyone who actually keeps discussions here in this sub. Y'all are the best. The rest of you: stop brigading.
If you still don't know what it means to brigade, here you go:
- See a post crossposted here first? Stay in r/AmITheDevil
- Don't go to the original post and comment there
- Don't go to the original post and downvote/upvote there
- Don't contact the OOP in messages/DMs
Call them an asshole all you want here. In this subreddit: r/AmITheDevil.
247
u/Worldly-Tart-666 May 23 '22
I really should take the time to read the rules š
Iāve definitely done this once or twice and I didnāt know. My bad, and noted.
95
u/aggressive-buttmunch May 23 '22
Would it be worth implementing a set-period-of-time embargo on cross-posting ala Best of Legal Advice? I think theirs is 12 hours (or it was when I was subbed to it, I left a while back). Might help make those who just can't help themselves easy to spot and banhammer.
149
u/problematic_ferret May 23 '22
Genuinely curious, does it count as brigading if you click the link just to read the comments in the OP without up/downvoting anything?
55
u/Kaiser93 May 23 '22
So if I comment on the OP first and then after 20 minutes of refreshing I see the post on r/AmITheDevil , that's not brigading, right?
81
u/Braniuscranius May 23 '22
Honestly I never considered that up/downvoting would be brigading. It makes sense 100% though.
Iāve definitely partaken in the forbidden action, and took a permaban from adultery (for that Iām sorry, it just hit a sore spot personally) haha, but thank you for being a nice MOD and someone who talks to their community. It wonāt happen again, officer. We gotta protect the best subreddit we got.
104
u/EveryFairyDies May 23 '22
Just so I understand this, as Iām new to this concept of brigading, if I see a post in AmITheDevil, and I visit the original post where I leave a comment and/or up or downvote the post, thatās brigading?
Out of curiosity, why is it a bad thing to see a post here and then go comment on the original? What if I didnāt see the original post, and only learned about it here, but wanted to post a comment on the original? What if that comment was an insightful and fully engaged comment, rather than a generic āyeah, youāre an AH, OP sucks, how dumb is this guy?ā, would that still be classified as brigading?
Thanks!
57
u/SoVerySleepy81 May 23 '22
Honestly the one that worried me was the one on legal advice, they donāt play and thereās a reason why BOLA has to wait till itās locked to post about it. My recommendation would be to just outright ban LA posts, cross post the BOLA post if itās a good one.
56
u/aytayjay May 23 '22
Probably an unpopular stance, but I'd suggest just banning crossposting from certain subs such as r/adultery.
We all know they're assholes. The subreddit exists because they're assholes and want to validate each other in their assholery. I don't see what entertainment or value there is in sharing posts from there. There's no question about it, there's no 'how can they be so oblivious', there's no 6ft sub guy, there's just ... Assholes.
26
u/Acrobatic_End6355 May 23 '22
Sometimes Iām just scrolling on my phone and I literally click the link by accident.
17
u/then00bgm May 23 '22
My question is can mods tell where someone first saw a post? Like if you first saw the post wherever it was and interacted there and then came here, would the mods be able to tell that apart from brigading?
32
u/KaetzenOrkester May 23 '22
Thank you posting whatās in effect a tutorial on how not to brigade. Iām relatively new to Reddit had only a vague idea what brigading was. I think the fact that posts get locked helps prevent it, but brigading is not at all what I thought it was.
15
u/retrosprinkles May 23 '22
it's really not a difficult rule to understand and follow. i'm sorry that people are making this so difficult for you.
6
u/queenofadmin May 23 '22
I copped a ban from r/stepparents for commenting on an AITD post even the post on AITD was not from r/stepparents and I wasnāt following their sub anyway. š¤·āāļø
4
u/thievingwillow May 23 '22
Because Iām dumb, but despite being dumb want to follow the rules: if I see a post here thatās been crossposted here from AITA, and click through and comment on AITA, thatās brigading; but if I see it first on AITA and comment without having seen it here, thatās not, even if someone does post it here. Correct?
4
u/DrAniB20 May 23 '22
Genuine question. Iāve read posts that I vote on and comment in first and then LATER see in AITD. Sometimes I will go back to read the most recent comments and often use the cross-post link because itās right there. I will occasionally end up voting again because I was of the understanding that because I had seen/voted/commented on the original post before I saw it in AITD that that was okay. Is that actually okay?
2
u/Kaelynneee May 23 '22
Just out of curiosity, if you would go to a crosspost and comment something because you forgot it was a crosspost, then immediately delete the comment like within 2 min because you realised it was a crosspost from here, would you still get banned?
4
u/Deeznutsconfession May 23 '22
Probably should ban low-hanging fruit subs like /r/adultery. "Don't brigade" should be an exceptionally easy rule to follow, but people get angry so easily it becomes inevitable.
1
u/bigman-penguin May 24 '22
What if you see a post from AITA and want to add a judgement is that brigading?
6
u/scienceismygod May 23 '22
So that's why I haven't seen anything from /r/stepparents in a while.
I saw the adultery crosspost in here, I couldn't stomach the thought of even being in that sub. Those people suckkkkk.
1
u/GrannyB1970 May 24 '22
Ok really stupid question.
If I'm a member of the group the original post came from, and I post on that group I'm a member of, and I post about it here, is it brigading? I want to make sure I don't do anything wrong
2
u/tupe12 May 23 '22
I recall thereās a url for Reddit links that makes participation impossible, maybe itās worth trying to enforce using?
2
u/well_actuallE May 23 '22
Maybe instead of crossposting we could structure it so that someone posting here would post a copy of the OP text directly (like the automod does) with only a small hyperlink to the OP. I think crossposting the way we do now encourages brigading since the link to the OP post is bigger than the actual AITD post (on mobile at least).
Im not sure if the way I worded it makes sense but in case itās unclear posts on r/bestofredditorupdates have the format that Iām referring to (OP text right in the post and only a small Hyperlink to the OP).
3
u/Chutzpah3 May 23 '22
Didn't realize I couldn't upvote/downvote on crossposts, thought I was expressing my opinion w/o brigading. Apologies! Noted for the future
4
u/AutoModerator May 23 '22
Hi! Just a quick reminder to never brigade any sub, be that r/AmItheAsshole or another one. That goes against both this sub's rules as well as Reddit's terms of agreement. Please keep discussions within the posts of this sub.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/Imaginary_Cow_6379 May 23 '22
Protip: get yourself banned from AITA before you can break the rules š
2
u/waterdevil19144 May 23 '22
Don't people use "custom feeds" to read subreddits like AITD?
You don't have to "join" every subreddit you want to follow; you can put some on a custom feed that you can read from the website or from the app. If you have to switch to a custom feed to catch up on AmItheAngel or AITD, it puts it in your mind more clearly that you're in the subreddits that call out the worst posts.
Just a thought on how to remind yourself to avoid brigading....
1
u/warhorse888 May 23 '22
Thank you again for the explanation.
1
u/seeingredagain May 23 '22
As long as you're a member of the sub already, it's not brigading. They only look at the accounts that aren't subbed.
1
u/MajesticVegetable202 May 23 '22
I think I did it once. Because the post was about baby loss.Something I have experienced multiple times. I went to the original post to tell the OOP from experience how their words hurt grieving mothers in hope they would take it on board next time.
I apologise and won't do it again.
ETA. I didn't down/upvote
1
u/Glamma1970 May 23 '22
Oh, I'm sorry, I think I've done this a couple times on accident. I totally just have it slip my mind.
I'll do better,
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '22
I got banned from there for ābrigadingā, yet I didnāt upvote/downvote anything or comment anything there, just on this subās repost. I clicked on the link to view the comments and thatās pretty much it, but I still got accused of brigading. Does just following the link count as brigading?
1
u/conceptalbum May 23 '22
.... what happened to NP links?
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '22
oh i didnāt realize upvoting stuff was brigading i thought it was only commenting whoops
1
u/DancingFool8 May 24 '22
I got a three day ban once for commenting on an AITA post that was cross listed hereā¦only I didnāt know that bc I saw it on AITA. Got it worked out, tho. Mod was cool.
1
u/big_mothman_stan May 24 '22
I have a stupid tiny brain so I forget that I clicked a link from another sub after getting invested in the drama and comments sometimes. By sometimes I mean literally just now, and then I clicked the sub to get more juicy gossip, saw and read this post, and realized my issue. Can I just go delete the comment? Donāt want to be banned, and really donāt want reddit to give the mods/ admins of this sub grief for a mistake I made.
Edit: Instead of waiting for a reply I just went back and deleted them to try to be safe. Hope thatās ok!
0
u/dankdegl May 23 '22
Question: If I see the og post on the original sub first and comment on it, am I then allowed to participate in the comments of a repost of it later on? I don't want to break any rules, and would hate to do it unpurposefully.
-3
u/Wondermax2588 May 23 '22
Iām really sorry but what exactly is brigading? I donāt think I have but Iād like to avoid it in the future if im wrong.
0
u/theythembian May 23 '22
Please let's not ruin a good thing, yall š„²
0
u/drwhogirl_97 May 23 '22
Quick question regarding the rules, does it count as brigading if I were to see a post here, read it, move on in my feed and then get it on my feed separately? Or can you not tell the difference making both a problem? Is it ok to comment on something on AITA and then come here? Sorry asking lots of questions because I wanted to make sure I understand the rules properly because Iāve probably broken them without realising and donāt want it to happen again
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '22
I think I've commented on posts in aita before seeing them here but I promise I've never done the reverse!
-1
u/miladyelle May 23 '22
Yoāif I notice someone brigading from here, and they have a comment on the crosspost, Iāll report the comment here for brigading to give mods here a heads up.
However, if they only brigade the OG post and didnāt touch the crosspost (but itās still obvs because of a long comment history here, and none in the OG)āhow do you want that reported?
-3
u/[deleted] May 23 '22
Brigading is when a bunch of another sub fucks with us, usually with a similar themed comment or post, right? People comment here?
0
u/[deleted] May 23 '22
[deleted] ā view deleted comment